Lyeyo, A Year in the City

Descriptions for each part of a year in the City of Red and Blue Gables. Lyöti, the young scribe of Tönolye and Notun na Nyahe, keeps the household book of her aunt Nadhi’s house and writes down what she sees in the market, in the wine shop by the bridge, in the Lane of Dyers and at home, from the snow water in spring to the accounts in winter.

I. Hagewu-de wese, The Snow Water

Lüye le, tülhalmepulya blethat yun, na hagewude wese darethat weseenyiten ra.
At the morning watch, the sluice keeper opened the gates, and the snow water came down into the canals.

Wese nat kile na lathi, na so lüweat ithire sari.
The water was grey and cold, and it smelled of the mountains.

Lyöẅe le, nyavu thiat loyi yonyule le.
By noon, there was mud in every lane.

Povan levöthat vowen ve, na seyan slethat lero nyun le.
Farmers came in from the villages with greens in their baskets.

Tru ulyi pova ẅushathat nolyuẅo le, na sey rizethat nyavu le.
An old farmer slipped on the bridge and sat down in the mud.

Lyanmu le, loyi lira shikothat.
The whole market laughed.

Gelen so, liny eli nenan krethat sey, na seyan süshethat seyde fure.
Then two young women pulled him up and wiped his coat.

Sey lenuthat tru yüẅode fe Vulade pevu le, na sey wenathat nyavu.
He bought a cup of plum wine at Vula’s shop and forgot about the mud.

Yon le, yülipürun nölyüiskt.
In the courtyards, the plum trees began to bloom.

Nadhi yethat nyülyude pöẅun nu le.
Nadhi counted the honey jars in the granary.

Thral ho pöẅu thiat.
There were eighteen.

Fayo le, liny thral pöẅu thithat.
In the autumn, there had been twenty-four.

Nadhi zeythat nay, na nay zeythat nyumin.
Nadhi looked at me, and I looked at the mice.

Preri efo le, züẅan thowuthat ithire ve, na nyülyude pevupulya ne dikrathat röli.
On the fifth day, the bees came back from the mountains, and the honey-seller stopped complaining.

Ẅöru le, pölyin yönethaivt labode enyun weseenyiten le.
In the evening, the children floated paper boats on the canals.

Enyun pirethat rokge ra, na pölyin thowuthat lyaten ra üre nye.
The boats went off to the marsh, and the children went home for their soup.

II. Vula-de pevu, Vula’s Shop

Vulade pevu thiat nolyuẅode vörlu le, Wefatharande yonyule le.
Vula’s shop is by the stone bridge, in the Lane of Dyers.

Sey ödhüusht rikse, zhuro, siton, lyesun na yüẅo.
She sells salt, lamp oil, needles, thread and plum wine.

Yüẅo thiusht röpti pöẅun le.
The wine is kept in big jars.

Tru dhani suvüle thiat pevu le, na povan rizeusht so le gelen lyöẅe.
There is a narrow bench in the shop, and the farmers sit on it in the afternoon.

Tru lyüẅi nareusht pevu le.
A dog lives in the shop.

Sey tuẅüusht pevu ve, na sey wivöusht povande yüẅo.
It runs in and out and spills the farmers’ wine.

Lira ne dikrausht.
Nobody minds.

Nure povan lenuusht lyanmu le, Vula mazhiusht seyande nyun.
While the farmers do their buying, Vula keeps their baskets.

Sey ifousht rulyon seyan nye, na seyan dhaleusht son fayo le.
She lends them money, and they pay it back in the autumn.

Vula faleusht loyi rulbelyatede lyösu.
Vula knows the news of every house.

Tru ralipulya levöthat möge ve, na sey yayethat the dösru flethaun hagewu shi.
A mammoth driver came in from the north and said that the pass had been closed by snow.

Gelen so, sey yayethat the seyde rali örethan tru könponde nyu möto le.
Then he said that his mammoth had eaten a basket of turnips on the way.

Lira ne nyirüthat sey, na sey lenuthat tru fe loyi lira nye.
Nobody believed him, and he bought everyone a cup.

Nire le, Vula nayiusht nami yüẅode telyi fen pölyin nye, na seyan thowuusht lyaten ra.
At dusk, Vula gives the children little cups of sweet wine, and they go home.

Lyüẅi lyedöusht riksede nyun le.
The dog sleeps on the salt baskets.

III. Blöko, The Caravan

Vene nayan zeythat blöko, nayan honuthat tönon.
We heard the bells before we saw the caravan.

A thral nin rali darethat mögede möto le.
Forty mammoths came down the north road.

Lyalydhu thiat seyande fülbu le.
Their wool was full of dust.

Ralipulyan kesathat zomgübon lyanmupulyade yo le.
The drivers unloaded the bales in the market keeper’s yard.

Zomgübon le, vadhede dhüdun, malo na lyamun thithat.
In the bales there were copper pots, resin and woven mats.

Lyanmupulya penithat loyi zomgübo yüho le.
The market keeper weighed every bale on the scales.

Tru fonga pirethat blöko dho; sey danthothat seyde lyamunde dösu.
A Phong had come with the caravan, and she bargained over her own mats.

Lira ne lyezathat sey.
Nobody cheated her.

Pölyin yethat ralin.
The children counted the mammoths.

Tru pölyi yayethat: “A thral nin.”
One child said: “Forty.”

Maẅi pölyi yayethat: “A thral ho.”
Another said: “Forty-two.”

Dhu le, ralipulyan milethat Vulade pevu le, na seyan minathat dösrunde nyüfon.
At night, the drivers drank in Vula’s shop and told stories about the passes.

Ithire le, tru völu thiatn ke yoneushn tru dhu le.
In the Íthir, they said, there is a lake that freezes in a single night.

Vula yayethat the sey honuusht sa nyüfo loyi lyeyo le.
Vula said that she hears that story every year.

Ralin yöpüat·r·zhülyuat yo le, na seyande sare nat owü.
The mammoths rested standing up in the yard, and their breath was white.

IV. Mulyilu, Summer

Mulyilu le, nödhon fleushut lyöẅe ve ẅöru ra.
In summer, the shutters are closed from noon until the evening watch.

Lyüẅin lyedöusht gömiyende ge le.
The dogs sleep in the shade of the walls.

Wuvometharan dörousht dhu le, mena dhu nat lathi lyöẅe ve.
The bakers bake at night, because the night is cooler than the day.

Ralipulyan lyonyuusht löfole Ithire ve, wipun le.
Drivers bring ice down from the Íthir, packed in reeds.

Lyanmu le, öman ödhüusht löfole fen le, zorekalyo dho.
In the market they sell ice in cups, with flower syrup.

Sode dösunet liny rulyo.
It costs two coins.

Nay örethat tru fe muwi, na nayde pulnyen dhüspethat.
I ate a cup of it slowly, and my teeth ached.

Weröro le, eli liran ẅelyousht, na ulyi nenan rizeusht nolyun le, na seyan zeyusht eli liran.
At the waterfall, the young people bathe, and the old women sit on the rocks and watch them.

Wese nat lathi, na loyi lira shofausht.
The water is cold, and everybody yells.

Sokide lyalli ne levöthat wese ra; sey rizethat nayde bavo le.
Soki’s hatchling would not go into the water; she sat on my shoulder.

Ẅöru le, liran sleusht lyamun nyimun ra, na seyan meviusht son le.
In the evening, people carry mats up onto the roofs and lie down on them.

Nyimu ve, nay honuthat pre thürnyun pre yon ve.
From the roof I heard five songs from five courtyards.

Nadhi yayethat the mulyilun nat lathi seyde eli lyeyon le.
Nadhi said that the summers were cooler when she was young.

Loyi ulyi lira yayeusht sa.
Every old person says so.

Dhu le, telyi shulẅo levöthat lüẅo ve, na loyi yonyule ahethat.
In the night, a small wind came from the south, and all the lanes sighed.

V. Wefatharan-de yonyule, The Lane of Dyers

Wefatharande yonyule le, vipen thiat loyi lyatede vörlu le.
In the Lane of Dyers there is a dye vat by the door of every house.

Yeyo wese pireat lyilyen ve weseenyite ra, na weseenyite zheyuat yeyo.
Blue water runs from the doorways into the canal, and the canal turns blue.

Wefatharande rösen na kesnyun mezheyut yeyo.
The dyers’ hands are blue up to the elbows.

Seyan wifousht son, day yeyo ne dhidhuusht.
They wash, but the blue does not come off.

Lüye le, wefatharan wefausht lüblun, na seyan dheẅiusht son rüven le.
In the mornings, the dyers dye the skeins and hang them on poles.

Rüven thiusht yonyule le, na lüblun lilöusht loyi lira le ke pireusht sonde ge le.
The poles reach across the lane, and the skeins drip on anyone who walks underneath.

Lüye le, tru öma levöthat yonyule le; seyde fure nat owü.
One morning, a merchant came along the lane in a white coat.

Ẅöru le, sey thowuthat, na seyde fure nat yeyo.
In the evening, he came back, and his coat was blue.

Sey pirethas lüblunde ge le.
He had walked under the skeins, by the look of it.

Wefatharan shikothat, na tru wefathara ödhüthat yeyo fure sey nye.
The dyers laughed, and one of them sold him a blue coat.

Eya tizeat·r·fopüat vipe.
Eya sings while she stirs the vat.

Sey nat eli, day sey faleat loyi vipede dösu.
She is young, but she knows the price of every dye.

Lyuwe nat tepö yeyo ve, mena lyuwe levöusht üde ve.
Red costs more than blue, because the red comes from the east.

Ulyi wefathara yeat nimude lyesun sito shi.
An old dyer counts the threads of a guest-cloth with a needle.

Tru ali nyönüthat sey, na sey wenathat yete.
A friend greeted her, and she lost count.

Sey yeiskt röli.
She began again.

Nire le, wefatharan wifousht vipen, na weseenyite zheyuusht lyuwe.
At dusk, the dyers wash out the vats, and the canal turns red.

VI. A yeyobuyen, Three Blue Tiles

Fayo le, yülin treushut, na son nyelöushut nyimun le.
In autumn, the plums are picked and laid out to dry on the roofs.

Thral efo le, lyöge lüweusht yülin sari.
For twelve days the City smells of plums.

Sa fayo le, Göga nipethat Nadhide nyimu.
This autumn, Göga mended Nadhi’s roof.

Sey ne mazhithat ẅeshi lyuwebuyen, na sey lalethat a yeyobuyen lyuwebuyen dho.
He did not have enough red tiles, so he put three blue ones in among the red.

Nadhi danthothat; Göga yayethat: “Lira ne rezeyr son yonyule ve.”
Nadhi argued. Göga said: “Nobody will see them from the lane.”

Üno ve, loyi lira zeyusht son.
From the hill, everybody sees them.

Ralin dareusht ithire ve, na ralipulyan rükousht seyan lyanmu le.
The mammoths come down from the mountains, and the drivers comb them in the market.

Fülbu vigausht loyi yonyule le hagewu sari.
The wool blows about every lane like snow.

Nadhi yeat gihun, na nay södheat yete nyahe le.
Nadhi counts the grain, and I write the tally in the household book.

Tru memülmi levöthat möge ve lyösu dho.
A courier came from the north with news.

Vulade pevu le, ulyi liran danthothat so ẅöru ra.
In Vula’s shop the old people argued about it until the evening watch.

Gelen so, seyan thowuthat lyaten ra; seyan ne dhöshathat.
Then they went home. They had not decided anything.

Yülipürunde vaẅun zheyuthat lyuwe, day a yeyobuyen ne zheyuthat.
The leaves of the plum trees turned red, but the three blue tiles did not.

VII. Mayöma na Rüli, Mayöma and Rüli

Gelen rünye, Mayömade rulbelyate na Rülide rulbelyate ledöthat.
After the harvest, Mayöma’s house and Rüli’s house came to an agreement.

Rüli renarer Mayömade lyate le.
Rüli will live in Mayöma’s house.

Mayömade miya blethat kiyo, na sey wifothat nimu.
Mayöma’s grandmother opened the chest and washed the guest-cloth.

Sey vlethat so vene liny thral ho lyeyo.
She had woven it thirty years before.

A efo le, liny rulbelyatende nenan dörothat fümen.
For three days the women of both houses baked cakes.

Rüli levöthat seyde rulöban dho.
Rüli came with his aunts.

Liny eli liran slethat yüẅode röpti pöẅu rüve shi.
Two young people carried a big jar of wine on a pole.

Pöẅu nat nöki, na rüve nokethat.
The jar was heavy, and the pole bent.

Fongali müvethat ẅiwen lyilye le, na sey yayethat: “Ẅiwen nat mömi.”
The Phong priest laid out pebbles in the doorway and said: “The pebbles are pleased.”

Mayömade miya hüruthat; gelen so, sey frömuthat loyi lira, mena loyi lira hüruat.
Mayöma’s grandmother wept. Then she scolded everyone for weeping.

Liran küköiskt kipen, na ulyi nenan lyonyathat muwi.
The drums began, and the old women danced slowly.

Rüli lyonyathat.
Rüli danced.

Seyde lyonyate nat kuhi, na loyi lira yayethat so sey nye.
He danced badly, and everyone told him so.

Mayöma shikothat, na sey lyonyathat sey dho.
Mayöma laughed and danced with him.

Dhu le, miman thowuthat lyaten ra, na yonyule le fümende lyüköken thithat.
At night the guests went home, and there were cake crumbs in the lane.

Lyüẅin örethat son vene lüye.
The dogs ate them before the morning watch.

VIII. Üno, The Hill

Ithode dhu le, rulbelyaten tumeusht üno ra vene lüye.
On the night of the festival, the households climb the hill before the morning watch.

Loyi nena sleusht tru telyi hüve.
Every woman carries a small covered lamp.

Nolyuẅo ve, nay zeythat hüven; son pireat üno le lyuwe lyesu sari.
From the bridge I watched the lamps go up the hill like a red thread.

Ünode blüẅo le, lyasu thiat lyüshu le, na pöẅunde wese meyonet.
At the top there was frost on the grass, and the water in the jars had frozen.

Loyi lirade sare nat owü.
Everyone’s breath was white.

Nadhi yayethat: “Nay ne nat lathi.”
Nadhi said: “I am not cold.”

Rulbelyaten rizethat lyamun le, na seyan satuthat üre fare le.
The households sat on their mats and boiled soup over the fires.

Üde zheyuthat kile; gelen so, so zheyuthat zeshü.
The east turned grey, then yellow.

Salyu lureiskt Ithirede hagewu le; gelen so, so levöthat nayan ra.
The sun lit the snow on the Íthir first, and then it reached us.

Gelen salyu levöthat ünode blüẅo ra, lyasu klüthat nolyun le.
When the sun reached the top of the hill, the frost on the stones crackled.

Fongande lyallin ẅushathat lyüshu le, seyande nyon le.
The Phong hatchlings slid down the grass on their wings.

Lin yayeusht the ithoket vörande itho.
The priests say that the festival belongs to the goddesses.

Pölyin yayeusht the so et ürede itho.
The children say that it is for the soup.

IX. Nyahe, The Household Book

Piyu le, hagewu nümuthat lyuwenyimun, yeyonyimun na Nadhide nyimude a yeyobuyen.
In winter, the snow covered the red roofs and the blue roofs, and the three blue tiles on Nadhi’s roof.

Weseenyitende vörlun meyonet, na bowan pireat löfole le.
The canals froze at the edges, and the ducks walked about on the ice.

Vulade lyüẅi lyedöat ligude vörlu le, na sey ne yöpüat.
Vula’s dog slept beside the brazier and would not get up.

Ẅöru le, rulbelyaten rizeusht bürende vörlun le, na miyan minausht shayödi nyüfon.
In the evenings the households sit round their hearths, and the grandmothers tell old stories.

Vene nyüfon dhidhuusht, pölyin lyedöusht.
The children fall asleep before the stories end.

Soki minausht fongande nyüfon.
Soki tells Phong stories.

Tru vey liny son nar uyi.
One or two of them may even be true.

Blökon ne levöushn; dösrun mefleun.
The caravans do not come; the passes are closed, the couriers say.

Tru dhu le, Nadhi na nay zopithat nyahe.
One night, Nadhi and I added up the household book.

Sa lyeyo le, rulbelyate lenuthat liny öno, liny thral nyülyude pöẅu na er yüẅode pöẅu.
This year the house bought two looms, twenty-four jars of honey and ten jars of plum wine.

Rulbelyate dhalethat Göga nye lyuwebuyende dösu, na so örlyethat a yeyobuyen.
It paid Göga the price of red tiles, and it received three blue ones.

Nadhi södhethat a yeyobuyen nyahe le, na sey flethat so.
Nadhi wrote the three blue tiles in the book, and she closed it.

Dhu le, hagewu dhuleat, na tru lyüẅi zohiat maẅi yonyule le.
In the night, the snow was falling, and a dog was barking in another lane.

Notes on the sentences

Y001 · Lüye le, tülhalmepulya ble-tha=t yun, na hagewu-de wese dare-tha=t weseenyiten ra.
morning LOC sluice.keeper open-PFV=DIR gate-PL and snow-GEN water descend-PFV=DIR canal-PL ALL
At morning watch the sluice keeper opened gates, and snow’s water descended to the canals (direct).

Y002 · Wese na=t kile na lathi, na so lüwe-at=t ithire sari.
water ATTR=DIR grey and cold and 3IN smell-IPFV=DIR mountains SIM
Water is grey and cold, and it smells like the mountains (direct).

Y003 · Lyöẅe le, nyavu thi-at=t loyi yonyule le.
noon LOC mud exist-IPFV=DIR every lane LOC
At noon, mud exists in every lane (direct).

Y004 · Povan levö-tha=t vowen ve, na seyan sle-tha=t lero nyun le.
farmer-PL come-PFV=DIR village-PL ABL and 3AN.PL carry-PFV=DIR greens basket-PL LOC
Farmers came from villages, and they carried greens in baskets (direct).

Y005 · Tru ulyi pova ẅusha-tha=t nolyuẅo le, na sey rize-tha=t nyavu le.
one senior farmer slip-PFV=DIR stone.bridge LOC and 3AN sit-PFV=DIR mud LOC
One old farmer slipped on the stone bridge, and he sat in mud (direct).

Y006 · Lyanmu le, loyi lira shiko-tha=t.
market LOC every person laugh-PFV=DIR
In the market every person laughed suddenly (direct).

Y007 · Gelen so, liny eli nenan kre-tha=t sey, na seyan süshe-tha=t sey-de fure.
after 3IN two young woman-PL lift-PFV=DIR 3AN and 3AN.PL wipe-PFV=DIR 3AN-GEN coat
After that, two young women lifted him, and they wiped his coat clean (direct).

Y008 · Sey lenu-tha=t tru yüẅo-de fe Vula-de pevu le, na sey wena-tha=t nyavu.
3AN buy-PFV=DIR one plum.wine-GEN cup Vula-GEN shop LOC and 3AN forget-PFV=DIR mud
He bought one cup of plum wine at Vula’s shop, and he forgot the mud (direct).

Y009 · Yon le, yülipürun nölyü-isk=t.
courtyard-PL LOC plum.tree-PL bloom-INCEP=DIR
In courtyards plum trees begin to bloom (direct).

Y010 · Nadhi ye-tha=t nyülyu-de pöẅun nu le.
Nadhi count-PFV=DIR honey-GEN jar-PL granary LOC
Nadhi counted honey’s jars in the granary (direct).

Y011 · Thral ho pöẅu thi-at=t.
twelve six jar exist-IPFV=DIR
Twelve-six jars exist (direct).

Y012 · Fayo le, liny thral pöẅu thi-tha=t.
autumn LOC two twelve jar exist-PFV=DIR
In autumn, two-twelve jars existed (direct).

Y013 · Nadhi zey-tha=t nay, na nay zey-tha=t nyumin.
Nadhi see-PFV=DIR 1SG and 1SG see-PFV=DIR mouse-PL
Nadhi looked at me, and I looked at the mice (direct).

Y014 · Pre-ri efo le, züẅan thowu-tha=t ithire ve, na nyülyu-de pevupulya ne dikra-tha=t röli.
five-ORD day LOC bee-PL return-PFV=DIR mountains ABL and honey-GEN shopkeeper NEG protest-PFV=DIR again
On the fifth day bees returned from the mountains, and the honey shopkeeper did not protest again (direct).

Y015 · Ẅöru le, pölyin yöne-tha-iv=t labo-de enyun weseenyiten le.
evening LOC child-PL float-PFV-CAUS=DIR paper-GEN boat-PL canal-PL LOC
At evening watch children made paper’s boats float on the canals (direct).

Y016 · Enyun pire-tha=t rokge ra, na pölyin thowu-tha=t lyaten ra üre nye.
boat-PL travel-PFV=DIR marsh ALL and child-PL return-PFV=DIR house-PL ALL soup DAT
Boats travelled to the marsh, and children returned to houses for soup (direct).

Y017 · Vula-de pevu thi-at=t nolyuẅo-de vörlu le, Wefatharan-de yonyule le.
Vula-GEN shop exist-IPFV=DIR stone.bridge-GEN border LOC dyer-PL-GEN lane LOC
Vula’s shop exists at the stone bridge’s edge, in the dyers’ lane (direct).

Y018 · Sey ödhü-ush=t rikse, zhuro, siton, lyesun na yüẅo.
3AN sell-HAB=DIR salt oil needle-PL thread-PL and plum.wine
She sells salt, lamp oil, needles, threads and plum wine (direct, habitual).

Y019 · Yüẅo thi-ush=t röpti pöẅun le.
plum.wine exist-HAB=DIR great jar-PL LOC
Plum wine exists in great jars (direct, habitual).

Y020 · Tru dhani suvüle thi-at=t pevu le, na povan rize-ush=t so le gelen lyöẅe.
one narrow bench exist-IPFV=DIR shop LOC and farmer-PL sit-HAB=DIR 3IN LOC after noon
One narrow bench exists in the shop, and farmers sit on it after noon (direct).

Y021 · Tru lyüẅi nare-ush=t pevu le.
one dog dwell-HAB=DIR shop LOC
One dog lives in the shop (direct, habitual).

Y022 · Sey tuẅü-ush=t pevu ve, na sey wivö-ush=t povan-de yüẅo.
3AN run-HAB=DIR shop ABL and 3AN spill-HAB=DIR farmer-PL-GEN plum.wine
It runs from the shop, and it spills farmers’ plum wine (direct, habitual).

Y023 · Lira ne dikra-ush=t.
person NEG protest-HAB=DIR
A person does not protest (direct, habitual).

Y024 · Nure povan lenu-ush=t lyanmu le, Vula mazhi-ush=t seyan-de nyun.
while farmer-PL buy-HAB=DIR market LOC Vula keep-HAB=DIR 3AN.PL-GEN basket-PL
While farmers buy in the market, Vula keeps their baskets (direct, habitual).

Y025 · Sey ifo-ush=t rulyon seyan nye, na seyan dhale-ush=t son fayo le.
3AN lend-HAB=DIR coin-PL 3AN.PL DAT and 3AN.PL pay-HAB=DIR 3IN.PL autumn LOC
She lends coins to them, and they pay them in autumn (direct, habitual).

Y026 · Vula fale-ush=t loyi rulbelyate-de lyösu.
Vula know-HAB=DIR every maternal.house-GEN news
Vula knows every maternal house’s news (direct, habitual).

Y027 · Tru ralipulya levö-tha=t möge ve, na sey yaye-tha=t the dösru fle-tha-u=n hagewu shi.
one mammoth.driver come-PFV=DIR north ABL and 3AN say-PFV=DIR COMP pass close-PFV-PASS=REP snow INS
One mammoth driver came from the north, and he said that the pass was closed by snow (direct; reportative).

Y028 · Gelen so, sey yaye-tha=t the sey-de rali öre-tha=n tru könpon-de nyu möto le.
after 3IN 3AN say-PFV=DIR COMP 3AN-GEN mammoth eat-PFV=REP one turnip-PL-GEN basket road LOC
After that, he said that his mammoth ate one basket of turnips on the road (direct; reportative).

Y029 · Lira ne nyirü-tha=t sey, na sey lenu-tha=t tru fe loyi lira nye.
person NEG believe-PFV=DIR 3AN and 3AN buy-PFV=DIR one cup every person DAT
A person did not believe him, and he bought one cup for every person (direct).

Y030 · Nire le, Vula nayi-ush=t nami yüẅo-de telyi fen pölyin nye, na seyan thowu-ush=t lyaten ra.
dusk LOC Vula give-HAB=DIR sweet plum.wine-GEN small cup-PL child-PL DAT and 3AN.PL return-HAB=DIR house-PL ALL
At dusk, Vula gives small cups of sweet plum wine to children, and they return to houses (direct, habitual).

Y031 · Lyüẅi lyedö-ush=t rikse-de nyun le.
dog sleep-HAB=DIR salt-GEN basket-PL LOC
The dog sleeps in salt’s baskets (direct, habitual).

Y032 · Vene nayan zey-tha=t blöko, nayan honu-tha=t tönon.
before 1PL see-PFV=DIR caravan 1PL hear-PFV=DIR bell-PL
Before we saw the caravan, we heard bells (direct).

Y033 · A thral nin rali dare-tha=t möge-de möto le.
three twelve four mammoth descend-PFV=DIR north-GEN road LOC
Three-twelve-four mammoths descended on the north’s road (direct).

Y034 · Lyalydhu thi-at=t seyan-de fülbu le.
dust exist-IPFV=DIR 3AN.PL-GEN wool LOC
Dust exists in their wool (direct).

Y035 · Ralipulyan kesa-tha=t zomgübon lyanmupulya-de yo le.
mammoth.driver-PL unload-PFV=DIR bale-PL market.keeper-GEN courtyard LOC
Mammoth drivers unloaded bales in the market keeper’s courtyard (direct).

Y036 · Zomgübon le, vadhe-de dhüdun, malo na lyamun thi-tha=t.
bale-PL LOC copper-GEN pot-PL resin and mat-PL exist-PFV=DIR
In the bales copper pots, resin and mats existed (direct).

Y037 · Lyanmupulya peni-tha=t loyi zomgübo yüho le.
market.keeper weigh-PFV=DIR every bale scales LOC
The market keeper weighed every bale on the balance (direct).

Y038 · Tru fonga pire-tha=t blöko dho; sey dantho-tha=t sey-de lyamun-de dösu.
one Phong travel-PFV=DIR caravan COM 3AN dispute-PFV=DIR 3AN-GEN mat-PL-GEN price
One Phong travelled with the caravan; she disputed the price of her mats (direct).

Y039 · Lira ne lyeza-tha=t sey.
person NEG deceive-PFV=DIR 3AN
A person did not cheat her (direct).

Y040 · Pölyin ye-tha=t ralin.
child-PL count-PFV=DIR mammoth-PL
Children counted mammoths (direct).

Y041 · Tru pölyi yaye-tha=t: “A thral nin.”
one child say-PFV=DIR three twelve four
One child said: “Three-twelve-four” (direct).

Y042 · Maẅi pölyi yaye-tha=t: “A thral ho.”
other child say-PFV=DIR three twelve six
Another child said: “Three-twelve-six” (direct).

Y043 · Dhu le, ralipulyan mile-tha=t Vula-de pevu le, na seyan mina-tha=t dösrun-de nyüfon.
night LOC mammoth.driver-PL drink-PFV=DIR Vula-GEN shop LOC and 3AN.PL tell-PFV=DIR pass-PL-GEN story-PL
At night, mammoth drivers drank in Vula’s shop, and they told stories of the passes (direct).

Y044 · Ithire le, tru völu thi-at=n ke yone-ush=n tru dhu le.
mountains LOC one lake exist-IPFV=REP REL freeze-HAB=REP one night LOC
In the Íthir one lake exists, reportedly, which freezes in one night (reportative).

Y045 · Vula yaye-tha=t the sey honu-ush=t sa nyüfo loyi lyeyo le.
Vula say-PFV=DIR COMP 3AN hear-HAB=DIR this story every year LOC
Vula said that she hears this story in every year (direct).

Y046 · Ralin yöpü-at=t=r=zhülyu-at=t yo le, na seyan-de sare na=t owü.
mammoth-PL stand-IPFV=DIR=SS.SIM=rest-IPFV=DIR courtyard LOC and 3AN.PL-GEN breath ATTR=DIR white
Mammoths stand and at the same time rest in the courtyard, and their breath is white (direct).

Y047 · Mulyilu le, nödhon fle-ush-u=t lyöẅe ve ẅöru ra.
summer LOC shutter-PL close-HAB-PASS=DIR noon ABL evening ALL
In summer shutters are closed from noon to evening watch (direct, habitual).

Y048 · Lyüẅin lyedö-ush=t gömiyen-de ge le.
dog-PL sleep-HAB=DIR wall-PL-GEN shadow LOC
Dogs sleep in the walls’ shadow (direct, habitual).

Y049 · Wuvometharan döro-ush=t dhu le, mena dhu na=t lathi lyöẅe ve.
baker-PL bake-HAB=DIR night LOC because night ATTR=DIR cold noon ABL
Bakers bake at night, because night is cold from noon (direct, habitual).

Y050 · Ralipulyan lyonyu-ush=t löfole Ithire ve, wipun le.
mammoth.driver-PL bring-HAB=DIR ice mountains ABL reed-PL LOC
Mammoth drivers bring ice from the Íthir, in reeds (direct, habitual).

Y051 · Lyanmu le, öman ödhü-ush=t löfole fen le, zorekalyo dho.
market LOC merchant-PL sell-HAB=DIR ice cup-PL LOC flower.syrup COM
In the market traders sell ice in cups, with flower syrup (direct, habitual).

Y052 · So-de dösu-n-e=t liny rulyo.
3IN-GEN price-LINK-COP=DIR two coin
Its price is two coins (direct).

Y053 · Nay öre-tha=t tru fe muwi, na nay-de pulnyen dhüspe-tha=t.
1SG eat-PFV=DIR one cup slow and 1SG-GEN tooth-PL ache-PFV=DIR
I ate one cup slowly, and my teeth ached with cold (direct).

Y054 · Weröro le, eli liran ẅelyo-ush=t, na ulyi nenan rize-ush=t nolyun le, na seyan zey-ush=t eli liran.
waterfall LOC young person-PL bathe-HAB=DIR and senior woman-PL sit-HAB=DIR stone-PL LOC and 3AN.PL see-HAB=DIR young person-PL
At the waterfall young people bathe, and old women sit on stones, and they watch young people (direct, habitual).

Y055 · Wese na=t lathi, na loyi lira shofa-ush=t.
water ATTR=DIR cold and every person yell-HAB=DIR
Water is cold, and every person yells (direct).

Y056 · Soki-de lyalli ne levö-tha=t wese ra; sey rize-tha=t nay-de bavo le.
Soki-GEN hatchling NEG come-PFV=DIR water ALL 3AN sit-PFV=DIR 1SG-GEN shoulder LOC
Soki’s hatchling did not come to the water; she sat on my shoulder (direct).

Y057 · Ẅöru le, liran sle-ush=t lyamun nyimun ra, na seyan mevi-ush=t son le.
evening LOC person-PL carry-HAB=DIR mat-PL roof-PL ALL and 3AN.PL lie.down-HAB=DIR 3IN.PL LOC
At evening watch people carry mats to the roofs, and they lie on them (direct, habitual).

Y058 · Nyimu ve, nay honu-tha=t pre thürnyun pre yon ve.
roof ABL 1SG hear-PFV=DIR five song-PL five courtyard-PL ABL
From the roof I heard five songs from five courtyards (direct).

Y059 · Nadhi yaye-tha=t the mulyilun na=t lathi sey-de eli lyeyon le.
Nadhi say-PFV=DIR COMP summer-PL ATTR=DIR cold 3AN-GEN young year-PL LOC
Nadhi said that summers were cold in her young years (direct).

Y060 · Loyi ulyi lira yaye-ush=t sa.
every senior person say-HAB=DIR this
Every old person says this (direct, habitual).

Y061 · Dhu le, telyi shulẅo levö-tha=t lüẅo ve, na loyi yonyule ahe-tha=t.
night LOC small wind come-PFV=DIR south ABL and every lane sigh-PFV=DIR
At night, a small wind came from the south, and every lane sighed (direct).

Y062 · Wefatharan-de yonyule le, vipen thi-at=t loyi lyate-de vörlu le.
dyer-PL-GEN lane LOC dye.vat-PL exist-IPFV=DIR every house-GEN border LOC
In the dyers’ lane dye vats exist at every house’s edge (direct).

Y063 · Yeyo wese pire-at=t lyilyen ve weseenyite ra, na weseenyite zheyu-at=t yeyo.
blue water travel-IPFV=DIR doorway-PL ABL canal ALL and canal become-IPFV=DIR blue
Blue water travels from doorways to the canal, and the canal becomes blue (direct).

Y064 · Wefatharan-de rösen na kesnyun me=zheyu=t yeyo.
dyer-PL-GEN palm-PL and elbow-PL RES=become=DIR blue
Dyers’ palms and elbows have become blue (direct, resultative).

Y065 · Seyan wifo-ush=t son, day yeyo ne dhidhu-ush=t.
3AN.PL wash-HAB=DIR 3IN.PL but blue NEG stop-HAB=DIR
They wash them, but blueness does not end (direct, habitual).

Y066 · Lüye le, wefatharan wefa-ush=t lüblun, na seyan dheẅi-ush=t son rüven le.
morning LOC dyer-PL dye-HAB=DIR skein-PL and 3AN.PL hang-HAB=DIR 3IN.PL pole-PL LOC
At morning, watch dyers dye skeins, and they hang them on poles (direct, habitual).

Y067 · Rüven thi-ush=t yonyule le, na lüblun lilö-ush=t loyi lira le ke pire-ush=t son-de ge le.
pole-PL exist-HAB=DIR lane LOC and skein-PL drip-HAB=DIR every person LOC REL travel-HAB=DIR 3IN.PL-GEN shadow LOC
Poles exist in the lane, and skeins drip on every person who walks in their shadow (direct, habitual).

Y068 · Lüye le, tru öma levö-tha=t yonyule le; sey-de fure na=t owü.
morning LOC one merchant come-PFV=DIR lane LOC 3AN-GEN coat ATTR=DIR white
At morning, watch one merchant came into the lane; his coat was white (direct).

Y069 · Ẅöru le, sey thowu-tha=t, na sey-de fure na=t yeyo.
evening LOC 3AN return-PFV=DIR and 3AN-GEN coat ATTR=DIR blue
At evening watch he returned, and his coat was blue (direct).

Y070 · Sey pire-tha=s lüblun-de ge le.
3AN travel-PFV=INFER skein-PL-GEN shadow LOC
He walked in the skeins’ shadow, evidently (inferential).

Y071 · Wefatharan shiko-tha=t, na tru wefathara ödhü-tha=t yeyo fure sey nye.
dyer-PL laugh-PFV=DIR and one dyer sell-PFV=DIR blue coat 3AN DAT
Dyers laughed, and one dyer sold a blue coat to him (direct).

Y072 · Eya tize-at=r=fopü-at=t vipe.
Eya sing-IPFV=SS.SIM=stir-IPFV=DIR dye.vat
Eya sings while stirring the dye vat (direct).

Y073 · Sey na=t eli, day sey fale-at=t loyi vipe-de dösu.
3AN ATTR=DIR young but 3AN know-IPFV=DIR every dye.vat-GEN price
She is young, but she knows every dye’s price (direct).

Y074 · Lyuwe na=t tepö yeyo ve, mena lyuwe levö-ush=t üde ve.
red ATTR=DIR dear blue ABL because red come-HAB=DIR east ABL
Red is dear from blue, because red comes from the east (direct).

Y075 · Ulyi wefathara ye-at=t nimu-de lyesun sito shi.
senior dyer count-IPFV=DIR guest.cloth-GEN thread-PL needle INS
Senior dyer counts a guest-cloth’s threads with a needle (direct).

Y076 · Tru ali nyönü-tha=t sey, na sey wena-tha=t yete.
one friend greet-PFV=DIR 3AN and 3AN forget-PFV=DIR tally
One friend greeted her, and she forgot the counting (direct).

Y077 · Sey ye-isk=t röli.
3AN count-INCEP=DIR again
She begins to count again (direct).

Y078 · Nire le, wefatharan wifo-ush=t vipen, na weseenyite zheyu-ush=t lyuwe.
dusk LOC dyer-PL wash-HAB=DIR dye.vat-PL and canal become-HAB=DIR red
At dusk, dyers wash dye vats, and the canal becomes red (direct, habitual).

Y079 · Fayo le, yülin tre-ush-u=t, na son nyelö-ush-u=t nyimun le.
autumn LOC plum-PL gather-HAB-PASS=DIR and 3IN.PL dry-HAB-PASS=DIR roof-PL LOC
In autumn, plums are gathered, and they are dried on roofs (direct, habitual).

Y080 · Thral efo le, lyöge lüwe-ush=t yülin sari.
twelve day LOC city smell-HAB=DIR plum-PL SIM
In twelve days the city smells like plums (direct, habitual).

Y081 · Sa fayo le, Göga nipe-tha=t Nadhi-de nyimu.
this autumn LOC Göga mend-PFV=DIR Nadhi-GEN roof
This autumn, Göga mended Nadhi’s roof (direct).

Y082 · Sey ne mazhi-tha=t ẅeshi lyuwebuyen, na sey lale-tha=t a yeyobuyen lyuwebuyen dho.
3AN NEG keep-PFV=DIR many red.tile-PL and 3AN set.down-PFV=DIR three blue.tile-PL red.tile-PL COM
He did not hold many red tiles, and he set three blue tiles with the red tiles (direct).

Y083 · Nadhi dantho-tha=t; Göga yaye-tha=t: “Lira ne re=zey=r son yonyule ve.”
Nadhi dispute-PFV=DIR Göga say-PFV=DIR person NEG PROSP=see=ASSUM 3IN.PL lane ABL
Nadhi disputed; Göga said: “A person will not see them from the lane” (direct; assumptive).

Y084 · Üno ve, loyi lira zey-ush=t son.
hill ABL every person see-HAB=DIR 3IN.PL
From the hill every person sees them (direct, habitual).

Y085 · Ralin dare-ush=t ithire ve, na ralipulyan rüko-ush=t seyan lyanmu le.
mammoth-PL descend-HAB=DIR mountains ABL and mammoth.driver-PL comb-HAB=DIR 3AN.PL market LOC
Mammoths descend from the mountains, and mammoth drivers comb them in the market (direct, habitual).

Y086 · Fülbu viga-ush=t loyi yonyule le hagewu sari.
wool fly-HAB=DIR every lane LOC snow SIM
Wool flies in every lane like snow (direct, habitual).

Y087 · Nadhi ye-at=t gihun, na nay södhe-at=t yete nyahe le.
Nadhi count-IPFV=DIR grain-PL and 1SG record-IPFV=DIR tally account.book LOC
Nadhi counts grains, and I record the counting in the household book (direct).

Y088 · Tru memülmi levö-tha=t möge ve lyösu dho.
one courier come-PFV=DIR north ABL news COM
One courier came from the north with news (direct).

Y089 · Vula-de pevu le, ulyi liran dantho-tha=t so ẅöru ra.
Vula-GEN shop LOC senior person-PL dispute-PFV=DIR 3IN evening ALL
In Vula’s shop old people disputed it toward evening watch (direct).

Y090 · Gelen so, seyan thowu-tha=t lyaten ra; seyan ne dhösha-tha=t.
after 3IN 3AN.PL return-PFV=DIR house-PL ALL 3AN.PL NEG decide-PFV=DIR
After that, they returned to houses; they did not decide (direct).

Y091 · Yülipürun-de vaẅun zheyu-tha=t lyuwe, day a yeyobuyen ne zheyu-tha=t.
plum.tree-PL-GEN leaf-PL become-PFV=DIR red but three blue.tile-PL NEG become-PFV=DIR
Plum trees’ leaves became red, but the three blue tiles did not become (direct).

Y092 · Gelen rünye, Mayöma-de rulbelyate na Rüli-de rulbelyate ledö-tha=t.
after harvest Mayöma-GEN maternal.house and Rüli-GEN maternal.house consent-PFV=DIR
After harvest, Mayöma’s maternal house and Rüli’s maternal house agreed (direct).

Y093 · Rüli re=nare=r Mayöma-de lyate le.
Rüli PROSP=dwell=ASSUM Mayöma-GEN house LOC
Rüli is to live in Mayöma’s house (assumptive).

Y094 · Mayöma-de miya ble-tha=t kiyo, na sey wifo-tha=t nimu.
Mayöma-GEN grandmother open-PFV=DIR chest and 3AN wash-PFV=DIR guest.cloth
Mayöma’s grandmother opened the chest, and she washed the guest-cloth (direct).

Y095 · Sey vle-tha=t so vene liny thral ho lyeyo.
3AN weave-PFV=DIR 3IN before two twelve six year
She wove it before two-twelve-six years (direct).

Y096 · A efo le, liny rulbelyaten-de nenan döro-tha=t fümen.
three day LOC two maternal.house-PL-GEN woman-PL bake-PFV=DIR cake-PL
In three days the two maternal houses’ women baked cakes (direct).

Y097 · Rüli levö-tha=t sey-de rulöban dho.
Rüli come-PFV=DIR 3AN-GEN aunt-PL COM
Rüli came with his maternal aunts (direct).

Y098 · Liny eli liran sle-tha=t yüẅo-de röpti pöẅu rüve shi.
two young person-PL carry-PFV=DIR plum.wine-GEN great jar pole INS
Two young people carried a great jar of plum wine by means of a pole (direct).

Y099 · Pöẅu na=t nöki, na rüve noke-tha=t.
jar ATTR=DIR heavy and pole bend-PFV=DIR
The jar is heavy, and the pole bent (direct).

Y100 · Fongali müve-tha=t ẅiwen lyilye le, na sey yaye-tha=t: “Ẅiwen na=t mömi.”
Phong.priest lay.out-PFV=DIR pebble-PL doorway LOC and 3AN say-PFV=DIR pebble-PL ATTR=DIR glad
The Phong priest arranged pebbles at the doorway, and she said: “Pebbles are glad” (direct).

Y101 · Mayöma-de miya hüru-tha=t; gelen so, sey frömu-tha=t loyi lira, mena loyi lira hüru-at=t.
Mayöma-GEN grandmother weep-PFV=DIR after 3IN 3AN scold-PFV=DIR every person because every person weep-IPFV=DIR
Mayöma’s grandmother wept; after that, she scolded every person, because every person was weeping (direct).

Y102 · Liran kükö-isk=t kipen, na ulyi nenan lyonya-tha=t muwi.
person-PL knock-INCEP=DIR drum-PL and senior woman-PL dance-PFV=DIR slow
People began to strike drums, and old women danced slowly (direct).

Y103 · Rüli lyonya-tha=t.
Rüli dance-PFV=DIR
Rüli danced (direct).

Y104 · Sey-de lyonyate na=t kuhi, na loyi lira yaye-tha=t so sey nye.
3AN-GEN dance ATTR=DIR bad and every person say-PFV=DIR 3IN 3AN DAT
His dancing was bad, and every person said it to him (direct).

Y105 · Mayöma shiko-tha=t, na sey lyonya-tha=t sey dho.
Mayöma laugh-PFV=DIR and 3AN dance-PFV=DIR 3AN COM
Mayöma laughed, and she danced with him (direct).

Y106 · Dhu le, miman thowu-tha=t lyaten ra, na yonyule le fümen-de lyüköken thi-tha=t.
night LOC guest-PL return-PFV=DIR house-PL ALL and lane LOC cake-PL-GEN crumb-PL exist-PFV=DIR
At night, guests returned to houses, and in the lane cakes’ crumbs existed (direct).

Y107 · Lyüẅin öre-tha=t son vene lüye.
dog-PL eat-PFV=DIR 3IN.PL before morning
Dogs ate them before morning watch (direct).

Y108 · Itho-de dhu le, rulbelyaten tume-ush=t üno ra vene lüye.
festival-GEN night LOC maternal.house-PL climb-HAB=DIR hill ALL before morning
On the festival’s night, maternal houses climb to the hill before morning watch (direct, habitual).

Y109 · Loyi nena sle-ush=t tru telyi hüve.
every woman carry-HAB=DIR one small lamp
Every woman carries one small covered lamp (direct, habitual).

Y110 · Nolyuẅo ve, nay zey-tha=t hüven; son pire-at=t üno le lyuwe lyesu sari.
stone.bridge ABL 1SG see-PFV=DIR lamp-PL 3IN.PL travel-IPFV=DIR hill LOC red thread SIM
From the stone bridge I saw lamps; they move on the hill like a red thread (direct).

Y111 · Üno-de blüẅo le, lyasu thi-at=t lyüshu le, na pöẅun-de wese me=yone=t.
hill-GEN height LOC frost exist-IPFV=DIR grass LOC and jar-PL-GEN water RES=freeze=DIR
At the hill’s height frost exists on the grass, and the jars’ water has frozen (direct).

Y112 · Loyi lira-de sare na=t owü.
every person-GEN breath ATTR=DIR white
Every person’s breath is white (direct).

Y113 · Nadhi yaye-tha=t: “Nay ne na=t lathi.”
Nadhi say-PFV=DIR 1SG NEG ATTR=DIR cold
Nadhi said: “I am not cold” (direct).

Y114 · Rulbelyaten rize-tha=t lyamun le, na seyan satu-tha=t üre fare le.
maternal.house-PL sit-PFV=DIR mat-PL LOC and 3AN.PL boil-PFV=DIR soup fire LOC
Maternal houses sat on mats, and they boiled soup on fire (direct).

Y115 · Üde zheyu-tha=t kile; gelen so, so zheyu-tha=t zeshü.
east become-PFV=DIR grey after 3IN 3IN become-PFV=DIR yellow
The east became grey; after that, it became yellow (direct).

Y116 · Salyu lure-isk=t Ithire-de hagewu le; gelen so, so levö-tha=t nayan ra.
sun shine-INCEP=DIR mountains-GEN snow LOC after 3IN 3IN come-PFV=DIR 1PL ALL
The sun began to shine on the Íthir’s snow; after that, it came to us (direct).

Y117 · Gelen salyu levö-tha=t üno-de blüẅo ra, lyasu klü-tha=t nolyun le.
after sun come-PFV=DIR hill-GEN height ALL frost crackle-PFV=DIR stone-PL LOC
After the sun came to the hill’s height, frost crackled on stones (direct).

Y118 · Fongan-de lyallin ẅusha-tha=t lyüshu le, seyan-de nyon le.
Phong-PL-GEN hatchling-PL slip-PFV=DIR grass LOC 3AN.PL-GEN wing-PL LOC
Phong’s hatchlings slid on the grass, on their wings (direct).

Y119 · Lin yaye-ush=t the itho-k-e=t vöran-de itho.
priest-PL say-HAB=DIR COMP festival-LINK-COP=DIR goddess-PL-GEN festival
Priests say that the festival is the goddesses’ festival (direct, habitual).

Y120 · Pölyin yaye-ush=t the so e=t üre-de itho.
child-PL say-HAB=DIR COMP 3IN EQU=DIR soup-GEN festival
Children say that it is the soup’s festival (direct, habitual).

Y121 · Piyu le, hagewu nümu-tha=t lyuwenyimun, yeyonyimun na Nadhi-de nyimu-de a yeyobuyen.
winter LOC snow cover-PFV=DIR red.roof-PL blue.roof-PL and Nadhi-GEN roof-GEN three blue.tile-PL
In winter snow covered red roofs, blue roofs and Nadhi’s roof’s three blue tiles (direct).

Y122 · Weseenyiten-de vörlun me=yone=t, na bowan pire-at=t löfole le.
canal-PL-GEN border-PL RES=freeze=DIR and duck-PL travel-IPFV=DIR ice LOC
The canals’ edges have frozen, and ducks walk on ice (direct).

Y123 · Vula-de lyüẅi lyedö-at=t ligu-de vörlu le, na sey ne yöpü-at=t.
Vula-GEN dog sleep-IPFV=DIR brazier-GEN border LOC and 3AN NEG stand-IPFV=DIR
Vula’s dog sleeps at the brazier’s edge, and it does not stand (direct).

Y124 · Ẅöru le, rulbelyaten rize-ush=t büren-de vörlun le, na miyan mina-ush=t shayödi nyüfon.
evening LOC maternal.house-PL sit-HAB=DIR hearth-PL-GEN border-PL LOC and grandmother-PL tell-HAB=DIR ancient story-PL
At evening watch households sit at the hearths’ edges, and grandmothers tell ancient stories (direct, habitual).

Y125 · Vene nyüfon dhidhu-ush=t, pölyin lyedö-ush=t.
before story-PL stop-HAB=DIR child-PL sleep-HAB=DIR
Before stories end, children sleep (direct, habitual).

Y126 · Soki mina-ush=t fongan-de nyüfon.
Soki tell-HAB=DIR Phong-PL-GEN story-PL
Soki tells the Phong’s stories (direct, habitual).

Y127 · Tru vey liny son na=r uyi.
one or two 3IN.PL ATTR=ASSUM true
One or two of them are true, presumably (assumptive).

Y128 · Blökon ne levö-ush=n; dösrun me=fle-u=n.
caravan-PL NEG come-HAB=REP pass-PL RES=close-PASS=REP
Caravans do not come, reportedly; passes have been closed, reportedly (reportative).

Y129 · Tru dhu le, Nadhi na nay zopi-tha=t nyahe.
one night LOC Nadhi and 1SG add.up-PFV=DIR account.book
One night, Nadhi and I added up the household book (direct).

Y130 · Sa lyeyo le, rulbelyate lenu-tha=t liny öno, liny thral nyülyu-de pöẅu na er yüẅo-de pöẅu.
this year LOC maternal.house buy-PFV=DIR two loom two twelve honey-GEN jar and ten plum.wine-GEN jar
In this year the maternal house bought two looms, two-twelve honey jars and ten plum-wine jars (direct).

Y131 · Rulbelyate dhale-tha=t Göga nye lyuwebuyen-de dösu, na so örlye-tha=t a yeyobuyen.
maternal.house pay-PFV=DIR Göga DAT red.tile-PL-GEN price and 3IN receive-PFV=DIR three blue.tile-PL
The maternal house paid to Göga the price of red tiles, and it received three blue tiles (direct).

Y132 · Nadhi södhe-tha=t a yeyobuyen nyahe le, na sey fle-tha=t so.
Nadhi record-PFV=DIR three blue.tile-PL account.book LOC and 3AN close-PFV=DIR 3IN
Nadhi recorded the three blue tiles in the household book, and she closed it (direct).

Y133 · Dhu le, hagewu dhule-at=t, na tru lyüẅi zohi-at=t maẅi yonyule le.
night LOC snow fall-IPFV=DIR and one dog bark-IPFV=DIR other lane LOC
At night, snow falls, and one dog barks in another lane (direct).

Classical Khélai grammar

Lexicon: https://snapshotsofthelabyrinth.photo.blog/2026/11/09/classical-khelai-lexicon/

This text is based on Yo na lyafüru, a learning grammar of Classical Khélai (English name: High Florestican), the classical language of Némorath. Most of its examples are about everyday life in the City of Red and Blue Gables and the country around it: the market, the canals, the households of the clans, the Phong, and the weather through the year.

1. The language and its world

1.1 Where Khélai was spoken

High Florestican, also called Classical Khélai, is the classical language of the Six Clans of Némorath and of their empire, Khélythëa. In the capital, the City of Red and Blue Gables, it was the language of the clan councils and the sanctuaries and of the songs sung in the evening. Caravans from the Íthir Mountains, couriers from the north and merchants from the eastern coast learned enough of it for bargaining.

(1) Dödhewusorende üno ve, lira zeyusht ẅeshi lyuwenotun na yeyobuyen; son dareusht yon ra, zorepürunde ge le.
Dödhewusoren-de üno ve, lira zey-ush=t ẅeshi lyuwenotun na yeyobuyen; son dare-ush=t yon ra, zorepürun-de ge le.
council.sanctuary-PL-GEN hill ABL person see-HAB=DIR many red.gable-PL and blue.tile-PL 3IN.PL descend-HAB=DIR courtyard-PL ALL blossom.tree-PL-GEN shadow LOC
‘From the hill of the council sanctuaries you can see many red gables and blue tiles; they come down to the courtyards, in the shade of the flowering trees.’
(2) Lyöẅe le, wese nat avi, na pölyin zengausht weseenyiten; day slethara ke sleatt a nyu pireusht nolyuẅo le.
Lyöẅe le, wese na=t avi, na pölyin zenga-ush=t weseenyiten; day slethara ke sle-at=t a nyu pire-ush=t nolyuẅo le.
noon LOC water ATTR=DIR shallow and child-PL jump-HAB=DIR canal-PL but porter REL carry-IPFV=DIR three basket travel-HAB=DIR bridge LOC
‘At noon, the water is shallow, and children jump the canals; but a porter carrying three baskets goes over the bridge.’

Three peoples are around in the country. The Hyperboreans (kelyan) live in the towns and the fields, and the clans are theirs. The Phong have wings, fur and long beaks; they travel with the clans, serve in the sanctuaries, and speak telepathically. The Numi live in the ocean. Few people in the City have ever seen one.

(3) Fongade fure nat vösi; fongade nöru nat rori.
Fonga-de fure na=t vösi; fonga-de nöru na=t rori.
Phong-GEN fur ATTR=DIR beautiful Phong-GEN beak ATTR=DIR long
‘A Phong’s fur is delicate; a Phong’s beak is long.’
(4) Numiyade miri falete thiats.
Numiya-de miri falete thi-at=s.
Numi-GEN little knowledge exist-IPFV=INFER
‘Of the Numi, evidently, little is known.’

1.2 How the examples are set out

Each example is given three times. The first line, in italics, is the sentence as a Khélai scribe would write it. Below it the sentence is cut into its parts, with a gloss under each word: lure-at=t “shine-IPFV=DIR” is the verb lure “shine” with the imperfective suffix and the clitic of direct evidence. Then comes an English translation, which follows the Khélai closely.

(5) Lüye le, wuvometharan dörousht wu, na yonyule lüweusht shethi wu sari.
Lüye le, wuvometharan döro-ush=t wu, na yonyule lüwe-ush=t shethi wu sari.
morning LOC baker-PL bake-HAB=DIR bread and lane smell-HAB=DIR warm bread SIM
‘At the morning watch, the bakers bake bread, and the lane smells of warm bread.’

The abbreviations used in the glosses are listed at the end of the page. Also consult the lexicon: https://snapshotsofthelabyrinth.photo.blog/2026/11/09/classical-khelai-lexicon/

2. Sounds and spelling

2.1 Consonants

Khélai has twenty-four consonants. Six of them are written with two letters: th and dh are the sounds at the start of English thin and this, sh and zh those in ship and measure, ny and ly are palatal, made with the middle of the tongue against the roof of the mouth. y is the glide of English yes, and ẅ is a glide made with rounded lips and the tongue forward, as in French huit.

KindSoundsRomanization
Stops/p t k b d g/p t k b d g
Voiceless fricatives/f θ s ʃ h/f th s sh h
Voiced fricatives/v ð z ʒ/v dh z zh
Nasals/m n ɲ/m n ny
Liquids/l ʎ r/l ly r
Glides/w j ɥ/w y ẅ

thore “footprint” · dhu “night” · shulẅo “wind” · zhore “sword” · nyenyo “spring, well” · lyuwe “red” · yeyo “blue” · ẅöru “evening watch”

Several of them come together in this sentence:

(6) Ẅöru le, shulẅo shöẅüatt yeyobuyen le.
Ẅöru le, shulẅo shöẅü-at=t yeyobuyen le.
evening LOC wind blow-IPFV=DIR blue.tile-PL LOC
‘In the evening watch, the wind blows over the blue tiles.’

2.2 Vowels

There are seven vowels: i e a o u, and the two front rounded vowels ü (as in German über) and ö (as in German schön). There are no diphthongs. The rounded front vowels are common: lüye “morning watch”, lure “shine”, nöre “fade”, wüne “bead of dew”.

WrittenSoundDescription
i/i/close front
ü/y/close front rounded
u/u/close back rounded
e/e/mid front
ö/ø/mid front rounded
o/o/mid back rounded
a/a/open
(7) Zoren lureat·r·nöreatt wese le.
Zoren lure-at=r=nöre-at=t wese le.
flower-PL shine-IPFV=SS.SIM=fade-IPFV=DIR water LOC
‘Flowers shine in the water even while they fade.’

2.3 Two spellings

The examples are written in two ways. The reading form is ordinary Khélai spelling: suffixes are written onto their words and there are no equals signs. The analysis cuts each word at its boundaries, with a hyphen before a suffix and an equals sign before a clitic. The reading form has ẅelyoatt where the analysis has ẅelyo-at=t. Only one t is heard at the end of -at=t, and the poems often write only one: ẅelyoat.

(8) Pölyin ẅelyoatt weseenyite le, na seyande rulöba frömuatt seyan se ve.
Pölyin ẅelyo-at=t weseenyite le, na seyan-de rulöba frömu-at=t seyan se ve.
child-PL bathe-IPFV=DIR canal LOC and 3AN.PL-GEN aunt scold-IPFV=DIR 3AN.PL bank ABL
‘The children are bathing in the canal, and their aunt is scolding them from the bank.’

2.4 Syllables and stress

A syllable is (C)(C)V(C). The commonest clusters at the start of a syllable are a stop or a fricative with r or l: pr, tr, kr, pl, kl, bl, fl, fr, thr, sl, sr, shr, vr, vl. At the end of a syllable the usual consonants are nasals and liquids. Stress falls on the next-to-last mora and is not written: lyanmu “market” is said LYAN-mu, nölyuẅo “stone bridge” nö-LYU-ẅo.

(9) Blöko pireatt thral rali dho.
Blöko pire-at=t thral rali dho.
caravan travel-IPFV=DIR twelve mammoth COM
‘The caravan is travelling with twelve mammoths.’

2.5 Glides between vowels; nasals before consonants

Where a suffix beginning with a vowel follows a vowel, a short glide is heard between them, though it is not written: lure-at=t is said [luˈre.jat], ranü-at=t [raˈny.ɥat]. After i and e the glide is [j], after u and o it is [w], after ü and ö it is [ɥ]; after a it matches the next vowel. Before p, b, m the nasal n is said [m], before k, g it is said [ŋ], and before y it is said [ɲ].

(10) Lüye le, wese lureatt Lyuwenotu–Yeyonotu le.
Lüye le, wese lure-at=t Lyuwenotu-yeyonotu le.
morning LOC water shine-IPFV=DIR City.of.Gables LOC
‘At the morning watch, the water shines in the City of Red and Blue Gables.’

2.6 Soft words and hard words

Poets prefer words for light, water and care that are mostly made of liquids, glides and open vowels, while words for breaking and knocking that have more stops and clusters. The first two examples below are of the first kind, the last two of the second:

(11) Wüne gönyüthat welüẅe lyesu le.
Wüne gönyü-tha=t welüẅe lyesu le.
dew.bead catch.light-PFV=DIR last.light thread LOC
‘A bead of dew catches the last of the light on a thread.’
(12) Lyewa ranüatt lyödo.
Lyewa ranü-at=t lyödo.
moth brush-IPFV=DIR lantern
‘A moth is brushing the paper lantern.’
(13) Lyöti honuthat tinshebo.
Lyöti honu-tha=t tinshebo.
Lyöti hear-PFV=DIR crack
‘Lyöti hears a sharp crack.’
(14) Pevupulya küköatt lyinye nolyu le.
Pevupulya kükö-at=t lyinye nolyu le.
shopkeeper knock-IPFV=DIR weight stone LOC
‘The shopkeeper knocks a weight on the stone.’

3. Nouns

3.1 Animate and inanimate

Every noun belongs to one of two classes. Nouns ending in -a or -i are animate. Nouns ending in -e, -o or -u are inanimate. People, the Phong, animals and goddesses are usually animate, and things and places usually inanimate, but the class follows the ending whatever the meaning. A plum, yüli, ends in -i, so it is animate. The pronoun for it is sey “she, he”.

ClassEndingsExamples
Animate-a, -ilira “person”, fonga “Phong”, goya “fish”, züẅa “bee”, yüli “plum”
Inanimate-e, -o, -uwese “water”, sulo “moon”, zore “flower”, nyülyu “honey”
(15) Züẅan lünyeatt yülipürunde zoren le.
Züẅan lünye-at=t yülipürun-de zoren le.
bee-PL hum-IPFV=DIR plum.tree-PL-GEN flower-PL LOC
‘Bees are humming in the blossoms of the plum trees.’
(16) Yüli lyoweatt, na sey lureatt salyu le.
Yüli lyowe-at=t, na sey lure-at=t salyu le.
plum ripen-IPFV=DIR and 3AN shine-IPFV=DIR sun LOC
‘The plum is ripening, and she shines in the sun.’
(17) Möli örethat yüli.
Möli öre-tha=t yüli.
Möli eat-PFV=DIR plum
‘Möli ate a plum.’

3.2 The plural

The plural adds -n to the noun: wu “bread, a loaf”, wun “loaves”; goya “fish”, goyan “fish (more than one)”. After a number the plural may be left out, because the number already says how many.

(18) Wuvometharan laleatt wun ẅizhun le.
Wuvometharan lale-at=t wun ẅizhun le.
baker-PL set.down-IPFV=DIR bread-PL lattice.window-PL LOC
‘The bakers are setting out loaves in the windows.’
(19) Liny goya towüatt nolyuẅode ge le.
Liny goya towü-at=t nolyuẅo-de ge le.
two fish swim-IPFV=DIR bridge-GEN shadow LOC
‘Two fish are swimming in the shadow of the stone bridge.’
(20) Yeyonyimun lureatt wese le.
Yeyonyimun lure-at=t wese le.
blue.roof-PL shine-IPFV=DIR water LOC
‘The blue roofs shine in the water.’

3.3 The genitive

The genitive suffix -de marks the owner, the source or the thing something belongs to. The genitive comes before the noun it belongs to, so a chain of genitives reads from the outside in, like English “Nadhi’s house’s courtyard”.

(21) Nadhide lyatede yo le, tru yülipüru olyiatt.
Nadhi-de lyate-de yo le, tru yülipüru olyi-at=t.
Nadhi-GEN house-GEN courtyard LOC one plum.tree grow-IPFV=DIR
‘In the courtyard of Nadhi’s house a plum tree grows.’

When several owners are joined by na, only the last of them takes -de:

(22) Weseenyiten pireusht pevun, dhen na yonyulende vörlun le, na ẅeshi telyi nolyuẅon thiatt son le.
Weseenyiten pire-ush=t pevun, dhen na yonyulen-de vörlun le, na ẅeshi telyi nolyuẅon thi-at=t son le.
canal-PL travel-HAB=DIR shop-PL garden-PL and lane-PL-GEN border-PL LOC and many small bridge-PL exist-IPFV=DIR 3IN.PL LOC
‘The canals run along the edges of the shops, the gardens and the lanes, and there are many small stone bridges over them.’

3.4 Postpositions

Other relations are shown by short words that follow the whole noun phrase: le “in, at, on”, ra “to, towards”, ve “from”, shi “with, by means of”, nye “to, for”, dho “with, together with” and sari “like”. They never take endings of their own.

PostpositionMeaningExample
lein, at, onyo le “in the courtyard”
rato, towardslyanmu ra “to the market”
vefromithire ve “from the mountains”
shiwith, by means oflyave shi “by her voice”
nyeto, forlyalli nye “for the hatchling”
dhowith, alongsidenayan dho “with us”
sarilikesulo sari “like the moon”
(23) Möli lyedöatt yülipüru le.
Möli lyedö-at=t yülipüru le.
Möli sleep-IPFV=DIR plum.tree LOC
‘Möli is asleep beside the plum tree.’
(24) Yülipüru nöraatt zoredhe le.
Yülipüru nöra-at=t zoredhe le.
plum.tree lean-IPFV=DIR flower.garden LOC
‘A plum tree leans in the flower garden.’
(25) Lyalli tuẅüatt seyde miya ra.
Lyalli tuẅü-at=t sey-de miya ra.
hatchling run-IPFV=DIR 3AN-GEN grandmother ALL
‘The hatchling is running to her grandmother.’
(26) Ẅeshi möton levöusht lyanmu ra: yülipürunde dhen ve, nyürinde vowen ve, ithire ve, üdede fu ve, na Ophalrhande niyon ve.
Ẅeshi möton levö-ush=t lyanmu ra: yülipürun-de dhen ve, nyürin-de vowen ve, ithire ve, üde-de fu ve, na Ophalrhan-de niyon ve.
many road-PL come-HAB=DIR market ALL plum.tree-PL-GEN garden-PL ABL artisan-PL-GEN village-PL ABL mountains ABL east-GEN coast ABL and Ophalrhan-GEN camp-PL ABL
‘Many roads come to the market: from the plum orchards, from the craftsmen’s villages, from the mountains, from the eastern coast, and from the camps of the Ophalrhan.’
(27) Möli rözethat Lisha lyave shi.
Möli röze-tha=t Lisha lyave shi.
Möli recognise-PFV=DIR Lisha voice INS
‘Möli knew Lisha by her voice.’
(28) Lyöti nayithat telyi lare Sokide lyalli nye.
Lyöti nayi-tha=t telyi lare Soki-de lyalli nye.
Lyöti give-PFV=DIR small kite Soki-GEN hatchling DAT
‘Lyöti gave a little kite to Soki’s hatchling.’
(29) Ophalrhan, pireim nayan dho.
Ophalrhan, pire-im nayan dho.
Ophalrhan travel-IMP 1PL COM
‘Ophalrhan, travel with us.’
(30) Lyuwenyimun lulureatt sulo sari.
Lyuwenyimun lu-lure-at=t sulo sari.
red.roof-PL RED-shine-IPFV=DIR moon SIM
‘The red roofs flicker like the moon.’

3.5 Making new nouns and adjectives

Several suffixes make nouns and adjectives from other words. -te makes a noun for an action or a quality: lyonya “dance” to lyonyate “dancing”. -thar-a makes a noun for a person who does something: tize “sing” to tizethara “singer”. pulya “keeper” makes the names of offices: tülhalmepulya “sluice keeper”. -nali means “without”: gihunali “without grain”. -osi means “to do with”: teosi “to do with lamps”. -fi means “making”: shethifi “warming”.

(31) Tülhalmepulya siwüatt, na lüyede wese dareatt ithire ve.
Tülhalmepulya siwü-at=t, na lüye-de wese dare-at=t ithire ve.
sluice.keeper whistle-IPFV=DIR and morning-GEN water descend-IPFV=DIR mountains ABL
‘The sluice keeper is whistling, and the morning water comes down from the mountains.’
(32) Tizethara nödeatt seyde sino yo le.
Tizethara nöde-at=t sey-de sino yo le.
singer test-IPFV=DIR 3AN-GEN flute courtyard LOC
‘A singer is testing her flute in the courtyard.’
(33) Lyöge le, treguket falete na towifru.
Lyöge le, tregu-k-e=t falete na towifru.
city LOC music-LINK-COP=DIR knowledge and joy
‘In the city, music is learning and pleasure.’
(34) Lyöti zeythat lyafüru; sulover gihunali lyavo.
Lyöti zey-tha=t lyafüru; sulo-v-e=r gihunali lyavo.
Lyöti see-PFV=DIR sky moon-LINK-COP=ASSUM grainless bowl
‘Lyöti looked at the sky; the moon might be a bowl without grain.’
(35) Pölyin zhülyuatt shethifi bürede vörlu le.
Pölyin zhülyu-at=t shethifi büre-de vörlu le.
child-PL rest-IPFV=DIR warming hearth-GEN border LOC
‘The children are resting beside the warming hearth.’

3.6 Compounds and the four directions

Two nouns can be joined into one word, with the head last: yüli “plum” + püru “tree” gives yülipüru “plum tree”, zore “flower” + lyize “field” gives zorelyize “flower meadow”. The directions are möge “north”, lüẅo “south”, üde “east” and zöku “west”. The points between are compounds: lüẅozöku “southwest”.

(36) Lüẅozöku le, weröro dhuleatt ithire ve baso ra.
Lüẅozöku le, weröro dhule-at=t ithire ve baso ra.
southwest LOC waterfall fall-IPFV=DIR mountains ABL valley ALL
‘In the southwest a waterfall drops from the mountains into the valley.’

3.7 Verbs with a noun inside

A verb can take a noun into itself: zore “flower” + tre “gather” gives zoretre “go flower-gathering”. The noun inside the verb is not a particular flower. The verb takes no object:

(37) Iẅe le, nenan na pölyin zoretreusht zorelyizen le.
Iẅe le, nenan na pölyin zoretre-ush=t zorelyizen le.
spring LOC woman-PL and child-PL gather.flowers-HAB=DIR meadow-PL LOC
‘In spring, women and children go flower-gathering in the meadows.’
(38) Nadhi zanesödheatt lyu le.
Nadhi zane-södhe-at=t lyu le.
Nadhi record.prayer-IPFV=DIR scroll LOC
‘Nadhi is writing a prayer on a scroll.’

4. Pronouns, demonstratives and numbers

4.1 Personal pronouns

Khélai pronouns tell animate from inanimate. They say nothing about whether a person is a woman or a man. sey can be translated “she”, “he” or “they”, and is also used for animals and for animate things such as a plum. Pronouns are often left out when it is clear who is meant.

PersonSingularPlural
Firstnaynayan
Seconddudun
Third, animateseyseyan
Third, inanimatesoson
(39) “Du lenuthat mush?” “Nay lenuthat nyülyu.”
“Du lenu-tha=t mush?” “Nay lenu-tha=t nyülyu.”
2SG buy-PFV=DIR what 1SG buy-PFV=DIR honey
‘“What did you buy?” “I bought honey.”’
(40) Lyöti zeythat tru goya; sey towüatt wipun le.
Lyöti zey-tha=t tru goya; sey towü-at=t wipun le.
Lyöti see-PFV=DIR one fish 3AN swim-IPFV=DIR reed-PL LOC
‘Lyöti saw a fish; it was swimming among the reeds.’
(41) Lyöti zeythat tru lare; so vigaatt blüẅo le.
Lyöti zey-tha=t tru lare; so viga-at=t blüẅo le.
Lyöti see-PFV=DIR one kite 3IN fly-IPFV=DIR height LOC
‘Lyöti saw a kite; it was flying high up.’

4.2 This and that

sa “this”, su “that”, sani “these” and suni “those” come before the noun. Khélai has no word for “the” or “a”; tru “one” is used when a new thing comes into the story.

(42) Sa nyülyu nat nami, day su nyülyu nat yemnyi.
Sa nyülyu na=t nami, day su nyülyu na=t yemnyi.
this honey ATTR=DIR sweet but that honey ATTR=DIR bitter
‘This honey is sweet, but that honey is bitter.’
(43) Suni ralin darethat Ithire ve.
Suni ralin dare-tha=t Ithire ve.
those mammoth-PL descend-PFV=DIR mountains ABL
‘Those mammoths came down from the Íthir.’

4.3 Counting in twelves

Khélai counts in twelves. The numbers from one to twelve are tru, liny, a, nin, pre, ho, zu, bu, to, er, ha, thral. Higher numbers put the number of twelves before thral and the rest after it: liny thral is twenty-four, a thral nin is forty. A number comes before its noun. The noun need not be plural.

(44) Pevupulya yethat thral elo, na sey lalethat son nyu le.
Pevupulya ye-tha=t thral elo, na sey lale-tha=t son nyu le.
shopkeeper count-PFV=DIR twelve egg and 3AN set.down-PFV=DIR 3IN.PL basket LOC
‘The shopkeeper counted twelve eggs, and she put them in a basket.’
(45) Vlethara ödhüthat liny thral nimu.
Vlethara ödhü-tha=t liny thral nimu.
weaver sell-PFV=DIR two twelve guest.cloth
‘The weaver sold twenty-four guest-cloths.’
(46) Öma lenuthat a thral sino blöko ve.
Öma lenu-tha=t a thral sino blöko ve.
merchant buy-PFV=DIR three twelve flute caravan ABL
‘A merchant bought thirty-six flutes from the caravan.’
(47) A piyu le, lin fleusht nödho.
A piyu le, li-n fle-ush=t nödho.
three winter LOC priest-PL close-HAB=DIR screen
‘For three winters the priests closed the shutter.’

Ordinals add -ri: tru-ri “first”, liny-ri “second”, a-ri “third”.

(48) Linyri piyu le, lyavo freruthat.
Liny-ri piyu le, lyavo freru-tha=t.
two-ORD winter LOC bowl break-PFV=DIR
‘In the second winter, the bowl cracked.’

4.4 Every, many, few, other, same

loyi “every”, ẅeshi “many”, miri “a few, a little”, maẅi “other” and ami “same” come before the noun. A noun after loyi stays singular; after ẅeshi and miri, it is usually plural.

(49) Loyi lyate thiatt tru yo dho.
Loyi lyate thi-at=t tru yo dho.
every house exist-IPFV=DIR one courtyard COM
‘Every house has a courtyard.’
(50) Ẅeshi lyallin zhizhaatt lyüshu le, na miri ulyi fongan thenaatt se le.
Ẅeshi lyallin zhizha-at=t lyüshu le, na miri ulyi fongan thena-at=t se le.
many hatchling-PL play-IPFV=DIR grass LOC and little senior Phong-PL wait-IPFV=DIR bank LOC
‘Many hatchlings are playing in the grass, and a few old Phong are waiting on the bank.’
(51) Ami zore nölyüusht loyi iẅe le.
Ami zore nölyü-ush=t loyi iẅe le.
same flower bloom-HAB=DIR every spring LOC
‘The same flower blooms every spring.’

4.5 Times of day and seasons

The day is divided into watches: lüye the morning watch, lyöẅe noon, ẅöru the evening watch, dhu the night and nire is dusk. The year has four seasons: iẅe spring, mulyilu summer, fayo autumn and piyu winter. A time takes le, like a place, and usually stands at the head of the sentence.

(52) Nire le, dhöẅu pireusht lyatende nyimun ve lyafüru ra.
Nire le, dhöẅu pire-ush=t lyaten-de nyimun ve lyafüru ra.
dusk LOC smoke travel-HAB=DIR house-PL-GEN roof-PL ABL sky ALL
‘At dusk, smoke rises from the roofs of the houses into the sky.’
(53) Dhu le, pevupulyan lyedöusht seyande pevun le, na lyüẅin lyedöusht sonde lyilyen le.
Dhu le, pevupulyan lyedö-ush=t seyan-de pevun le, na lyüẅin lyedö-ush=t son-de lyilyen le.
night LOC shopkeeper-PL sleep-HAB=DIR 3AN.PL-GEN shop-PL LOC and dog-PL sleep-HAB=DIR 3IN.PL-GEN doorway-PL LOC
‘At night, the shopkeepers sleep in their shops, and the dogs sleep in the doorways.’
(54) Iẅe le, zorelyizen zheyuusht kölye, na nenan wifousht nimun weseenyiten le.
Iẅe le, zorelyizen zheyu-ush=t kölye, na nenan wifo-ush=t nimun weseenyiten le.
spring LOC meadow-PL become-HAB=DIR green and woman-PL wash-HAB=DIR guest.cloth-PL canal-PL LOC
‘In spring, the meadows turn green, and the women wash the guest-cloths in the canals.’
(55) Mulyilu le, liran ẅelyousht werörode lathi wese le, na pölyin towüusht weseenyiten le.
Mulyilu le, liran ẅelyo-ush=t weröro-de lathi wese le, na pölyin towü-ush=t weseenyiten le.
summer LOC person-PL bathe-HAB=DIR waterfall-GEN cold water LOC and child-PL swim-HAB=DIR canal-PL LOC
‘In summer, people bathe in the cold water of the waterfall, and the children swim in the canals.’
(56) Fayo le, ralin dareusht ithire ve, na vletharan lenuusht seyande fülbu.
Fayo le, ralin dare-ush=t ithire ve, na vletharan lenu-ush=t seyan-de fülbu.
autumn LOC mammoth-PL descend-HAB=DIR mountains ABL and weaver-PL buy-HAB=DIR 3AN.PL-GEN wool
‘In autumn, the mammoths come down from the mountains, and the weavers buy their wool.’
(57) Piyu le, hagewu nümuusht lyuwenyimun na yeyonyimun, na son nat ami.
Piyu le, hagewu nümu-ush=t lyuwenyimun na yeyonyimun, na son na=t ami.
winter LOC snow cover-HAB=DIR red.roof-PL and blue.roof-PL and 3IN.PL ATTR=DIR same
‘In winter, snow covers the red roofs and the blue roofs, and they look the same.’

5. Verbs

5.1 The parts of a verb

A Khélai verb is built in a fixed order: the root, then a suffix of aspect, then a suffix that changes who does what, then a clitic of evidence. Only the root and, in a statement, the aspect and the evidence are needed. The verb does not change for person or number.

RootAspectValencyEvidence
södhe “write”-tha perfective-u passive=t direct
(58) Karalo södhethaut lyu le.
Karalo södhe-tha-u=t lyu le.
clan.oath record-PFV-PASS=DIR scroll LOC
‘The clan oath was written on a scroll.’

5.2 Aspect

Aspect shows whether an event is going on, finished, repeated, starting or carried through to the end. Khélai has no tense. When the time matters it is given by a phrase such as lüye le “at the morning watch”.

FormNameMeaning
-atimperfectivegoing on; a scene
-thaperfectivea whole event, finished
-ushhabitualdone again and again; a custom
-iskinceptivebeginning
-ompcompletivedone to the end
re=prospectiveabout to happen; intended
me=resultativethe state left by an earlier event

The imperfective describes a scene while it is going on:

(59) Vlethara lalyeatt zoren nimu le, na sey lünyeatt.
Vlethara lalye-at=t zoren nimu le, na sey lünye-at=t.
weaver embroider-IPFV=DIR flower-PL guest.cloth LOC and 3AN hum-IPFV=DIR
‘A weaver is embroidering flowers on a guest-cloth, and she is humming.’
(60) Töno tizeatt lyanmu le.
Töno tize-at=t lyanmu le.
bell sing-IPFV=DIR market LOC
‘The bell is singing (ringing) in the market.’

The perfective talks about one event as a whole:

(61) Shulẅo shöẅüthat, na tru lare vigathat baso ra.
Shulẅo shöẅü-tha=t, na tru lare viga-tha=t baso ra.
wind blow-PFV=DIR and one kite fly-PFV=DIR valley ALL
‘The wind blew, and a kite flew off towards the valley.’
(62) Soreyu blethaut.
Soreyu ble-tha-u=t.
sanctuary.gate open-PFV-PASS=DIR
‘The sanctuary gate was opened.’

The habitual tells what happens again and again. This is the aspect of customs, seasons and daily work:

(63) Lisha lyüwiusht mumo lyavo le.
Lisha lyüwi-ush=t mumo lyavo le.
Lisha serve.rice-HAB=DIR rice bowl LOC
‘Lisha serves rice into a bowl.’
(64) Vletharan vleusht lyesun lyanmu le.
Vletharan vle-ush=t lyesun lyanmu le.
weaver-PL weave-HAB=DIR thread-PL market LOC
‘The weavers weave threads in the market.’
(65) Iẅe le, türan levöusht rokge ra.
Iẅe le, türan levö-ush=t rokge ra.
spring LOC heron-PL come-HAB=DIR marsh ALL
‘In spring, the herons come to the marsh.’

The inceptive marks the start of something:

(66) Lüye le, saron nöreiskt, na liẅan tizeiskt.
Lüye le, saron nöre-isk=t, na liẅan tize-isk=t.
morning LOC star-PL fade-INCEP=DIR and bird-PL sing-INCEP=DIR
‘At the morning watch, the stars begin to fade, and the birds begin to sing.’

The completive says that something was done to the very end:

(67) Pölyi öreompt seyde üre, na sey löbithat elo.
Pölyi öre-omp=t sey-de üre, na sey löbi-tha=t elo.
child eat-COMPL=DIR 3AN-GEN soup and 3AN ask-PFV=DIR egg
‘The child finished all her soup, and she asked for an egg.’

The particles re= and me= stand before the verb in place of the aspect suffix. re= says that something is about to happen or is meant to. me= describes the state that something has left behind.

(68) Woshwun levöatt ithire ve; möve redhuler.
Woshwun levö-at=t ithire ve; möve re=dhule=r.
cloud-PL come-IPFV=DIR mountains ABL rain PROSP=fall=ASSUM
‘Clouds are coming from the mountains; it is about to rain.’
(69) Yülin melyowet.
Yülin me=lyowe=t.
plum-PL RES=ripen=DIR
‘The plums are ripe.’
(70) Lyuwenyimun menöres.
Lyuwenyimun me=nöre=s.
red.roof-PL RES=fade=INFER
‘The red roofs have faded, it seems.’

5.3 Who does what: the valency suffixes

Four suffixes come after the aspect and change the people taking part. -iv makes someone do something or makes something happen; -u leaves out the doer; -ely means “each other”; -om means “oneself”.

(71) Pölyin vigaativt laren üno le.
Pölyin viga-at-iv=t laren üno le.
child-PL fly-IPFV-CAUS=DIR kite-PL hill LOC
‘The children are flying kites on the hill.’
(72) Nadhi olyiushivt zoren seyde yo le.
Nadhi olyi-ush-iv=t zoren sey-de yo le.
Nadhi grow-HAB-CAUS=DIR flower-PL 3AN-GEN courtyard LOC
‘Nadhi grows flowers in her courtyard.’
(73) Wun dörothaut vene lüye.
Wun döro-tha-u=t vene lüye.
bread-PL bake-PFV-PASS=DIR before morning
‘The loaves were baked before the morning watch.’
(74) Liny ali nyönüthaelyt nolyuẅo le, na seyan shikothat.
Liny ali nyönü-tha-ely=t nolyuẅo le, na seyan shiko-tha=t.
two friend greet-PFV-RECP=DIR bridge LOC and 3AN.PL laugh-PFV=DIR
‘Two friends greeted each other on the bridge, and they laughed.’
(75) Türa zeyatomt avi wese le.
Türa zey-at-om=t avi wese le.
heron see-IPFV-REFL=DIR shallow water LOC
‘The heron is looking at itself in the shallow water.’
(76) Lyöti zeythat zorelye vipe le; sey zeyatomt wese le.
Lyöti zey-tha=t zorelye vipe le; sey zey-at-om=t wese le.
Lyöti see-PFV=DIR flower.image dye LOC 3AN see-IPFV-REFL=DIR water LOC
‘Lyöti saw a blossom’s image in the dye vat; she saw herself in the water.’

5.4 Must, may and want

Three particles at the end of a clause add necessity, possibility and wish: ta “must”, lu “may, might” and the “wants to, means to”. With ta and the the verb usually takes the prospective re=.

(77) Mima levöatt; nayan relyöder zorekalyo ta.
Mima levö-at=t; nayan re=lyöde=r zorekalyo ta.
guest come-IPFV=DIR 1PL PROSP=pour=ASSUM flower.syrup NEC
‘A guest is coming; we must pour the flower syrup.’
(78) Iẅe le, ithirede liran levöusht lyanmu ra, na seyan lyonyuusht nyülyu lu.
Iẅe le, ithire-de liran levö-ush=t lyanmu ra, na seyan lyonyu-ush=t nyülyu lu.
spring LOC mountains-GEN person-PL come-HAB=DIR market ALL and 3AN.PL bring-HAB=DIR honey POSS
‘In spring, the mountain people come to the market, and they may bring honey.’
(79) Lyöti relenur sino the.
Lyöti re=lenu=r sino the.
Lyöti PROSP=buy=ASSUM flute VOL
‘Lyöti wants to buy a flute.’

5.5 Commands

A command adds -im to the verb and has no evidential, since it says nothing about what anyone knows. It is spoken in a level, high voice. A prayer to a goddess uses the same form.

(80) Söpaim sa üre.
Söpa-im sa üre.
taste-IMP this soup
‘Taste this soup.’
(81) Ne tuẅüim nolyuẅo le!
Ne tuẅü-im nolyuẅo le!
NEG run-IMP bridge LOC
‘Don’t run on the bridge!’
(82) Threim pölyin.
Thre-im pölyin.
protect-IMP child-PL
‘Keep the children safe.’

5.6 Saying no

ne comes directly before the verb, or before re= or me=. It cannot stand before a noun. Khélai cannot say “not the sword, the bread”, and says instead:

(83) Nadhi ne zeythat zhore; sey zeythat wu.
Nadhi ne zey-tha=t zhore; sey zey-tha=t wu.
Nadhi NEG see-PFV=DIR sword 3AN see-PFV=DIR bread
‘Nadhi did not see a sword; she saw bread.’
(84) Sa piyu le, hagewu ne dhulethat lyöge le, day so dhulethat Ithire le.
Sa piyu le, hagewu ne dhule-tha=t lyöge le, day so dhule-tha=t Ithire le.
this winter LOC snow NEG fall-PFV=DIR city LOC but 3IN fall-PFV=DIR mountains LOC
‘This winter, no snow fell in the city, but it fell in the Íthir Mountains.’
(85) Pölyin ne relyedör; seyan honuatt kipen.
Pölyin ne re=lyedö=r; seyan honu-at=t kipen.
child-PL NEG PROSP=sleep=ASSUM 3AN.PL hear-IPFV=DIR drum-PL
‘The children are not going to sleep; they hear the drums.’

6. How the speaker knows: the evidentials

6.1 Four kinds of knowledge

A statement in Khélai says how the speaker knows it. Four clitics are attached to the verb, or to a copula, and one of them is chosen in every careful sentence. The clitic shows where the knowledge came from. A speaker who is unsure adds lu “may” (§5.4).

CliticNameThe speaker …
=tdirectsaw, heard, tasted or did it herself
=nreportativewas told it, or has it from a book or from tradition
=sinferentialworked it out from what she can see
=rassumptivetakes it for granted, or supposes it on general grounds

With =t the speaker was there:

(86) Mumo nat shethi.
Mumo na=t shethi.
rice ATTR=DIR warm
‘The rice is warm.’
(87) Nay söpathat nyülyu; so nat nami.
Nay söpa-tha=t nyülyu; so na=t nami.
1SG taste-PFV=DIR honey 3IN ATTR=DIR sweet
‘I tasted the honey; it is sweet.’
(88) Nay ẅelyothat werörode wese le; so nat lathi.
Nay ẅelyo-tha=t weröro-de wese le; so na=t lathi.
1SG bathe-PFV=DIR waterfall-GEN water LOC 3IN ATTR=DIR cold
‘I bathed in the water of the waterfall; it was cold.’

With =n she was told:

(89) Narshaliyan pireatn lyire shi.
Narshaliyan pire-at=n lyire shi.
Narshaliya-PL travel-IPFV=REP lyira INS
‘The Narshalye travel by way of a lyira, so it is said.’
(90) Ithirede liran nareushn werörode vörlu le, na seyande pölyin towüushn lathi wese le.
Ithire-de liran nare-ush=n weröro-de vörlu le, na seyan-de pölyin towü-ush=n lathi wese le.
mountains-GEN person-PL dwell-HAB=REP waterfall-GEN border LOC and 3AN.PL-GEN child-PL swim-HAB=REP cold water LOC
‘The mountain people live by the waterfall, they say, and their children swim in the cold water.’

With =s she reasons from what is in front of her:

(91) Yode lyason nas nüẅi; möve dhulethas dhu le.
Yo-de lyason na=s nüẅi; möve dhule-tha=s dhu le.
courtyard-GEN floor-PL ATTR=INFER wet rain fall-PFV=INFER night LOC
‘The courtyard floor is wet; it must have rained in the night.’
(92) Lözhen thiisks zoredhe le.
Lözhen thi-isk=s zoredhe le.
weed-PL exist-INCEP=INFER flower.garden LOC
‘Weeds are coming up in the flower gardens, by the look of it.’

With =r she assumes:

(93) Ithirede blüẅo le, hagewu lowiatr.
Ithire-de blüẅo le, hagewu lowi-at=r.
mountains-GEN height LOC snow stay-IPFV=ASSUM
‘Up in the Íthir the snow will still be lying.’

6.2 Evidence inside a sentence

A clause after the “that” keeps its own evidential when it comes from someone else’s knowledge. In the sentence below Nadhi remembers for herself (=t), but what she remembers is something she was told (=n).

(94) Nadhi zheatt the seyde miya döroushn wu sa büre le.
Nadhi zhe-at=t the sey-de miya döro-ush=n wu sa büre le.
Nadhi remember-IPFV=DIR COMP 3AN-GEN grandmother bake-HAB=REP bread this hearth LOC
‘Nadhi remembers being told that her grandmother used to bake bread at this hearth.’

Quoted speech carries the evidentials of the person quoted. The narrator takes over again when the quotation ends.

(95) Lisha yayethat: “Lyavo freruthat linyri piyu le.”
Lisha yaye-tha=t: “Lyavo freru-tha=t liny-ri piyu le.”
Lisha say-PFV=DIR bowl break-PFV=DIR two-ORD winter LOC
‘Lisha says: “The bowl broke in the second winter.”’

6.3 One evidential for a chain

When two verbs share one subject and are known in the same way, the evidential can be put once, at the end (Chapter 9). The flowers below are seen shining and fading at the same moment. The =t covers both.

(96) Zoren lureat·r·nöreatt wese le.
Zoren lure-at=r=nöre-at=t wese le.
flower-PL shine-IPFV=SS.SIM=fade-IPFV=DIR water LOC
‘Flowers shine in the water even while they fade.’

6.4 How the clitics sound

The evidential clitics change their sound to suit the next word, though the spelling does not change. Before b, d, g =t is said [d], before a nasal [n], before a fricative [s], and before l, ly or r [r]. =n is said [m] before p, b, m, [ŋ] before k, g and [ɲ] before y. =s is said [z] before a voiced sound. =r is said [n] before a nasal and [l] before l. So pire-tha=t Nemore ra “travelled to Némorath” is said [pireθan nemore ra].

CliticNext soundSaid as
=tb, d, g[d]
=tm, n, ny[n]
=ta fricative[s]
=tl, ly, r[r]
=np, b, m[m]
=nk, g[ŋ]
=ny[ɲ]
=sa voiced sound[z]
=ra nasal[n]
=rl[l]

7. Being, seeming and becoming

7.1 Three ways to say “is”

Where English has “is”, Khélai uses one of three words. thi says that something exists or is somewhere; it is an ordinary verb, with aspect and evidential. e says what something is. na says what something is like. The last two have no aspect, but they carry an evidential clitic.

WordUseExample
thithere is; is somewherenyülyu thi-at=t pöẅu le “there is honey in the jar”
eis (a thing, a person)Soki e=t fonga “Soki is a Phong”
nais (of a quality)üre na=t felyi “the soup is sour”
(97) Nyülyu thiatt pöẅu le, na züẅa thiatt pöẅude vörlu le.
Nyülyu thi-at=t pöẅu le, na züẅa thi-at=t pöẅu-de vörlu le.
honey exist-IPFV=DIR jar LOC and bee exist-IPFV=DIR jar-GEN border LOC
‘There is honey in the jar, and there is a bee on the rim of the jar.’
(98) Zoredhe thiatt sore le.
Zoredhe thi-at=t sore le.
flower.garden exist-IPFV=DIR sanctuary LOC
‘There is a flower garden inside the sanctuary.’
(99) Soki et Lyötide ali.
Soki e=t Lyöti-de ali.
Soki EQU=DIR Lyöti-GEN friend
‘Soki is Lyöti’s friend.’
(100) Mölivet Lishade pölyi.
Möli-v-e=t Lisha-de pölyi.
Möli-LINK-COP=DIR Lisha-GEN child
‘Möli is Lisha’s child.’
(101) Üre nat felyi, day pötho nat nami.
Üre na=t felyi, day pötho na=t nami.
soup ATTR=DIR sour but steamed.cake ATTR=DIR sweet
‘The soup is sour, but the steamed cake is sweet.’
(102) Lyuwenotu–Yeyonotu nat vösi.
Lyuwenotu-yeyonotu na=t vösi.
City.of.Gables ATTR=DIR beautiful
‘The City of Red and Blue Gables is beautiful.’

7.2 More and less

There is no word for “more”. A quality is compared with na and the postposition ve “from”. Literally, honey is sweet “from” flower syrup.

(103) Nyülyu nat nami zorekalyo ve.
Nyülyu na=t nami zorekalyo ve.
honey ATTR=DIR sweet flower.syrup ABL
‘Honey is sweeter than flower syrup.’
(104) Weröro nat vöyi kipen ve.
Weröro na=t vöyi kipen ve.
waterfall ATTR=DIR loud drum-PL ABL
‘The waterfall is louder than the drums.’

7.3 Like

sari “like” follows the thing compared. After na it can make the whole predicate.

(105) Pevupulyade lyave nat kipe sari.
Pevupulya-de lyave na=t kipe sari.
shopkeeper-GEN voice ATTR=DIR drum SIM
‘The shopkeeper’s voice is like a drum.’
(106) Fayo le, dhöẅu nat müẅu sari baso le.
Fayo le, dhöẅu na=t müẅu sari baso le.
autumn LOC smoke ATTR=DIR moss SIM valley LOC
‘In autumn, the smoke in the valley is like moss.’

7.4 Becoming and making

zheyu “become” takes what something becomes as its object. vome “make” can take an adjective after its object: “make the stones bright”.

(107) Fayo le, yülipürunde vaẅun zheyuusht lyuwe.
Fayo le, yülipürun-de vaẅun zheyu-ush=t lyuwe.
autumn LOC plum.tree-PL-GEN leaf-PL become-HAB=DIR red
‘In autumn, the leaves of the plum trees turn red.’
(108) Möve vomethat lyögede nolyun luri.
Möve vome-tha=t lyöge-de nolyun luri.
rain make-PFV=DIR city-GEN stone-PL luminous
‘The rain made the stones of the city bright.’

8. Liaison

8.1 The hidden consonant

Some nouns once ended in a consonant that has since been lost. It is silent when the noun stands alone and is heard again in a few close places: before the copula e, after a genitive when the next word begins with a vowel, and after one of the few adjectives listed with a linker when the noun begins with a vowel. There are four of these linkers, -l-, -n-, -v- and -k-, and the one a noun takes has to be learned with the noun, as a dictionary shows it: liẅa (L) “bird”, lare (N) “kite”, nyülyu (V) “honey”, tregu (K) “music”. Most nouns have none.

(109) Tru liẅalet türa, na sey thenaatt höẅu le.
Tru liẅa-l-e=t türa, na sey thena-at=t höẅu le.
one bird-LINK-COP=DIR heron and 3AN wait-IPFV=DIR ford LOC
‘One of the birds is a heron, and it is waiting at the ford.’
(110) Larenet lyallide zhizhate.
Lare-n-e=t lyalli-de zhizhate.
kite-LINK-COP=DIR hatchling-GEN game
‘The kite is the hatchling’s plaything.’
(111) Nyülyuvet züẅande lyözo.
Nyülyu-v-e=t züẅan-de lyözo.
honey-LINK-COP=DIR bee-PL-GEN wealth
‘Honey is the bees’ wealth.’
(112) Lyöge le, treguket falete na towifru.
Lyöge le, tregu-k-e=t falete na towifru.
city LOC music-LINK-COP=DIR knowledge and joy
‘In the city, music is learning and pleasure.’

8.2 After a genitive

A genitive followed by a noun beginning with a vowel brings out the linker of the owner. The genitive suffix comes first and the linker after it.

(113) Liẅadelelo thiatt lyüshu le.
Liẅa-de-l-elo thi-at=t lyüshu le.
bird-GEN-LINK-egg exist-IPFV=DIR grass LOC
‘A bird’s egg is lying in the grass.’
(114) Fongadenenyu yöneatt wipun le.
Fonga-de-n-enyu yöne-at=t wipun le.
Phong-GEN-LINK-boat float-IPFV=DIR reed-PL LOC
‘A Phong’s boat is drifting among the reeds.’

8.3 Where there is no linker

A verb that begins with a vowel does not bring out a linker, and nor does a postposition. A noun without a linker class never takes one, whatever follows.

(115) Möli örethat yüli.
Möli öre-tha=t yüli.
Möli eat-PFV=DIR plum
‘Möli ate a plum.’
(116) Sa zore er yülipürude zore.
Sa zore e=r yülipüru-de zore.
this flower EQU=ASSUM plum.tree-GEN flower
‘This flower must be a plum blossom.’

A pause also stops the linker. In Vüwu-v-e=r möto the noun and the copula are said in one breath and the linker is heard. In Vüwu, e=r möto there is a pause after vüwu, no linker is heard. The rainbow is named first as the topic.

(117) Vüwuver Ophalrhande möto.
Vüwu-v-e=r Ophalrhan-de möto.
rainbow-LINK-COP=ASSUM Ophalrhan-GEN road
‘The rainbow might be Ophalrhan’s road.’
(118) Vüwu, er Ophalrhande möto.
Vüwu, e=r Ophalrhan-de möto.
rainbow EQU=ASSUM Ophalrhan-GEN road
‘The rainbow: it might be Ophalrhan’s road.’

9. Chains of verbs

9.1 One thing after another

Two verbs with the same subject can be joined by =l=, which means that the second event follows the first. Each verb keeps its own evidential in careful prose.

(119) Wuvomethara krethat·l·söpathat tru wu.
Wuvomethara kre-tha=t=l=söpa-tha=t tru wu.
baker lift-PFV=DIR=SS.SEQ=taste-PFV=DIR one bread
‘The baker picked up a loaf and tasted it.’
(120) Möli lyilotha·l·vögethat.
Möli lyilo-tha=l=vöge-tha=t.
Möli blink-PFV=SS.SEQ=smile-PFV=DIR
‘Möli blinked, then smiled.’

9.2 At the same time

=r= joins two verbs whose events happen together. It sounds like the assumptive =r, but it always stands between two verbs.

(121) Pölyin tuẅüatt·r·shikoatt.
Pölyin tuẅü-at=t=r=shiko-at=t.
child-PL run-IPFV=DIR=SS.SIM=laugh-IPFV=DIR
‘The children run, laughing.’
(122) Vlethara vleat·r·yayeatt.
Vlethara vle-at=r=yaye-at=t.
weaver weave-IPFV=SS.SIM=say-IPFV=DIR
‘The weaver weaves and talks.’

9.3 One evidential for the chain

When the subject and the source of knowledge stay the same, the evidential may be put only on the last verb.

(123) Lyöti tumetha·l·zhülyuthat ünode blüẅo le.
Lyöti tume-tha=l=zhülyu-tha=t üno-de blüẅo le.
Lyöti climb-PFV=SS.SEQ=rest-PFV=DIR hill-GEN height LOC
‘Lyöti climbed to the top of the hill and rested there.’

9.4 Breaking the chain

A chain must break when the subject changes, when the source of knowledge changes, or when a new speaker begins. A new subject is named, and a semicolon or na marks the break.

(124) Nadhi wöpethat nimu; Lyöti slethat so.
Nadhi wöpe-tha=t nimu; Lyöti sle-tha=t so.
Nadhi fold-PFV=DIR guest.cloth Lyöti carry-PFV=DIR 3IN
‘Nadhi folds the guest-cloth; Lyöti carries it away.’
(125) Lisha dörothat pötho; Möli örethat so.
Lisha döro-tha=t pötho; Möli öre-tha=t so.
Lisha bake-PFV=DIR steamed.cake Möli eat-PFV=DIR 3IN
‘Lisha baked a steamed cake; Möli ate it.’

10. Phrases and clauses

10.1 The order of words

The usual order is subject, verb, object, and then the phrases of place and manner. A phrase that sets the scene, such as a time of day or a season, often comes first, followed by a comma.

(126) Ulyi nena lalyeatt türa nimu le.
Ulyi nena lalye-at=t türa nimu le.
senior woman embroider-IPFV=DIR heron guest.cloth LOC
‘An old woman is embroidering a heron on a guest-cloth.’
(127) Lüye le, yeyonyimun lureatt Nemore le.
Lüye le, yeyonyimu-n lure-at=t Nemore le.
morning LOC blue.roof-PL shine-IPFV=DIR Némorath LOC
‘At the morning watch, the blue-roofed houses shine in Némorath.’

10.2 The noun phrase

Inside a noun phrase the order is: demonstrative, number, adjective, noun. A genitive comes before its noun, and a relative clause after it.

(128) Sani liny telyi goya towüatt pöẅu le.
Sani liny telyi goya towü-at=t pöẅu le.
these two small fish swim-IPFV=DIR jar LOC
‘These two little fish are swimming in the jar.’

10.3 Relative clauses

A relative clause begins with ke and follows its noun. The noun is left out of the clause when it is the subject or the object.

(129) Lyöti lenuthat sino ke tru fonga vomethat.
Lyöti lenu-tha=t sino ke tru fonga vome-tha=t.
Lyöti buy-PFV=DIR flute REL one Phong make-PFV=DIR
‘Lyöti bought a flute that a Phong had made.’
(130) Lyöti zeythat fonga ke zhareatt wesede vöra.
Lyöti zey-tha=t fonga ke zhare-at=t wese-de vöra.
Lyöti see-PFV=DIR Phong REL worship-IPFV=DIR water-GEN goddess
‘Lyöti saw a Phong who worshipped the water goddess.’

When the noun is an owner, or goes with a postposition, a pronoun stands in for it inside the clause.

(131) Nay giyethat yo ke tru yülipüru olyiatt so le.
Nay giye-tha=t yo ke tru yülipüru olyi-at=t so le.
1SG find-PFV=DIR courtyard REL one plum.tree grow-IPFV=DIR 3IN LOC
‘I found a courtyard where a plum tree grows.’
(132) Tru vey liny lyeyo le, blöko lyonyuusht ziyu ke sode melyo ne thiatt lyöge le.
Tru vey liny lyeyo le, blöko lyonyu-ush=t ziyu ke so-de melyo ne thi-at=t lyöge le.
one or two year LOC caravan bring-HAB=DIR instrument REL 3IN-GEN name NEG exist-IPFV=DIR city LOC
‘Once or twice a year a caravan brings an instrument that has no name in the city.’

10.4 Clauses after “that”

A clause that says what someone knows, hears, remembers or says begins with the.

(133) Lyöti honuthat the türan levöthan röli rokge ra.
Lyöti honu-tha=t the türan levö-tha=n röli rokge ra.
Lyöti hear-PFV=DIR COMP heron-PL come-PFV=REP again marsh ALL
‘Lyöti heard that the herons had come back to the marsh.’

10.5 Questions

A yes-or-no question has the same words as a statement and a rising voice at the end. A question word appears where the answer would be.

WordMeaning
halwho
mushwhat
vöwhere
shewhen
dhawhy
ẅehow
prenyhow many
(134) Du honuatt kipen?
Du honu-at=t kipen?
2SG hear-IPFV=DIR drum-PL
‘Do you hear the drums?’
(135) Hal dörothat sa wu?
Hal döro-tha=t sa wu?
who bake-PFV=DIR this bread
‘Who baked this bread?’
(136) Blöko relevör she?
Blöko re=levö=r she?
caravan PROSP=come=ASSUM when
‘When is the caravan coming?’
(137) Pölyin shikoatt dha?
Pölyin shiko-at=t dha?
child-PL laugh-IPFV=DIR why
‘Why are the children laughing?’
(138) Preny elo thiatt nyu le?
Preny elo thi-at=t nyu le?
how.many egg exist-IPFV=DIR basket LOC
‘How many eggs are in the basket?’

10.6 And, but, or, because

na “and”, day “but” and vey “or” join words and clauses. mena “because” begins a clause.

(139) Lyöti tizeatt, day Soki lyonyaatt.
Lyöti tize-at=t, day Soki lyonya-at=t.
Lyöti sing-IPFV=DIR but Soki dance-IPFV=DIR
‘Lyöti is singing, but Soki is dancing.’
(140) Pölyi ne lyedöatt, mena sulo lureatt seyde ẅizhu le.
Pölyi ne lyedö-at=t, mena sulo lure-at=t sey-de ẅizhu le.
child NEG sleep-IPFV=DIR because moon shine-IPFV=DIR 3AN-GEN lattice.window LOC
‘The child is not asleep, because the moon is shining in her window.’

10.7 Before, after, while

vene “before”, gelen “after” and nure “while” begin a clause of time, which usually comes first. They can also stand before a noun of time, or before so “that”: gelen so “after that”, nure so “meanwhile”.

(141) Vene salyu daslyeusht, wuvometharan ümeusht seyande büren, na eli memülmin tuẅüusht·r·sleusht lyen lyatende yonyulen le.
Vene salyu daslye-ush=t, wuvometharan üme-ush=t seyan-de büren, na eli memülmin tuẅü-ush=t=r=sle-ush=t lyen lyaten-de yonyulen le.
before sun surface-HAB=DIR baker-PL ignite-HAB=DIR 3AN.PL-GEN hearth-PL and young courier-PL run-HAB=DIR=SS.SIM=carry-HAB=DIR tablet-PL house-PL-GEN lane-PL LOC
‘Before the sun comes up, the bakers light their hearths, and young couriers run through the lanes between the houses carrying slates.’
(142) Nure möve dhuleatt, pölyin zhizhaatt ẅizhude vörlu le.
Nure möve dhule-at=t, pölyin zhizha-at=t ẅizhu-de vörlu le.
while rain fall-IPFV=DIR child-PL play-IPFV=DIR lattice.window-GEN border LOC
‘While the rain is falling, the children play by the window.’
(143) Gelen nire, liran plokuusht goyan se le.
Gelen nire, liran ploku-ush=t goyan se le.
after dusk person-PL roast-HAB=DIR fish-PL bank LOC
‘After dusk, people grill fish on the bank.’

10.8 If

A condition begins with shele “if”, and the result may begin with ru “then”.

(144) Shele shulẅo shöẅüatt lüẅo ve, ru lyöge lüweusht zoren sari.
Shele shulẅo shöẅü-at=t lüẅo ve, ru lyöge lüwe-ush=t zoren sari.
if wind blow-IPFV=DIR south ABL then city smell-HAB=DIR flower-PL SIM
‘If the wind blows from the south, the city smells of flowers.’
(145) Shele liny rulbelyate ledöatt, ru lyan nareusht maẅi lyate le lu.
Shele liny rulbelyate ledö-at=t, ru lyan nare-ush=t maẅi lyate le lu.
if two maternal.house consent-IPFV=DIR then partner-PL dwell-HAB=DIR other house LOC POSS
‘If both houses agree, the couple may live in another house.’

10.9 Nobody and nothing

Khélai has no words for “nobody” or “nothing”. It says “there is no person who …”, “there is no thing that …”. When the person is the subject anyway, ne before the verb is enough: Lira ne lyöpe-ush=t rathido vrashe shi “Nobody gains standing by revenge”.

(146) Lira ne thiatt ke faleatt yonyulede ko sey sari.
Lira ne thi-at=t ke fale-at=t yonyule-de ko sey sari.
person NEG exist-IPFV=DIR REL know-IPFV=DIR lane-GEN tradition 3AN SIM
‘Nobody knows the history of the street as she does.’
(147) So ne thiatt ke lüweatt lyöre sari.
So ne thi-at=t ke lüwe-at=t lyöre sari.
3IN NEG exist-IPFV=DIR REL smell-IPFV=DIR Opal.Mead SIM
‘Nothing smells like opal mead.’

10.10 Topic and focus

shey puts a topic in front of the sentence. A pronoun then takes its place inside. kom follows a word that is picked out against others, much as English stresses a word. A focused phrase may be moved to the front of the clause. A phrase of place or time moved there is followed by a comma.

(148) Sulo shey, so lureatt yonyule le.
Sulo shey, so lure-at=t yonyule le.
moon TOP 3IN shine-IPFV=DIR lane LOC
‘As for the moon, it is shining in the narrow lane.’
(149) Lyöti kom dörothat sa wu.
Lyöti kom döro-tha=t sa wu.
Lyöti FOC bake-PFV=DIR this bread
‘It was Lyöti who baked this bread.’
(150) Sa yonyule le kom, öman ödhüusht nyülyu.
Sa yonyule le kom, öman ödhü-ush=t nyülyu.
this lane LOC FOC merchant-PL sell-HAB=DIR honey
‘It is in this lane that the merchants sell honey.’

10.11 Adjectives after the verb

A few adjectives of size, length and speed can follow the verb phrase and say how something is done: rori “long”, miri “little”, muwi “slow”. Other adjectives are not used in this way.

(151) Ulyi rali pireatt muwi.
Ulyi rali pire-at=t muwi.
senior mammoth travel-IPFV=DIR slow
‘The old mammoth walks slowly.’
(152) Lisha thenathat soreyu le rori.
Lisha thena-tha=t soreyu le rori.
Lisha wait-PFV=DIR sanctuary.gate LOC long
‘Lisha waited a long time at the sanctuary gate.’

10.12 What a thing is made of

The ablative ve “from” also names the material a thing is made of.

(153) Sa lare vomethaut labo ve.
Sa lare vome-tha-u=t labo ve.
this kite make-PFV-PASS=DIR paper ABL
‘This kite was made of paper.’
(154) Nimu vlethaut lyuwe fülbu ve.
Nimu vle-tha-u=t lyuwe fülbu ve.
guest.cloth weave-PFV-PASS=DIR red wool ABL
‘The guest-cloth was woven of red wool.’

11. Household law

The law of the maternal houses is spoken in the habitual, because it describes what is always done.

(166) Pölyi örlyeusht seyde rulbelyate, rulbehulyo na anyeshölyu sözhewi ve.
Pölyi örlye-ush=t sey-de rulbelyate, rulbehulyo na anyeshölyu sözhewi ve.
child receive-HAB=DIR 3AN-GEN maternal.house house.name and property mother ABL
‘A child receives house, house name and property from the mother.’
(167) Shele liny rulbelyate ledöatt, ru lyan nareusht maẅi lyate le lu.
Shele liny rulbelyate ledö-at=t, ru lyan nare-ush=t maẅi lyate le lu.
if two maternal.house consent-IPFV=DIR then partner-PL dwell-HAB=DIR other house LOC POSS
‘If both houses agree, the couple may live in another house.’
(168) Shele lira lenuatt pöẅu lyanmu le, ru sey dhaleusht sode dösu vene ẅöru ta.
Shele lira lenu-at=t pöẅu lyanmu le, ru sey dhale-ush=t so-de dösu vene ẅöru ta.
if person buy-IPFV=DIR jar market LOC then 3AN pay-HAB=DIR 3IN-GEN price before evening NEC
‘If someone buys a jar in the market, she must pay its price before the evening watch.’

12. Keeping a topic going

Once something has been named, a writer can keep it in view with pronouns over several clauses without naming it again, so long as nothing else of the same class comes in between.

(173) Sokide lyalli zeythat vöwo; sey tumethat so; sey ẅekothat seyde nyon; na sey shikothat.
Soki-de lyalli zey-tha=t vöwo; sey tume-tha=t so; sey ẅeko-tha=t sey-de nyon; na sey shiko-tha=t.
Soki-GEN hatchling see-PFV=DIR swing 3AN climb-PFV=DIR 3IN 3AN wave-PFV=DIR 3AN-GEN wing-PL and 3AN laugh-PFV=DIR
‘Soki’s hatchling saw the swing; she climbed onto it; she waved her wings; and she laughed.’

13. Rarer grammatical forms

13.1 Like and is

A simile uses sari “like”. A metaphor uses the copula e, usually with the assumptive =r:

(174) Ulyi rali yöpüatt lyüshu le üno sari.
Ulyi rali yöpü-at=t lyüshu le üno sari.
senior mammoth stand-IPFV=DIR grass LOC hill SIM
‘The old mammoth stands in the grass like a hill.’
(175) Sulover lilyẅe.
Sulo-v-e=r lilyẅe.
moon-LINK-COP=ASSUM path
‘The moon might be a road.’
(176) Sulover fe.
Sulo-v-e=r fe.
moon-LINK-COP=ASSUM cup
‘The moon might be a cup.’

13.2 Images: -lye

-lye makes a noun for the image of something: a reflection, a likeness, or what is left of a sound or a touch. sulolye is the moon seen in water, tönolye the sound of a bell after it has been struck, and nyöẅolye the warmth still felt after a hand has been taken away.

(177) Sulo ne thiatt lyafüru le.
Sulo ne thi-at=t lyafüru le.
moon NEG exist-IPFV=DIR sky LOC
‘There is no moon in the sky.’
(178) Sulolye thiatt wese le.
Sulolye thi-at=t wese le.
moon.image exist-IPFV=DIR water LOC
‘The moon’s image is in the water.’
(179) Lyöti zeythat vüwulye weseenyite le.
Lyöti zey-tha=t vüwulye weseenyite le.
Lyöti see-PFV=DIR rainbow.image canal LOC
‘Lyöti saw the rainbow’s image in the canal.’
(180) Nyöẅo lowiatt nimu le.
Nyöẅo lowi-at=t nimu le.
warmth stay-IPFV=DIR guest.cloth LOC
‘Warmth stays in the guest-cloth.’
(181) Töno tizethat; tönolye lowiatt.
Töno tize-tha=t; tönolye lowi-at=t.
bell sing-PFV=DIR after-sound stay-IPFV=DIR
‘The bell rang; its note hangs on.’
(182) Wöwo lowiatt fe le.
Wöwo lowi-at=t fe le.
steam stay-IPFV=DIR cup LOC
‘Steam hangs over the cup.’
(183) Malo lowiatt sore le.
Malo lowi-at=t sore le.
incense stay-IPFV=DIR sanctuary LOC
‘The smell of resin stays in the sanctuary.’

13.3 Persons: -ya

-ya turns a thing into a person for the length of a poem or a story. The new noun is animate and is taken up by sey.

(184) Weseya zeyatr lyöge.
Weseya zey-at=r lyöge.
water.PERS see-IPFV=ASSUM city
‘The water, like a person, may be watching the city.’
(185) Ẅöru le, shulẅoya küköatr ẅizhu le, na sey löbiatr lyamu.
Ẅöru le, shulẅoya kükö-at=r ẅizhu le, na sey löbi-at=r lyamu.
evening LOC wind.PERS knock-IPFV=ASSUM lattice.window LOC and 3AN ask-IPFV=ASSUM mat
‘In the evening, the Wind knocks at the window, it seems, and asks for a mat.’

13.4 Reduplication

A verb can repeat the start of its first syllable to show that something happens in small, repeated touches: lure “shine”, lu-lure “flicker”; nöre “fade”, nö-nöre “fade little by little”. It is found mostly in poems, fairytales and other childlike language.

(186) Büre le, fare lulureatt.
Büre le, fare lu-lure-at=t.
hearth LOC fire RED-shine-IPFV=DIR
‘In the hearth the fire flickers.’
(187) Wüne nönöreatt salyu le.
Wüne nö-nöre-at=t salyu le.
dew.bead RED-fade-IPFV=DIR sun LOC
‘The dew is fading, little by little, in the sun.’

13.5 Yes and no

Songs may set a negative clause beside a positive one with the same subject. A refrain repeats a whole clause.

(188) Lyalli ne örethat üre; sey örethat pötho.
Lyalli ne öre-tha=t üre; sey öre-tha=t pötho.
hatchling NEG eat-PFV=DIR soup 3AN eat-PFV=DIR steamed.cake
‘The hatchling did not eat the soup; she ate the steamed cake.’
(189) Ophalrhan, pireim nayan dho.
Ophalrhan, pire-im nayan dho.
Ophalrhan travel-IMP 1PL COM
‘Ophalrhan, travel with us.’
(190) Threim pölyin.
Thre-im pölyin.
protect-IMP child-PL
‘Keep the children safe.’

13.6 The point of view in a passage

Because every clause has an evidential, a narrator can move from what she saw to what she supposes or has been told without saying so in separate words. In the four sentences below she sees a caravan, supposes that the mammoths are tired, and repeats what she has heard about the snow.

(191) Ẅöru le, nay zeythat blöko nolyuẅo le.
Ẅöru le, nay zey-tha=t blöko nolyuẅo le.
evening LOC 1SG see-PFV=DIR caravan bridge LOC
‘In the evening, I saw a caravan on the bridge.’
(192) Blöko pirethat lyanmu ve möge ra.
Blöko pire-tha=t lyanmu ve möge ra.
caravan travel-PFV=DIR market ABL north ALL
‘The caravan went from the market towards the north.’
(193) Ralin nar löpi.
Ralin na=r löpi.
mammoth-PL ATTR=ASSUM tired
‘The mammoths will be tired.’

13.7 Festivals

A habitual verb describes what is done at a festival every year; an imperfective describes one festival while it is going on.

(194) Ithode dhu le, loyi rulbelyate dörousht pötho, na pölyin öreusht son nolyuẅon le.
Itho-de dhu le, loyi rulbelyate döro-ush=t pötho, na pölyin öre-ush=t son nolyuẅon le.
festival-GEN night LOC every maternal.house bake-HAB=DIR steamed.cake and child-PL eat-HAB=DIR 3IN.PL bridge-PL LOC
‘On the night of the festival, every maternal house bakes a steamed cake, and the children eat them on the bridges.’
(195) Kipen nat vöyi, sinon siwüatt, na ulyi nenan lyonyaatt muwi lyonyate.
Kipen na=t vöyi, sinon siwü-at=t, na ulyi nenan lyonya-at=t muwi lyonyate.
drum-PL ATTR=DIR loud flute-PL whistle-IPFV=DIR and senior woman-PL dance-IPFV=DIR slow dance
‘The drums are loud, the flutes are whistling, and the old women are dancing a slow dance.’

14. Ways of speaking

14.1 In prayer

A prayer addresses a goddess in the imperative, the form used to ask a neighbour for something. The goddess is named first.

(196) Ophalrhan, threim Sokide lyalli möto le.
Ophalrhan, thre-im Soki-de lyalli möto le.
Ophalrhan protect-IMP Soki-GEN hatchling road LOC
‘Ophalrhan, keep Soki’s hatchling safe on the road.’
(197) Lyölulen Ophalrhan.
Lyölu-l-e=n Ophalrhan.
river.shell-LINK-COP=REP Ophalrhan
‘The river shell is Ophalrhan, so they say.’

14.2 The Phong

The Phong play games with words and with things. Hyperboreans often cannot tell whether a Phong is joking. The Phong have the ability to predict the future through symbolic play. This ability is far from perfect. They also like playing for its own sake.

(198) Fonga nayiusht lyave ẅiwen nye, danthousht lyilye dho, minausht wipudelenyu dho seyde miya sari, na gelen so löbiusht lüyede gihufüme.
Fonga nayi-ush=t lyave ẅiwen nye, dantho-ush=t lyilye dho, mina-ush=t wipu-de-l-enyu dho sey-de miya sari, na gelen so löbi-ush=t lüye-de gihufüme.
Phong give-HAB=DIR voice pebble-PL DAT dispute-HAB=DIR doorway COM speak-HAB=DIR reed-GEN-LINK-boat COM 3AN-GEN grandmother SIM and after 3IN ask-HAB=DIR morning-GEN grain.cake
‘A Phong gives voices to pebbles, argues with a doorway, talks to a reed boat as if it were her grandmother, and then asks for her breakfast.’
(199) Liny fonga vomeusht fe dela zhizhate le lu; seyan danthoushelyt the hal renyüdhör sey nye, na seyan pireushivt sey enyite le, vaẅu le.
Liny fonga vome-ush=t fe dela zhizhate le lu; seyan dantho-ush-ely=t the hal re=nyüdhö=r sey nye, na seyan pire-ush-iv=t sey enyite le, vaẅu le.
two Phong make-HAB=DIR cup monarch game LOC POSS 3AN.PL dispute-HAB-RECP=DIR COMP who PROSP=serve=ASSUM 3AN DAT and 3AN.PL travel-HAB-CAUS=DIR 3AN canal LOC leaf LOC
‘Two Phong may make a cup a monarch in a game; they argue about who is to serve her, and they send her down a canal on a leaf.’
(200) Pölyin shikoatt.
Pölyin shiko-at=t.
child-PL laugh-IPFV=DIR
‘The children laugh.’
(201) Fongali shikoatt.
Fongali shiko-at=t.
Phong.priest laugh-IPFV=DIR
‘The Phong priest laughs.’

14.3 At home

At home people speak in short sentences, and evidentials may be left out. When one is used it is usually =t:

(202) “Hal blethat ẅizhu?” “Shulẅo kom blethat so.”
“Hal ble-tha=t ẅizhu?” “Shulẅo kom ble-tha=t so.”
who open-PFV=DIR lattice.window wind FOC open-PFV=DIR 3IN
‘“Who opened the window?” “It was the wind that opened it.”’
(203) Ne zezhiim lyüẅi!
Ne zezhi-im lyüẅi!
NEG tease-IMP dog
‘Don’t tease the dog!’
(204) Ulyi nena siwüthat, na lyüẅi levöthat sey ra.
Ulyi nena siwü-tha=t, na lyüẅi levö-tha=t sey ra.
senior woman whistle-PFV=DIR and dog come-PFV=DIR 3AN ALL
‘The old woman whistled, and the dog came to her.’
(205) Karasözhewin shikothat.
Karasözhewi-n shiko-tha=t.
clan.mother-PL laugh-PFV=DIR
‘The clan mothers burst out laughing.’

15. Some sound changes

15.1 From Proto–Hyperborean (ʃir) to Khélai

Khélai descends from Proto-Hyperborean (ʃir), the language of the people who came down in the Ark. Most of the changes are regular. The ejective stops became plain stops, the glottal stop was lost, x became h, the central vowels moved forward, and l, n and z before j became the palatal sounds ly, ny and zh. u and o next to palatal sounds became ü and ö, which is why so many Khélai words have them. Consonants lost at the ends of words left behind the linkers of Chapter 8.

Proto-ʃirKhélaiMeaningChange
prakanprage (N)Arkk between vowels became g; the final n was lost but comes back as the N-linker, and the word took the ending -e
vomvomemakea vowel was added to the root
zejzeyseethe final j stayed, written y
pir, falpire, faletravel, knowthe same
xalhalwhox became h
xahaelevenx became h
muʃmushwhatregular; ʃ is written sh
preɲprenyhow manyregular; ɲ is written ny
-ux-upassive suffixx became h, and the final h was then lost

15.2 From Khélai to Toukanta

Toukanta, or Southern Cant, is a later language of the south. In Toukanta a final y became the second half of a diphthong, stressed e and u broke into two vowels, th and dh became s and z, h was lost, and so were most stops and fricatives at the ends of syllables, though nasals and liquids stayed. The evidentials became suffixes on the verb, and the linkers grew into a larger system that also tracks a change of subject.

KhélaiToukantaMeaning
naynaiI
seyseishe, he
daydaibut
veyveior
menaməinabecause
gelengəilənafter
venevəinəbefore
ruɾouthen
nurenouɾəwhile

Abbreviations

GlossMeaning
1SG, 1PLI, we
2SG, 2PLyou
3AN, 3AN.PLshe, he, they (animate)
3IN, 3IN.PLit, they (inanimate)
ABLablative ve “from”
ALLallative ra “to”
ASSUMassumptive =r
ATTRattributive copula na
CAUScausative -iv
COMcomitative dho “with”
COMPcomplementiser the “that”
COMPLcompletive -omp
COPcopula e after a linker
DATdative nye “to, for”
DIRdirect evidential =t
EQUequational copula e
FOCfocus kom
GENgenitive -de
HABhabitual -ush
IMPimperative -im
INCEPinceptive -isk
INFERinferential =s
INSinstrumental shi
IPFVimperfective -at
LINKlinker -l-, -n-, -v-, -k-
LOClocative le
NECnecessity ta
NEGnegative ne
ORDordinal -ri
PASSpassive -u
PERSperson-making -ya
PFVperfective -tha
PLplural -n
POSSpossibility lu
PROSPprospective re=
RECPreciprocal -ely
REDrepeated first syllable
REFLreflexive -om
RELrelative ke
REPreportative =n
RESresultative me=
SIMsari “like”
SS.SEQsame subject, one after the other =l=
SS.SIMsame subject, at the same time =r=
TOPtopic shey
VOLvolitional the “wants to”

Nözibevo, a list of omens in Classical Khélai

Ho karade lin södhethan Nözibevo ẅeshi lyeyon le.
The priests of the six clans are said to have written the Sign-Book over many years.

Loyi nözibede melyo, nöbu na söẅewösre thiatt so le.
Each omen has its name, its sign and its judgment.

Rulbede lablörlordhülo na fösite, Matrilineal law

Kara, anyeshölyu na melyo pireusht sözhewin ve pölyin ra.
Clan, property and name pass from mothers to children.

Dödhewu nayiusht waslyengülyuren ewöran nye, na so zhönyüusht son röli.
The council gives mandates to officeholders, and it takes them back again.

Ewöra ne dhömgüusht; sey nyüdhöusht rulbelyaten.
An officeholder does not rule; she serves the maternal houses.

Nözibe ne vomeusht tru dela, na so ne nayiusht pölyin yerüẅun nye.
An omen does not make anyone a monarch, and it does not hand children over to strangers.

Pölyi ne örlyeusht nözibede kuhite; rulbelyate mürvuusht sey.
A child does not take the blame for an omen; the maternal house brings her up.

1. Lyafürude nöbun, Signs of the sky

001 sulofarle, The Crowned Moon

Shele sulo daslyeatt farle dho,
If the moon rises with a halo,

ru ulyi rulbelyate relyöper rathido dödhewu le; so reẅepüdher sode thepabe karasözhewin nye ta.
then the senior maternal house will gain precedence in the council; it must proclaim its claim to the clan mothers.

002 lüyege, The Morning Shadow

Shele salyude yilo thiatt lüye le,
If the sun is darkened in the morning watch,

ru röpti rulbelyatede ryofridhotivlashe hesüatur; karasözhewin revirer dödhewu le ta, na seyan renyölyar lyesa ta.
then the succession of a great maternal house is under threat; the clan mothers must meet in council and choose a successor.

003 ẅörunyomru, The Evening Plague

Shele salyude yilo thiatt ẅöru le,
If the sun is darkened in the evening watch,

ru nyomru rehesür lyögen; rulbelyaten rebler wöẅon höwi liran nye na lyatenali liran nye ta.
then plague will threaten the towns; the maternal houses must open their storehouses to the sick and the homeless.

004 silyfleyilo, The Wrong-Way Dark

Shele yilode ge pireatt üde ve zöku ra,
If the shadow of the darkening moves from east to west,

ru röpti zazhute rehesür lyögen; ho kara revomer pleunen na lyüshe gihu ta.
then a great flood will threaten the towns; the six clans must make places of shelter and a common store of grain.

005 nyoshpeyofuyoru, The Obscured Heart

Shele yilo freiskt salyu yoru ve,
If the dark begins to hide the sun from its centre outward,

ru dödhewude ulyi karasözhewi regöror vey rezhamur seyde waslyengülyure lu; Tiriyade luẅidhete le, Tyre hesüatur.
then the senior clan mother of the council may die or lose her mandate; in the Tyrian reading, Tyre itself is in danger.

006 lyoyililyẅe, The Raven’s Path

Shele lyoyide saro levöthat salyude lilyẅe ra,
If the Raven Star reaches the path of the sun,

ru ünede dösu rezheẅür na öman redikrar; lyanmupulyan reminar so karade dödhewun nye ta.
then prices will fall and the merchants will protest; the market keepers must tell the clan councils.

007 zelyotumunto, The Yoke Ascendant

Shele zelyode saro yöpüatt lyafürude blüẅo le,
If the Yoke Star stands high in the sky,

ru rünye reözher; rulbelyaten remazhir nupen na rehinyöẅer bilye gihu ta.
then the harvest will grow; the maternal houses must keep back seed and share out the grain that is left over.

008 lyalyusaro, The Right-Hand Star

Shele saro zöẅithat sulode lyalyu ve sulode ẅölyo ra,
If a star flashes from the right of the moon to its left,

ru lipode pirete nar löyi; day karasözhewin remeẅir sode ẅeli ta.
then the war expedition has good signs; but the clan mothers must appoint its captain.

009 ẅölyosaro, The Left-Hand Star

Shele saro zöẅithat sulode ẅölyo ve sulode lyalyu ra,
If a star flashes from the left of the moon to its right,

ru lipode pirete nar kuhi; karasözhewin rezhönyür sode ẅeli ta.
then the expedition has bad signs; the clan mothers must recall its captain.

010 woshwuyölinöbu, The Cloud-Lion

Shele woshwu thiatt yöli sari lyafüru le,
If a cloud stands in the sky like a lion,

ru elwi rulbelyate reyeyür bilye külyebüẅun lyüshe liran ve; maẅi rulbelyaten relyüsör so ta.
then a strong maternal house will take too much in levies from the common people; the other houses must look into it.

Note: A “lion” resembles a terror bird.

011 woshwuralinöbu, The Cloud-Mammoth

Shele woshwu thiatt rali sari lyafüru le,
If a cloud stands in the sky like a mammoth,

ru züyi rulbelyate redanthor rathido dödhewu le; dödhewu rerüẅör thepabe honute le ta.
then a rival maternal house will dispute precedence in the council; the council must settle the claim at a hearing.

012 lyuwelyalydhu, The Red Dust

Shele lyuwelyalydhu daslyeatt üde le,
If red dust rises in the east,

ru lipo rehesür linylode rulbelyaten; karasözhewin revaner renyitede dödhewu ta.
then fighting will threaten the allied houses; the clan mothers must call a council of reconciliation.

013 lyatkulyalydhu, The White Dust

Shele lyatkulyalydhu daslyeatt,
If white dust rises,

ru rünye na zefu hesüatur; rulbelyaten relühar gihu wöẅon ve lyüri lyaten nye ta.
then the harvest and the silver are under threat; the maternal houses must give grain from the storehouses to poor households.

014 piyulaye, Winter Thunder

Shele laye honuatut piyu le,
If thunder is heard in winter,

ru dödhewude kozisheya renunzhor dödhewu lu; sözhewin reyeyür lyüshe fösite ta.
then a council’s entrusted speaker may betray it; the mothers must demand testimony in public.

015 linyfarle, The Double Halo

Shele liny farle thiatt salyu le,
If the sun has two halos,

ru liny rulbelyate redanthor tru dödhewude melyo; dödhewu ne reörlyer thepabe ta, shele karasözhewin ne ledöthar.
then two maternal houses will dispute one council title; the council must not accept a claim the clan mothers have not consented to.

016 blüẅoẅörusaro, The High Evening Star

Shele ẅörude saro yöpüatt blüẅo le,
If the evening star stands high,

ru lyüte, eslute na linylon reözher; day lipo remoler dödhewude söẅewösre le.
then love, births and alliances will increase; but war stays a matter for the council’s judgment.

017 silyflelyuwesaro, The Reversing Red Star

Shele lyuwesaro thowuatt,
If the red star turns back,

ru köẅi linylode rulbelyaten rezhönyür sonde ledöte lu, na fare repirer vörlude lyizen le lu.
then distant allied houses may withdraw their consent, and fire may spread through the border fields.

018 liresulo, The Missing Moon

Shele sulo ne zeyatut truri efo le,
If the moon is not seen on the first day,

ru karade vöran nar ẅüyi; rulbelyaten relyöneyör na rezarer renyite ta.
then the goddesses of the clans are angry; the maternal houses must mourn and seek reconciliation.

019 nalyodhu, The Bright Night

Shele nalyo thiatt dhu le,
If there is a brightness in the night,

ru dödhewu refaler ewörade vey rulbepulyade lümi tüvifemfo.
then the council will learn of hidden misuse of office by an officeholder or a keeper of a lineage.

020 lyögeyadübe, City Starfall

Shele yadüben dhuleatt lyöge le,
If stars fall around the city,

ru lyögede zushan renunzhor seyande waslyengülyure lu; sözhewin relyüsör seyande ẅelide lyönemthrithanyo ta.
then the city guards may betray their mandate; the mothers must examine the appointment of their captain.

2. Thare na lyögede nöbun, Signs of the land and the city

021 blüẅolyöge, The High City

Shele lyöge ke thiatt üno le lureatt dhu le,
If a city on a hill shines at night,

ru lyöge relyöper rathido maẅi lyögen dho; day rulbelyaten revomer so lyülelyumon shi ta.
then the city will gain standing among other cities; but the houses must win it by agreements.

022 woyu, The Silent Gate

Shele lyögede yu ne nükeatt,
If the city gate does not creak,

ru üne redüvyör; lyögede sözhewin reniper blökomöton na rethrer lyüri lyaten ta.
then trade will fail; the city’s mothers must mend the caravan roads and protect the poor households.

023 linnyogömiye, The Weeping Wall

Shele linnyo thiiskt gömiye le,
If tears begin to show on the wall,

ru thile na pawu relevör; rulbelyaten revomer gihu na pleunen ta.
then siege and grief are coming; the maternal houses must make ready grain and shelter.

024 lüẅewürlye, The Fungus Crown

Shele lüẅe olyiatt kelythodödhewude nyimu le,
If fungus grows on the roof of the imperial assembly,

ru elwi rulbelyatede söẅewösre memokör; maẅi rulbelyaten revaner lyüsöte ta.
then the judgment of a powerful maternal house has gone rotten; the other houses must call an inquiry.

025 wolyireyo, The Owl’s Court

Shele wolyi nareatt sovarande reyo le,
If an owl lives in the ancestors’ archive,

ru tru sovarande lyu redüẅur rulbede thepabe vey resrer lümi ryofridhotivlashe.
then a record of the ancestors will change a lineage’s claim or bring a hidden succession to light.

026 yüẅulyebüre, The Broken Hearth

Shele zhorenyade büre zheyuthat lathi,
If the smith’s hearth goes cold,

ru tharo rezhamur sode zhoren lipo le lu; sözhewin redönyer lipode pirete röli ta.
then the army may lose its swords in battle; the mothers must judge the war expedition again.

027 lyuwilyilye, The Snake’s Path

Shele lyuwi pirethat lyilye ve lyate ra,
If a snake goes over the threshold into the house,

ru ẅözha meedhür dödhewude ralyi minate ra.
then a spy has got into the council’s secret talks.

028 linyge, The Double Shadow

Shele tru lirade liny ge thiatt lyöẅe le,
If one person has two shadows at noon,

ru seyde kara nyaneatur; rulbelyate relyüsör sa nözibe ta, vene dödhewu dönyeatr.
then their clan is divided; the maternal house must look into the omen before the council gives judgment.

029 plonlyenyenyo, The Bloody Well

Shele nyenyode wese zheyuthat lyuwe,
If the water of a well turns red,

ru tharo retawur lyöge lu; rulbelyaten rethrer na rehinyöẅer lyüshe gihu ta.
then an army may attack the city; the maternal houses must guard the common grain and share it out.

030 lerulyüẅinöbu, The Ghost Dog

Shele lyüẅi zohiatt yonyule le, day lira ne thiatt so le,
If a dog barks in a lane where there is no one,

ru nyomrude lerun thiatr lyöge le; rulbelyaten rethrer höwi liran zane shi na rüfete shi ta.
then plague spirits are in the city; the maternal houses must protect the sick with prayer and with healing.

031 tohtethululethünshe, The Reversed River

Shele tohtethu pireatt ithire ra,
If a river flows back toward the mountains,

ru wesede lablörlordhülo medüẅur; züyi rulbelyaten revomer eyi vörlulyülelyumon ta.
then the law of the waters has changed; rival maternal houses must make new boundary agreements.

032 nyöyolyize, The Salted Field

Shele nyöyo thiatt lyize le,
If there is salt in a field,

ru rünye hesüatur; sözhewin rethrer nupen ta, eyi zamu nye.
then the harvest is under threat; the mothers must protect the seed for the new season.

033 nolyulöle, The Stone Birth

Shele nolyu thiatt eyi pölyide nyilo le,
If there is a stone in a newborn’s cradle,

ru pölyi rezheyur elwi; rulbelyate relutrir sey ta.
then the child will grow strong; the maternal house must teach her.

034 lyulalyüẅallyu, The Fox’s Laugh

Shele lyula shikoatt rumen le,
If a fox laughs among the ruins,

ru liran reavör lyöge, na gize reedhür so.
then the people will leave the city, and the forest will come into it.

035 lyorulyanmu, The Empty Market

Shele lyanmupevun düvyöthat, day shulẅo ne thiatt,
If market stalls fall down when there is no wind,

ru lyanmude lyülelyumo redüvyör lu; dödhewun relyüsör lyinyen, zuken na lyüshe wöẅon ta.
then the market agreement may fail; the councils must examine the weights, the debts and the common storehouses.

036 liẅalipo, The Birds of War

Shele liẅan vigaatt shilyenyo shi dödhewulyate le,
If birds fly in a formation over the council house,

ru lipode dödhewu revirer sa efo le ta; ẅeli ne repirer ta, shele karasözhewin ne rövethar.
then the war council must meet that very day; no captain may march unless the clan mothers have allowed it.

037 liẅapölyso, The Birds of Peace

Shele liẅan vigaatt sloregi möto le ẅölyo ra,
If birds fly in a circle toward the left,

ru karasözhewin repireivr zan ta, na reher seyande lipode ẅelin ta.
then the clan mothers must send negotiators and hold back their war captains.

038 lyüleyölne, The Black Mould

Shele lyüleyölne nümuatt mögede gömiye,
If black mould covers the north wall,

ru tru rulbe ne nyüdhöthar sovaran; sode rulbelyate renayir wündhelso ta.
then a lineage has failed in its duty to the ancestors; its maternal house must make amends.

039 lyatkuyölne, The White Mould

Shele lyatkuyölne nümuatt lüẅode gömiye,
If white mould covers the south wall,

ru lerun nar lali; löyi efon relevör.
then the spirits are at peace; good days will come.

040 rolelolu, The Cracking Tower

Shele lolu shotethat blüẅo ve thare ra,
If a tower cracks from top to ground,

ru eli lin reükör ulyi linde söẅewösren; sorepulyan revirer honute le ta.
then younger priests will object to the rulings of the senior priests; the sanctuary custodians must meet for a hearing.

041 rabulyaso, The Whispering Floor

Shele lyaso nükeusht dhu le,
If the floor creaks over and over at night,

ru lerun lyonyaatr; li relyuver son ta.
then ghosts are dancing; a priest must drive them out.

042 lyebuyöẅo, The Lost Key

Shele lyögede yöẅo zhamuthaut,
If the city key is lost,

ru tru yupulya menunzhor tru rulbelyate; sözhewin relyüsör yun na sonde zushan ta.
then a keeper of the gates has betrayed a maternal house; the mothers must examine the gates and their guards.

043 ẅölyterulyo, The Found Coin

Shele shayödi rulyo giyethaut yonyule le,
If an ancient coin is found in a lane,

ru lyözo ke liran methar rethowur tru rulbe ra; sözhewin renöder sovarande thepabe ta.
then wealth that people had forgotten will return to a lineage; the mothers must test the ancestral claim.

044 yerüẅusolyu, The Stranger’s Face

Shele yerüẅude solyu et tru kozisheyade solyu,
If a stranger’s face is the face of an entrusted speaker,

ru kisothara zareatr kozisheyade melyo vey waslyengülyure.
then a pretender is after the title or the mandate of that speaker.

045 nyölyyonürlo, The Dry Fountain

Shele lyüshe nürlo zheyuthat nyölyyo,
If a public fountain runs dry,

ru Ophalrhan meavör wesepulyan; Ophalrhande sözhewin redivar eyitede zanen ta.
then Ophalrhan has left the water keepers; the Ophalrhan mothers must lead the prayers of renewal.

046 helyuẅösro, The Overflowing Cup

Shele wese avöatt ẅösro ve, day lira ne lyödethat so,
If water spills from a cup that no one has filled,

ru lyözo relevör; day liran renekrur nyüvlu ta.
then plenty will come; but people must beware of drunkenness.

047 yüẅulyebo, The Broken Mirror

Shele bo shotethat, day lira ne ranüthat so,
If a mirror cracks when no one has touched it,

ru karade lyaẅo mefrerur; rulbelyate rezarer renyite ta, vene so dönyeatr.
then a bond of kinship has broken; the maternal house must seek reconciliation before it gives any judgment.

048 yelyiẅeleyo, The Unseen Knocker

Shele leyo honuatut yu le, day lira ne thiatt yu le,
If there is knocking at the gate and no one is there,

ru göle thenaatr yu le.
then death is waiting at the gate.

049 nyeyiruẅeyanöbu, The Swarming Ants

Shele ẅeyade nyeyiru thiatt dödhewulyate le,
If a swarm of ants is in the council house,

ru dödhewude ulyi rulbelyatede züyin nar ẅeshi; day seyan nar löni.
then the leading maternal house of the council has many rivals; but they are weak.

050 dölyelilanöbu, The Lone Wolf

Shele tru lila edhüthat lyöge ra,
If a single wolf comes into the city,

ru röpti yerüẅu melevör; karasözhewin redhöshar yerüẅude nyüdhöten na thepaben ta.
then a stranger of great weight has arrived; the clan mothers must decide what the stranger owes and what the stranger may claim.

051 yadübelyate, The Falling Star (Urban)

Shele saro dhulethat tru lyate ra,
If a star falls on a house,

ru sa rulbelyate redüvyör vey relyöper röpti rathido; sode pulyan rezarer maẅi luẅidhete ta.
then that maternal house will either fall or rise to great standing; its keepers must seek a further reading.

052 kölyelyafüru, The Green Sky

Shele lyafüru zheyuthat kölye ẅöru le,
If the sky turns green at sunset,

ru elwi nelyshun relevör, vey lümi nöbu redhuler lyafüru ve.
then great storms will come, or something hidden will fall from the sky.

053 lyuwetohtethu, The Red River

Shele tohtethu zheyuthat lyuwe,
If a river turns red,

ru lipo vey nyomru thiatr ithire le.
then there is war or plague in the mountains.

054 mulyilulyasu, The Frozen Summer

Shele lyasu thiatt mulyilu le,
If there is frost in summer,

ru zamunde liye mefrerur; rulbelyaten rethrer gihu na wese ta, vene liye thowuatr.
then the round of the seasons is broken; the maternal houses must guard grain and water until the round returns.

055 yarunyenyo, The Boiling Well

Shele nyenyode wese satuatt,
If the water of a well boils,

ru fare pireatr thare le, vey leru thiatr nyenyo le.
then fire is moving under the ground, or a spirit is in the well.

056 thürnyunolyu, The Singing Stone

Shele nolyun tizeatt,
If stones hum,

ru thare zireiskr; so relyüthlur lu.
then the earth is beginning to wake; it may shake.

057 plonlyelinnyu, The Bleeding Tree

Shele linnyude ẅimu thiatt plonlye sari,
If the sap of a tree is like blood,

ru thare mediẅöur; rulbelyaten revomer lave ke dödhewu rövethar ta; lira ne reküzar ta, shele dödhewu ne rövethar.
then the land has been wounded; the maternal houses must make an offering the council has appointed, and no one may kill unless the council allows it.

058 nyiyolyülyẅanyu, The Sudden Fog

Shele lyülyẅanyu nümuatt lyöge lyöẅe le,
If fog covers the city at noon,

ru vöran freatr tru nöbu; liran rethenar ta.
then the goddesses are hiding a sign; people must wait.

059 liẅalyate, The Bird in the House

Shele tru liẅa vigathat lyate ra,
If a bird flies into a house,

ru lyösu relevör köẅi möto ve, na so relyonyur göle vey düẅute.
then news will come along a distant road, and it will bring a death or a change.

060 lüyilyönybo, The Rat King

Shele lüyinde nyörden meheut,
If rats are found with their tails tied together,

ru ralyi linylo na nyomru thiatr.
then there is a secret alliance, and plague.

3. Waflülimshu na lyilyede nöbun, Signs of the entrails and the threshold

061 linyyoru, The Double Heart

Shele liny yoru thiatt lave le,
If there are two hearts in the offering,

ru ulyi karasözhewi relütar rori; seyde rulbe reözher.
then a senior clan mother will live long, and her lineage will grow.

062 silyfleshalye, The Reversed Liver

Shele lavede shalye thiatt silyfle sari,
If the liver of the offering lies the wrong way round,

ru göle hesüatr tru nafi, tru rulöbade pölyi, vey tru kozisheya ke rulbe meẅithar.
then death threatens a mother’s brother, a sister’s child, or a speaker the lineage has appointed.

063 plonlyelyize, The Bleeding Field

Shele plonlye avöatt thare ve, nure liran reatt so,
If blood comes out of the soil while people are cutting into it,

ru moköte hesüatr thare; sözhewin rethrer rünyede dhavin ta, na relühar gihu lyaten nye ta.
then rot threatens the land; the mothers must protect the harvest workers and give grain to the households.

064 wolenyinöbu, The Silent Frog

Shele lenyi zeyatut, day sey ne gözhüatt,
If a frog is seen but does not croak,

ru wese rezheyur nyölyyo; tru gu regöror.
then the water will dry up; a stream will die.

065 raligo, The Dream of the Mammoth

Shele lira ürzethat rali,
If someone dreams of a mammoth,

ru sey rezheyur zanyümi na elwi.
then that person will become rich and strong.

066 yugo, The Dream of the Gate

Shele lira ürzethat yu ke bleatomt,
If someone dreams of a gate opening,

ru seyde üne reözher; sey repirer köẅi möton le.
then that person’s trade will grow; they will travel distant roads.

067 mövafeyilöle, The Birth of the Chimera

Shele pölyi esluthaut mövafeyide solyu dho,
If a child is born with the face of a chimera,

ru dödhewu relöbir lin ta; liran rethrer sözhewi na eyi pölyi ta; nözibe ne redamfur seyan ta.
then the council must ask the priests; people must protect the mother and the newborn; the omen must not punish them.

068 nyördepölyinöbu, The Child with a Tail

Shele eyi pölyide nyörde thiatt,
If a newborn has a tail,

ru dödhewude ulyi rulbelyatede waslyengülyure renörer lu; liran ne redhüpar eyi pölyi ta.
then the mandate of the council’s leading maternal house may fade; no one may blame the newborn.

069 lyüẅiyasre, The Dog in the Bed

Shele lyüẅi thiatt dhenyözhenprade yasre le,
If a dog is lying in an elder’s bed,

ru rulbelyatende linylo hesüatur; rulbede dhenyözhenpran rethrer sode liran ta.
then an alliance of households is under threat; the elders of the lineage must protect its people.

070 röyebo, The Falling Mirror

Shele bo dhulethat, day so ne freruthat,
If a mirror falls and does not break,

ru tru kozisheya renunzhor dödhewu lu; rulbelyaten rehonur fösite ta, vene seyan damfuatr.
then an entrusted speaker may betray a council; the houses must hear testimony before they punish anyone.

071 töblühunzhewese, The Water Stutter

Shele zhuro na wese virethaelyt, day son zufeompelyt,
If oil and water mix and then part completely,

ru lin mevirer liny nöbu; maẅi ẅayin redönyer sonde tharnyiyu röli ta.
then the priests have run two signs together; other witnesses must judge their prophecy again.

072 lyüledanyözane, The Black Liaison

Shele danyözane ne thithat kozisheyade rölyo le, nure sey pabiatt kelythode lablörlordhülo,
If the linking sound is missing from a speaker’s words while she reads out imperial law,

ru dödhewude lyülelyumo refrerur lu.
then the council’s compact may break.

073 silyfletohtethu, The Wrong-Way River

Shele tohtethu pireiskt ithire ra,
If a river begins to flow toward the mountains,

ru kelytho mezhamur vörande wuwe; sözhewin redönyer sode lyülelyumon röli ta.
then the empire has lost the favour of the goddesses; the mothers must judge its compacts again.

074 böẅenyfilyömo, The Phoenix Sighting

Shele lira zeythat böẅenyfi,
If someone sees the phoenix,

ru eyi yeyüthara redaslyer, na sey rezarer dödhewude melyo; dödhewun regöbir ryofridhotivlashe ke so ne rövethar ta.
then a new claimant will appear and seek a council title; the councils must refuse any succession they have not allowed.

075 woliru, The Silent Crowd

Shele röpti liru zheyuthat söfi,
If a great crowd falls silent,

ru rulbelyaten mevomer ralyi linylo lyüshe dödhewu ve.
then maternal houses have made a secret alliance away from the public council.

076 yüẅulyethore, The Broken Footprint

Shele thore zeyatut, day sode tru lizhu ne thiatt,
If a footprint is seen with one toe missing,

ru tru pirethara rezhamur seyde lyatede möto lu; seyde rulbelyate revomer thretede zanen sey nye ta.
then a traveller may lose the road home; her maternal house must say prayers of protection for her.

077 lyafüruthirye, The Sky-Shear

Shele fongan zeythan zekasi nöbu lyafüru le,
If the Phong are reported to have seen a strange sign in the sky,

ru matuklarunde selyu freruiskr.
then the veil of the other worlds is beginning to tear.

078 spöẅonyötoshilyenyo, The Breaker Pattern

Shele tru shilyenyo shoteatt ẅeshi shilyenyon ra, na loyi shilyenyo düvyöatt,
If a pattern splits into many patterns and every one of them falls apart,

ru kelythodödhewude dödhewun redüvyör lu; rulbelyaten retelyanler sonde nyüdhöte ta.
then the councils of the imperial assembly may fail together; the maternal houses must keep up their own duties.

079 lyörelyiso, The Opal Mead

Shele lyöre ne lülaatt wese le,
If Opal Mead will not dissolve in water,

ru linde waslyengülyure nöreatr; karasözhewin rehonur na relyüsör seyande thepaben ta.
then the priests’ authority is fading; the clan mothers must hear their claims and examine them.

080 salyupulnye, The Sun’s Tooth

Shele lyülemülyo thiatt salyu le,
If there is a small black spot on the sun,

ru ralyi liran wöniatr the seyan reküzar ulyi karasözhewi vey seyde kozisheya.
then people are secretly planning to kill a senior clan mother or her entrusted speaker.

081 paẅeẅule, The Twisted Cord

Shele eyi pölyide ẅule thiatt seyde nayu le,
If a newborn has the cord round its neck,

ru ẅeshi nariyande thepaben heatr pölyi; rulbelyate rerüẅör thepaben ta, na rethrer pölyi ta.
then the claims of many relatives bind the child; the maternal house must settle the claims and look after the child.

082 lyatkushalye, The White Liver

Shele lavede shalye zheyuthat lyatku,
If the liver of the offering turns pale,

ru gihude lire relevör thare le.
then there will be no grain in the land.

083 lyüleshalye, The Black Liver

Shele lavede shalye zheyuthat lyüle,
If the liver of the offering turns black,

ru nyomru vey Róskaïde ẅüyite relevör.
then plague will come, or the anger of Róskaï.

084 linylyürolyelanöbu, The Two-Headed Calf

Shele lyela esluthaut liny lyüro dho,
If a calf is born with two heads,

ru kelythodödhewu nyaneatur lu; sözhewin rezarer eyi pölysode lyülelyumo ta.
then the imperial assembly may split; the mothers must seek a new compact of peace.

085 lirelyürolöle, The Headless Birth

Shele pölyi esluthaut, day seyde lyüro ne thiatt,
If a child is born without a head,

ru ulyi rulbede ryofridhotivlashe hesüatur; dödhewu revomer so eyi ta.
then the succession of the senior lineage is under threat; the council must make it new.

086 rölyowaflülimshu, The Speaking Entrails

Shele yore honuatut lave ve,
If a sound is heard from the offering,

ru tru vöra nöyeatr rulbelyate ke lave mazhiatt; lin reminar so sözhewin nye ta.
then a goddess is warning the maternal house that keeps the offering; the priests must tell the mothers.

087 lyüẅallyudilyu, The Laughing Skull

Shele dilyu giyethaut, na so vögeatt,
If a skull is found and it is smiling,

ru sovaran shikoatr; kuhi efon relevör.
then the ancestors are laughing; bad days will come.

088 plonlyefiyasinu, The Bleeding Stone (Visceral)

Shele plonlye avöatt fiyasinu ve,
If blood comes out of the sacrificial stone,

ru vöra megöbir lave; sorepulyan relöbir rulbelyate ke rövethar so ta.
then the goddess has refused the offering; the sanctuary custodians must ask the maternal house that allowed it.

089 lirelerarẅöflu, The Missing Gallbladder

Shele lerarẅöflu ne thiatt lave le,
If there is no gallbladder in the offering,

ru tharo reörlyer yemnyi düvyöte; sözhewin redhöshar sode ẅelide waslyengülyure ta.
then the army will meet a bitter defeat; the mothers must decide on the mandate of its captain.

090 bilyesilyo, The Extra Limb

Shele pölyi esluthaut bilye silyo dho,
If a child is born with an extra limb,

ru liran rethrer pölyi ta; dödhewu relyüsör löle gewi ta; maẅi lirande wure nar blaki lu, na liran ne redamfur pölyi ta.
then people must look after the child; the council must look into the birth patiently; what others say about it may be false, and no one may punish the child.

091 lyuwiyazo, The Serpent in the Womb

Shele lyuwi thiatt lavede yazo le,
If there is a snake in the womb of the offering,

ru elwi leru edhüatr rulbe ra lu; liran rethrer sözhewi na eyi pölyi ta, vene lin luẅidheompr.
then a strong spirit may be entering the lineage; people must protect the mother and the newborn until the priests have finished their reading.

092 nolyuyoru, The Stone Heart

Shele lavede yoru zheyuthat nolyu,
If the heart of the offering has turned to stone,

ru tru ewöra mezhamur nesishne; karasözhewin renöyer sey vey rezhönyür sey ta.
then an officeholder has lost mercy; the clan mothers must warn her or recall her.

093 lyarlyulüru, The Blind Eye

Shele lyülyẅanyu thiatt lavede lüru le,
If there is a fog in the eye of the offering,

ru söẅewösre memokör; rulbede nipünyiyun rebler honuten röli ta, na remazhir fösite ta.
then judgment has gone rotten; the courts of the lineages must open their hearings again and keep the testimony.

094 lyüẅoyelyu, The Deaf Ear

Shele lavede yelyun nat zekasi,
If the ears of the offering are misshapen,

ru soren ne örlyethar tru thösüte; sorepulyan relyüsör zanen ta.
then the sanctuaries have failed to receive a petition; the sanctuary custodians must examine the prayers.

095 lyameraye, The Tongueless Mouth

Shele lizho ne thiatt lavede raye le,
If there is no tongue in the mouth of the offering,

ru liran fleatr lyüshe rölyo; sözhewin rethrer ẅayin na thösüte ta.
then public speech is being shut off; the mothers must protect witnesses and the right to petition.

096 tolyupölyinöbu, The Horned Child

Shele pölyi esluthaut tolyun dho,
If a child is born with horns,

ru pölyi rezheyur divathara lu; rulbelyate remürvur sey ta, na nözibe ne dhöshaatr seyde lyeyon.
then the child may become a leader; the maternal house must bring her up, and the omen does not decide her years.

097 lyafolörüre, The Scaled Skin

Shele lyafon thiatt eyi pölyide lörüre le,
If a newborn has scales on its skin,

ru nawi walude lümi lyaẅo thiatr sey le; liran relöbir fongan na numiyan ta, na liran ne redhüpar pölyi ta.
then there may be a hidden tie between the child and the deep ocean; people must ask the Phong and the Numi, and no one may blame the child.

098 yeyoplonlye, The Blue Blood

Shele lavede plonlye nat yeyo,
If the blood of the offering is blue,

ru ulyi rulbe hesüatur; sode nenan rethrer sode liran na revomer uyi ryofridhotivlashe ta.
then a senior lineage is under threat; its women must look after its people and make a lawful succession.

099 lyoruyazo, The Empty Womb

Shele lavede yazo nat lyoru,
If the womb of the offering is empty,

ru eyi rewose hesüatur; gihu, pleune na sözhewinde na pölyinde liyüthe reörlyer rathido ta.
then the next generation is under threat; food, shelter and care for mothers and children must come first.

4. Rölyo na matuklarunde nöbun, Signs of speech and of the other worlds

100 lyöẅolyuwinöbu, The Twin Serpent

Shele liny lyuwi heatelyt,
If two snakes are wound round each other,

ru shele seyan lütaatt, rüfete na pölyin reözher; shele seyan megörot, rulbe refrerur lu, na lyate rezharer vöran ta.
then, if they are alive, healing and children will increase; if they are dead, a lineage may break, and the household must pray to the goddesses.

101 liyeshilyenyo, The Cycle Pattern

Shele wesen na gihun pireatt liye le,
If water and grain move round in a cycle,

ru liye remayer, shele lyaten mazhiatr sonde nyüdhöte na hinyöẅeatelyr.
then the cycle will last, if the households keep their duties and share with one another.

102 ẅolyolinöbu, The Mediator

Shele lyoli pireatt maẅi lyögen le, na sey heatt son,
If a wanderer goes between different cities and binds them together,

ru tru ya revomer pölysode lyülelyumo eyi lu.
then a mediator may renew the compact of peace.

103 vörluloẅinöbu, The Edge-Folk

Shele loẅin nareatt vörlun le,
If people are living on the borders,

ru düẅute relevör vörlude nariyan ve na lyatenali liran ve; dödhewu rehonur seyande thepaben ta.
then change will come from kin on the borders and from people without houses; the council must hear their claims.

104 yumo, The Gate Flow

Shele mo pireatt lyire ve,
If a current flows out of a lyira,

ru lyiren relyonyur lyözo vey sorite; rulbelyaten reder muröfiye na rethrer piretharan ta.
then the lyira passages will bring wealth or danger; the maternal houses must measure out the crossing and protect the travellers.

105 süsernirẅurolu, The Telepathic Echo

Shele lira honuatt maẅi lirade tho,
If someone hears another person’s thought,

ru fongan minaatelyr süsernirẅu shi lu; dödhewu resödher tho zeyte ve ta.
then Phong may be talking to one another mind to mind; the council must record the thought apart from what was seen.

106 lyüshego, The Shared Dream

Shele ẅeshi liran ürzethat ami go,
If many people dream the same dream,

ru maẅi ẅayin redöbir lyüshego ta, vene so heatr dödhewu.
then separate witnesses must describe the shared dream before it can bind a council.

107 lerulyave, The Ghost Voice

Shele lira honuatt lyaven shulẅo le,
If someone hears voices in the wind,

ru tru sovara minaatr lu; lin resödher lyave ke liran honuthat, sode toyete ve ta.
then an ancestor may be speaking; the priests must record the voice that was heard apart from what it is taken to mean.

108 bomuröfiye, The Mirror Walk

Shele lira edhüthat bo ra,
If someone walks into a mirror,

ru sey repirer matuklaru ra.
then they will travel to another world.

109 gedhilye, The Shadow Self

Shele lira zeythat seyde gedhilye,
If someone meets their double,

ru sey regöror, vey sey revirer seyde dhilye dho.
then they will die, or they will be joined with their own self.

110 lyatuliyu, The Burning Bush

Shele liyu köteatt, day so ne nöreatt,
If a bush burns but does not burn away,

ru tru vöra sreatomr.
then a goddess is showing herself.

111 nolyurölyo, The Stone Speech

Shele ẅepidhönywe thiiskt nolyu le,
If writing appears on a stone,

ru shayödi lablörlordhülo rezheyur eyi lu; day liran repabir so karasözhewin nye ta.
then the ancient law may be made new; but it must be read aloud to the clan mothers.

112 wesesolyu, The Water Face

Shele solyu thiiskt wese le,
If a face appears in the water,

ru tru leru zeyatr.
then a spirit is watching.

113 shulẅomelyo, The Wind Name

Shele shulẅo yayeatt tru melyo,
If the wind says a name,

ru melyo ke liran honuthat revaner tru lira nyüdhöte ra lu; rulbelyate redönyer thepabe ta.
then the name that was heard may call someone to service; the maternal house must weigh the claim.

114 zülrewo, The Final Silence

Shele wo dhulethat, na yore ne thiatt,
If silence falls, and there is no sound,

ru röpti zamu renörer lu; rulbelyaten rethrer pölyin, melyon, gihu na reyon ta, vene eyi dödhewu vireatr.
then an age may end; the maternal houses must keep safe the children, the names, the grain and the archives before a new council meets.

Sentence notes

SI-01

Segmented: Ho kara-de lin södhe-tha=n Nözibevo ẅeshi lyeyon le.

Gloss: six clan-GEN priest-PL record-PFV=REP Sign-Book many year-PL LOC

SI-02

Segmented: Sa vo le, er thral nözibe thi-at=t.

Gloss: this codex LOC ten twelve omen exist-IPFV=DIR

SI-03

Segmented: Loyi nözibe-de melyo, nöbu na söẅewösre thi-at=t so le.

Gloss: every omen-GEN name omen and judgment exist-IPFV=DIR 3IN LOC

SI-04

Segmented: Shele nöbu e=t tru nözibe, ru dödhewu re=mitö=r so-de söẅewösre ta.

Gloss: if omen EQU=DIR one omen then council PROSP=follow=ASSUM 3IN-GEN judgment NEC

SI-05

Segmented: Shele nöbu ne e=t tru nözibe, ru söẅewösre ne he-at=t dödhewu.

Gloss: if omen NEG EQU=DIR one omen then judgment NEG bind-IPFV=DIR council

SL-01

Segmented: Kara, anyeshölyu na melyo pire-ush=t sözhewin ve pölyin ra.

Gloss: clan property and name travel-HAB=DIR mother-PL ABL child-PL ALL

SL-02

Segmented: Dödhewu nayi-ush=t waslyengülyuren ewöran nye, na so zhönyü-ush=t son röli.

Gloss: council give-HAB=DIR mandate-PL officeholder-PL DAT and 3IN recall-HAB=DIR 3IN.PL again

SL-03

Segmented: Ewöra ne dhömgü-ush=t; sey nyüdhö-ush=t rulbelyaten.

Gloss: officeholder NEG rule.alone-HAB=DIR 3AN serve-HAB=DIR maternal.house-PL

SL-04

Segmented: Nözibe ne vome-ush=t tru dela, na so ne nayi-ush=t pölyin yerüẅun nye.

Gloss: omen NEG make-HAB=DIR one monarch and 3IN NEG give-HAB=DIR child-PL stranger-PL DAT

SL-05

Segmented: Ẅayi yaye-ush=t so ke sey zey-tha=t; li yaye-ush=t so-de toyete.

Gloss: witness say-HAB=DIR 3IN REL 3AN see-PFV=DIR priest say-HAB=DIR 3IN-GEN meaning

SL-06

Segmented: Ki södhe-ush=t son liny lyu le; maẅi ki ne düẅu-ush=t son.

Gloss: scribe record-HAB=DIR 3IN.PL two scroll LOC other scribe NEG change-HAB=DIR 3IN.PL

SL-07

Segmented: Pölyi ne örlye-ush=t nözibe-de kuhite; rulbelyate mürvu-ush=t sey.

Gloss: child NEG receive-HAB=DIR omen-GEN harm maternal.house bring.up-HAB=DIR 3AN

SN-01

Segmented: Loyi nözibe-de melyo-v-e=t tru eyi nyivo, ke liran vome-tha=t shayödi nyivon ve na eyi nyivon ve.

Gloss: every omen-GEN name-LINK-COP=DIR one new word REL person-PL make-PFV=DIR ancient word-PL ABL and new word-PL ABL

SN-02

Segmented: Zülre nyivo e=t melyo-de yoru; maẅi nyivon ẅepüdhe-at=t so-de toyete.

Gloss: ending word EQU=DIR name-GEN heart other word-PL proclaim-IPFV=DIR 3IN-GEN meaning

SN-03

Segmented: Liran ne yaye-ush=t sani melyon lyanmu le; lin na kin yaye-ush=t son honute le.

Gloss: person-PL NEG say-HAB=DIR these name-PL market LOC priest-PL and scribe-PL say-HAB=DIR 3IN.PL hearing LOC

S001P

Segmented: Shele sulo daslye-at=t farle dho,

Gloss: if moon surface-IPFV=DIR halo COM

S001A

Segmented: ru ulyi rulbelyate re=lyöpe=r rathido dödhewu le; so re=ẅepüdhe=r so-de thepabe karasözhewin nye ta.

Gloss: then senior maternal.house PROSP=gain=ASSUM precedence council LOC 3IN PROSP=proclaim=ASSUM 3IN-GEN claim clan.mother-PL DAT NEC

S002P

Segmented: Shele salyu-de yilo thi-at=t lüye le,

Gloss: if sun-GEN darkness exist-IPFV=DIR morning LOC

S002A

Segmented: ru röpti rulbelyate-de ryofridhotivlashe hesü-at-u=r; karasözhewin re=vire=r dödhewu le ta, na seyan re=nyölya=r lyesa ta.

Gloss: then great maternal.house-GEN succession threaten-IPFV-PASS=ASSUM clan.mother-PL PROSP=join=ASSUM council LOC NEC and 3AN.PL PROSP=choose=ASSUM successor NEC

S003P

Segmented: Shele salyu-de yilo thi-at=t ẅöru le,

Gloss: if sun-GEN darkness exist-IPFV=DIR evening LOC

S003A

Segmented: ru nyomru re=hesü=r lyögen; rulbelyaten re=ble=r wöẅon höwi liran nye na lyatenali liran nye ta.

Gloss: then pestilence PROSP=threaten=ASSUM city-PL maternal.house-PL PROSP=open=ASSUM storehouse-PL sick person-PL DAT and homeless person-PL DAT NEC

S004P

Segmented: Shele yilo-de ge pire-at=t üde ve zöku ra,

Gloss: if darkness-GEN shadow travel-IPFV=DIR east ABL west ALL

S004A

Segmented: ru röpti zazhute re=hesü=r lyögen; ho kara re=vome=r pleunen na lyüshe gihu ta.

Gloss: then great flood PROSP=threaten=ASSUM city-PL six clan PROSP=make=ASSUM shelter-PL and shared grain NEC

S005P

Segmented: Shele yilo fre-isk=t salyu yoru ve,

Gloss: if darkness conceal-INCEP=DIR sun heart ABL

S005A

Segmented: ru dödhewu-de ulyi karasözhewi re=göro=r vey re=zhamu=r sey-de waslyengülyure lu; Tiriya-de luẅidhete le, Tyre hesü-at-u=r.

Gloss: then council-GEN senior clan.mother PROSP=die=ASSUM or PROSP=lose=ASSUM 3AN-GEN mandate POSS Tiriya-GEN interpreting LOC Tyre threaten-IPFV-PASS=ASSUM

S006P

Segmented: Shele lyoyi-de saro levö-tha=t salyu-de lilyẅe ra,

Gloss: if raven-GEN star come-PFV=DIR sun-GEN path ALL

S006A

Segmented: ru üne-de dösu re=zheẅü=r na öman re=dikra=r; lyanmupulyan re=mina=r so kara-de dödhewun nye ta.

Gloss: then trade-GEN price PROSP=fall.in.price=ASSUM and merchant-PL PROSP=protest=ASSUM market.keeper-PL PROSP=speak=ASSUM 3IN clan-GEN council-PL DAT NEC

S007P

Segmented: Shele zelyo-de saro yöpü-at=t lyafüru-de blüẅo le,

Gloss: if yoke-GEN star stand-IPFV=DIR sky-GEN height LOC

S007A

Segmented: ru rünye re=özhe=r; rulbelyaten re=mazhi=r nupen na re=hinyöẅe=r bilye gihu ta.

Gloss: then harvest PROSP=increase=ASSUM maternal.house-PL PROSP=keep=ASSUM seed-PL and PROSP=distribute=ASSUM excess grain NEC

S008P

Segmented: Shele saro zöẅi-tha=t sulo-de lyalyu ve sulo-de ẅölyo ra,

Gloss: if star flash.once-PFV=DIR moon-GEN right.hand ABL moon-GEN left.hand ALL

S008A

Segmented: ru lipo-de pirete na=r löyi; day karasözhewin re=meẅi=r so-de ẅeli ta.

Gloss: then war-GEN journey ATTR=ASSUM good but clan.mother-PL PROSP=appoint=ASSUM 3IN-GEN captain NEC

S009P

Segmented: Shele saro zöẅi-tha=t sulo-de ẅölyo ve sulo-de lyalyu ra,

Gloss: if star flash.once-PFV=DIR moon-GEN left.hand ABL moon-GEN right.hand ALL

S009A

Segmented: ru lipo-de pirete na=r kuhi; karasözhewin re=zhönyü=r so-de ẅeli ta.

Gloss: then war-GEN journey ATTR=ASSUM bad clan.mother-PL PROSP=recall=ASSUM 3IN-GEN captain NEC

S010P

Segmented: Shele woshwu thi-at=t yöli sari lyafüru le,

Gloss: if cloud exist-IPFV=DIR lion SIM sky LOC

S010A

Segmented: ru elwi rulbelyate re=yeyü=r bilye külyebüẅun lyüshe liran ve; maẅi rulbelyaten re=lyüsö=r so ta.

Gloss: then strong maternal.house PROSP=demand=ASSUM excess tax-PL shared person-PL ABL other maternal.house-PL PROSP=examine=ASSUM 3IN NEC

S011P

Segmented: Shele woshwu thi-at=t rali sari lyafüru le,

Gloss: if cloud exist-IPFV=DIR mammoth SIM sky LOC

S011A

Segmented: ru züyi rulbelyate re=dantho=r rathido dödhewu le; dödhewu re=rüẅö=r thepabe honute le ta.

Gloss: then rival maternal.house PROSP=dispute=ASSUM precedence council LOC council PROSP=settle=ASSUM claim hearing LOC NEC

S012P

Segmented: Shele lyuwelyalydhu daslye-at=t üde le,

Gloss: if Red.Dust surface-IPFV=DIR east LOC

S012A

Segmented: ru lipo re=hesü=r linylo-de rulbelyaten; karasözhewin re=vane=r renyite-de dödhewu ta.

Gloss: then war PROSP=threaten=ASSUM alliance-GEN maternal.house-PL clan.mother-PL PROSP=invite=ASSUM reconciliation-GEN council NEC

S013P

Segmented: Shele lyatkulyalydhu daslye-at=t,

Gloss: if White.Dust surface-IPFV=DIR

S013A

Segmented: ru rünye na zefu hesü-at-u=r; rulbelyaten re=lüha=r gihu wöẅon ve lyüri lyaten nye ta.

Gloss: then harvest and silver threaten-IPFV-PASS=ASSUM maternal.house-PL PROSP=supply=ASSUM grain storehouse-PL ABL poor house-PL DAT NEC

S014P

Segmented: Shele laye honu-at-u=t piyu le,

Gloss: if thunder hear-IPFV-PASS=DIR winter LOC

S014A

Segmented: ru dödhewu-de kozisheya re=nunzho=r dödhewu lu; sözhewin re=yeyü=r lyüshe fösite ta.

Gloss: then council-GEN speaker PROSP=betray=ASSUM council POSS mother-PL PROSP=demand=ASSUM shared testimony NEC

S015P

Segmented: Shele liny farle thi-at=t salyu le,

Gloss: if two halo exist-IPFV=DIR sun LOC

S015A

Segmented: ru liny rulbelyate re=dantho=r tru dödhewu-de melyo; dödhewu ne re=örlye=r thepabe ta, shele karasözhewin ne ledö-tha=r.

Gloss: then two maternal.house PROSP=dispute=ASSUM one council-GEN name council NEG PROSP=receive=ASSUM claim NEC if clan.mother-PL NEG consent-PFV=ASSUM

S016P

Segmented: Shele ẅöru-de saro yöpü-at=t blüẅo le,

Gloss: if evening-GEN star stand-IPFV=DIR height LOC

S016A

Segmented: ru lyüte, eslute na linylon re=özhe=r; day lipo re=mole=r dödhewu-de söẅewösre le.

Gloss: then love childbearing and alliance-PL PROSP=increase=ASSUM but war PROSP=remain=ASSUM council-GEN judgment LOC

S017P

Segmented: Shele lyuwesaro thowu-at=t,

Gloss: if red.star return-IPFV=DIR

S017A

Segmented: ru köẅi linylo-de rulbelyaten re=zhönyü=r son-de ledöte lu, na fare re=pire=r vörlu-de lyizen le lu.

Gloss: then distant alliance-GEN maternal.house-PL PROSP=recall=ASSUM 3IN.PL-GEN consent POSS and fire PROSP=travel=ASSUM border-GEN field-PL LOC POSS

S018P

Segmented: Shele sulo ne zey-at-u=t tru-ri efo le,

Gloss: if moon NEG see-IPFV-PASS=DIR one-ORD day LOC

S018A

Segmented: ru kara-de vöran na=r ẅüyi; rulbelyaten re=lyöneyö=r na re=zare=r renyite ta.

Gloss: then clan-GEN goddess-PL ATTR=ASSUM angry maternal.house-PL PROSP=mourn=ASSUM and PROSP=seek=ASSUM reconciliation NEC

S019P

Segmented: Shele nalyo thi-at=t dhu le,

Gloss: if radiance exist-IPFV=DIR darkness LOC

S019A

Segmented: ru dödhewu re=fale=r ewöra-de vey rulbepulya-de lümi tüvifemfo.

Gloss: then council PROSP=know=ASSUM officeholder-GEN or lineage.keeper-GEN hidden abuse.of.office

S020P

Segmented: Shele yadüben dhule-at=t lyöge le,

Gloss: if meteor-PL fall-IPFV=DIR city LOC

S020A

Segmented: ru lyöge-de zushan re=nunzho=r seyan-de waslyengülyure lu; sözhewin re=lyüsö=r seyan-de ẅeli-de lyönemthrithanyo ta.

Gloss: then city-GEN guard-PL PROSP=betray=ASSUM 3AN.PL-GEN mandate POSS mother-PL PROSP=examine=ASSUM 3AN.PL-GEN captain-GEN commission NEC

S021P

Segmented: Shele lyöge ke thi-at=t üno le lure-at=t dhu le,

Gloss: if city REL exist-IPFV=DIR hill LOC shine-IPFV=DIR darkness LOC

S021A

Segmented: ru lyöge re=lyöpe=r rathido maẅi lyögen dho; day rulbelyaten re=vome=r so lyülelyumon shi ta.

Gloss: then city PROSP=gain=ASSUM precedence other city-PL COM but maternal.house-PL PROSP=make=ASSUM 3IN agreement-PL INS NEC

S022P

Segmented: Shele lyöge-de yu ne nüke-at=t,

Gloss: if city-GEN gate NEG creak-IPFV=DIR

S022A

Segmented: ru üne re=düvyö=r; lyöge-de sözhewin re=nipe=r blökomöton na re=thre=r lyüri lyaten ta.

Gloss: then trade PROSP=collapse=ASSUM city-GEN mother-PL PROSP=mend=ASSUM caravan.road-PL and PROSP=protect=ASSUM poor house-PL NEC

S023P

Segmented: Shele linnyo thi-isk=t gömiye le,

Gloss: if tears exist-INCEP=DIR wall LOC

S023A

Segmented: ru thile na pawu re=levö=r; rulbelyaten re=vome=r gihu na pleunen ta.

Gloss: then siege and grief PROSP=come=ASSUM maternal.house-PL PROSP=make=ASSUM grain and shelter-PL NEC

S024P

Segmented: Shele lüẅe olyi-at=t kelythodödhewu-de nyimu le,

Gloss: if fungus grow-IPFV=DIR imperial.assembly-GEN roof LOC

S024A

Segmented: ru elwi rulbelyate-de söẅewösre me=mokö=r; maẅi rulbelyaten re=vane=r lyüsöte ta.

Gloss: then strong maternal.house-GEN judgment RES=rot=ASSUM other maternal.house-PL PROSP=invite=ASSUM inquiry NEC

S025P

Segmented: Shele wolyi nare-at=t sovaran-de reyo le,

Gloss: if owl dwell-IPFV=DIR ancestor-PL-GEN archive LOC

S025A

Segmented: ru tru sovaran-de lyu re=düẅu=r rulbe-de thepabe vey re=sre=r lümi ryofridhotivlashe.

Gloss: then one ancestor-PL-GEN scroll PROSP=change=ASSUM lineage-GEN claim or PROSP=reveal=ASSUM hidden succession

S026P

Segmented: Shele zhorenya-de büre zheyu-tha=t lathi,

Gloss: if swordsmith-GEN hearth become-PFV=DIR cold

S026A

Segmented: ru tharo re=zhamu=r so-de zhoren lipo le lu; sözhewin re=dönye=r lipo-de pirete röli ta.

Gloss: then army PROSP=lose=ASSUM 3IN-GEN sword-PL war LOC POSS mother-PL PROSP=judge=ASSUM war-GEN journey again NEC

S027P

Segmented: Shele lyuwi pire-tha=t lyilye ve lyate ra,

Gloss: if serpent travel-PFV=DIR threshold ABL house ALL

S027A

Segmented: ru ẅözha me=edhü=r dödhewu-de ralyi minate ra.

Gloss: then spy RES=enter=ASSUM council-GEN secret talk ALL

S028P

Segmented: Shele tru lira-de liny ge thi-at=t lyöẅe le,

Gloss: if one person-GEN two shadow exist-IPFV=DIR noon LOC

S028A

Segmented: ru sey-de kara nyane-at-u=r; rulbelyate re=lyüsö=r sa nözibe ta, vene dödhewu dönye-at=r.

Gloss: then 3AN-GEN clan divide-IPFV-PASS=ASSUM maternal.house PROSP=examine=ASSUM this omen NEC before council judge-IPFV=ASSUM

S029P

Segmented: Shele nyenyo-de wese zheyu-tha=t lyuwe,

Gloss: if well-GEN water become-PFV=DIR red

S029A

Segmented: ru tharo re=tawu=r lyöge lu; rulbelyaten re=thre=r na re=hinyöẅe=r lyüshe gihu ta.

Gloss: then army PROSP=attack=ASSUM city POSS maternal.house-PL PROSP=protect=ASSUM and PROSP=distribute=ASSUM shared grain NEC

S030P

Segmented: Shele lyüẅi zohi-at=t yonyule le, day lira ne thi-at=t so le,

Gloss: if dog bark-IPFV=DIR lane LOC but person NEG exist-IPFV=DIR 3IN LOC

S030A

Segmented: ru nyomru-de lerun thi-at=r lyöge le; rulbelyaten re=thre=r höwi liran zane shi na rüfete shi ta.

Gloss: then pestilence-GEN ghost-PL exist-IPFV=ASSUM city LOC maternal.house-PL PROSP=protect=ASSUM sick person-PL prayer INS and healing INS NEC

S031P

Segmented: Shele tohtethu pire-at=t ithire ra,

Gloss: if river travel-IPFV=DIR mountains ALL

S031A

Segmented: ru wese-de lablörlordhülo me=düẅu=r; züyi rulbelyaten re=vome=r eyi vörlulyülelyumon ta.

Gloss: then water-GEN law RES=change=ASSUM rival maternal.house-PL PROSP=make=ASSUM new boundary.agreement-PL NEC

S032P

Segmented: Shele nyöyo thi-at=t lyize le,

Gloss: if salt exist-IPFV=DIR field LOC

S032A

Segmented: ru rünye hesü-at-u=r; sözhewin re=thre=r nupen ta, eyi zamu nye.

Gloss: then harvest threaten-IPFV-PASS=ASSUM mother-PL PROSP=protect=ASSUM seed-PL NEC new season DAT

S033P

Segmented: Shele nolyu thi-at=t eyi pölyi-de nyilo le,

Gloss: if stone exist-IPFV=DIR new child-GEN cradle LOC

S033A

Segmented: ru pölyi re=zheyu=r elwi; rulbelyate re=lutri=r sey ta.

Gloss: then child PROSP=become=ASSUM strong maternal.house PROSP=teach=ASSUM 3AN NEC

S034P

Segmented: Shele lyula shiko-at=t rumen le,

Gloss: if fox laugh-IPFV=DIR ruin-PL LOC

S034A

Segmented: ru liran re=avö=r lyöge, na gize re=edhü=r so.

Gloss: then person-PL PROSP=go.out=ASSUM city and forest PROSP=enter=ASSUM 3IN

S035P

Segmented: Shele lyanmupevun düvyö-tha=t, day shulẅo ne thi-at=t,

Gloss: if market.stall-PL collapse-PFV=DIR but wind NEG exist-IPFV=DIR

S035A

Segmented: ru lyanmu-de lyülelyumo re=düvyö=r lu; dödhewun re=lyüsö=r lyinyen, zuken na lyüshe wöẅon ta.

Gloss: then market-GEN agreement PROSP=collapse=ASSUM POSS council-PL PROSP=examine=ASSUM weight-PL debt-PL and shared storehouse-PL NEC

S036P

Segmented: Shele liẅan viga-at=t shilyenyo shi dödhewulyate le,

Gloss: if bird-PL fly-IPFV=DIR pattern INS council.house LOC

S036A

Segmented: ru lipo-de dödhewu re=vire=r sa efo le ta; ẅeli ne re=pire=r ta, shele karasözhewin ne röve-tha=r.

Gloss: then war-GEN council PROSP=join=ASSUM this day LOC NEC captain NEG PROSP=travel=ASSUM NEC if clan.mother-PL NEG allow-PFV=ASSUM

S037P

Segmented: Shele liẅan viga-at=t sloregi möto le ẅölyo ra,

Gloss: if bird-PL fly-IPFV=DIR circular road LOC left.hand ALL

S037A

Segmented: ru karasözhewin re=pire-iv=r zan ta, na re=he=r seyan-de lipo-de ẅelin ta.

Gloss: then clan.mother-PL PROSP=travel-CAUS=ASSUM negotiator-PL NEC and PROSP=bind=ASSUM 3AN.PL-GEN war-GEN captain-PL NEC

S038P

Segmented: Shele lyüleyölne nümu-at=t möge-de gömiye,

Gloss: if Black.Mould cover-IPFV=DIR north-GEN wall

S038A

Segmented: ru tru rulbe ne nyüdhö-tha=r sovaran; so-de rulbelyate re=nayi=r wündhelso ta.

Gloss: then one lineage NEG serve-PFV=ASSUM ancestor-PL 3IN-GEN maternal.house PROSP=give=ASSUM compensation NEC

S039P

Segmented: Shele lyatkuyölne nümu-at=t lüẅo-de gömiye,

Gloss: if White.Mould cover-IPFV=DIR south-GEN wall

S039A

Segmented: ru lerun na=r lali; löyi efon re=levö=r.

Gloss: then ghost-PL ATTR=ASSUM gentle good day-PL PROSP=come=ASSUM

S040P

Segmented: Shele lolu shote-tha=t blüẅo ve thare ra,

Gloss: if tower crack-PFV=DIR height ABL earth ALL

S040A

Segmented: ru eli lin re=ükö=r ulyi lin-de söẅewösren; sorepulyan re=vire=r honute le ta.

Gloss: then young priest-PL PROSP=object.to=ASSUM senior priest-PL-GEN judgment-PL custodian-PL PROSP=join=ASSUM hearing LOC NEC

S041P

Segmented: Shele lyaso nüke-ush=t dhu le,

Gloss: if floor creak-HAB=DIR darkness LOC

S041A

Segmented: ru lerun lyonya-at=r; li re=lyuve=r son ta.

Gloss: then ghost-PL dance-IPFV=ASSUM priest PROSP=drive.out=ASSUM 3IN.PL NEC

S042P

Segmented: Shele lyöge-de yöẅo zhamu-tha-u=t,

Gloss: if city-GEN key lose-PFV-PASS=DIR

S042A

Segmented: ru tru yupulya me=nunzho=r tru rulbelyate; sözhewin re=lyüsö=r yun na son-de zushan ta.

Gloss: then one gatekeeper RES=betray=ASSUM one maternal.house mother-PL PROSP=examine=ASSUM gate-PL and 3IN.PL-GEN guard-PL NEC

S043P

Segmented: Shele shayödi rulyo giye-tha-u=t yonyule le,

Gloss: if ancient coin find-PFV-PASS=DIR lane LOC

S043A

Segmented: ru lyözo ke liran me-tha=r re=thowu=r tru rulbe ra; sözhewin re=nöde=r sovaran-de thepabe ta.

Gloss: then wealth REL person-PL forget-PFV=ASSUM PROSP=return=ASSUM one lineage ALL mother-PL PROSP=test=ASSUM ancestor-PL-GEN claim NEC

S044P

Segmented: Shele yerüẅu-de solyu e=t tru kozisheya-de solyu,

Gloss: if stranger-GEN face EQU=DIR one speaker-GEN face

S044A

Segmented: ru kisothara zare-at=r kozisheya-de melyo vey waslyengülyure.

Gloss: then pretender seek-IPFV=ASSUM speaker-GEN name or mandate

S045P

Segmented: Shele lyüshe nürlo zheyu-tha=t nyölyyo,

Gloss: if shared fountain become-PFV=DIR dryness

S045A

Segmented: ru Ophalrhan me=avö=r wesepulyan; Ophalrhan-de sözhewin re=diva=r eyite-de zanen ta.

Gloss: then Ophalrhan RES=go.out=ASSUM water.keeper-PL Ophalrhan-GEN mother-PL PROSP=lead=ASSUM renewal-GEN prayer-PL NEC

S046P

Segmented: Shele wese avö-at=t ẅösro ve, day lira ne lyöde-tha=t so,

Gloss: if water go.out-IPFV=DIR cup ABL but person NEG pour-PFV=DIR 3IN

S046A

Segmented: ru lyözo re=levö=r; day liran re=nekru=r nyüvlu ta.

Gloss: then wealth PROSP=come=ASSUM but person-PL PROSP=fear=ASSUM drunkenness NEC

S047P

Segmented: Shele bo shote-tha=t, day lira ne ranü-tha=t so,

Gloss: if mirror crack-PFV=DIR but person NEG brush-PFV=DIR 3IN

S047A

Segmented: ru kara-de lyaẅo me=freru=r; rulbelyate re=zare=r renyite ta, vene so dönye-at=r.

Gloss: then clan-GEN bond RES=break=ASSUM maternal.house PROSP=seek=ASSUM reconciliation NEC before 3IN judge-IPFV=ASSUM

S048P

Segmented: Shele leyo honu-at-u=t yu le, day lira ne thi-at=t yu le,

Gloss: if knocking hear-IPFV-PASS=DIR gate LOC but person NEG exist-IPFV=DIR gate LOC

S048A

Segmented: ru göle thena-at=r yu le.

Gloss: then death wait-IPFV=ASSUM gate LOC

S049P

Segmented: Shele ẅeya-de nyeyiru thi-at=t dödhewulyate le,

Gloss: if ant-GEN swarm exist-IPFV=DIR council.house LOC

S049A

Segmented: ru dödhewu-de ulyi rulbelyate-de züyin na=r ẅeshi; day seyan na=r löni.

Gloss: then council-GEN senior maternal.house-GEN rival-PL ATTR=ASSUM many but 3AN.PL ATTR=ASSUM weak

S050P

Segmented: Shele tru lila edhü-tha=t lyöge ra,

Gloss: if one wolf enter-PFV=DIR city ALL

S050A

Segmented: ru röpti yerüẅu me=levö=r; karasözhewin re=dhösha=r yerüẅu-de nyüdhöten na thepaben ta.

Gloss: then great stranger RES=come=ASSUM clan.mother-PL PROSP=decide=ASSUM stranger-GEN duty-PL and claim-PL NEC

S051P

Segmented: Shele saro dhule-tha=t tru lyate ra,

Gloss: if star fall-PFV=DIR one house ALL

S051A

Segmented: ru sa rulbelyate re=düvyö=r vey re=lyöpe=r röpti rathido; so-de pulyan re=zare=r maẅi luẅidhete ta.

Gloss: then this maternal.house PROSP=collapse=ASSUM or PROSP=gain=ASSUM great precedence 3IN-GEN keeper-PL PROSP=seek=ASSUM other interpreting NEC

S052P

Segmented: Shele lyafüru zheyu-tha=t kölye ẅöru le,

Gloss: if sky become-PFV=DIR green evening LOC

S052A

Segmented: ru elwi nelyshun re=levö=r, vey lümi nöbu re=dhule=r lyafüru ve.

Gloss: then strong storm-PL PROSP=come=ASSUM or hidden omen PROSP=fall=ASSUM sky ABL

S053P

Segmented: Shele tohtethu zheyu-tha=t lyuwe,

Gloss: if river become-PFV=DIR red

S053A

Segmented: ru lipo vey nyomru thi-at=r ithire le.

Gloss: then war or pestilence exist-IPFV=ASSUM mountains LOC

S054P

Segmented: Shele lyasu thi-at=t mulyilu le,

Gloss: if frost exist-IPFV=DIR summer LOC

S054A

Segmented: ru zamun-de liye me=freru=r; rulbelyaten re=thre=r gihu na wese ta, vene liye thowu-at=r.

Gloss: then season-PL-GEN cycle RES=break=ASSUM maternal.house-PL PROSP=protect=ASSUM grain and water NEC before cycle return-IPFV=ASSUM

S055P

Segmented: Shele nyenyo-de wese satu-at=t,

Gloss: if well-GEN water boil-IPFV=DIR

S055A

Segmented: ru fare pire-at=r thare le, vey leru thi-at=r nyenyo le.

Gloss: then fire travel-IPFV=ASSUM earth LOC or ghost exist-IPFV=ASSUM well LOC

S056P

Segmented: Shele nolyun tize-at=t,

Gloss: if stone-PL sing-IPFV=DIR

S056A

Segmented: ru thare zire-isk=r; so re=lyüthlu=r lu.

Gloss: then earth awaken-INCEP=ASSUM 3IN PROSP=shake=ASSUM POSS

S057P

Segmented: Shele linnyu-de ẅimu thi-at=t plonlye sari,

Gloss: if tree-GEN sap exist-IPFV=DIR blood SIM

S057A

Segmented: ru thare me=diẅö-u=r; rulbelyaten re=vome=r lave ke dödhewu röve-tha=r ta; lira ne re=küza=r ta, shele dödhewu ne röve-tha=r.

Gloss: then earth RES=wound-PASS=ASSUM maternal.house-PL PROSP=make=ASSUM offering REL council allow-PFV=ASSUM NEC person NEG PROSP=kill=ASSUM NEC if council NEG allow-PFV=ASSUM

S058P

Segmented: Shele lyülyẅanyu nümu-at=t lyöge lyöẅe le,

Gloss: if fog cover-IPFV=DIR city noon LOC

S058A

Segmented: ru vöran fre-at=r tru nöbu; liran re=thena=r ta.

Gloss: then goddess-PL conceal-IPFV=ASSUM one omen person-PL PROSP=wait=ASSUM NEC

S059P

Segmented: Shele tru liẅa viga-tha=t lyate ra,

Gloss: if one bird fly-PFV=DIR house ALL

S059A

Segmented: ru lyösu re=levö=r köẅi möto ve, na so re=lyonyu=r göle vey düẅute.

Gloss: then news PROSP=come=ASSUM distant road ABL and 3IN PROSP=bring=ASSUM death or change

S060P

Segmented: Shele lüyin-de nyörden me=he-u=t,

Gloss: if rat-PL-GEN tail-PL RES=bind-PASS=DIR

S060A

Segmented: ru ralyi linylo na nyomru thi-at=r.

Gloss: then secret alliance and pestilence exist-IPFV=ASSUM

S061P

Segmented: Shele liny yoru thi-at=t lave le,

Gloss: if two heart exist-IPFV=DIR offering LOC

S061A

Segmented: ru ulyi karasözhewi re=lüta=r rori; sey-de rulbe re=özhe=r.

Gloss: then senior clan.mother PROSP=live=ASSUM long 3AN-GEN lineage PROSP=increase=ASSUM

S062P

Segmented: Shele lave-de shalye thi-at=t silyfle sari,

Gloss: if offering-GEN liver exist-IPFV=DIR reversal SIM

S062A

Segmented: ru göle hesü-at=r tru nafi, tru rulöba-de pölyi, vey tru kozisheya ke rulbe meẅi-tha=r.

Gloss: then death threaten-IPFV=ASSUM one uncle one aunt-GEN child or one speaker REL lineage appoint-PFV=ASSUM

S063P

Segmented: Shele plonlye avö-at=t thare ve, nure liran re-at=t so,

Gloss: if blood go.out-IPFV=DIR earth ABL while person-PL carve-IPFV=DIR 3IN

S063A

Segmented: ru moköte hesü-at=r thare; sözhewin re=thre=r rünye-de dhavin ta, na re=lüha=r gihu lyaten nye ta.

Gloss: then rot threaten-IPFV=ASSUM earth mother-PL PROSP=protect=ASSUM harvest-GEN worker-PL NEC and PROSP=supply=ASSUM grain house-PL DAT NEC

S064P

Segmented: Shele lenyi zey-at-u=t, day sey ne gözhü-at=t,

Gloss: if frog see-IPFV-PASS=DIR but 3AN NEG croak-IPFV=DIR

S064A

Segmented: ru wese re=zheyu=r nyölyyo; tru gu re=göro=r.

Gloss: then water PROSP=become=ASSUM dryness one stream PROSP=die=ASSUM

S065P

Segmented: Shele lira ürze-tha=t rali,

Gloss: if person dream-PFV=DIR mammoth

S065A

Segmented: ru sey re=zheyu=r zanyümi na elwi.

Gloss: then 3AN PROSP=become=ASSUM rich and strong

S066P

Segmented: Shele lira ürze-tha=t yu ke ble-at-om=t,

Gloss: if person dream-PFV=DIR gate REL open-IPFV-REFL=DIR

S066A

Segmented: ru sey-de üne re=özhe=r; sey re=pire=r köẅi möton le.

Gloss: then 3AN-GEN trade PROSP=increase=ASSUM 3AN PROSP=travel=ASSUM distant road-PL LOC

S067P

Segmented: Shele pölyi eslu-tha-u=t mövafeyi-de solyu dho,

Gloss: if child bear-PFV-PASS=DIR chimera-GEN face COM

S067A

Segmented: ru dödhewu re=löbi=r lin ta; liran re=thre=r sözhewi na eyi pölyi ta; nözibe ne re=damfu=r seyan ta.

Gloss: then council PROSP=ask=ASSUM priest-PL NEC person-PL PROSP=protect=ASSUM mother and new child NEC omen NEG PROSP=punish=ASSUM 3AN.PL NEC

S068P

Segmented: Shele eyi pölyi-de nyörde thi-at=t,

Gloss: if new child-GEN tail exist-IPFV=DIR

S068A

Segmented: ru dödhewu-de ulyi rulbelyate-de waslyengülyure re=nöre=r lu; liran ne re=dhüpa=r eyi pölyi ta.

Gloss: then council-GEN senior maternal.house-GEN mandate PROSP=fade=ASSUM POSS person-PL NEG PROSP=blame=ASSUM new child NEC

S069P

Segmented: Shele lyüẅi thi-at=t dhenyözhenpra-de yasre le,

Gloss: if dog exist-IPFV=DIR elder-GEN bed LOC

S069A

Segmented: ru rulbelyaten-de linylo hesü-at-u=r; rulbe-de dhenyözhenpran re=thre=r so-de liran ta.

Gloss: then maternal.house-PL-GEN alliance threaten-IPFV-PASS=ASSUM lineage-GEN elder-PL PROSP=protect=ASSUM 3IN-GEN person-PL NEC

S070P

Segmented: Shele bo dhule-tha=t, day so ne freru-tha=t,

Gloss: if mirror fall-PFV=DIR but 3IN NEG break-PFV=DIR

S070A

Segmented: ru tru kozisheya re=nunzho=r dödhewu lu; rulbelyaten re=honu=r fösite ta, vene seyan damfu-at=r.

Gloss: then one speaker PROSP=betray=ASSUM council POSS maternal.house-PL PROSP=hear=ASSUM testimony NEC before 3AN.PL punish-IPFV=ASSUM

S071P

Segmented: Shele zhuro na wese vire-tha-ely=t, day son zufe-omp-ely=t,

Gloss: if oil and water join-PFV-RECP=DIR but 3IN.PL separate-COMPL-RECP=DIR

S071A

Segmented: ru lin me=vire=r liny nöbu; maẅi ẅayin re=dönye=r son-de tharnyiyu röli ta.

Gloss: then priest-PL RES=join=ASSUM two omen other witness-PL PROSP=judge=ASSUM 3IN.PL-GEN prophecy again NEC

S072P

Segmented: Shele danyözane ne thi-tha=t kozisheya-de rölyo le, nure sey pabi-at=t kelytho-de lablörlordhülo,

Gloss: if liaison NEG exist-PFV=DIR speaker-GEN speech LOC while 3AN read.aloud-IPFV=DIR empire-GEN law

S072A

Segmented: ru dödhewu-de lyülelyumo re=freru=r lu.

Gloss: then council-GEN agreement PROSP=break=ASSUM POSS

S073P

Segmented: Shele tohtethu pire-isk=t ithire ra,

Gloss: if river travel-INCEP=DIR mountains ALL

S073A

Segmented: ru kelytho me=zhamu=r vöran-de wuwe; sözhewin re=dönye=r so-de lyülelyumon röli ta.

Gloss: then empire RES=lose=ASSUM goddess-PL-GEN favour mother-PL PROSP=judge=ASSUM 3IN-GEN agreement-PL again NEC

S074P

Segmented: Shele lira zey-tha=t böẅenyfi,

Gloss: if person see-PFV=DIR phoenix

S074A

Segmented: ru eyi yeyüthara re=daslye=r, na sey re=zare=r dödhewu-de melyo; dödhewun re=göbi=r ryofridhotivlashe ke so ne röve-tha=r ta.

Gloss: then new claimant PROSP=surface=ASSUM and 3AN PROSP=seek=ASSUM council-GEN name council-PL PROSP=refuse=ASSUM succession REL 3IN NEG allow-PFV=ASSUM NEC

S075P

Segmented: Shele röpti liru zheyu-tha=t söfi,

Gloss: if great crowd become-PFV=DIR silent

S075A

Segmented: ru rulbelyaten me=vome=r ralyi linylo lyüshe dödhewu ve.

Gloss: then maternal.house-PL RES=make=ASSUM secret alliance shared council ABL

S076P

Segmented: Shele thore zey-at-u=t, day so-de tru lizhu ne thi-at=t,

Gloss: if footprint see-IPFV-PASS=DIR but 3IN-GEN one toe NEG exist-IPFV=DIR

S076A

Segmented: ru tru pirethara re=zhamu=r sey-de lyate-de möto lu; sey-de rulbelyate re=vome=r threte-de zanen sey nye ta.

Gloss: then one pilgrim PROSP=lose=ASSUM 3AN-GEN house-GEN road POSS 3AN-GEN maternal.house PROSP=make=ASSUM protecting-GEN prayer-PL 3AN DAT NEC

S077P

Segmented: Shele fongan zey-tha=n zekasi nöbu lyafüru le,

Gloss: if Phong-PL see-PFV=REP strange omen sky LOC

S077A

Segmented: ru matuklarun-de selyu freru-isk=r.

Gloss: then other.world-PL-GEN veil break-INCEP=ASSUM

S078P

Segmented: Shele tru shilyenyo shote-at=t ẅeshi shilyenyon ra, na loyi shilyenyo düvyö-at=t,

Gloss: if one pattern crack-IPFV=DIR many pattern-PL ALL and every pattern collapse-IPFV=DIR

S078A

Segmented: ru kelythodödhewu-de dödhewun re=düvyö=r lu; rulbelyaten re=telyanle=r son-de nyüdhöte ta.

Gloss: then imperial.assembly-GEN council-PL PROSP=collapse=ASSUM POSS maternal.house-PL PROSP=preserve=ASSUM 3IN.PL-GEN duty NEC

S079P

Segmented: Shele lyöre ne lüla-at=t wese le,

Gloss: if opal.mead NEG dissolve-IPFV=DIR water LOC

S079A

Segmented: ru lin-de waslyengülyure nöre-at=r; karasözhewin re=honu=r na re=lyüsö=r seyan-de thepaben ta.

Gloss: then priest-PL-GEN mandate fade-IPFV=ASSUM clan.mother-PL PROSP=hear=ASSUM and PROSP=examine=ASSUM 3AN.PL-GEN claim-PL NEC

S080P

Segmented: Shele lyülemülyo thi-at=t salyu le,

Gloss: if black.spot exist-IPFV=DIR sun LOC

S080A

Segmented: ru ralyi liran wöni-at=r the seyan re=küza=r ulyi karasözhewi vey sey-de kozisheya.

Gloss: then secret person-PL plan-IPFV=ASSUM COMP 3AN.PL PROSP=kill=ASSUM senior clan.mother or 3AN-GEN speaker

S081P

Segmented: Shele eyi pölyi-de ẅule thi-at=t sey-de nayu le,

Gloss: if new child-GEN cord exist-IPFV=DIR 3AN-GEN neck LOC

S081A

Segmented: ru ẅeshi nariyan-de thepaben he-at=r pölyi; rulbelyate re=rüẅö=r thepaben ta, na re=thre=r pölyi ta.

Gloss: then many kin-PL-GEN claim-PL bind-IPFV=ASSUM child maternal.house PROSP=settle=ASSUM claim-PL NEC and PROSP=protect=ASSUM child NEC

S082P

Segmented: Shele lave-de shalye zheyu-tha=t lyatku,

Gloss: if offering-GEN liver become-PFV=DIR whiteness

S082A

Segmented: ru gihu-de lire re=levö=r thare le.

Gloss: then grain-GEN absence PROSP=come=ASSUM earth LOC

S083P

Segmented: Shele lave-de shalye zheyu-tha=t lyüle,

Gloss: if offering-GEN liver become-PFV=DIR blackness

S083A

Segmented: ru nyomru vey Róskaï-de ẅüyite re=levö=r.

Gloss: then pestilence or Róskaï-GEN anger PROSP=come=ASSUM

S084P

Segmented: Shele lyela eslu-tha-u=t liny lyüro dho,

Gloss: if calf bear-PFV-PASS=DIR two head COM

S084A

Segmented: ru kelythodödhewu nyane-at-u=r lu; sözhewin re=zare=r eyi pölyso-de lyülelyumo ta.

Gloss: then imperial.assembly divide-IPFV-PASS=ASSUM POSS mother-PL PROSP=seek=ASSUM new peace-GEN agreement NEC

S085P

Segmented: Shele pölyi eslu-tha-u=t, day sey-de lyüro ne thi-at=t,

Gloss: if child bear-PFV-PASS=DIR but 3AN-GEN head NEG exist-IPFV=DIR

S085A

Segmented: ru ulyi rulbe-de ryofridhotivlashe hesü-at-u=r; dödhewu re=vome=r so eyi ta.

Gloss: then senior lineage-GEN succession threaten-IPFV-PASS=ASSUM council PROSP=make=ASSUM 3IN new NEC

S086P

Segmented: Shele yore honu-at-u=t lave ve,

Gloss: if sound hear-IPFV-PASS=DIR offering ABL

S086A

Segmented: ru tru vöra nöye-at=r rulbelyate ke lave mazhi-at=t; lin re=mina=r so sözhewin nye ta.

Gloss: then one goddess warn-IPFV=ASSUM maternal.house REL offering keep-IPFV=DIR priest-PL PROSP=speak=ASSUM 3IN mother-PL DAT NEC

S087P

Segmented: Shele dilyu giye-tha-u=t, na so vöge-at=t,

Gloss: if skull find-PFV-PASS=DIR and 3IN smile-IPFV=DIR

S087A

Segmented: ru sovaran shiko-at=r; kuhi efon re=levö=r.

Gloss: then ancestor-PL laugh-IPFV=ASSUM bad day-PL PROSP=come=ASSUM

S088P

Segmented: Shele plonlye avö-at=t fiyasinu ve,

Gloss: if blood go.out-IPFV=DIR altar.stone ABL

S088A

Segmented: ru vöra me=göbi=r lave; sorepulyan re=löbi=r rulbelyate ke röve-tha=r so ta.

Gloss: then goddess RES=refuse=ASSUM offering custodian-PL PROSP=ask=ASSUM maternal.house REL allow-PFV=ASSUM 3IN NEC

S089P

Segmented: Shele lerarẅöflu ne thi-at=t lave le,

Gloss: if gallbladder NEG exist-IPFV=DIR offering LOC

S089A

Segmented: ru tharo re=örlye=r yemnyi düvyöte; sözhewin re=dhösha=r so-de ẅeli-de waslyengülyure ta.

Gloss: then army PROSP=receive=ASSUM bitter defeat mother-PL PROSP=decide=ASSUM 3IN-GEN captain-GEN mandate NEC

S090P

Segmented: Shele pölyi eslu-tha-u=t bilye silyo dho,

Gloss: if child bear-PFV-PASS=DIR excess limb COM

S090A

Segmented: ru liran re=thre=r pölyi ta; dödhewu re=lyüsö=r löle gewi ta; maẅi liran-de wure na=r blaki lu, na liran ne re=damfu=r pölyi ta.

Gloss: then person-PL PROSP=protect=ASSUM child NEC council PROSP=examine=ASSUM birth patient NEC other person-PL-GEN rumour ATTR=ASSUM false POSS and person-PL NEG PROSP=punish=ASSUM child NEC

S091P

Segmented: Shele lyuwi thi-at=t lave-de yazo le,

Gloss: if serpent exist-IPFV=DIR offering-GEN womb LOC

S091A

Segmented: ru elwi leru edhü-at=r rulbe ra lu; liran re=thre=r sözhewi na eyi pölyi ta, vene lin luẅidhe-omp=r.

Gloss: then strong ghost enter-IPFV=ASSUM lineage ALL POSS person-PL PROSP=protect=ASSUM mother and new child NEC before priest-PL interpret-COMPL=ASSUM

S092P

Segmented: Shele lave-de yoru zheyu-tha=t nolyu,

Gloss: if offering-GEN heart become-PFV=DIR stone

S092A

Segmented: ru tru ewöra me=zhamu=r nesishne; karasözhewin re=nöye=r sey vey re=zhönyü=r sey ta.

Gloss: then one officeholder RES=lose=ASSUM mercy clan.mother-PL PROSP=warn=ASSUM 3AN or PROSP=recall=ASSUM 3AN NEC

S093P

Segmented: Shele lyülyẅanyu thi-at=t lave-de lüru le,

Gloss: if fog exist-IPFV=DIR offering-GEN eye LOC

S093A

Segmented: ru söẅewösre me=mokö=r; rulbe-de nipünyiyun re=ble=r honuten röli ta, na re=mazhi=r fösite ta.

Gloss: then judgment RES=rot=ASSUM lineage-GEN ritual.court-PL PROSP=open=ASSUM hearing-PL again NEC and PROSP=keep=ASSUM testimony NEC

S094P

Segmented: Shele lave-de yelyun na=t zekasi,

Gloss: if offering-GEN ear-PL ATTR=DIR strange

S094A

Segmented: ru soren ne örlye-tha=r tru thösüte; sorepulyan re=lyüsö=r zanen ta.

Gloss: then sanctuary-PL NEG receive-PFV=ASSUM one petition custodian-PL PROSP=examine=ASSUM prayer-PL NEC

S095P

Segmented: Shele lizho ne thi-at=t lave-de raye le,

Gloss: if tongue NEG exist-IPFV=DIR offering-GEN mouth LOC

S095A

Segmented: ru liran fle-at=r lyüshe rölyo; sözhewin re=thre=r ẅayin na thösüte ta.

Gloss: then person-PL close-IPFV=ASSUM shared speech mother-PL PROSP=protect=ASSUM witness-PL and petition NEC

S096P

Segmented: Shele pölyi eslu-tha-u=t tolyun dho,

Gloss: if child bear-PFV-PASS=DIR horn-PL COM

S096A

Segmented: ru pölyi re=zheyu=r divathara lu; rulbelyate re=mürvu=r sey ta, na nözibe ne dhösha-at=r sey-de lyeyon.

Gloss: then child PROSP=become=ASSUM leader POSS maternal.house PROSP=bring.up=ASSUM 3AN NEC and omen NEG decide-IPFV=ASSUM 3AN-GEN year-PL

S097P

Segmented: Shele lyafon thi-at=t eyi pölyi-de lörüre le,

Gloss: if scale-PL exist-IPFV=DIR new child-GEN skin LOC

S097A

Segmented: ru nawi walu-de lümi lyaẅo thi-at=r sey le; liran re=löbi=r fongan na numiyan ta, na liran ne re=dhüpa=r pölyi ta.

Gloss: then deep ocean-GEN hidden bond exist-IPFV=ASSUM 3AN LOC person-PL PROSP=ask=ASSUM Phong-PL and Numi.whale-PL NEC and person-PL NEG PROSP=blame=ASSUM child NEC

S098P

Segmented: Shele lave-de plonlye na=t yeyo,

Gloss: if offering-GEN blood ATTR=DIR blue

S098A

Segmented: ru ulyi rulbe hesü-at-u=r; so-de nenan re=thre=r so-de liran na re=vome=r uyi ryofridhotivlashe ta.

Gloss: then senior lineage threaten-IPFV-PASS=ASSUM 3IN-GEN woman-PL PROSP=protect=ASSUM 3IN-GEN person-PL and PROSP=make=ASSUM true succession NEC

S099P

Segmented: Shele lave-de yazo na=t lyoru,

Gloss: if offering-GEN womb ATTR=DIR emptiness

S099A

Segmented: ru eyi rewose hesü-at-u=r; gihu, pleune na sözhewin-de na pölyin-de liyüthe re=örlye=r rathido ta.

Gloss: then new generation threaten-IPFV-PASS=ASSUM grain shelter and mother-PL-GEN and child-PL-GEN care PROSP=receive=ASSUM precedence NEC

S100P

Segmented: Shele liny lyuwi he-at-ely=t,

Gloss: if two serpent bind-IPFV-RECP=DIR

S100A

Segmented: ru shele seyan lüta-at=t, rüfete na pölyin re=özhe=r; shele seyan me=göro=t, rulbe re=freru=r lu, na lyate re=zhare=r vöran ta.

Gloss: then if 3AN.PL live-IPFV=DIR healing and child-PL PROSP=increase=ASSUM if 3AN.PL RES=die=DIR lineage PROSP=break=ASSUM POSS and house PROSP=worship=ASSUM goddess-PL NEC

S101P

Segmented: Shele wesen na gihun pire-at=t liye le,

Gloss: if water-PL and grain-PL travel-IPFV=DIR cycle LOC

S101A

Segmented: ru liye re=maye=r, shele lyaten mazhi-at=r son-de nyüdhöte na hinyöẅe-at-ely=r.

Gloss: then cycle PROSP=endure=ASSUM if house-PL keep-IPFV=ASSUM 3IN.PL-GEN duty and distribute-IPFV-RECP=ASSUM

S102P

Segmented: Shele lyoli pire-at=t maẅi lyögen le, na sey he-at=t son,

Gloss: if wanderer travel-IPFV=DIR other city-PL LOC and 3AN bind-IPFV=DIR 3IN.PL

S102A

Segmented: ru tru ya re=vome=r pölyso-de lyülelyumo eyi lu.

Gloss: then one mediator PROSP=make=ASSUM peace-GEN agreement new POSS

S103P

Segmented: Shele loẅin nare-at=t vörlun le,

Gloss: if people-PL dwell-IPFV=DIR border-PL LOC

S103A

Segmented: ru düẅute re=levö=r vörlu-de nariyan ve na lyatenali liran ve; dödhewu re=honu=r seyan-de thepaben ta.

Gloss: then change PROSP=come=ASSUM border-GEN kin-PL ABL and homeless person-PL ABL council PROSP=hear=ASSUM 3AN.PL-GEN claim-PL NEC

S104P

Segmented: Shele mo pire-at=t lyire ve,

Gloss: if current travel-IPFV=DIR lyira ABL

S104A

Segmented: ru lyiren re=lyonyu=r lyözo vey sorite; rulbelyaten re=de=r muröfiye na re=thre=r piretharan ta.

Gloss: then lyira-PL PROSP=bring=ASSUM wealth or danger maternal.house-PL PROSP=measure=ASSUM crossing and PROSP=protect=ASSUM pilgrim-PL NEC

S105P

Segmented: Shele lira honu-at=t maẅi lira-de tho,

Gloss: if person hear-IPFV=DIR other person-GEN thought

S105A

Segmented: ru fongan mina-at-ely=r süsernirẅu shi lu; dödhewu re=södhe=r tho zeyte ve ta.

Gloss: then Phong-PL speak-IPFV-RECP=ASSUM telepathy INS POSS council PROSP=record=ASSUM thought vision ABL NEC

S106P

Segmented: Shele ẅeshi liran ürze-tha=t ami go,

Gloss: if many person-PL dream-PFV=DIR same dream

S106A

Segmented: ru maẅi ẅayin re=döbi=r lyüshego ta, vene so he-at=r dödhewu.

Gloss: then other witness-PL PROSP=describe=ASSUM Shared.Dream NEC before 3IN bind-IPFV=ASSUM council

S107P

Segmented: Shele lira honu-at=t lyaven shulẅo le,

Gloss: if person hear-IPFV=DIR voice-PL wind LOC

S107A

Segmented: ru tru sovara mina-at=r lu; lin re=södhe=r lyave ke liran honu-tha=t, so-de toyete ve ta.

Gloss: then one ancestor speak-IPFV=ASSUM POSS priest-PL PROSP=record=ASSUM voice REL person-PL hear-PFV=DIR 3IN-GEN meaning ABL NEC

S108P

Segmented: Shele lira edhü-tha=t bo ra,

Gloss: if person enter-PFV=DIR mirror ALL

S108A

Segmented: ru sey re=pire=r matuklaru ra.

Gloss: then 3AN PROSP=travel=ASSUM other.world ALL

S109P

Segmented: Shele lira zey-tha=t sey-de gedhilye,

Gloss: if person see-PFV=DIR 3AN-GEN Shadow.Self

S109A

Segmented: ru sey re=göro=r, vey sey re=vire=r sey-de dhilye dho.

Gloss: then 3AN PROSP=die=ASSUM or 3AN PROSP=join=ASSUM 3AN-GEN self COM

S110P

Segmented: Shele liyu köte-at=t, day so ne nöre-at=t,

Gloss: if bush burn-IPFV=DIR but 3IN NEG fade-IPFV=DIR

S110A

Segmented: ru tru vöra sre-at-om=r.

Gloss: then one goddess reveal-IPFV-REFL=ASSUM

S111P

Segmented: Shele ẅepidhönywe thi-isk=t nolyu le,

Gloss: if inscription exist-INCEP=DIR stone LOC

S111A

Segmented: ru shayödi lablörlordhülo re=zheyu=r eyi lu; day liran re=pabi=r so karasözhewin nye ta.

Gloss: then ancient law PROSP=become=ASSUM new POSS but person-PL PROSP=read.aloud=ASSUM 3IN clan.mother-PL DAT NEC

S112P

Segmented: Shele solyu thi-isk=t wese le,

Gloss: if face exist-INCEP=DIR water LOC

S112A

Segmented: ru tru leru zey-at=r.

Gloss: then one ghost see-IPFV=ASSUM

S113P

Segmented: Shele shulẅo yaye-at=t tru melyo,

Gloss: if wind say-IPFV=DIR one name

S113A

Segmented: ru melyo ke liran honu-tha=t re=vane=r tru lira nyüdhöte ra lu; rulbelyate re=dönye=r thepabe ta.

Gloss: then name REL person-PL hear-PFV=DIR PROSP=invite=ASSUM one person duty ALL POSS maternal.house PROSP=judge=ASSUM claim NEC

S114P

Segmented: Shele wo dhule-tha=t, na yore ne thi-at=t,

Gloss: if silence fall-PFV=DIR and sound NEG exist-IPFV=DIR

S114A

Segmented: ru röpti zamu re=nöre=r lu; rulbelyaten re=thre=r pölyin, melyon, gihu na reyon ta, vene eyi dödhewu vire-at=r.

Gloss: then great season PROSP=fade=ASSUM POSS maternal.house-PL PROSP=protect=ASSUM child-PL name-PL grain and archive-PL NEC before new council join-IPFV=ASSUM

Pleune, the Last Gate at Esuosi

After the capital had fallen, Pleune remained standing beside the Esuosi marsh. The voices in this poem belong to Saẅi, a scribe of a maternal house, and to reports repeated after the siege. One account says that the people who escaped left the world altogether.

I. The two waters

B01 Esuosi le, no lowiatt rokge le. B02 Pleunede lyonye thiatt rokgede hadhe le. B03 Wipun moleatt avi wese le. B04 Thoren lowiatt nyavu le. B05 Kelythokohu dheẅiatt yu le. B06 Fiẅe lureatt lolu le. B07 Töno tizethat; tönolye lowiatt.

Mist lay over Esuosi before the watch changed. Pleune stood with its back to the marsh. Reeds stood in the shallow water. Yesterday’s footprints remained in the mud. The six-clan banner hung above the wet gate. In the tower a little covered lamp was still alight. The bell sounded, and the note hung on afterwards.

II. The earth of the truce

B08 Nyuraket Pleunede karasözhewi. B09 Saẅi södheatt melyon nyahe le. B10 Lyema slethat föle Pleune ra. B11 Nyura ranüthat ẅaro. B12 Nyura södhethat föle. B13 Narshaliyan deyuthan dhethu. B14 Saẅi zeythat nyavu dhethu le. B15 Dhethu es lilyẅe.

Nyura was a clan mother of Pleune. Saẅi was writing names in the household book. A courier brought the rolled truce. Nyura touched the council seal. She wrote out the truce. Under the truce, the northern soldiers packed the moat with earth. Saẅi saw the fresh earth in the moat, black with water. The ditch had become a road.

III. Counting the children

B16 Ophalrhande karasözhewi slethan kohu Narshaliyan nye. B17 Sey srelgothan. B18 Nyura ne södhethat srelgote. B19 Saẅi södhethat melyon. B20 Gihu ne thiats nu le. B21 “Södheim melyon.” B22 Saẅi södheatt melyon; Nyura yeatt pölyin.

Across the channel a mother of Ophalrhan took her house banner to the besiegers. By morning that house had changed allegiance. Nyura did not write down that the house had gone over. Saẅi wrote the names. There was almost no grain left to divide. “Write the names.” Saẅi went on writing names. Nyura counted the children.

IV. The sluice

B23 Ẅöru le, Narshaliyan pirethan Pleune ra. B24 Rüwun freruthat yu le. B25 Narshaliyan plökuthan rüwun. B26 Salupron plökuthat nyavu. B27 Kohu zurstithat rokge le. B28 Nyura lyarmothat rokgeẅone. B29 Wese piretha·l·zazhuthat dhethu. B30 Gihu lyüẅeatt wese le. B31 Fiẅe ne lureatt lolu le. B32 Zöẅe lowiatt wipu le.

At the evening watch the northern army came back. The sharp stakes broke at their roots. The northerners were said to be hacking at the stakes. Shots came down in the mud. A banner fell into the reeds. Nyura lifted the marsh sluice. The water returned to the earth-packed ditch, covered it, and went on. Grain floated through the breached stores. The lamp in the tower was out. A little light still caught on one reed.

V. The gate behind the gate

B33 Nyura blethat yu. B34 Ẅowüyi ünimeatt pölyin enyu shi. B35 Saẅi slethat nyahe. B36 Saẅi rüwithat vo. B37 Nyura ne pirethat enyu shi. B38 Nyura welyathat rarüzo; sey flethat yu. B39 Enyun lyüẅeatt wipun le. B40 Töno tizethat. B41 Tönolye lowiats Esuosi le. B42 Saẅi ne zeythat Nyura.

Nyura opened the back gate for the people. A ferrywoman brought the children through the channels. Saẅi carried the household book. Beneath her cloak she kept the sacred book dry. Nyura did not get into the boat. She freed the rope and closed the gate before the boat turned. The boats drifted among the reeds without a lantern. The bell rang once more. Over Esuosi the sound was slower to die. Saẅi did not see Nyura again.

VI. The road of the moon

B43 Fongali södhethan sulolilyẅe. B44 Moletharan pirethan sulo ra. B45 Sulover lilyẅe. B46 Saẅi ne zeythat lilyẅe lyafüru le. B47 Sulolye thiatt rokge le. B48 Enyun ne thiatt rokge le. B49 Sowe moleats wese le. B50 Nyurade nyawo moleatt nyavu le. B51 Saẅi zeythat nyawo; sey ne zeythat thoren. B52 Sulolye nörethat. B53 Melyon moleatt nyahe le. B54 Saẅi södhethat Nyurade melyo nyahe le.

A Phong priest later wrote that the moon had a road. From that came the story that the last people of Pleune went to the moon. The moon might be a road. Saẅi, who had been there, saw no road in the sky. The moon stood in the water of Esuosi. By morning there were no boats to be found. There was still a wake on the water. Nyura’s sandal lay in the mud. Saẅi found the sandal. There were no footprints beside it. Then the moon in the water broke up and was gone. The names were still in the book. Saẅi added Nyura’s name.

Sentence apparatus

Direct =t marks what the scribe remembers seeing; reportative =n marks what others said, including the story of the moon. Inference is marked =s. The analytical line shows the morphology that the running text joins up.

B01 · toponym; locative; direct imperfective

Khélai: Esuosi le, no lowiatt rokge le.

Segmentation: Esuosi le, no lowi-at=t rokge le.

Literal: At Esuosi, mist lingers in the marsh (witnessed).

Literary: Mist lay over Esuosi before the watch changed.

B02 · genitive; existential; nested location

Khélai: Pleunede lyonye thiatt rokgede hadhe le.

Segmentation: Pleune-de lyonye thi-at=t rokge-de hadhe le.

Literal: The fortress of Pleune stands on the shore of the marsh (witnessed).

Literary: Pleune stood with its back to the marsh.

B03 · plural; adjectival modifier; witnessed scene

Khélai: Wipun moleatt avi wese le.

Segmentation: Wipu-n mole-at=t avi wese le.

Literal: Reeds remain in shallow water (witnessed).

Literary: Reeds stood in the shallow water.

B04 · imperfective; plural; locative

Khélai: Thoren lowiatt nyavu le.

Segmentation: Thore-n lowi-at=t nyavu le.

Literal: Footprints linger in mud (witnessed).

Literary: Yesterday’s footprints remained in the mud.

B05 · generated verb; compound; location

Khélai: Kelythokohu dheẅiatt yu le.

Segmentation: Kelythokohu dheẅi-at=t yu le.

Literal: The imperial banner hangs at the gate (witnessed).

Literary: The six-clan banner hung above the wet gate.

B06 · facet word; direct evidential

Khélai: Fiẅe lureatt lolu le.

Segmentation: Fiẅe lure-at=t lolu le.

Literal: A marsh lamp shines at the tower (witnessed).

Literary: In the tower a little covered lamp was still alight.

B07 · perfective, then imperfective; after-sound noun

Khélai: Töno tizethat; tönolye lowiatt.

Segmentation: Töno tize-tha=t; tönolye lowi-at=t.

Literal: The bell rings once; its after-sound continues (witnessed).

Literary: The bell sounded, and the note hung on afterwards.

B08 · equation; matrilineal office; personal name

Khélai: Nyuraket Pleunede karasözhewi.

Segmentation: Nyura-k-e=t Pleune-de karasözhewi.

Literal: Nyura is a clan mother of Pleune (witnessed).

Literary: Nyura was a clan mother of Pleune.

B09 · scribe; SVO; locative

Khélai: Saẅi södheatt melyon nyahe le.

Segmentation: Saẅi södhe-at=t melyo-n nyahe le.

Literal: Saẅi records names in the household book (witnessed).

Literary: Saẅi was writing names in the household book.

B10 · allative; treaty noun; perfective

Khélai: Lyema slethat föle Pleune ra.

Segmentation: Lyema sle-tha=t föle Pleune ra.

Literal: A courier carries a truce document to Pleune (witnessed).

Literary: A courier brought the rolled truce.

B11 · perfective; new council term

Khélai: Nyura ranüthat ẅaro.

Segmentation: Nyura ranü-tha=t ẅaro.

Literal: Nyura touches the council seal lightly (witnessed).

Literary: Nyura touched the council seal.

B12 · perfective; legal record

Khélai: Nyura södhethat föle.

Segmentation: Nyura södhe-tha=t föle.

Literal: Nyura records the truce (witnessed).

Literary: She wrote out the truce.

B13 · reportative; siege verb

Khélai: Narshaliyan deyuthan dhethu.

Segmentation: Narshaliya-n deyu-tha=n dhethu.

Literal: The Narshalye reportedly filled the defensive moat with earth.

Literary: Under the truce, the northern soldiers packed the moat with earth.

B14 · direct evidence beside a reported action

Khélai: Saẅi zeythat nyavu dhethu le.

Segmentation: Saẅi zey-tha=t nyavu dhethu le.

Literal: Saẅi saw mud in the moat (witnessed).

Literary: Saẅi saw the fresh earth in the moat, black with water.

B15 · inferential equation

Khélai: Dhethu es lilyẅe.

Segmentation: Dhethu e=s lilyẅe.

Literal: The defensive ditch is apparently a road (inferred).

Literary: The ditch had become a road.

B16 · reported defection; genitive; dative

Khélai: Ophalrhande karasözhewi slethan kohu Narshaliyan nye.

Segmentation: Ophalrhan-de karasözhewi sle-tha=n kohu Narshaliya-n nye.

Literal: An Ophalrhan clan mother reportedly carried a war banner to the Narshalye.

Literary: Across the channel a mother of Ophalrhan took her house banner to the besiegers.

B17 · reportative; neutral verb of allegiance

Khélai: Sey srelgothan.

Segmentation: Sey srelgo-tha=n.

Literal: She reportedly changed allegiance.

Literary: By morning that house had changed allegiance.

B18 · negation; legal term

Khélai: Nyura ne södhethat srelgote.

Segmentation: Nyura ne södhe-tha=t srelgote.

Literal: Nyura did not record a change of allegiance (witnessed).

Literary: Nyura did not write down that the house had gone over.

B19 · perfective; plural object

Khélai: Saẅi södhethat melyon.

Segmentation: Saẅi södhe-tha=t melyo-n.

Literal: Saẅi recorded the names (witnessed).

Literary: Saẅi wrote the names.

B20 · negative existential; inferential; scarcity

Khélai: Gihu ne thiats nu le.

Segmentation: Gihu ne thi-at=s nu le.

Literal: Grain apparently does not remain in the granary.

Literary: There was almost no grain left to divide.

B21 · imperative; quoted speech; no evidential

Khélai: “Södheim melyon.”

Segmentation: “Södhe-im melyo-n.”

Literal: “Write the names!” (imperative).

Literary: “Write the names.”

B22 · two clauses; change of subject; imperfective

Khélai: Saẅi södheatt melyon; Nyura yeatt pölyin.

Segmentation: Saẅi södhe-at=t melyo-n; Nyura ye-at=t pölyi-n.

Literal: Saẅi records names; Nyura counts children (witnessed).

Literary: Saẅi went on writing names. Nyura counted the children.

B23 · time locative; reported movement

Khélai: Ẅöru le, Narshaliyan pirethan Pleune ra.

Segmentation: Ẅöru le, Narshaliya-n pire-tha=n Pleune ra.

Literal: At evening watch the Narshalye reportedly moved toward Pleune.

Literary: At the evening watch the northern army came back.

B24 · edge vocabulary; perfective rupture

Khélai: Rüwun freruthat yu le.

Segmentation: Rüwu-n freru-tha=t yu le.

Literal: Palisade stakes split at the gate (witnessed).

Literary: The sharpened stakes broke at their roots.

B25 · reportative; violent verb

Khélai: Narshaliyan plökuthan rüwun.

Segmentation: Narshaliya-n plöku-tha=n rüwu-n.

Literal: The Narshalye reportedly struck the palisade stakes.

Literary: The northerners were said to be hacking at the stakes.

B26 · edge consonants; witnessed impact

Khélai: Salupron plökuthat nyavu.

Segmentation: Salupro-n plöku-tha=t nyavu.

Literal: Shots struck the mud (witnessed).

Literary: Shots came down in the mud.

B27 · edge verb; locative

Khélai: Kohu zurstithat rokge le.

Segmentation: Kohu zursti-tha=t rokge le.

Literal: A banner sinks into the marsh (witnessed).

Literary: A banner fell into the reeds.

B28 · perfective; maternal authority

Khélai: Nyura lyarmothat rokgeẅone.

Segmentation: Nyura lyarmo-tha=t rokgeẅone.

Literal: Nyura releases the marsh sluice (witnessed).

Literary: Nyura lifted the marsh sluice.

B29 · sequential chain; one evidential; intransitive plus transitive predicate

Khélai: Wese piretha·l·zazhuthat dhethu.

Segmentation: Wese pire-tha=l=zazhu-tha=t dhethu.

Literal: The water moves, then inundates the defensive ditch (one direct evidential over a same-subject mixed-valency chain).

Literary: The water returned to the earth-packed ditch, covered it, and went on.

B30 · imperfective; locative

Khélai: Gihu lyüẅeatt wese le.

Segmentation: Gihu lyüẅe-at=t wese le.

Literal: Grain drifts in the water (witnessed).

Literary: Grain floated through the breached stores.

B31 · negation; repeated image

Khélai: Fiẅe ne lureatt lolu le.

Segmentation: Fiẅe ne lure-at=t lolu le.

Literal: The marsh lamp does not shine in the tower (witnessed).

Literary: The lamp in the tower was out.

B32 · imperfective; quiet consonants after the attack

Khélai: Zöẅe lowiatt wipu le.

Segmentation: Zöẅe lowi-at=t wipu le.

Literal: A glint stays on a reed (witnessed).

Literary: A little light still caught on one reed.

B33 · perfective; a second gate, not the sluice

Khélai: Nyura blethat yu.

Segmentation: Nyura ble-tha=t yu.

Literal: Nyura opened the gate (witnessed).

Literary: Nyura opened the back gate for the people.

B34 · animate agent; plural object; instrumental

Khélai: Ẅowüyi ünimeatt pölyin enyu shi.

Segmentation: Ẅowüyi ünime-at=t pölyi-n enyu shi.

Literal: The ferrywoman ferries children by boat (witnessed).

Literary: A ferrywoman brought the children through the channels.

B35 · perfective; object

Khélai: Saẅi slethat nyahe.

Segmentation: Saẅi sle-tha=t nyahe.

Literal: Saẅi carries the household book (witnessed).

Literary: Saẅi carried the household book.

B36 · perfective; verb of care

Khélai: Saẅi rüwithat vo.

Segmentation: Saẅi rüwi-tha=t vo.

Literal: Saẅi shelters the scripture-book (witnessed).

Literary: Beneath her cloak she kept the sacred book dry.

B37 · negation; instrumental

Khélai: Nyura ne pirethat enyu shi.

Segmentation: Nyura ne pire-tha=t enyu shi.

Literal: Nyura did not travel by boat (witnessed).

Literary: Nyura did not get into the boat.

B38 · two complete clauses; no improper chain

Khélai: Nyura welyathat rarüzo; sey flethat yu.

Segmentation: Nyura welya-tha=t rarüzo; sey fle-tha=t yu.

Literal: Nyura loosened the rope; she shut the gate (witnessed).

Literary: She freed the rope and closed the gate before the boat turned.

B39 · uncontrolled motion; plural

Khélai: Enyun lyüẅeatt wipun le.

Segmentation: Enyu-n lyüẅe-at=t wipu-n le.

Literal: Boats drift among the reeds (witnessed).

Literary: The boats drifted among the reeds without a lantern.

B40 · refrain; perfective

Khélai: Töno tizethat.

Segmentation: Töno tize-tha=t.

Literal: The bell rang once (witnessed).

Literary: The bell rang once more.

B41 · inference; lexicalised after-sound

Khélai: Tönolye lowiats Esuosi le.

Segmentation: Tönolye lowi-at=s Esuosi le.

Literal: The after-sound apparently remained in Esuosi.

Literary: Over Esuosi the sound was slower to die.

B42 · negation; personal name as object

Khélai: Saẅi ne zeythat Nyura.

Segmentation: Saẅi ne zey-tha=t Nyura.

Literal: Saẅi did not see Nyura (witnessed).

Literary: Saẅi did not see Nyura again.

B43 · reported priestly testimony; moon-path noun

Khélai: Fongali södhethan sulolilyẅe.

Segmentation: Fongali södhe-tha=n sulolilyẅe.

Literal: A Phong priest reportedly recorded the moon-path.

Literary: A Phong priest later wrote that the moon had a road.

B44 · reportative; collective tradition; allative

Khélai: Moletharan pirethan sulo ra.

Segmentation: Molethara-n pire-tha=n sulo ra.

Literal: The survivors reportedly travelled toward the moon.

Literary: From that came the story that the last people of Pleune went to the moon.

B45 · assumptive evidential; inherited V-class liaison; conjectural image

Khélai: Sulover lilyẅe.

Segmentation: Sulo-v-e=r lilyẅe.

Literal: The moon is provisionally taken to be a road (assumptive, with licensed V liaison).

Literary: The moon might be a road.

B46 · negative direct evidence; source contrast

Khélai: Saẅi ne zeythat lilyẅe lyafüru le.

Segmentation: Saẅi ne zey-tha=t lilyẅe lyafüru le.

Literal: Saẅi did not witness a path in the sky.

Literary: Saẅi, who had been there, saw no road in the sky.

B47 · image noun; existential

Khélai: Sulolye thiatt rokge le.

Segmentation: Sulolye thi-at=t rokge le.

Literal: The moon-image is present in the marsh (witnessed).

Literary: The moon stood in the water of Esuosi.

B48 · negative existential; imperfective

Khélai: Enyun ne thiatt rokge le.

Segmentation: Enyu-n ne thi-at=t rokge le.

Literal: The boats were not in the marsh (witnessed).

Literary: By morning there were no boats to be found.

B49 · inferential; transient evidence

Khélai: Sowe moleats wese le.

Segmentation: Sowe mole-at=s wese le.

Literal: A wake apparently remained in the water.

Literary: There was still a wake on the water.

B50 · genitive; material evidence

Khélai: Nyurade nyawo moleatt nyavu le.

Segmentation: Nyura-de nyawo mole-at=t nyavu le.

Literal: Nyura’s sandal remains in the mud (witnessed).

Literary: Nyura’s sandal lay in the mud.

B51 · parallelism; witnessed contrast

Khélai: Saẅi zeythat nyawo; sey ne zeythat thoren.

Segmentation: Saẅi zey-tha=t nyawo; sey ne zey-tha=t thore-n.

Literal: Saẅi saw the sandal; she did not see footprints (witnessed).

Literary: Saẅi found the sandal. There were no footprints beside it.

B52 · perfective; image noun

Khélai: Sulolye nörethat.

Segmentation: Sulolye nöre-tha=t.

Literal: The reflection of the moon faded (witnessed).

Literary: Then the moon in the water broke up and was gone.

B53 · plural; imperfective

Khélai: Melyon moleatt nyahe le.

Segmentation: Melyo-n mole-at=t nyahe le.

Literal: Names remain in the household book (witnessed).

Literary: The names were still in the book.

B54 · perfective; genitive; locative

Khélai: Saẅi södhethat Nyurade melyo nyahe le.

Segmentation: Saẅi södhe-tha=t Nyura-de melyo nyahe le.

Literal: Saẅi wrote Nyura’s name in the household book (witnessed).

Literary: Saẅi added Nyura’s name.

Classical Khélai Lexicon

FormMeaningPart of speechClass
nayI, mepronoun—
nayanwe, uspronoun—
duyoupronoun—
dunyou (plural)pronoun—
seyhe, she, they (singular animate)pronounanimate
seyanthey (animate)pronounanimate
soitpronouninanimate
sonthey (inanimate)pronouninanimate
halwhointerrogative—
mushwhatinterrogative—
vöwhereinterrogative—
shewheninterrogative—
dhawhyinterrogative—
ẅehowinterrogative—
prenyhow manyinterrogative—
sathisdemonstrative—
suthatdemonstrative—
sanithesedemonstrative—
sunithosedemonstrative—
sheytopic markerdiscourse particle—
komfocus markerdiscourse particle—
naand; also an attributive copula before a predicate adjectiveconjunction/copula—
daybutconjunction—
veyorconjunction—
sheleifconjunction—
ruthenconjunction—
menabecauseconjunction—
nurewhileconjunction—
gelenafterconjunction—
venebeforeconjunction—
nenotparticle—
tamust, necessityparticle—
lumay, possibilityparticle—
theintend, want; complementiserparticle—
kerelative clause markerparticle—
leat, in, onpostposition—
rato, toward, intopostposition—
vefrom, away frompostposition—
shiby means ofpostposition—
nyeto, forpostposition—
dhowith, alongsidepostposition—
-npluralsuffix—
-degenitivesuffix—
-thaperfectiveverbal aspect suffix—
-atimperfectiveverbal aspect suffix—
-ushhabitualverbal aspect suffix—
-iskinceptiveverbal aspect suffix—
-ompcompletiveverbal aspect suffix—
-imimperativeverbal mood suffix—
re=prospectivepreverbal particle—
me=resultativepreverbal particle—
-ivcausativeverbal valency suffix—
-upassiveverbal valency suffix—
-elyreciprocalverbal valency suffix—
-omreflexiveverbal valency suffix—
=tdirect evidenceevidential clitic—
=nreportative evidenceevidential clitic—
=sinferential evidenceevidential clitic—
=rassumptive evidenceevidential clitic—
=l=same-subject sequentialclause-chain clitic—
=r=same-subject simultaneousclause-chain clitic—
-tharagentivederivational suffixanimate
-teabstractivederivational suffixinanimate
thiexist, be presentcopula/verb—
ebe, equal, be identical tocopula—
Khélmelaioldest goddess; eponym of the first imperial allianceproper namefossilised
Ophalrhanwater-associated goddess; eponym of the nomadic clanproper namefossilised
Sévadraigoddess; eponym of the army-bearing clanproper namefossilised
Azravoryoungest goddess in the main line; eponym of a sanctuaryproper namefossilised
Róskaïgoddess; eponym of the parallel allianceproper namefossilised
Lunetyengoddess; child of Róskaïproper namefossilised
kelyaHyperboreannounanimate -a
fongaPhongnounanimate -a
numiyaNumi whalenounanimate -a
lirapersonnounanimate -a
dhaviworker, retainernounanimate -i
karaclan, lineage, corporate kin-groupnounanimate -a
ravayanomad, wayfarernounanimate -a
lyarasoulnounanimate -a
nariyakin, relativenounanimate -a
vöragoddessnounanimate -a
sovaraancestornounanimate -a
shalianimal spiritnounanimate -i
wesewaternouninanimate -e
sulomoonnouninanimate -o
prageark, great vesselnouninanimate -e
rumeruin, remainsnouninanimate -e
ithiremountain regionnouninanimate -e
NemoreNémorath, meadowlandproper nouninanimate -e
thareearth, soilnouninanimate -e
sareair, breathnouninanimate -e
dhudarkness, nightnouninanimate -u
farefirenouninanimate -e
yoresound, resonancenouninanimate -e
waluocean, open waternouninanimate -u
tharoarmy, hostnouninanimate -o
soresanctuary, sacred precinctnouninanimate -e
furefur, coatnouninanimate -e
nörubeaknouninanimate -u
sarostarnouninanimate -o
sharocelestial bodynouninanimate -o
kelythoempire, imperial ordernouninanimate -o
zoreflower, blossomnouninanimate -e
zaneprayer, ritual utterancenouninanimate -e
nyerepuzzle, riddle, design; as a verb, conceive, devise; secret name of Khélmelainoun/verbinanimate -e as noun
thorefootprint, track; secret name of Ophalrhannouninanimate -e
zhoresword; secret name of Sévadrainouninanimate -e
korecave, hollow; secret name of Azravornouninanimate -e
shoroobsidian; secret name of Róskaïnouninanimate -o
lyöreopal mead; secret name of Lunetyennouninanimate -e
zeysee, witnessverb—
naredwell, live in a placeverb—
zireawaken, stir into lifeverb—
piretravel, moveverb—
vomemake, create, establishverb—
faleknow, understandverb—
zhareworship, propitiateverb—
daredescend, landverb—
virejoin, uniteverb—
shalefight, feudverb—
zareseekverb—
vaneinvite, summon into an allianceverb—
yaveadmit, incorporate into an institutionverb—
moleremain, stayverb—
lureshine, radiateverb—
nörefade, dissipate; fleeting, transientverb/adjective—
vösidelicate, beautifuladjective—
luriluminous, brightadjective—
nyelitelepathic, mind-linkedadjective—
rorilong, extendedadjective—
mirilittle, scantadjective—
piretejourney, pilgrimagenouninanimate -e
faleteknowledge, learningnouninanimate -e
nöretetransiencenouninanimate -e
truonenumeral—
linytwonumeral—
athreenumeral—
ninfournumeral—
prefivenumeral—
hosixnumeral—
zusevennumeral—
bueightnumeral—
toninenumeral—
ertennumeral—
haelevennumeral—
thraltwelvenumeral—
lyihealernounanimate -i
shrescatterverb—
flecloseverb—
lipriestnounanimate -i
srerevealverb—
threprotectverb—
nyaartisannounanimate -a
ẅulagoonnouninanimate -u
nomistnouninanimate -o
ralyisecretadjective—
bomirrornouninanimate -o
dayifragileadjective—
önoloomnouninanimate -o
kiscribenounanimate -i
geshadownouninanimate -e
serateachernounanimate -a
ziexilenounanimate -i
bürehearthnouninanimate -e
demeasureverb—
recarveverb—
roinknouninanimate -o
laligentleadjective—
üpepromiseverb—
nugranarynouninanimate -u
hebindverb—
zecrystalnouninanimate -e
godreamnouninanimate -o
fucoastnouninanimate -u
namisweetadjective—
lyostandardnouninanimate -o
hagewusnownouninanimate -u
freconcealverb—
mamemliscoutnounanimate -i
yugatenouninanimate -u
povibrittleadjective—
bleopenverb—
ẅelicaptainnounanimate -i
pawugriefnouninanimate -u
towifrujoynouninanimate -u
wosilencenouninanimate -o
rudheanchorverb—
mayeendureverb—
gustreamnouninanimate -u
lesoaltarnouninanimate -o
söynediveverb—
nezhirestlessadjective—
dhüliswiftadjective—
yecountverb—
nyanedivideverb—
nipemendverb—
södherecordverb—
luyetidenouninanimate -e
ẅayiwitnessnounanimate -i
köẅidistantadjective—
shethiwarmadjective—
tizesingverb—
söfisilentadjective—
frusignalnouninanimate -u
laveofferingnouninanimate -e
nyubasketnouninanimate -u
ürzedreamverb—
nözibeomennouninanimate -e
yemnyibitteradjective—
gewipatientadjective—
telampnouninanimate -e
yonefreezeverb—
dhegardennouninanimate -e
pelensnouninanimate -e
rökeinhaleverb—
zhofuelnouninanimate -o
meforgetverb—
islesailverb—
kreliftverb—
lathicoldadjective—
rokgemarshnouninanimate -e
mözetraceverb—
lyetabletnouninanimate -e
rükhawuislandnouninanimate -u
wecompassnouninanimate -e
hadheshorenouninanimate -e
zushaguardnounanimate -a
dhaninarrowadjective—
ümeigniteverb—
riksesaltnouninanimate -e
fecupnouninanimate -e
klepolishverb—
tohtethurivernouninanimate -u
shretescattering; act of scatteringnouninanimate -e
kumemorynouninanimate -u
maapprenticenounanimate -a
örlyereceiveverb—
rikaenvoynounanimate -a
gömiyewallnouninanimate -e
slecarryverb—
lyuscrollnouninanimate -u
mocurrentnouninanimate -o
looathnouninanimate -o
vreextinguishverb—
woshwucloudnouninanimate -u
becopyverb—
nesishnemercynouninanimate -e
nezhiterestlessness; quality of being restlessnouninanimate -e
föklechartnouninanimate -e
liosipriest-relatedadjective—
tenaliwithout lamp; lacking lampadjective—
wubreadnouninanimate -u
pleshelterverb—
senaliwithout riverbank; lacking riverbankadjective—
ẅobridgenouninanimate -o
lyonyefortressnouninanimate -e
zoechonouninanimate -o
vleweaveverb—
thothoughtnouninanimate -o
fleteclosing; act of closingnouninanimate -e
tregatherverb—
lümihiddenadjective—
moosicurrent-relatedadjective—
garimessengernounanimate -i
kazheexhaleverb—
mülkeswimverb—
nawideepadjective—
avishallowadjective—
dönyejudgeverb—
zherememberverb—
vretharapractitioner of extinguishingnounanimate -a
lyoosistandard-relatedadjective—
ẅunaliwithout lagoon; lacking lagoonadjective—
zheteremembering; act of rememberingnouninanimate -e
wuosibread-relatedadjective—
geosishadow-relatedadjective—
fruosisignal-relatedadjective—
möverainnouninanimate -e
teosilamp-relatedadjective—
nyaosiartisan-relatedadjective—
seriverbanknouninanimate -e
monaliwithout current; lacking currentadjective—
yuzhasailornounanimate -a
fletharapractitioner of closingnounanimate -a
södhetharapractitioner of recordingnounanimate -a
lyunaliwithout scroll; lacking scrolladjective—
freteconcealing; act of concealingnouninanimate -e
rüfehealverb—
nökiheavyadjective—
kuletemelting; act of meltingnouninanimate -e
thumfafishernounanimate -a
thretharapractitioner of protectingnounanimate -a
gariosimessenger-relatedadjective—
ümetharapractitioner of ignitingnounanimate -a
gizeforestnouninanimate -e
gihugrainnouninanimate -u
rarüzoropenouninanimate -o
luworeefnouninanimate -o
thoosithought-relatedadjective—
yunaliwithout gate; lacking gateadjective—
shisgetechanting; act of chantingnouninanimate -e
röketeinhaling; act of inhalingnouninanimate -e
fuosicoast-relatedadjective—
luyeositide-relatedadjective—
mövenaliwithout rain; lacking rainadjective—
kuosimemory-relatedadjective—
gihuosigrain-relatedadjective—
shilyenyopatternnouninanimate -o
noosimist-relatedadjective—
nyimunaliwithout roof; lacking roofadjective—
isletesailing; act of sailingnouninanimate -e
nyimuroofnouninanimate -u
köẅitedistantness; quality of being distantnouninanimate -e
önonaliwithout loom; lacking loomadjective—
nuosigranary-relatedadjective—
sreterevealing; act of revealingnouninanimate -e
daslyesurfaceverb—
üpetharapractitioner of promisingnounanimate -a
detharapractitioner of measuringnounanimate -a
dherihollowadjective—
söynetharapractitioner of divingnounanimate -a
tönyibroadadjective—
kulemeltverb—
shisgechantverb—
yuzhaosisailor-relatedadjective—
feosicup-relatedadjective—
mötoroadnouninanimate -o
hagewunaliwithout snow; lacking snowadjective—
gewitepatientness; quality of being patientnouninanimate -e
dönyetharapractitioner of judgingnounanimate -a
rudheteanchoring; act of anchoringnouninanimate -e
woshwunaliwithout cloud; lacking cloudadjective—
bürenaliwithout hearth; lacking hearthadjective—
rikseosisalt-relatedadjective—
üpetepromising; act of promisingnouninanimate -e
farezhofire fuelnouninanimate -o
sretharapractitioner of revealingnounanimate -a
sarenoair mistnouninanimate -o
mötonaliwithout road; lacking roadadjective—
bleteopening; act of openingnouninanimate -e
ziosiexile-relatedadjective—
ẅeliosicaptain-relatedadjective—
ẅoosibridge-relatedadjective—
seosiriverbank-relatedadjective—
karakiclan scribenounanimate -i
mülketeswimming; act of swimmingnouninanimate -e
nawitedeepness; quality of being deepnouninanimate -e
hetebinding; act of bindingnouninanimate -e
zaneboprayer mirrornouninanimate -o
söfitesilentness; quality of being silentnouninanimate -e
löfoleicenouninanimate -e
shethitewarmness; quality of being warmnouninanimate -e
ümeteigniting; act of ignitingnouninanimate -e
weseẅuwater lagoonnouninanimate -u
gunaliwithout stream; lacking streamadjective—
olodhemechanismnouninanimate -e
retecarving; act of carvingnouninanimate -e
sletharapractitioner of carryingnounanimate -a
dhenyözhenpraeldernounanimate -a
lyiosihealer-relatedadjective—
nyanetharapractitioner of dividingnounanimate -a
thorebofootprint mirrornouninanimate -o
mamemliosiscout-relatedadjective—
woosisilence-relatedadjective—
lyuosiscroll-relatedadjective—
faretefire lampnouninanimate -e
wesefewater cupnouninanimate -e
daslyetharapractitioner of surfacingnounanimate -a
lyörelesoopal-mead altarnouninanimate -o
yonetefreezing; act of freezingnouninanimate -e
kelytholoimperial oathnouninanimate -o
zoredheflower gardennouninanimate -e
vleteweaving; act of weavingnouninanimate -e
büreosihearth-relatedadjective—
shalilaveanimal-spirit offeringnouninanimate -e
thoremötofootprint roadnouninanimate -o
sorelisanctuary priestnounanimate -i
lalitegentleness; quality of being gentlenouninanimate -e
mayeteenduring; act of enduringnouninanimate -e
tharoyecount army (generically, as an activity)verb—
zanelyeprayer tabletnouninanimate -e
tönyitebroadness; quality of being broadnouninanimate -e
yenokshetranslateverb—
retharapractitioner of carvingnounanimate -a
shisgetharapractitioner of chantingnounanimate -a
numiyafruNumi signalnouninanimate -u
fökleosichart-relatedadjective—
vletharapractitioner of weavingnounanimate -a
isletharapractitioner of sailingnounanimate -a
fösreyocensusnouninanimate -o
thumfaosifisher-relatedadjective—
tizetharapractitioner of singingnounanimate -a
nyuosibasket-relatedadjective—
guosistream-relatedadjective—
threteprotecting; act of protectingnouninanimate -e
kazheteexhaling; act of exhalingnouninanimate -e
thoreẅofootprint bridgenouninanimate -o
shaliboanimal-spirit mirrornouninanimate -o
zhorelosword oathnouninanimate -o
walufuocean-facing coastnouninanimate -u
zoreslecarry flower (generically, as an activity)verb—
dhuzhallyunobatterynouninanimate -o
gihunaliwithout grain; lacking grainadjective—
waluẅuocean lagoonnouninanimate -u
luyenaliwithout tide; lacking tideadjective—
wendöskelyucircuitnouninanimate -u
föwülocalendarnouninanimate -o
fareslecarry fire (generically, as an activity)verb—
pletesheltering; act of shelteringnouninanimate -e
ronaliwithout ink; lacking inkadjective—
dayitefragileness; quality of being fragilenouninanimate -e
sarobostar mirrornouninanimate -o
sletecarrying; act of carryingnouninanimate -e
zushaosiguard-relatedadjective—
seraositeacher-relatedadjective—
sloregicircularadjective—
sulogomoon dreamnouninanimate -o
lyöreslecarry opal-mead (generically, as an activity)verb—
zanzhurnotribunalnouninanimate -o
shayödiancientadjective—
yemnyitebitterness; quality of being bitternouninanimate -e
dhüliteswiftness; quality of being swiftnouninanimate -e
zhorebosword mirrornouninanimate -o
zorenoflower mistnouninanimate -o
lawolfitransparentadjective—
gisobispiraladjective—
gizeosiforest-relatedadjective—
hadhenaliwithout shore; lacking shoreadjective—
funaliwithout coast; lacking coastadjective—
nöruklepolish beak (generically, as an activity)verb—
soresrereveal sanctuary (generically, as an activity)verb—
ürzetedreaming; act of dreamingnouninanimate -e
bletharapractitioner of openingnounanimate -a
farezefire crystalnouninanimate -e
hagewuosisnow-relatedadjective—
farebofire mirrornouninanimate -o
shilyenyoosipattern-relatedadjective—
woshwuosicloud-relatedadjective—
mözetharapractitioner of tracingnounanimate -a
layisteallyverb—
kiosiscribe-relatedadjective—
dhusödherecord darkness (generically, as an activity)verb—
walumoocean currentnouninanimate -o
shaligoanimal-spirit dreamnouninanimate -o
fongaẅayiPhong witnessnounanimate -i
shretharapractitioner of scatteringnounanimate -a
hetharapractitioner of bindingnounanimate -a
wesedemeasure water (generically, as an activity)verb—
zorefeflower cupnouninanimate -e
slevilöshöshfealloynouninanimate -e
yonetharapractitioner of freezingnounanimate -a
ẅuosilagoon-relatedadjective—
tharosödherecord army (generically, as an activity)verb—
nesishneosimercy-relatedadjective—
ẅiyenoshriyeobservatorynouninanimate -e
sulodemeasure moon (generically, as an activity)verb—
örlyetharapractitioner of receivingnounanimate -a
yetecounting; act of countingnouninanimate -e
saropestar lensnouninanimate -e
dheritehollowness; quality of being hollownouninanimate -e
nyereboriddle mirrornouninanimate -o
zünyamshrunlonaliwithout glacier; lacking glacieradjective—
lirenasveprodecreenouninanimate -o
tretharapractitioner of gatheringnounanimate -a
thoresefootprint riverbanknouninanimate -e
wesebowater mirrornouninanimate -o
wesedhewater gardennouninanimate -e
shorosödherecord obsidian (generically, as an activity)verb—
maosiapprentice-relatedadjective—
dhenyözhenpraosielder-relatedadjective—
gömiyenaliwithout wall; lacking walladjective—
shoroslecarry obsidian (generically, as an activity)verb—
waluhadheocean shorenouninanimate -e
sareboair mirrornouninanimate -o
ithireẅoÍthir bridgenouninanimate -o
sulobomoon mirrornouninanimate -o
vöragodivine dreamnouninanimate -o
furevleweave fur (generically, as an activity)verb—
lümitehiddenness; quality of being hiddennouninanimate -e
ithireyuÍthir gatenouninanimate -u
walufruocean signalnouninanimate -u
tretegathering; act of gatheringnouninanimate -e
zhoregesword shadownouninanimate -e
waluyuzhaocean sailornounanimate -a
pletharapractitioner of shelteringnounanimate -a
sorelavesanctuary offeringnouninanimate -e
wesepewater lensnouninanimate -e
ithireweÍthir compassnouninanimate -e
fretharapractitioner of concealingnounanimate -a
koresrereveal cave (generically, as an activity)verb—
gösüshpecalculateverb—
korelesocave altarnouninanimate -o
zhorenyasword artisannounanimate -a
namitesweetness; quality of being sweetnouninanimate -e
nyerekuriddle memorynouninanimate -u
kretelifting; act of liftingnouninanimate -e
lyöreörlyereceive opal-mead (generically, as an activity)verb—
vuwelidivinernounanimate -i
dhanitenarrowness; quality of being narrownouninanimate -e
thrabuwechartverb—
dhusrereveal darkness (generically, as an activity)verb—
thareslecarry earth (generically, as an activity)verb—
peosilens-relatedadjective—
zanekuprayer memorynouninanimate -u
rükhawuosiisland-relatedadjective—
tohtethunaliwithout river; lacking riveradjective—
lesoosialtar-relatedadjective—
savrokrawutöshoconstellationnouninanimate -o
nörudemeasure beak (generically, as an activity)verb—
korezocave echonouninanimate -o
kletepolishing; act of polishingnouninanimate -e
tizetesinging; act of singingnouninanimate -e
rükhawunaliwithout island; lacking islandadjective—
löfolenaliwithout ice; lacking iceadjective—
boosimirror-relatedadjective—
korezecave crystalnouninanimate -e
yetharapractitioner of countingnounanimate -a
karaloclan oathnouninanimate -o
mötoosiroad-relatedadjective—
wesefruwater signalnouninanimate -u
lyaragosoul dreamnouninanimate -o
yidhöẅiresilientadjective—
tharedemeasure earth (generically, as an activity)verb—
yoredemeasure sound (generically, as an activity)verb—
sulosödherecord moon (generically, as an activity)verb—
fareümeignite fire (generically, as an activity)verb—
lyenaliwithout tablet; lacking tabletadjective—
karazushaclan guardnounanimate -a
loosioath-relatedadjective—
shorolesoobsidian altarnouninanimate -o
koreshezucave manuscriptnouninanimate -u
dheosigarden-relatedadjective—
farevreextinguish fire (generically, as an activity)verb—
rokgenaliwithout marsh; lacking marshadjective—
tohtethuosiriver-relatedadjective—
nörusödherecord beak (generically, as an activity)verb—
lyöreboopal-mead mirrornouninanimate -o
möveosirain-relatedadjective—
lyörethoopal-mead thoughtnouninanimate -o
kazhetharapractitioner of exhalingnounanimate -a
sulofrumoon signalnouninanimate -u
zhetharapractitioner of rememberingnounanimate -a
sharosödherecord celestial body (generically, as an activity)verb—
ralyitesecretness; quality of being secretnouninanimate -e
dönyetejudging; act of judgingnouninanimate -e
dhudemeasure darkness (generically, as an activity)verb—
waluthreprotect ocean (generically, as an activity)verb—
ithireguÍthir streamnouninanimate -u
daslyetesurfacing; act of surfacingnouninanimate -e
nyerelyeriddle tabletnouninanimate -e
ẅonaliwithout bridge; lacking bridgeadjective—
shaliẅuanimal-spirit lagoonnouninanimate -u
pragesrereveal ark (generically, as an activity)verb—
fenaliwithout cup; lacking cupadjective—
lyumyobenegotiateverb—
kretharapractitioner of liftingnounanimate -a
zanefruprayer signalnouninanimate -u
goosidream-relatedadjective—
sarowestar compassnouninanimate -e
lyarapawusoul griefnouninanimate -u
wösdhinloseenginenouninanimate -e
söynetediving; act of divingnouninanimate -e
nyanetedividing; act of dividingnouninanimate -e
farebürefire hearthnouninanimate -e
betecopying; act of copyingnouninanimate -e
nipetharapractitioner of mendingnounanimate -a
fongarikaPhong envoynounanimate -a
rüfetehealing; act of healingnouninanimate -e
sarefruair signalnouninanimate -u
zaneroprayer inknouninanimate -o
lyüpödhetransmitverb—
leranleprocessionnouninanimate -e
womdhenonfrölruvacuumnouninanimate -u
numiyamoNumi currentnouninanimate -o
ithiregeÍthir shadownouninanimate -e
föpinlesurveyverb—
rumesödherecord ruin (generically, as an activity)verb—
zanethoprayer thoughtnouninanimate -o
örlyetereceiving; act of receivingnouninanimate -e
sarezoair echonouninanimate -o
fureklepolish fur (generically, as an activity)verb—
zanelyuprayer scrollnouninanimate -u
skünloteligenyiinterpreternounanimate -i
lyeositablet-relatedadjective—
hadheosishore-relatedadjective—
vöralesodivine altarnouninanimate -o
talyolynecommuneverb—
lyarapleshelter soul (generically, as an activity)verb—
zhoreslecarry sword (generically, as an activity)verb—
zorelaveflower offeringnouninanimate -e
pragepeark lensnouninanimate -e
södheterecording; act of recordingnouninanimate -e
vörawodivine silencenouninanimate -o
korewocave silencenouninanimate -o
zhorezesword crystalnouninanimate -e
lyarakusoul memorynouninanimate -u
nyereperiddle lensnouninanimate -e
metharapractitioner of forgettingnounanimate -a
meteforgetting; act of forgettingnouninanimate -e
zoosiecho-relatedadjective—
lyararüfeheal soul (generically, as an activity)verb—
nonaliwithout mist; lacking mistadjective—
sarosödherecord star (generically, as an activity)verb—
shalirüfeheal animal-spirit (generically, as an activity)verb—
pragesödherecord ark (generically, as an activity)verb—
nipetemending; act of mendingnouninanimate -e
waluluyeocean tidenouninanimate -e
yuosigate-relatedadjective—
vreteextinguishing; act of extinguishingnouninanimate -e
saroyecount star (generically, as an activity)verb—
detemeasuring; act of measuringnouninanimate -e
rudhetharapractitioner of anchoringnounanimate -a
lathitecoldness; quality of being coldnouninanimate -e
dhunyaysomyiastronomernounanimate -i
lyörefeopal-mead cupnouninanimate -e
luwoosireef-relatedadjective—
povitebrittleness; quality of being brittlenouninanimate -e
ẅayiosiwitness-relatedadjective—
mülketharapractitioner of swimmingnounanimate -a
zhoosifuel-relatedadjective—
fongagariPhong messengernounanimate -i
nyunaliwithout basket; lacking basketadjective—
lyörelaveopal-mead offeringnouninanimate -e
NemoredheNémorath gardennouninanimate -e
thoresrereveal footprint (generically, as an activity)verb—
nökiteheavyness; quality of being heavynouninanimate -e
karagariclan messengernounanimate -i
weosicompass-relatedadjective—
shaliluwoanimal-spirit reefnouninanimate -o
röketharapractitioner of inhalingnounanimate -a
walufökleocean chartnouninanimate -e
kletharapractitioner of polishingnounanimate -a
thorefufootprint coastnouninanimate -u
sulogemoon shadownouninanimate -e
thorewefootprint compassnouninanimate -e
rümgipemyuedictnouninanimate -u
önoosiloom-relatedadjective—
koregecave shadownouninanimate -e
vöralavedivine offeringnouninanimate -e
shaligizeanimal-spirit forestnouninanimate -e
rokgeosimarsh-relatedadjective—
zoretregather flower (generically, as an activity)verb—
ifrullyünopilgrimage sitenouninanimate -o
thowödhenaliwithout delta; lacking deltaadjective—
numiyaẅuNumi lagoonnouninanimate -u
aviteshallowness; quality of being shallownouninanimate -e
saroföklestar chartnouninanimate -e
zoreboflower mirrornouninanimate -o
zaneshezuprayer manuscriptnouninanimate -u
lyörezoopal-mead echonouninanimate -o
pawuosigrief-relatedadjective—
lyonyeosifortress-relatedadjective—
salyükerlogearnouninanimate -o
NemorenuNémorath granarynouninanimate -u
betharapractitioner of copyingnounanimate -a
mözetetracing; act of tracingnouninanimate -e
thoremözetrace footprint (generically, as an activity)verb—
fleeseinstrument for closingnouninanimate -e
sorebüresanctuary hearthnouninanimate -e
zeosicrystal-relatedadjective—
gizenaliwithout forest; lacking forestadjective—
zanelaveprayer offeringnouninanimate -e
nezhifirestless-making; causing restlessnessadjective—
lyarawosoul silencenouninanimate -o
füvulyafvlotreasurynouninanimate -o
roosiink-relatedadjective—
zorelyoflower standardnouninanimate -o
fongalyiPhong healernounanimate -i
soresödherecord sanctuary (generically, as an activity)verb—
züdherüshamperelaynouninanimate -e
duthilyerawucovenantnouninanimate -u
treeseinstrument for gatheringnouninanimate -e
rarüzonaliwithout rope; lacking ropeadjective—
weseluwowater reefnouninanimate -o
rarüzoosirope-relatedadjective—
shororecarve obsidian (generically, as an activity)verb—
prageweark compassnouninanimate -e
zanezoprayer echonouninanimate -o
rumesrereveal ruin (generically, as an activity)verb—
suloluyemoon tidenouninanimate -e
kleeseinstrument for polishingnouninanimate -e
towifruosijoy-relatedadjective—
rüfetharapractitioner of healingnounanimate -a
karalyoclan standardnouninanimate -o
pragezhoark fuelnouninanimate -o
weseslecarry water (generically, as an activity)verb—
wetsüthreinscribeverb—
lyarathosoul thoughtnouninanimate -o
mayetharapractitioner of enduringnounanimate -a
vöralodivine oathnouninanimate -o
numiyazoNumi echonouninanimate -o
korelavecave offeringnouninanimate -e
kuletharapractitioner of meltingnounanimate -a
shorolyeobsidian tabletnouninanimate -e
zorelesoflower altarnouninanimate -o
shorolyoobsidian standardnouninanimate -o
zorelyuflower scrollnouninanimate -u
bleeseinstrument for openingnouninanimate -e
nözibeosiomen-relatedadjective—
wesemowater currentnouninanimate -o
waluluwoocean reefnouninanimate -o
tharopleshelter army (generically, as an activity)verb—
zaneshisgechant prayer (generically, as an activity)verb—
skareteguchroniclenouninanimate -u
luwonaliwithout reef; lacking reefadjective—
shoropeobsidian lensnouninanimate -e
farefrufire signalnouninanimate -u
zoreroflower inknouninanimate -o
weseörlyereceive water (generically, as an activity)verb—
nyimuosiroof-relatedadjective—
telyanlepreserveverb—
zorevleweave flower (generically, as an activity)verb—
talyolynetecommuning; act of communingnouninanimate -e
avifishallow-making; causing shallownessadjective—
rikaosienvoy-relatedadjective—
hinyöẅedistributeverb—
thoresödherecord footprint (generically, as an activity)verb—
löfoleosiice-relatedadjective—
zhoreẅelisword captainnounanimate -i
ẅepidhönyweinscriptionnouninanimate -e
zhorelyosword standardnouninanimate -o
korebocave mirrornouninanimate -o
laveosioffering-relatedadjective—
zorenyuflower basketnouninanimate -u
sulolesomoon altarnouninanimate -o
ürzetharapractitioner of dreamingnounanimate -a
shezumanuscriptnouninanimate -u
vörabodivine mirrornouninanimate -o
shoroboobsidian mirrornouninanimate -o
shalilesoanimal-spirit altarnouninanimate -o
tharnyiyuprophecynouninanimate -u
thoreyufootprint gatenouninanimate -u
vörazodivine echonouninanimate -o
wösathnodhümyearchivenouninanimate -e
korepecave lensnouninanimate -e
yoresödherecord sound (generically, as an activity)verb—
ümeeseinstrument for ignitingnouninanimate -e
goralyinynayopressurenouninanimate -o
örlyeuneplace for receivingnouninanimate -e
fongagoPhong dreamnouninanimate -o
gömiyeosiwall-relatedadjective—
lyörekuopal-mead memorynouninanimate -u
zoreshezuflower manuscriptnouninanimate -u
nyeregoriddle dreamnouninanimate -o
heuneplace for bindingnouninanimate -e
voyufanyüreestuarynouninanimate -e
kararikaclan envoynounanimate -a
sarofrustar signalnouninanimate -u
zhoreklepolish sword (generically, as an activity)verb—
telyanletepreserving; act of preservingnouninanimate -e
fongathoPhong thoughtnouninanimate -o
nyerethoriddle thoughtnouninanimate -o
shorozeobsidian crystalnouninanimate -e
fureslecarry fur (generically, as an activity)verb—
sorelosanctuary oathnouninanimate -o
elfolyuzhosensornouninanimate -o
waluweocean compassnouninanimate -e
sorelyosanctuary standardnouninanimate -o
lyarazosoul echonouninanimate -o
föpinleeseinstrument for surveyingnouninanimate -e
NemoreyuNémorath gatenouninanimate -u
koredhecave gardennouninanimate -e
sharodemeasure celestial body (generically, as an activity)verb—
voyufanyürenaliwithout estuary; lacking estuaryadjective—
saremövewind-driven rainnouninanimate -e
nindarzhenavigateverb—
karaẅeliclan captainnounanimate -i
shoroklepolish obsidian (generically, as an activity)verb—
threuneplace for protectingnouninanimate -e
deuneplace for measuringnouninanimate -e
thowödhedeltanouninanimate -e
soreyusanctuary gatenouninanimate -u
deeseinstrument for measuringnouninanimate -e
thowödheosidelta-relatedadjective—
sulolyomoon standardnouninanimate -o
lyumyobetharapractitioner of negotiatingnounanimate -a
lyöregoopal-mead dreamnouninanimate -o
sareweair compassnouninanimate -e
shorolaveobsidian offeringnouninanimate -e
reuneplace for carvingnouninanimate -e
mözeeseinstrument for tracingnouninanimate -e
isleuneplace for sailingnouninanimate -e
thoregizefootprint forestnouninanimate -e
lyüpödheuneplace for transmittingnouninanimate -e
yöharvyöpivyanavigatornounanimate -a
dönyeuneplace for judgingnouninanimate -e
luẅidheinterpretverb—
luẅidhetharapractitioner of interpretingnounanimate -a
rüfeeseinstrument for healingnouninanimate -e
zünyamshrunloglaciernouninanimate -o
sorenyimusanctuary roofnouninanimate -u
nörurecarve beak (generically, as an activity)verb—
suloföklemoon chartnouninanimate -e
sorethreprotect sanctuary (generically, as an activity)verb—
faregihufire grainnouninanimate -u
farenyimufire roofnouninanimate -u
ifrullyünoosipilgrimage site-relatedadjective—
shalithreprotect animal-spirit (generically, as an activity)verb—
talyolynetharapractitioner of communingnounanimate -a
yemnyifibitter-making; causing bitternessadjective—
sorelesosanctuary altarnouninanimate -o
NemoreguNémorath streamnouninanimate -u
lümifihidden-making; causing hiddennessadjective—
vleuneplace for weavingnouninanimate -e
NemorelyoNémorath standardnouninanimate -o
sareluyeair tidenouninanimate -e
kelythozushaimperial guardnounanimate -a
zhorefreconceal sword (generically, as an activity)verb—
talyolyneuneplace for communingnouninanimate -e
layisteteallying; act of allyingnouninanimate -e
numiyafuNumi coastnouninanimate -u
dhuluẅidheinterpret darkness (generically, as an activity)verb—
yidhöẅiteresilientness; quality of being resilientnouninanimate -e
thüslanbolnyithrovalvenouninanimate -o
shisgeuneplace for chantingnouninanimate -e
weselesowater altarnouninanimate -o
heeseinstrument for bindingnouninanimate -e
hinyöẅetharapractitioner of distributingnounanimate -a
örlyeeseinstrument for receivingnouninanimate -e
zhorelyonyesword fortressnouninanimate -e
lyumyobeuneplace for negotiatingnouninanimate -e
shalisödherecord animal-spirit (generically, as an activity)verb—
zünyamshrunloosiglacier-relatedadjective—
shezuosimanuscript-relatedadjective—
wendöskelyuosicircuit-relatedadjective—
gösüshpetecalculating; act of calculatingnouninanimate -e
namifisweet-making; causing sweetnessadjective—
treuneplace for gatheringnouninanimate -e
luẅidheeseinstrument for interpretingnouninanimate -e
polufrenuwanyolabyrinthnouninanimate -o
nawifideep-making; causing deepnessadjective—
farenözibedissipation omen: Fire → Sound; animal spirits dispersenouninanimate -e
fongamamemliPhong scoutnounanimate -i
shayöditeancientness; quality of being ancientnouninanimate -e
föpinleuneplace for surveyingnouninanimate -e
fleuneplace for closingnouninanimate -e
zanesödherecord prayer (generically, as an activity)verb—
zanetharnyiyuprayer prophecynouninanimate -u
thorenözibeawakening omen: Earth → Water; animal spirits awakennouninanimate -e
lirenasveproosidecree-relatedadjective—
lyaraörlyereceive soul (generically, as an activity)verb—
beuneplace for copyingnouninanimate -e
rudheeseinstrument for anchoringnouninanimate -e
vöranesishnedivine mercynouninanimate -e
slevilöshöshfeosialloy-relatedadjective—
lyumyobetenegotiating; act of negotiatingnouninanimate -e
karaleranleclan processionnouninanimate -e
vleeseinstrument for weavingnouninanimate -e
kreeseinstrument for liftingnouninanimate -e
vuweliosidiviner-relatedadjective—
yenokshetetranslating; act of translatingnouninanimate -e
zoreleranleflower processionnouninanimate -e
lyarashezusoul manuscriptnouninanimate -u
sulotharnyiyumoon prophecynouninanimate -u
yenokshetharapractitioner of translatingnounanimate -a
kelytholeranleimperial processionnouninanimate -e
dhuzhallyunoosibattery-relatedadjective—
kelytholyoimperial standardnouninanimate -o
thoreföklefootprint chartnouninanimate -e
lalifigentle-making; causing gentlenessadjective—
sleeseinstrument for carryingnouninanimate -e
lyaratharnyiyusoul prophecynouninanimate -u
kelytholyonyeimperial fortressnouninanimate -e
shorofüvulyafvloobsidian treasurynouninanimate -o
kelythogariimperial messengernounanimate -i
rumetelyanlepreserve ruin (generically, as an activity)verb—
skareteguosichronicle-relatedadjective—
faretelyanlepreserve fire (generically, as an activity)verb—
yorelyüpödhetransmit sound (generically, as an activity)verb—
ithiretharnyiyuÍthir prophecynouninanimate -u
vreuneplace for extinguishingnouninanimate -e
züdherüshampeosirelay-relatedadjective—
tharoföpinlesurvey army (generically, as an activity)verb—
beeseinstrument for copyingnouninanimate -e
lathificold-making; causing coldnessadjective—
thoreluẅidheinterpret footprint (generically, as an activity)verb—
lyöretelyanlepreserve opal-mead (generically, as an activity)verb—
saroshilyenyostar patternnouninanimate -o
lyöretharnyiyuopal-mead prophecynouninanimate -u
shaliskareteguanimal-spirit chroniclenouninanimate -u
dhanifinarrow-making; causing narrownessadjective—
tönyifibroad-making; causing broadnessadjective—
sulonözibemoon omennouninanimate -e
föwüloosicalendar-relatedadjective—
karadhenyözhenpraclan eldernounanimate -a
södheeseinstrument for recordingnouninanimate -e
karafösreyoclan censusnouninanimate -o
thorehadhefootprint shorenouninanimate -e
thrabuwetecharting; act of chartingnouninanimate -e
shalitharnyiyuanimal-spirit prophecynouninanimate -u
pragesalyükerloark gearnouninanimate -o
yeeseinstrument for countingnouninanimate -e
ithiremötoÍthir roadnouninanimate -o
kelythothreprotect imperial (generically, as an activity)verb—
walunindarzhenavigate ocean (generically, as an activity)verb—
zanewösathnodhümyeprayer archivenouninanimate -e
kelythosödherecord imperial (generically, as an activity)verb—
pragewösathnodhümyeark archivenouninanimate -e
nindarzheuneplace for navigatingnouninanimate -e
ithirefökleÍthir chartnouninanimate -e
wösathnodhümyeosiarchive-relatedadjective—
thrabuweeseinstrument for chartingnouninanimate -e
lyöreskareteguopal-mead chroniclenouninanimate -u
sharothrabuwechart celestial body (generically, as an activity)verb—
nökifiheavy-making; causing heavynessadjective—
faregoralyinynayofire pressurenouninanimate -o
nyaneeseinstrument for dividingnouninanimate -e
lyüpödhetetransmitting; act of transmittingnouninanimate -e
soretharnyiyusanctuary prophecynouninanimate -u
köẅifidistant-making; causing distantnessadjective—
ralyifisecret-making; causing secretnessadjective—
rümgipemyuosiedict-relatedadjective—
povifibrittle-making; causing brittlenessadjective—
kelythofösreyoimperial censusnouninanimate -o
rüfeuneplace for healingnouninanimate -e
lyaratelyanlepreserve soul (generically, as an activity)verb—
zoretelyanlepreserve flower (generically, as an activity)verb—
sarowösdhinlosestar enginenouninanimate -e
sharoluẅidheinterpret celestial body (generically, as an activity)verb—
faretharnyiyufire prophecynouninanimate -u
nyereshezuriddle manuscriptnouninanimate -u
koreföpinlesurvey cave (generically, as an activity)verb—
olodheosimechanism-relatedadjective—
numiyaluwoNumi reefnouninanimate -o
telyanleuneplace for preservingnouninanimate -e
vreeseinstrument for extinguishingnouninanimate -e
fongathumfaPhong fishernounanimate -a
zhorezanzhurnosword tribunalnouninanimate -o
womdhenonfrölruosivacuum-relatedadjective—
vöratowifrudivine joynouninanimate -u
thorezünyamshrunlofootprint glaciernouninanimate -o
wetsüthreteinscribing; act of inscribingnouninanimate -e
dherifihollow-making; causing hollownessadjective—
lawolfifitransparent-making; causing transparentnessadjective—
shayödifiancient-making; causing ancientnessadjective—
polufrenuwanyoosilabyrinth-relatedadjective—
shoroẅepidhönyweobsidian inscriptionnouninanimate -e
thrabuwetharapractitioner of chartingnounanimate -a
goralyinynayoosipressure-relatedadjective—
shethifiwarm-making; causing warmnessadjective—
nindarzhetenavigating; act of navigatingnouninanimate -e
nindarzhetharapractitioner of navigatingnounanimate -a
soregömiyesanctuary wallnouninanimate -e
voyufanyüreosiestuary-relatedadjective—
layistetharapractitioner of allyingnounanimate -a
saroẅiyenoshriyestar observatorynouninanimate -e
tharnyiyuosiprophecy-relatedadjective—
thrabuweuneplace for chartingnouninanimate -e
saregoralyinynayoair pressurenouninanimate -o
saroelfolyuzhostar sensornouninanimate -o
reeseinstrument for carvingnouninanimate -e
yoneuneplace for freezingnouninanimate -e
soreẅepidhönywesanctuary inscriptionnouninanimate -e
sloregitecircularness; quality of being circularnouninanimate -e
pleuneplace for sheltering (common noun); Pleune (proper name of the last imperial fortress)noun / proper nameinanimate -e
leranleosiprocession-relatedadjective—
gewifipatient-making; causing patientnessadjective—
shalitohtethuanimal-spirit rivernouninanimate -u
kelythowösathnodhümyeimperial archivenouninanimate -e
lyöretowifruopal-mead joynouninanimate -u
fongaduthilyerawuPhong covenantnouninanimate -u
lyörewösathnodhümyeopal-mead archivenouninanimate -e
suloẅiyenoshriyemoon observatorynouninanimate -e
saroföwülostar calendarnouninanimate -o
nyereshilyenyoriddle patternnouninanimate -o
bleuneplace for openingnouninanimate -e
wetsüthreeseinstrument for inscribingnouninanimate -e
fareslevilöshöshfefire alloynouninanimate -e
zoreskareteguflower chroniclenouninanimate -u
pragetelyanlepreserve ark (generically, as an activity)verb—
yidhöẅifiresilient-making; causing resilientnessadjective—
kelythoduthilyerawuimperial covenantnouninanimate -u
shaliẅepidhönyweanimal-spirit inscriptionnouninanimate -e
suloföwülomoon calendarnouninanimate -o
saroskaretegustar chroniclenouninanimate -u
sareskareteguair chroniclenouninanimate -u
shaliluẅidheinterpret animal-spirit (generically, as an activity)verb—
korewösathnodhümyecave archivenouninanimate -e
weseelfolyuzhowater sensornouninanimate -o
fongadhenyözhenpraPhong eldernounanimate -a
kelythoföpinlesurvey imperial (generically, as an activity)verb—
fösreyoosicensus-relatedadjective—
NemoretohtethuNémorath rivernouninanimate -u
wesethüslanbolnyithrowater valvenouninanimate -o
sarewoshwuhigh drifting cloudnouninanimate -u
sulothrabuwechart moon (generically, as an activity)verb—
yenoksheeseinstrument for translatingnouninanimate -e
waluföpinlesurvey ocean (generically, as an activity)verb—
NemoretharnyiyuNémorath prophecynouninanimate -u
gisobitespiralness; quality of being spiralnouninanimate -e
fonganözibePhong omennouninanimate -e
elfolyuzhoosisensor-relatedadjective—
soreleranlesanctuary processionnouninanimate -e
zanzhurnoositribunal-relatedadjective—
wetsüthreuneplace for inscribingnouninanimate -e
lyörelyüpödhetransmit opal-mead (generically, as an activity)verb—
tizeuneplace for singingnouninanimate -e
telyanleeseinstrument for preservingnouninanimate -e
zoretharnyiyuflower prophecynouninanimate -u
fongaskünloteligenyiPhong interpreternounanimate -i
farewösdhinlosefire enginenouninanimate -e
södheuneplace for recordingnouninanimate -e
suloleranlemoon processionnouninanimate -e
rudheuneplace for anchoringnouninanimate -e
shorotharnyiyuobsidian prophecynouninanimate -u
sarenözibecelestial omen: Air → Darkness; stellar signsnouninanimate -e
kelythoskareteguimperial chroniclenouninanimate -u
fongayuzhaPhong sailornounanimate -a
saronözibestar omennouninanimate -e
prageẅepidhönyweark inscriptionnouninanimate -e
nyerewösathnodhümyeriddle archivenouninanimate -e
lawolfitetransparentness; quality of being transparentnouninanimate -e
zhorezushasword guardnounanimate -a
numiyahadheNumi shorenouninanimate -e
lyüpödhetharapractitioner of transmittingnounanimate -a
luẅidheteinterpreting; act of interpretingnouninanimate -e
numiyaduthilyerawuNumi covenantnouninanimate -u
lyüpödheeseinstrument for transmittingnouninanimate -e
wetsüthretharapractitioner of inscribingnounanimate -a
ithirezünyamshrunloÍthir glaciernouninanimate -o
föpinletharapractitioner of surveyingnounanimate -a
föpinletesurveying; act of surveyingnouninanimate -e
vöraleranledivine processionnouninanimate -e
nipeeseinstrument for mendingnouninanimate -e
prageföpinlesurvey ark (generically, as an activity)verb—
wösdhinloseosiengine-relatedadjective—
prageelfolyuzhoark sensornouninanimate -o
kelythorümgipemyuimperial edictnouninanimate -u
yöharvyöpivyaosinavigator-relatedadjective—
ithirenözibeÍthir omennouninanimate -e
hinyöẅetedistributing; act of distributingnouninanimate -e
suloẅepidhönywemoon inscriptionnouninanimate -e
gösüshpeuneplace for calculatingnouninanimate -e
shalinözibeanimal-spirit omennouninanimate -e
waluẅiyenoshriyeocean observatorynouninanimate -e
walutharnyiyuocean prophecynouninanimate -u
nindarzheeseinstrument for navigatingnouninanimate -e
kelythotelyanlepreserve imperial (generically, as an activity)verb—
zhorerümgipemyusword edictnouninanimate -u
koreskaretegucave chroniclenouninanimate -u
ẅiyenoshriyeosiobservatory-relatedadjective—
lyöreleranleopal-mead processionnouninanimate -e
shalirokgeanimal-spirit marshnouninanimate -e
NemorewösathnodhümyeNémorath archivenouninanimate -e
NemorefösreyoNémorath censusnouninanimate -o
NemoremötoNémorath roadnouninanimate -o
zhoreskaretegusword chroniclenouninanimate -u
ithirelesoÍthir altarnouninanimate -o
sarodhuzhallyunostar batterynouninanimate -o
waluthrabuwechart ocean (generically, as an activity)verb—
waluthumfaocean fishernounanimate -a
lyarawösathnodhümyesoul archivenouninanimate -e
ithirelyonyeÍthir fortressnouninanimate -e
gösüshpetharapractitioner of calculatingnounanimate -a
numiyaẅayiNumi witnessnounanimate -i
shoroslevilöshöshfeobsidian alloynouninanimate -e
yoreluẅidheinterpret sound (generically, as an activity)verb—
zhoretelyanlepreserve sword (generically, as an activity)verb—
wesegoralyinynayowater pressurenouninanimate -o
shalihadheanimal-spirit shorenouninanimate -e
gösüshpeeseinstrument for calculatingnouninanimate -e
wesehagewusnowmelt; water released by thawing snownouninanimate -u
telyanletharapractitioner of preservingnounanimate -a
lyöreshezuopal-mead manuscriptnouninanimate -u
tharetelyanlepreserve earth (generically, as an activity)verb—
vörawösathnodhümyedivine archivenouninanimate -e
yenoksheuneplace for translatingnouninanimate -e
zhoreslevilöshöshfesword alloynouninanimate -e
lyaranözibesoul omennouninanimate -e
sarothrabuwechart star (generically, as an activity)verb—
duthilyerawuosicovenant-relatedadjective—
soreskaretegusanctuary chroniclenouninanimate -u
nyerepolufrenuwanyoriddle labyrinthnouninanimate -o
lyaranesishnesoul mercynouninanimate -e
vöratharnyiyudivine prophecynouninanimate -u
NemoreleranleNémorath processionnouninanimate -e
farethüslanbolnyithrofire valvenouninanimate -o
numiyatharnyiyuNumi prophecynouninanimate -u
dhunyaysomyiosiastronomer-relatedadjective—
weselöfolefreshwater icenouninanimate -e
numiyaluyeNumi tidenouninanimate -e
shoroshezuobsidian manuscriptnouninanimate -u
ẅepidhönyweosiinscription-relatedadjective—
zhoreẅepidhönywesword inscriptionnouninanimate -e
füvulyafvloositreasury-relatedadjective—
sareelfolyuzhoair sensornouninanimate -o
pragewösdhinloseark enginenouninanimate -e
NemoregihuNémorath grainnouninanimate -u
thoreskaretegufootprint chroniclenouninanimate -u
tharethrabuwechart earth (generically, as an activity)verb—
suloluẅidheinterpret moon (generically, as an activity)verb—
thoretharnyiyufootprint prophecynouninanimate -u
zaneluẅidheinterpret prayer (generically, as an activity)verb—
wesetelyanlepreserve water (generically, as an activity)verb—
salyükerloosigear-relatedadjective—
soretelyanlepreserve sanctuary (generically, as an activity)verb—
karazanzhurnoclan tribunalnouninanimate -o
fongawösathnodhümyePhong archivenouninanimate -e
nyeretharnyiyuriddle prophecynouninanimate -u
nyerenöziberiddle omennouninanimate -e
nyereẅepidhönyweriddle inscriptionnouninanimate -e
skünloteligenyiosiinterpreter-relatedadjective—
furetelyanlepreserve fur (generically, as an activity)verb—
korethrabuwechart cave (generically, as an activity)verb—
koreẅepidhönywecave inscriptionnouninanimate -e
zaneskareteguprayer chroniclenouninanimate -u
numiyawösathnodhümyeNumi archivenouninanimate -e
koretelyanlepreserve cave (generically, as an activity)verb—
kelythozanzhurnoimperial tribunalnouninanimate -o
saretharnyiyuair prophecynouninanimate -u
numiyaẅiyenoshriyeNumi observatorynouninanimate -e
vöraẅepidhönywedivine inscriptionnouninanimate -e
karawösathnodhümyeclan archivenouninanimate -e
shoroskareteguobsidian chroniclenouninanimate -u
NemoreskareteguNémorath chroniclenouninanimate -u
sarotharnyiyustar prophecynouninanimate -u
savrokrawutöshoosiconstellation-relatedadjective—
thüslanbolnyithroosivalve-relatedadjective—
pragedhuzhallyunoark batterynouninanimate -o
walunözibesoul-flight omen: Water → Air; soul takes flightnouninanimate -e
saroluẅidheinterpret star (generically, as an activity)verb—
koretharnyiyucave prophecynouninanimate -u
shorowösathnodhümyeobsidian archivenouninanimate -e
lyaratowifrusoul joynouninanimate -u
ithireskareteguÍthir chroniclenouninanimate -u
sareẅiyenoshriyeair observatorynouninanimate -e
prageslevilöshöshfeark alloynouninanimate -e
zanelyüpödhetransmit prayer (generically, as an activity)verb—
lyaraskaretegusoul chroniclenouninanimate -u
kelytholirenasveproimperial decreenouninanimate -o
pragewendöskelyuark circuitnouninanimate -u
prageskareteguark chroniclenouninanimate -u
karaskareteguclan chroniclenouninanimate -u
zaneẅepidhönyweprayer inscriptionnouninanimate -e
rumeföpinlesurvey ruin (generically, as an activity)verb—
nyereskareteguriddle chroniclenouninanimate -u
kelythofüvulyafvloimperial treasurynouninanimate -o
pragethüslanbolnyithroark valvenouninanimate -o
lyaraduthilyerawusoul covenantnouninanimate -u
numiyaskareteguNumi chroniclenouninanimate -u
NemorefüvulyafvloNémorath treasurynouninanimate -o
karaduthilyerawuclan covenantnouninanimate -u
ithirewösathnodhümyeÍthir archivenouninanimate -e
sorewösathnodhümyesanctuary archivenouninanimate -e
vöraduthilyerawudivine covenantnouninanimate -u
pragezüdherüshampeark relaynouninanimate -e
sarilike; in the likeness of (comparative postposition)postposition—
weseyawaters personified as an animate beingnounanimate -a
suloyamoon personified as an animate beingnounanimate -a
zoreyaflower personified as an animate beingnounanimate -a
sulolyemoon-image; reflection or remembered likeness of the moonnouninanimate -e
weselyewater-image; an impression or likeness of waternouninanimate -e
zorelyeflower-image; remembered or reflected blossomnouninanimate -e
thorelyeimage or remembered trace of a footprintnouninanimate -e
lireabsence, missing thingnouninanimate
linyloalliancenouninanimate
fiyasinusacrificial stonenouninanimate
ẅeyaantnounanimate
reyoancestral archivenouninanimate
tumuntoascent, risingnouninanimate
lyavibeastnounanimate
yasrebednouninanimate
liẅabirdnounanimate
lölebirthnouninanimate
lyüleblacknessnouninanimate
lyarlyublindnessnouninanimate
plonlyebloodnouninanimate
yeyobluenessnouninanimate
yaruboilingnouninanimate
lyaẅobond, covenantnouninanimate
spöẅonyötobreaker, rupturenouninanimate
yüẅulyefracture, broken conditionnouninanimate
polyibull (mammoth)nounanimate
lyatuburningnouninanimate
liyubush, shrubnouninanimate
lyelacalf (mammoth)nounanimate
pölyichildnounanimate
mövafeyihybrid creature, chimeranounanimate
lyögecity, city-statenouninanimate
rulyocoinnouninanimate
ẅulecordnouninanimate
rolecrack, fracturenouninanimate
muröfiyecrossing, transitnouninanimate
lirucrowdnouninanimate
würlyecrown, circletnouninanimate
ẅösrocupnouninanimate
liyerecurring cyclenouninanimate
yilodarkness, eclipse-darknouninanimate
lyüẅodeafnessnouninanimate
sleludepthnouninanimate
ẅölyteunexpected discoverynouninanimate
lyüẅidognounanimate
nyölyyodrynessnouninanimate
lyalydhudustnouninanimate
yelyuearnouninanimate
roluechonouninanimate
vörluborder, marginnouninanimate
lyoruemptinessnouninanimate
waflülimshuentrailsnouninanimate
ẅöruevening watchnouninanimate
bilyeexcess, an additional membernouninanimate
lürueyenouninanimate
solyufacenouninanimate
röyefall, fallingnouninanimate
lyizefield, cultivated landnouninanimate
zülreending, finalitynouninanimate
lyasofloor, pavingnouninanimate
lyülyẅanyufognouninanimate
nürlofountainnouninanimate
lyulafoxnounanimate
lenyifrognounanimate
lyasufrostnouninanimate
lüẅefungusnouninanimate
lerarẅöflugallbladdernouninanimate
lerughost, wandering spiritnouninanimate
kölyegreen colournouninanimate
farlehalo, luminous ringnouninanimate
lyüroheadnouninanimate
yoruheart, centrenouninanimate
blüẅoheight, elevationnouninanimate
ẅeyohoard, extractive storenouninanimate
tolyuhornnouninanimate
lyatehousenouninanimate
yelyiẅeunseen presencenouninanimate
yöẅokeynouninanimate
leyoknocking soundnouninanimate
lyönyboknotnouninanimate
lyüẅallyulaughternouninanimate
ẅölyoleft hand, unfavourable directionnouninanimate
danyözanestructural liaisonnouninanimate
silyolimbnouninanimate
rulbematernal lineagenouninanimate
yölilion (a bird-like creature)nounanimate
shalyelivernouninanimate
dölyesolitudenouninanimate
lyebuloss, disappearancenouninanimate
lyanmumarketnouninanimate
yölnemould, mildewnouninanimate
lüyemorning watchnouninanimate
rayemouthnouninanimate
lyameabsence of speech, mutenessnouninanimate
melyopersonal or ceremonial namenouninanimate
nyoshpeyofuocclusionnouninanimate
helyuoverflownouninanimate
wolyiowlnounanimate
lilyẅepath, orbitnouninanimate
pölysopeacenouninanimate
loẅipeople, communitynounanimate
böẅenyfiphoenixnounanimate
nyomrupestilencenouninanimate
nalyoradiance, brilliancenouninanimate
lüyiratnounanimate
lyoyiravennounanimate
lyuweredness, red pigmentnouninanimate
lyisorefusal, failure to dissolvenouninanimate
lulethünshecontrary flownouninanimate
silyflereversal or contrary directionnouninanimate
lyalyuright hand, favourable directionnouninanimate
nyöyosaltnouninanimate
lyafoscale, scaled surfacenouninanimate
yönyudispersionnouninanimate
dhilyeself, inward identitynouninanimate
lyuwiserpentnounanimate
lyüsheshared, held in commonnouninanimate
thiryeshearing, riftnouninanimate
lyömosightingnouninanimate
lörüreskinnouninanimate
dilyuskullnouninanimate
lyafüruskynouninanimate
zhürlosleepnouninanimate
thürnyusong, singingnouninanimate
rölyospeech, articulated languagenouninanimate
yadübemeteor fallnouninanimate
nolyustonenouninanimate
yerüẅustrangernouninanimate
töblühunzhestammering, interruptionnouninanimate
nyiyosuddennessnouninanimate
mulyilusummernouninanimate
salyusunnouninanimate
nyeyiruswarmnouninanimate
nyördetailnouninanimate
linnyotears, weepingnouninanimate
süsernirẅutelepathynouninanimate
lyilyethreshold, doorwaynouninanimate
layethundernouninanimate
pulnyetoothnouninanimate
lolutowernouninanimate
linnyutreenouninanimate
lyöẅotwinningnouninanimate
paẅetwistingnouninanimate
lyavevoicenouninanimate
lyoliwanderer, mediatornounanimate
lipowarnouninanimate
nyenyowell, springnouninanimate
rabuwhispernouninanimate
lyatkuwhiteness, pale pigmentnouninanimate
shulẅowindnouninanimate
piyuwinternouninanimate
lilawolfnounanimate
yazowombnouninanimate
zelyoyokenouninanimate
nöbuomen; observed sign with a formal interpretationnouninanimate
sulofarleThe Crowned Moon (omen 001)noun / named omeninanimate
lüyegeThe Morning Shadow (omen 002)noun / named omeninanimate
ẅörunyomruThe Evening Plague (omen 003)noun / named omeninanimate
silyfleyiloThe Wrong-Way Dark (omen 004)noun / named omeninanimate
nyoshpeyofuyoruThe Obscured Heart (omen 005)noun / named omeninanimate
lyoyililyẅeThe Raven’s Path (omen 006)noun / named omeninanimate
zelyotumuntoThe Yoke Ascendant (omen 007)noun / named omeninanimate
lyalyusaroThe Right-Hand Star (omen 008)noun / named omeninanimate
ẅölyosaroThe Left-Hand Star (omen 009)noun / named omeninanimate
woshwuyölinöbuThe Cloud-Lion (omen 010)noun / named omeninanimate
woshwuralinöbuThe Cloud-Mammoth (omen 011)noun / named omeninanimate
lyuwelyalydhuThe Red Dust (omen 012)noun / named omeninanimate
lyatkulyalydhuThe White Dust (omen 013)noun / named omeninanimate
piyulayeWinter Thunder (omen 014)noun / named omeninanimate
linyfarleThe Double Halo (omen 015)noun / named omeninanimate
blüẅoẅörusaroThe High Evening Star (omen 016)noun / named omeninanimate
silyflelyuwesaroThe Reversing Red Star (omen 017)noun / named omeninanimate
liresuloThe Missing Moon (omen 018)noun / named omeninanimate
nalyodhuThe Bright Night (omen 019)noun / named omeninanimate
lyögeyadübeCity Starfall (omen 020)noun / named omeninanimate
blüẅolyögeThe High City (omen 021)noun / named omeninanimate
woyuThe Silent Gate (omen 022)noun / named omeninanimate
linnyogömiyeThe Weeping Wall (omen 023)noun / named omeninanimate
lüẅewürlyeThe Fungus Crown (omen 024)noun / named omeninanimate
wolyireyoThe Owl’s Court (omen 025)noun / named omeninanimate
yüẅulyebüreThe Broken Hearth (omen 026)noun / named omeninanimate
lyuwilyilyeThe Snake’s Path (omen 027)noun / named omeninanimate
linygeThe Double Shadow (omen 028)noun / named omeninanimate
plonlyenyenyoThe Bloody Well (omen 029)noun / named omeninanimate
lerulyüẅinöbuThe Ghost Dog (omen 030)noun / named omeninanimate
tohtethululethünsheThe Reversed River (omen 031)noun / named omeninanimate
nyöyolyizeThe Salted Field (omen 032)noun / named omeninanimate
nolyulöleThe Stone Birth (omen 033)noun / named omeninanimate
lyulalyüẅallyuThe Fox’s Laugh (omen 034)noun / named omeninanimate
lyorulyanmuThe Empty Market (omen 035)noun / named omeninanimate
liẅalipoThe Birds of War (omen 036)noun / named omeninanimate
liẅapölysoThe Birds of Peace (omen 037)noun / named omeninanimate
lyüleyölneThe Black Mould (omen 038)noun / named omeninanimate
lyatkuyölneThe White Mould (omen 039)noun / named omeninanimate
roleloluThe Cracking Tower (omen 040)noun / named omeninanimate
rabulyasoThe Whispering Floor (omen 041)noun / named omeninanimate
lyebuyöẅoThe Lost Key (omen 042)noun / named omeninanimate
ẅölyterulyoThe Found Coin (omen 043)noun / named omeninanimate
yerüẅusolyuThe Stranger’s Face (omen 044)noun / named omeninanimate
nyölyyonürloThe Dry Fountain (omen 045)noun / named omeninanimate
helyuẅösroThe Overflowing Cup (omen 046)noun / named omeninanimate
yüẅulyeboThe Broken Mirror (omen 047)noun / named omeninanimate
yelyiẅeleyoThe Unseen Knocker (omen 048)noun / named omeninanimate
nyeyiruẅeyanöbuThe Swarming Ants (omen 049)noun / named omeninanimate
dölyelilanöbuThe Lone Wolf (omen 050)noun / named omeninanimate
yadübelyateThe Falling Star (Urban) (omen 051)noun / named omeninanimate
kölyelyafüruThe Green Sky (omen 052)noun / named omeninanimate
lyuwetohtethuThe Red River (omen 053)noun / named omeninanimate
mulyilulyasuThe Frozen Summer (omen 054)noun / named omeninanimate
yarunyenyoThe Boiling Well (omen 055)noun / named omeninanimate
thürnyunolyuThe Singing Stone (omen 056)noun / named omeninanimate
plonlyelinnyuThe Bleeding Tree (omen 057)noun / named omeninanimate
nyiyolyülyẅanyuThe Sudden Fog (omen 058)noun / named omeninanimate
liẅalyateThe Bird in the House (omen 059)noun / named omeninanimate
lüyilyönyboThe Rat King (omen 060)noun / named omeninanimate
linyyoruThe Double Heart (omen 061)noun / named omeninanimate
silyfleshalyeThe Reversed Liver (omen 062)noun / named omeninanimate
plonlyelyizeThe Bleeding Field (omen 063)noun / named omeninanimate
wolenyinöbuThe Silent Frog (omen 064)noun / named omeninanimate
raligoThe Dream of the Mammoth (omen 065)noun / named omeninanimate
yugoThe Dream of the Gate (omen 066)noun / named omeninanimate
mövafeyilöleThe Birth of the Chimera (omen 067)noun / named omeninanimate
nyördepölyinöbuThe Child with a Tail (omen 068)noun / named omeninanimate
lyüẅiyasreThe Dog in the Bed (omen 069)noun / named omeninanimate
röyeboThe Falling Mirror (omen 070)noun / named omeninanimate
töblühunzheweseThe Water Stutter (omen 071)noun / named omeninanimate
lyüledanyözaneThe Black Liaison (omen 072)noun / named omeninanimate
silyfletohtethuThe Wrong-Way River (omen 073)noun / named omeninanimate
böẅenyfilyömoThe Phoenix Sighting (omen 074)noun / named omeninanimate
woliruThe Silent Crowd (omen 075)noun / named omeninanimate
yüẅulyethoreThe Broken Footprint (omen 076)noun / named omeninanimate
lyafüruthiryeThe Sky-Shear (omen 077)noun / named omeninanimate
spöẅonyötoshilyenyoThe Breaker Pattern (omen 078)noun / named omeninanimate
lyörelyisoThe Opal Mead (omen 079)noun / named omeninanimate
salyupulnyeThe Sun’s Tooth (omen 080)noun / named omeninanimate
paẅeẅuleThe Twisted Cord (omen 081)noun / named omeninanimate
lyatkushalyeThe White Liver (omen 082)noun / named omeninanimate
lyüleshalyeThe Black Liver (omen 083)noun / named omeninanimate
linylyürolyelanöbuThe Two-Headed Calf (omen 084)noun / named omeninanimate
lirelyürolöleThe Headless Birth (omen 085)noun / named omeninanimate
rölyowaflülimshuThe Speaking Entrails (omen 086)noun / named omeninanimate
lyüẅallyudilyuThe Laughing Skull (omen 087)noun / named omeninanimate
plonlyefiyasinuThe Bleeding Stone (Visceral) (omen 088)noun / named omeninanimate
lirelerarẅöfluThe Missing Gallbladder (omen 089)noun / named omeninanimate
bilyesilyoThe Extra Limb (omen 090)noun / named omeninanimate
lyuwiyazoThe Serpent in the Womb (omen 091)noun / named omeninanimate
nolyuyoruThe Stone Heart (omen 092)noun / named omeninanimate
lyarlyulüruThe Blind Eye (omen 093)noun / named omeninanimate
lyüẅoyelyuThe Deaf Ear (omen 094)noun / named omeninanimate
lyamerayeThe Tongueless Mouth (omen 095)noun / named omeninanimate
tolyupölyinöbuThe Horned Child (omen 096)noun / named omeninanimate
lyafolörüreThe Scaled Skin (omen 097)noun / named omeninanimate
yeyoplonlyeThe Blue Blood (omen 098)noun / named omeninanimate
lyoruyazoThe Empty Womb (omen 099)noun / named omeninanimate
lyöẅolyuwinöbuThe Twin Serpent (omen 100)noun / named omeninanimate
liyeshilyenyoThe Cycle Pattern (omen 101)noun / named omeninanimate
ẅolyolinöbuThe Mediator (omen 102)noun / named omeninanimate
vörluloẅinöbuThe Edge-Folk (omen 103)noun / named omeninanimate
yumoThe Gate Flow (omen 104)noun / named omeninanimate
süsernirẅuroluThe Telepathic Echo (omen 105)noun / named omeninanimate
lyüshegoThe Shared Dream (omen 106)noun / named omeninanimate
lerulyaveThe Ghost Voice (omen 107)noun / named omeninanimate
bomuröfiyeThe Mirror Walk (omen 108)noun / named omeninanimate
gedhilyeThe Shadow Self (omen 109)noun / named omeninanimate
lyatuliyuThe Burning Bush (omen 110)noun / named omeninanimate
nolyurölyoThe Stone Speech (omen 111)noun / named omeninanimate
wesesolyuThe Water Face (omen 112)noun / named omeninanimate
shulẅomelyoThe Wind Name (omen 113)noun / named omeninanimate
zülrewoThe Final Silence (omen 114)noun / named omeninanimate
notugablenouninanimate
buyeroof tile; fired tilenouninanimate
nyahehousehold book; account book of a housenouninanimate
sözhewimother; maternal-house guardiannounanimate
lyötiLyöti, the young scribe (personal name)proper nameanimate
nadhiNadhi, the clan mother (personal name)proper nameanimate
sokiSoki, a Phong witness (personal name)proper nameanimate
esumoisture; dampnessnouninanimate
beluration; allotted provisionnouninanimate
shümefamine; widespread wantnouninanimate
wurerumour; circulating reportnouninanimate
yonyulelane; narrow streetnouninanimate
tönohandbell; market bellnouninanimate
lyesuthread; single strand of yarnnouninanimate
lyemacourier; messengernounanimate
rulöbamaternal aunt; mother’s sisternounanimate
vipedye; coloured dyebathnouninanimate
idhuhunger; gnawing neednouninanimate
temalyupublic council proclamation; formal noticenouninanimate
tanolyuwritten decision of a maternal councilnouninanimate
karasözhewiclan mother; keeper of a maternal housenounanimate
lyuwenotured gablenouninanimate
yeyonotublue gablenouninanimate
lyuwebuyered-fired roof tilenouninanimate
yeyobuyeblue-fired roof tilenouninanimate
lyuwenyimured-roofed house / red roofnouninanimate
yeyonyimublue-roofed house / blue roofnouninanimate
karanyaheclan account book; register of a maternal housenouninanimate
lyanmunyahemarket account-booknouninanimate
gihubelugrain ration; allocated portion of grainnouninanimate
nyimuyaroof personified as a living participantnounanimate
lyuwenotu-yeyonotuCity of Red and Blue Gables; imperial capital (literary endonym)proper nameinanimate
lyesuosithreadlike; filamentousadjective—
esuosimoist, damp (adjective); Esuosi (traditional swamp toponym, homographic proper name)adjective / proper name—
lyirelyira; northern ice tunnel and portal (assimilated loan)nouninanimate
pürutree, woody plantnouninanimate
yoenclosed courtyard, shared household courtnouninanimate
enyitecanal, artificial water channelnouninanimate
tülhalmesluice, water-control gatenouninanimate
dödhewudeliberative council; body of trusted representativesnouninanimate
mömnyiwadhepublic assembly court, formal meeting groundnouninanimate
wöẅoguarded storehouse; public reserve depotnouninanimate
pevushop, stall, small trading housenouninanimate
blökomerchant caravan; travelling convoynouninanimate
fülbuwool, fleece fibrenouninanimate
pudye pigment; dye-bearing substancenouninanimate
musaltnouninanimate
lyülelyumobinding agreement, contractnouninanimate
ünetrade, reciprocal exchange of goodsnouninanimate
myaföthaẅocargo shipping, organised transport by waternouninanimate
iyalöẅucredit, advance against expected goodsnouninanimate
alyocraft workshop, workspace for skilled manufacturenouninanimate
belöfomedicine, healing compoundnouninanimate
poschool, place of instructionnouninanimate
witeacher, instructornounanimate
pulyakeeper, custodian of a place or objectnounanimate
kozisheyaentrusted speaker, delegate of a council or housenounanimate
zanegotiator, bargaining representativenounanimate
lyüẅacommercial broker or trade intermediarynounanimate
nyüriartisan, craft workernounanimate
memülmicourier, letter-bearernounanimate
shüryamutreasury, pool of household or public fundsnouninanimate
beyutablet for inscription or family memorialnouninanimate
galynopublic bathhousenouninanimate
wöẅesharzeshünyoritualised personal combat, duelnouninanimate
yamediator, conciliatornounanimate
pümospenoodle, strand of cooked flour pastenouninanimate
fümecake, baked or steamed grain roundnouninanimate
vömẅolentil, pulsenouninanimate
kalyosyrup, concentrated sweet liquidnouninanimate
tregumusic, organised melodynouninanimate
ithofestival, recurring communal celebrationnouninanimate
ziyumusical instrumentnouninanimate
sitnyosrefoengineered technology, technical skill and devicesnouninanimate
külyebüẅutax, communal levynouninanimate
nyuspamürzuadoption into a maternal housenouninanimate
lulözüklöẅoinherited title or property successionnouninanimate
anyeshölyuproperty, legally held collective assetnouninanimate
miyamaternal grandmothernounanimate
nafimaternal uncle, mother’s brothernounanimate
mömidhafather, acknowledged parent not determining descentnounanimate
lyamarital or household partnernounanimate
lyödhohumarriage, socially recognised partnershipnouninanimate
ryofridhotivlashesuccession to entrusted office or house stewardshipnouninanimate
waslyengülyurelimited public mandate, delegated authoritynouninanimate
lyönemthrithanyoappointment or authorisation to public officenouninanimate
baluwoformal withdrawal of an entrusted commissionnouninanimate
tüvifemfoabuse of entrusted authority, corruptionnouninanimate
wündhelsocompensation, restitution after injurynouninanimate
lablörlordhülocustomary law; binding legal ordernouninanimate
söẅewösrebinding finding or judgmentnouninanimate
ẅepakütbulegal or divinatory precedentnouninanimate
vocodex, book, ordered written collectionnouninanimate
hulyopersonal name, formal name of a lineagenouninanimate
srelyötpamuinterpretation, authoritative readingnouninanimate
alyidhavrivedivine conception, bringing forth a successornouninanimate
rihotransition from one cosmological element to anothernouninanimate
gegügakesecret divine name, ritual object-namenouninanimate
vüshadhechronicle, ordered record of historical eventsnouninanimate
thalelymamlyönlyudirectly observed evidencenouninanimate
kawilesubmerged or oceanic habitatnouninanimate
muthreice, frozen waternouninanimate
mismuwinter pasture of the boreal herdsnouninanimate
ralimammoth, large shaggy northern herd animalnounanimate
niherder, pastoral caretaker of animalsnounanimate
zhuice fissure, split in icenouninanimate
matuklaruother world, alternate traversable realmnouninanimate
myethrüthuspatial cross-section of a manifold worldnouninanimate
müyewütpehyperplanet, world with many accessible cross-sectionsnouninanimate
yenödhopolitical or military alliancenouninanimate
nespuvlarmoright of refuge under sanctuary protectionnouninanimate
koinherited tradition, living historical transmissionnouninanimate
füplowhispered report, social rumournouninanimate
kruwafünimemother-line descent as a juridical principlenouninanimate
rörzüsomüshehereditary right held by a maternal housenouninanimate
bitetgosettlement by mutual recognition, reconciliationnouninanimate
lyowumenatural philosophy, systematic sciencenouninanimate
lyölẅitavutheory of the geometry of the portalsnouninanimate
nipünyiyucouncil-sanctioned ritual courtnouninanimate
zorepüruflowering tree, blossom treenouninanimate
nolyuẅostone bridgenouninanimate -o
weseenyitewater canal, irrigating channelnouninanimate
tülhalmepulyasluice keeper; caretaker of water gatesnounanimate
dödhewusorecouncil sanctuary; protected precinct of assemblynouninanimate -e
dödhewulyatecouncil house, meeting residencenouninanimate
kelythowöẅocommunal storehouse governed by councilsnouninanimate
rulbelyatematernal house; matrilineal corporate householdnouninanimate
lyateyoancestral household courtyardnouninanimate
lyanmupevumarket shop, licensed trading stallnouninanimate
blökomötocaravan roadnouninanimate -o
ithiremumountain saltnouninanimate
zorepudye-bearing flower or plantnouninanimate
fumyaföthaẅocoastal shippingnouninanimate
södhelyülelyumowritten contract, witnessed trade instrumentnouninanimate
karalyülelyumointer-clan agreementnouninanimate
pevupulyashopkeeper, custodian of a market stall (any gender)nounanimate
södhememülmikeeper and deliverer of messagesnounanimate
iyalöẅunyahebook of debts; list of credit owednouninanimate
üneblökotrading caravannouninanimate
vlealyoweaving workshopnouninanimate
alyodödhewucooperative guild councilnouninanimate
tohtethuzoreedible river plantsnouninanimate -e
zorekalyoflower syrupnouninanimate
gihufümegrain cake or prepared flour foodnouninanimate
soretreguceremonial sanctuary musicnouninanimate
ithotregumusic for annual festivalsnouninanimate
sovarasitnyosrefoancestral technology of the Ark settlersnouninanimate
pragerumeruins of the ancestral Arknouninanimate -e
pragelyowumestudy of surviving Ark technologynouninanimate
blökokülyebüẅucaravan levynouninanimate
rulbelulözüklöẅomatrilineal inheritancenouninanimate
karaanyeshölyuinalienable clan propertynouninanimate
nyuspamürzupölyichild adopted into maternal descentnounanimate
rulbemiyamaternal grandmothernounanimate
rulbenafimaternal unclenounanimate
karalyödhohumarriage linking distinct maternal housesnouninanimate
rulberyofridhotivlashesuccession within a maternal housenouninanimate
lyögedödhewudistrict or ward councilnouninanimate
kelythodödhewuimperial assembly of the six maternal clansnouninanimate
rulbekozisheyaentrusted speaker of a maternal housenounanimate
dödhewuwaslyengülyuremandate issued by a councilnouninanimate
ẅelilyönemthrithanyoappointment of a war captainnouninanimate
lyönemthrithanyobaluwowithdrawal of office by the councilsnouninanimate
nariyalablörlordhülokinship law, rules of clan identitynouninanimate
sorenespuvlarmoinstitutional right of sanctuarynouninanimate
rulbehulyoinherited name of a maternal housenouninanimate
lablörlordhülowündhelsolegally sanctioned restitutionnouninanimate
nözibesöẅewösrebinding judgment of an omennouninanimate
nözibeẅepakütbubinding precedent for interpreting an omennouninanimate
nözibevoSign-Book; ordered imperial collection of omensnouninanimate
nözibesrelyötpamuritual reading or construal of an omennouninanimate
nözibelablörlordhüloomen law, authoritative ritual precedentnouninanimate
zanewündhelsoaverting or compensatory ritual; native gloss for namburbinouninanimate
vöragegügakesecret name of a goddessnouninanimate
vörarulbegenealogy of the divine mothersnouninanimate
vöraalyidhavrivedivine conception or progeniturenouninanimate
tharerihotransformation between ritual elementsnouninanimate
shalikodoctrine of animal spiritsnouninanimate
sorevüshadhesacred historical chroniclenouninanimate
nolyuthalelymamlyönlyumaterial evidence, observed signnouninanimate
fongasüsernirẅuPhong telepathic communionnouninanimate
numiyakawileaquatic environment of the Numinouninanimate
numiyalyowumenatural philosophy concerning the Numinouninanimate
muthrelyireice tunnel or lyira portalnouninanimate
ralinimammoth herdernounanimate
matuklarumyethrüthucross-section of another region of the hyperplanetnouninanimate
lyirelyölẅitavutheory of the lyira and other worldsnouninanimate
karayenödhoalliance of maternal clansnouninanimate
lipoyenödhoalliance formed for war or defencenouninanimate
kelythotüvifemfoillegal conversion of entrusted office into personal sovereigntynouninanimate
TiriyaTyrian person; inhabitant of Tyreproper nounanimate
NarshaliyaNarshalye person; member of an exiled northern lineageproper nounanimate
TyreTyre, eastern coastal city and city-stateproper nouninanimate
Lë’khnuLë’khnu, the Boreal Wastesproper nouninanimate
petharalens-maker; worker with lenses and optical instrumentsnounanimate
tharovireconquer, incorporate by force of armsverb—
piretharapilgrim; person making a religious journeynounanimate -a
belöfopulyaherbalist; keeper and seller of medicinal preparationsnounanimate -a
shüryamupulyahousehold treasurer; keeper of shared fundsnounanimate -a
sorepulyasanctuary custodian; keeper of a holy precinctnounanimate -a
nyuspamürzuvomeadopt a child formally into a maternal houseverb—
liyüthecare shown in small practical thingsnouninanimate
nimucloth set aside for a guest or absent household membernouninanimate
nyöẅowarmth remaining in cloth after it has been touchednouninanimate
welüẅelast light; the glow a surface keeps after the sun or a lamp has gonenouninanimate
wünebead of dew or water suspended from a threadnouninanimate
nyarushort quiet between two bells or two callsnouninanimate
öẅesuslanting glint visible when its surface movesnouninanimate
lüfefine line of lightnouninanimate
zöẅebrief wandering point of reflected lightnouninanimate
spertosplit or fracture in stone or another rigid surfacenouninanimate
tinshebosharp crack; a sudden hard sound breaking into a quieter onenouninanimate
zotenick on the edge of a polished objectnouninanimate
lowilinger; stay on after its source has goneverb—
ranübrush or touch lightly, without holdingverb—
wöpefold cloth deliberately and neatlyverb—
lavöglitter by intermittent reflected facetsverbanimate
gönyücatch a passing glint of lightverbanimate
thikösnap or crack suddenlyverb—
frerubreak under pressure; split along a strained jointverb—
tönolyethe after-sound of a bell; the note that seems to hang in the air after the bell has stoppednouninanimate
nyöẅolyeremembered warmth; the feel of a touch after the hand has gonenouninanimate
sulolüfea narrow line of moonlight, especially a reflection crossing waternouninanimate
zorelüfethe threadlike illuminated edge of a blossomnouninanimate
enyuboat with a shallow draft; flat marsh boatnouninanimate
wipureed; flexible marsh stemnouninanimate
nyavusoft mud, siltnouninanimate
sowewake; transient track made by a boat on waternouninanimate
alörewoven mat of reedsnouninanimate
füẅosmall landing stage at a marsh channelnouninanimate
fiẅesmall covered lamp carried through wetlandsnouninanimate
ẅonesluice; controlled outlet for stored waternouninanimate
ẅaroseal of a maternal council, pressed into wax or claynouninanimate
fölewritten truce; sworn cessation of fightingnouninanimate
öyosmall cup carried for drinking on a journeynouninanimate
lilönesmall white flower of the marsh reedsnouninanimate
saẅiSaẅi; a Pleune scribe of a maternal houseproper nameanimate
nyuraNyura; a clan mother at the siege of Pleuneproper nameanimate
ẅowüyiferrywoman; boat operator through marsh channelsnounanimate
padosiege; sustained encirclement of a fortified settlementnouninanimate
dhethumoat; dug defensive ditch around a fortressnouninanimate
kohuwar banner used by a clan or military companynouninanimate
rüwupointed palisade stakenouninanimate
velzhoearth embankment restraining waternouninanimate
saluproshot or heavy shellnouninanimate
ünimeferry people or goods across a waterwayverb—
lyüẅedrift with a current without steeringverb—
rüwishelter or guard someone against immediate harmverb—
welyaslacken or loosen a held rope or tieverb—
dheẅihang or suspend something from a supportverb—
deyufill a defensive ditch with soil or rubbleverb—
srelgochange political or military allegianceverb—
plökustrike a barricade or palisade with forceverb—
lyarmorelease water through a sluice or retaining gateverb—
zurstisink suddenly into water or saturated earthverb—
hintewithdraw a fighting force from a positionverb—
kelythokohuimperial war banner; banner bearing the six-clan insignianouninanimate
rokgeẅonemarsh sluice; sluice governing the marsh channelnouninanimate
sulolilyẅemoon-path; silver line of reflected moonlight on water, later a name for a legendary passagenouninanimate
fongaliPhong priest; Phong member of a priestly ordernounanimate
moletharasurvivor; one who has endured and remains alivenounanimate
srelgotechange of allegiance; going over to another sidenouninanimate
zazhuinundate low ground or a ditch; cover with released waterverb—
minyaMinya; Phong reared in a Némorath priestly householdproper nameanimate
lyalliPhong hatchling; young Phong chicknounanimate
tüneloose feather, particularly one shed from a wingnouninanimate
wöwosteam rising from hot bread or a warm vesselnouninanimate
lülenarrow woven ribbon or binding stripnouninanimate
nyilyechip or shard of fired ceramicnouninanimate
yüfishetranslucent glaze on fired earthenwarenouninanimate
püzehairline crack at the lip of a cup or bowlnouninanimate
maloresin incense prepared for burningnouninanimate
güthoiron grate used above a communal hearthnouninanimate
defocooked meat served at a mealnouninanimate
tüboash remaining after a charcoal firenouninanimate
lyödepour a small measured quantity of liquidverb—
ẅümolose consciousness; become insensateverb—
nyöẅarub out or wipe off a written markverb—
öreeat; take food at a mealverb—
plokuroast over an open charcoal fireverb—
shotecrack or snap suddenly (intransitive)verb—
ẅelyicatch or snag on an edge (intransitive)verb—
yönyegleam through cloth, glaze, or a narrow openingverb—
zöẅiflash once; glint for an instantverb—
süẅilet go of an object deliberately; release from an open handverb—
zeytevision, act of seeing; in a temple record, what a witness describes seeingnouninanimate
yeyonyimulyereflected image of a blue roof; remembered blue-roof outlinenouninanimate
lishaLisha; Phong woman who delivers food to the closed sanctuaryproper nameanimate
möliMöli; Lisha’s daughter, novice among the Phong priesthoodsproper nameanimate
yüliplum, plum fruitnounanimate
lüzenarrow food hatch in a wallnouninanimate
nödhowooden shutter or sliding panel of a small aperturenouninanimate
mumocooked rice served warm in a bowlnouninanimate
lyavoplain earthenware bowlnouninanimate
ẅiruraised stone terracenouninanimate
wözegold; worked yellow precious metalnouninanimate
nyimanovice serving under a priestly teachernounanimate
yözohand-carried market basketnouninanimate
nyowing, especially the wing of a Phongnouninanimate
hüvesmall lamp with a protected flamenouninanimate
lyamuwoven floor mat for a meal or guestsnouninanimate
sövuwaxed cord tied across a door or gatenouninanimate
thraneheavy bolt or bar holding a gatenouninanimate
pöthosoft sweet steamed grain cakenouninanimate
muleslide a small vessel through an apertureverb—
reyicool slowly, lose heat without sudden changeverb—
vögesmile at another personverb—
lyiloblink or narrow the eyes against bright lightverb—
rözerecognise a person by a familiar voice or gestureverb—
sotasever a taut cord in one strokeverb—
shikolaugh suddenly, with an audible burstverb—
yayesay or utter a brief statement aloudverb—
relyihand a small object gently to another personverb—
rizesit and remain in one placeverb—
thenawait at a particular place for another personverb—
laleset an object down on a surfaceverb—
lyüwiserve rice or grain into a bowlverb—
zidhuclang or strike with one hard metallic soundverb—
lyedösleep lightly in a familiar sheltered placeverb—
nöralean to one side, as a tree or standing objectverb—
wözeyöẅogolden key; gold ceremonial keynouninanimate
wözefegold cup or chalicenouninanimate
yülipüruplum treenouninanimate
linyrisecond; ordinal numeral preceding a nounordinal numeral—
lyeshosymbolic map assembled from objects; a Phong tableaunouninanimate
yalerunning current in a channel or rivernouninanimate
niyoseasonal encampment of travelling householdsnouninanimate
nölosecurity lasting through several seasons; assured dwellingnouninanimate
sarködhecalamity, severe disruption threatening a communitynouninanimate
müvearrange movable things into a symbolic mapverb—
nüyeattach one’s household to another group for mutual shelterverb—
höẅushallow ford; a place where a caravan can cross a rivernouninanimate
löwolong pole used to feel the riverbed from a ferryboatnouninanimate
ẅiwesmall, water-polished pebblenouninanimate
lyölulittle river shell, worn smooth by currentnouninanimate
nyawotravelling sandal with a soft strapnouninanimate
rösepalm of a handnouninanimate
zefroknot pulled tight under a heavy loadnouninanimate
rödewade with careful footing through shallow waterverb—
tölepull a rope taut, taking the strainverb—
pörnyesnap abruptly under tensionverb—
düẅitumble or roll over in moving waterverb—
golicry goods for sale; call out one’s wares in a marketverb—
honuhear; catch a soundverb—
lözheweed; wild plant growing where it is not wantednouninanimate
avögo out, leaveverb—
damfupunishverb—
danthodispute, argue a claimverb—
dhulefall, dropverb—
dhömgürule alone; hold power as a sovereignverb—
dhöshadecideverb—
dhüpablame, accuseverb—
dikraprotest loudly; shout against somethingverb—
divalead, commandverb—
diẅöwound, injureverb—
döbidescribeverb—
düvyöcollapse, fail, fall apartverb—
düẅuchange, alterverb—
edhüenter, go inverb—
eslubear, give birth toverb—
fösitestify, give evidenceverb—
giyefindverb—
göbirefuse, rejectverb—
görodieverb—
gözhücroak, as a frogverb—
hesüthreatenverb—
kisopretend; act out as if realverb—
köteburn, be on fireverb—
küzakillverb—
ledöconsent, agree toverb—
levöcome, arriveverb—
lutriteachverb—
lyonyadanceverb—
lyonyubringverb—
lyuvedrive out, expelverb—
lyöneyömournverb—
lyöpegain, winverb—
lyüloveverb—
lyüsöexamine, look intoverb—
lyüthlushake, trembleverb—
löbiaskverb—
lühasupply, provide forverb—
lüladissolveverb—
lütalive, be aliveverb—
mazhikeep, holdverb—
meẅiappoint to an officeverb—
minaspeak, tellverb—
mitöfollowverb—
mokörot, go badverb—
mürvubring up, rear a childverb—
nayigiveverb—
nekrufear; be wary ofverb—
nunzhobetrayverb—
nyölyachooseverb—
nyüdhöserve; owe service toverb—
nödetest, proveverb—
nöyewarnverb—
nükecreakverb—
nümucoververb—
olyigrowverb—
pabiread aloudverb—
renyireconcile, make peace betweenverb—
röveallow, permitverb—
rüẅösettle a disputeverb—
satuboilverb—
tawuattack, invadeverb—
thowureturn, turn backverb—
thösüpetitionverb—
toyemean, signifyverb—
vigaflyverb—
wöniplanverb—
yeyüdemandverb—
yöpüstandverb—
zhamuloseverb—
zheyubecome, turn intoverb—
zheẅüfall in value, decreaseverb—
zhönyürecall an officer; take back a mandateverb—
zohibarkverb—
zufeseparate, partverb—
özheincrease, grow in numberverb—
üköobject toverb—
ẅepüdheproclaimverb—
amisameadjective—
blakifalseadjective—
eliyoung; junioradjective—
elwistrong, powerfuladjective—
eyinewadjective—
höwisick, illadjective—
kuhibad, ill-omenedadjective—
loyievery, allquantifier—
lyüripoor, in wantadjective—
löniweakadjective—
löyigood, favourableadjective—
maẅiother, differentadjective—
röptigreat, largeadjective—
soridangerousadjective—
ulyisenior, elder, leadingadjective—
uyitrue; lawfuladjective—
zanyümirichadjective—
zekasistrange, unusualadjective—
ẅeshimanyquantifier—
ẅüyiangryadjective—
röliagain; backadverb—
delamonarch; hereditary sole rulernounanimate
dösupricenouninanimate
efodaynouninanimate
ewöraofficeholder, appointeenounanimate
göledeathnouninanimate
lizhotonguenouninanimate
lizhutoenouninanimate
lyesasuccessornounanimate
lyeyoyearnouninanimate
lyinyeweight used in measuringnouninanimate
lyösunewsnouninanimate
lyözowealth, plentynouninanimate
lyöẅenoonnouninanimate
lüẅosouthnouninanimate
mögenorthnouninanimate
mülyospot, small marknouninanimate
nayunecknouninanimate
nelyshustormnouninanimate
nenawomannounanimate
nupeseednouninanimate
nyilocradlenouninanimate
nyivowordnouninanimate
nyüvludrunkennessnouninanimate
rathidoprecedence, rank, standingnouninanimate
rewosegenerationnouninanimate
rünyeharvestnouninanimate
selyuveilnouninanimate
thepabeclaimnouninanimate
thilesiegenouninanimate
wuwefavour, gracenouninanimate
zamuseasonnouninanimate
zefusilvernouninanimate
zhurooil, lamp oilnouninanimate
zukedebtnouninanimate
zökuwestnouninanimate
züyirival, enemynounanimate
ömamerchant, tradernounanimate
üdeeastnouninanimate
ünohillnouninanimate
ẅimusapnouninanimate
ẅözhaspynounanimate
esamannounanimate
telyismalladjective—
wifowashverb—
zengajump; jump oververb—
vowevillagenouninanimate
ulühelpverb—
ifolendverb—
thivoward, district of a citynouninanimate
vüyokind, sortnouninanimate
födhework, labourverb—
tuẅürun; run awayverb—
süfesweepverb—
zürotoolnouninanimate
suzheclothing, clothesnouninanimate
mimaguestnounanimate
lyezadeceive, cheatverb—
dhidhustop, come to an endverb—
ödhüsellverb—
alifriendnounanimate
nonyutrustverb—
vrasherevengenouninanimate
uvishort, briefadjective—
huwofreedom, self-governmentnouninanimate
dhithereason, causenouninanimate
zhizhaplayverb—
lyezhithink, reasonverb—
dhülyepainnouninanimate
tilyeorder, sequencenouninanimate
zidopart, portionnouninanimate
lanshuplacenouninanimate
nünewonder, amazementnouninanimate
zhukoterrornouninanimate
vaẅuleafnouninanimate
fönalesser spirit of a goddess’s retinuenounanimate
lyanmupulyamarket keepernounanimate
rulbepulyakeeper of a lineagenounanimate
wesepulyawater keeper; keeper of a fountain or channelnounanimate
yupulyagatekeepernounanimate
lyuwesarothe red wandering starnouninanimate
lyülemülyoblack spotnouninanimate
vörlulyülelyumoboundary agreementnouninanimate
lyatenalihomeless; without a houseadjective—
divatharaleadernounanimate
kisotharapretender, impostornounanimate
yeyütharaclaimantnounanimate
düvyötedefeat; collapsenouninanimate
düẅutechangenouninanimate
eslutechildbearing; birthsnouninanimate
eyiterenewal, newnessnouninanimate
fösitetestimony, evidence givennouninanimate
honutehearing; a formal hearingnouninanimate
kuhiteharm, ill fortune; blamenouninanimate
ledöteconsentnouninanimate
lyüsöteinquiry, examinationnouninanimate
lyütelovenouninanimate
minatetalk, discussionnouninanimate
moköterot, decay; pollutionnouninanimate
nyüdhöteservice, dutynouninanimate
renyitereconciliationnouninanimate
soritedangernouninanimate
thösütepetition; the right to petitionnouninanimate
toyetemeaningnouninanimate
vometemaking, formationnouninanimate
zazhutefloodnouninanimate
ẅüyiteanger, wrathnouninanimate
KhélythëaKhélythëa, the empire of the Six Clansproper nounanimate
lüẅozökusouthwestnouninanimate
zorelyizeflower meadow; meadowlandnouninanimate
wuvometharabakernounanimate
faletharascholarnounanimate
ödhütharaseller, vendornounanimate
födhetework, labour; craftnouninanimate
danthotedispute, quarrelnouninanimate
pabiterecitation, reading aloudnouninanimate
höwitesicknessnouninanimate
lyonyatedance, dancingnouninanimate
meẅiteappointment to office; the right to appointnouninanimate
wöniteplannouninanimate
zhizhategame, playnouninanimate
kisotepretence; a scene acted outnouninanimate
amitelikeness, samenessnouninanimate
lütatelife, staying alivenouninanimate
döbitedescriptionnouninanimate
shaletefeud, fightingnouninanimate
tawuteinvasion, attacknouninanimate
lutriteteaching; a lessonnouninanimate
zharetharaworshippernounanimate
honutharalistenernounanimate
nekrutefearnouninanimate
nyüdhötharaservant; one bound to servicenounanimate
edhüteinitiation; entrynouninanimate
levötecoming, visitnouninanimate
nöyetewarningnouninanimate
yeyütedemandnouninanimate
lyöneyötemourningnouninanimate
dhöshatedecisionnouninanimate
vaneteinvitationnouninanimate
viretejoining, accessionnouninanimate
yaveteadmission into an institutionnouninanimate
thare-weseEarth–Water: the transition from Khélmelai to Ophalrhannouninanimate
wese-sareWater–Air: the transition from Ophalrhan to Sévadrainouninanimate
sare-dhuAir–Darkness: the transition from Sévadrai to Azravornouninanimate
fare-yoreFire–Sound: the transition from Róskaï to Lunetyennouninanimate
ẅepüdheteproclamation, public statementnouninanimate
thowutereturn, giving backnouninanimate
lüwesmell, give off a scentverb—
söpatasteverb—
ẅelyobatheverb—
siwüwhistleverb—
towüswimverb—
yönefloat on the surfaceverb—
tumeclimbverb—
dörobakeverb—
lalyeembroiderverb—
nyönügreetverb—
lyumoring, chime (of a bell)verb—
shöẅüblow (of the wind)verb—
zhülyurestverb—
lünyehumverb—
zezhiteaseverb—
ẅekowave (the hand or a wing)verb—
lyoweripenverb—
nölyübloom, open (of a flower)verb—
fopüstirverb—
lenubuyverb—
dhalepayverb—
küköknockverb—
frömuscoldverb—
kizechaseverb—
mömiglad, cheerfuladjective—
löpitiredadjective—
thedihungryadjective—
nüẅiwetadjective—
yeyifulladjective—
muwislowadjective—
lyalyicleanadjective—
vöyiloudadjective—
felyisouradjective—
goyafishnounanimate
züẅabeenounanimate
lyewamothnounanimate
türaheronnounanimate
nyülyuhoneynouninanimate
eloeggnouninanimate
üresoup, brothnouninanimate
müẅumossnouninanimate
lyüshugrassnouninanimate
dhöẅusmokenouninanimate
niredusknouninanimate
iẅespring (the season)nouninanimate
fayoautumnnouninanimate
vüwurainbownouninanimate
werörowaterfallnouninanimate
basovalleynouninanimate
zerusandnouninanimate
ẅizhulattice windownouninanimate
lyödopaper lanternnouninanimate
pöẅujarnouninanimate
tilocombnouninanimate
larekitenouninanimate
sinoflutenouninanimate
labopapernouninanimate
vöwoswingnouninanimate
kipedrumnouninanimate
sitoneedlenouninanimate
vüwulyeimage of a rainbow; a rainbow seen in waternouninanimate
shulẅoyathe Wind thought of as a personnounanimate
ẅushaslip, slide on a wet or icy surfaceverb—
wenaforgetverb—
miledrinkverb—
ahesighverb—
mevilie downverb—
lilödripverb—
wivöspill (a liquid)verb—
nyelödry in the sun or the windverb—
hüruweepverb—
nyirübelieveverb—
rükocomb (wool or hair)verb—
kesaunloadverb—
peniweigh on a balanceverb—
wefadye (cloth or yarn)verb—
zopiadd up, total (an account)verb—
süshewipe cleanverb—
klücrackle, tick (of frost or cooling stone)verb—
shofayell, cry outverb—
nokebend under a weightverb—
dhüspeache with cold (of teeth or fingers)verb—
zeshüyellow, pale goldadjective—
owüwhiteadjective—
kilegreyadjective—
tepödear, costlyadjective—
yüẅoplum wine, the sweet wine of the Citynouninanimate
nyüfostory, tale told aloudnouninanimate
völulake, mountain lakenouninanimate
lübluskein of yarnnouninanimate
bowaducknounanimate
lerogreens, leaf vegetablesnouninanimate
vulaVula, who keeps a wine shop by the stone bridge (personal name)proper nameanimate
eyaEya, a young dyer (personal name)proper nameanimate
mayömaMayöma, a young woman of the City (personal name)proper nameanimate
povafarmer; villager who brings produce to marketnounanimate
vadhecoppernouninanimate
dhüducooking potnouninanimate
yühobalance, pair of scalesnouninanimate
bavoshouldernouninanimate
kiyochest, lidded box for clothnouninanimate
ligubraziernouninanimate
suvülebenchnouninanimate
rüvepole; carrying polenouninanimate
rüliRüli, Mayöma’s partner (personal name)proper nameanimate
gögaGöga, a roofer (personal name)proper nameanimate
nyumimousenounanimate
könpoturnipnouninanimate
dösrumountain passnouninanimate
zomgübobale, bound loadnouninanimate
kesnyuelbownouninanimate
lyükökecrumbnouninanimate
ralipulyamammoth driver; keeper of a caravan’s mammothsnounanimate
wefatharadyernounanimate

Translation: বুদ্ধু ভুতুম

The complete classic fairytale in verse (with a few prose interludes including at the beginning). It’s thematically like The Ugly Duckling, but with a grand adventure.

আয় রে আমার নাতি-পুতি, আমি তোদের সেই আদিকালের ঠাকুরমা।
aj re amar nat̪i-put̪i, ami t̪od̪er ʃei ad̪:i-kaler ʈʰakurma
Gather around, grandkids, I am your ancient grandma.

আমার এই ঝুলি ভরা কত গল্প, কত ছড়া, শুনবি তোরা?
amar ei dʒʱuli bʱɔra kɔto gɔlpo, kɔto tʃʰɔɽa, ʃunbi t̪ora?
My bag is full of many stories, many rhymes, want to hear?

তবে ঝুলি খুলি— এই ঝুলি নড়ছে, এই ঝুলি নড়ছে, এই ঝুলি নড়ছে…
t̪ɔbe dʒʱuli kʰuli– ei dʒʱuli noɽtʃʰe, ei dʒʱuli noɽtʃʰe, ei dʒʱuli noɽtʃʰe…
Then let me open it– The bag moves, moves, moves…

সপ্তদ্বীপের রাজামশাই, সাতটি রানী তাঁর,
ʃɔpt̪od̪iper radʒamɔʃai, ʃat̪ʈi rani t̪ãr,
Mr. King of seven islands, he has seven queens,

পাঁচটি রানীর কোলে এল পাঁচটি রাজকুমার।
pãtʃʈi ranir kole elo pãtʃʈi radʒkumar.
to the laps of five queens came five princes.

হীরা রাজকুমার, মানিক রাজকুমার, মতি রাজকুমার, শঙ্খ রাজকুমার আর কাঞ্চন রাজকুমার।
hira radʒkumar, manik radʒkumar, mot̪i radʒkumar, ʃɔŋkʰo radʒkumar ar kantʃon radʒkumar.
Prince Diamond, Prince Gemstone, Prince Pearl, Prince Conch Shell and Prince Gold.

পাঁচটি রানীর পাঁচটি কুমার, রইল বাকি দুই,
pãtʃʈi ranir pãtʃʈi kumar, roilo baki d̪ui,
Five queens have five sons, two remain,

মনের দুঃখে সে দুই রানী পড়ে থাকেন ভুঁই।
mɔner d̪uk:ʰe ʃe d̪ui rani poɽe t̪ʰaken bʱũi.
those two queens lie prone on the dust in sorrow.

পাঁচ কুমারের পরে রাজার হয়েছিল কি, একটি বাঁদর, একটি প্যাঁচা— ছিঃ ছিঃ ছিঃ ছিঃ ছিঃ!
pãtʃ kumarer pɔre radʒar hojetʃʰilo ki, ekʈi bãd̪or, ekʈi pæ̃tʃa– tʃʰi tʃʰi tʃʰi tʃʰi tʃʰi!
After five princes, what did the king beget? A monkey and an owl– Ew! Yuck!

মানুষেরো পেটে নাকি বাঁদর-প্যাঁচা হয়?
manuʃero peʈe naki bãd̪or-pæ̃tʃa hɔj?
Can humans even sire monkeys and owls?

বুদ্ধু-ভুতুম নামে তাদের হলো পরিচয়।
bud̪:ʱu-bʱut̪um name t̪ad̪er holo poritʃɔj.
They were named Goofy and Fright.

তখন রাজা দুই রানীকে দিলেন নির্বাসন,
t̪ɔkʰon radʒa d̪ui ranike d̪ilen nirbaʃon,
Then the king exiled two queens,

পাঁচটি রানী হলো রাজার পরম আপন।
pãtʃʈi rani holo radʒar pɔrom apon.
the five queens became the king’s closest.

ছোট রানী কাঠকুড়ানি,
tʃʰoʈo rani kaʈʰkuɽani,
The youngest queen is a wood collector,

অন্যে কুড়োয় ঘুঁটে,
on:e kuɽoj ɡʱũʈe,
the other collects dung,

বুদ্ধু-ভুতুম চেয়ে থাকে গাছের ডালে উঠে।
bud̪:ʱu-bʱut̪um tʃeje t̪ʰake gatʃʰer ɖale uʈʰe.
Goofy and Fright watch them from the branches.

পাঁচ কুমারে ঘোড়ায় চড়ে চলে অভিযানে,
pãtʃ kumare ɡʱoɽaj tʃoɽe tʃɔle obʱidʒane,
Five princes go on adventures riding horses,

বুদ্ধু-ভুতুম চেয়ে থাকে পাঁচটি দাদার পানে।
bud̪:ʱu-bʱut̪um tʃeje t̪ʰake pãtʃʈi d̪ad̪ar pane.
Goofy and Fright stare after five elder brothers.

Goofy’s mother:

আয় রে আমার সোনা মানিক,
aj re amar ʃona manik,
Come to me, my gold, my gem,

আয় রে আমার বুদ্ধু।
aj re amar bud̪:ʱu.
come, my Goofy.

Goofy:

থাকলে পঙ্খী উড়ে যেতুম নিয়ে তোমায় শুদ্ধু।
t̪ʰakle poŋkʰi uɽe dʒet̪um nije tomaj ʃud̪:ʱu.
Had I a wing, I would have flown away with you.

Fight’s mother:

আয় রে আমার বুকেরও ধন,
aj re amar buker(o) d̪ʱɔn,
Come, my heart’s treasure,

আয় রে আমার ভুতুম।
aj re amar bʱut̪um.
Come, my Fright.

Fright:

থাকতো যদি ময়ূরপঙ্খী, দূর বিদেশে যেতুম।
t̪ʰakt̪o dʒod̪i mojurpoŋkʰi, d̪ur bid̪eʃe dʒet̪um.
Had I a Peacock’s Wing, I’d have left for faraway lands.

Goofy and Fright:

বাঁদর প্যাঁচা বলে সবাই কেন দেয় মা গালি?
bãd̪or pæ̃tʃa bole ʃɔbai kæno d̪æj ma gali?
Mother, why do they call us monkey and owl?

Their mothers:

হোক না বাঁদর, হোক না প্যাঁচা, মায়েরই দুলাল রে।
hok na bãd̪or, hok na pæ̃tʃa, majeri d̪ulal re.
You may be a monkey, you may be an owl, mother adores you.

এই তো তোদের দুঃখিনী মা নিলা তোদের কোলে,
ei t̪o t̪od̪er d̪ukʰini ma nilo t̪oder kole,
See how your sorrowful mother takes you into her lap,

ময়ূরপঙ্খী পক্ষীরাজ এই কোলেতেই দোলে।
mojurpoŋkʰi pok:ʰradʒ ei kolet̪ei d̪ole.
Peacock’s Wing and King of Birds sway here.

Note: King of Birds is a winged horse like Pegasus.

Goofy and Fright:

— আমাদের বাবা কোথায়?
amad̪er baba kot̪ʰaj?
Where is our father?

Two mothers:

— কেন, ওই রাজামশাই!
kæno, oi radʒamɔʃai!
Why, that Mr. King!

Goofy and Fright:

— কেন তুমি কাঠকুড়ুনি, চুলে কেন নেই চিরুনি?
kæno t̪umi kaʈʰkuɽuni, tʃule kæno nei tʃiruni?
Why are you a wood collector, why no comb in your hair?

কেন তুমি ঘুঁটে কুড়াও, প্রাসাদে কেন না যাও?
kæno t̪umi ɡʱũʈe kuɽao, praʃad̪e kæno na dʒao?
Why do you collect dung, why not go to the palace?

— আমরা দুটি ভাই, আমরা দুটি ভাই, চলো আমরা দুজন মিলে বাবার কাছে যাই।
amra d̪uʈi bʱai, amra d̪uʈi bʱai, tʃɔlo amra d̪udʒɔn mile babar katʃʰe dʒai.
We’re two bros, we’re two bros, come on, let us go to our father together.

Courtiers:

ওরে ওরে আয় না!
ore ore aj na!
Hey, hey, come here!

একটা বাঁদর দোরে এসেছে
ækʈa bãd̪or d̪ore eʃetʃʰe
A monkey has come to the door

কি মজার বায়না!
ki mɔdʒar bajna!
What an amusing demand!

ওরে ওরে আয় না!
ore ore aj na!
Hey, hey, come here!

ওই প্যাঁচাটার মুখের কাছে ধর দেখি এক আয়না!
oi pæ̃tʃaʈar mukʰer katʃʰe d̪ʱɔr d̪ekʰi æk ajna!
Hold a mirror before that owl!

ওরে ওরে আয়না!
ore ore aj na!
Hey, hey, come here!

Court ladies:

— এটা দেখি বাঁদরছানা, ঘুঁটেকুড়ুনির ছা!
eʈa d̪ekʰi bãd̪ortʃʰana, ɡʱũʈekuɽunir tʃʰa!
This I see is monkey boy, dung collector’s brat!

ও মা ও মা ছি ছি ছি ছি, যা যা যা যা যা!
o ma o ma tʃʰi tʃʰi tʃʰi tʃʰi, dʒa dʒa dʒa dʒa dʒa!
Ew, ew, yuck, yuck! Get lost!

Narrator:

একদিন হয়েছে কি—
ækd̪in hojetʃʰe ki–
One day, it so happened–

রেখে সোনার খাটে পা,
rekʰe ʃonar kʰaʈe pa,
Foot resting on golden stool,

আর রূপার খাটে গা,
ar rupar kʰaʈe ga,
body leaning on a silver bed,

সিঁথিপাটি করতেছিল পাঁচটি রানীরা।
ʃĩt̪ʰipaʈi kort̪etʃʰilo pãtʃʈi ranira.
the queens were doing their hair.

দাসী এসে খবর দিল—
d̪aʃi eʃe kʰɔbor d̪ilo–
A slave girl gives the news–

Slave girl:

— ওগো রানী মা!
ogo rani ma!
Oh queen mother!

ঘাটেতে লেগেছে এক শুকপঙ্খী নাও!
ɡʱaʈet̪e legetʃʰe æk ʃukpoŋkʰi nao!
There has come to the port a Shuk’s Wing boat!

নায়ে আছে হীরার হাল,
naje atʃʰe hirar hal,
The boat has a diamond helm,

রূপার বৈঠা,
rupar boiʈʰa,
and silver oar.

নায়ের মধ্যে কুঁচবরণ রয়েছে কন্যা,
najer mod̪:ʱe kũtʃbɔron rojetʃʰe kon:a,
In the boat, there is a bead-bright maiden,

মেঘবরণ চুল তার,
meɡʱbɔron tʃul t̪ar,
cloud-dark is her hair,

হলুদবরণ গা!
holudbɔron ga!
yellow is her skin!

ওগো রানী মা, ওগো রানী মা, ওগো রানী মা!
ogo rani ma, ogo rani ma, ogo rani ma!
Oh queen mother, oh queen mother, oh queen mother!

Five queens:

— ওলো ওলো, চল না সবাই, দেখতে যাবি না?
olo olo, tʃɔl na ʃɔbai, d̪ekʰt̪e dʒabi na?
Hey, hey, let’s go together, want to see?

কুঁচবরণ কন্যা লো তোর মেঘবরণ চুল,
kũtʃbɔron kon:a lo t̪or meɡʱbɔron tʃul,
Bead-bright maiden thou art, Cloud-Dark Hair!

মোদের ঘরে আসো যদি,
mod̪er ɡʱɔre aʃo dʒod̪i,
If you come to our house,

দেব সোনার দুল।
d̪ebo ʃonar d̪ul.
we shall give thee a gold earring.

কুঁচবরণ কন্যা…
kũtʃbɔron kon:a…
Oh, bead-bright maiden…

Enchanted princess:

সোনার ফুল নাহি চাই,
ʃonar pʰul nahi tʃai,
Fashioned gold I don’t care for,

চাই মোতির ফুল,
tʃai mot̪ir pʰul,
I like fashioned pearl,

তবে যাবে তোমার ঘরে মেঘবরণ চুল।
t̪ɔbe dʒabe t̪omar ɡʱɔre meɡʱbɔron tʃul.
then shall enter thy home Cloud-Dark Hair.

Five queens:

মোতির ফুল কোথায় আছে, যদি বলে যাও,
mot̪ir pʰul kot̪ʰaj atʃʰe, dʒod̪i bole dʒao,
If thou tell us where to find fashioned pearl,

ঘরে আছে পাঁচ কুমার, ময়ূরপঙ্খী নাও।
ɡʱɔre atʃʰe pãtʃ kumar, mojurpoŋkʰi nao.
in our house are five youths and Peacock’s Wing boat.

কুঁচবরণ কন্যা…
kũtʃbɔron kon:a…
Oh, bead-bright maiden…

Enchanted princess:

মোতির ফুল, মোতির ফুল আছে বহুদূর,
mot̪ir pʰul, mot̪ir pʰul atʃʰe bohud̪ur,
Fashioned pearl, fashioned pearl is far away

যেতে কি পারবে কুমার কলাবতীর পুর?
dʒet̪e ki parbe kumar kɔlabot̪ir pur?
Can the youth reach Kɔlaboti Kingdom?

হাটের সওদা ঢোল-ডগরে, গাছের পাতি ফল, নকশী কাঁথার মাঠ পেরিয়ে রাঙা নদীর জল।
haʈer ʃɔod̪a ɖʱol-ɖɔgore, gatʃʰer pat̪i pʰɔl, nokʃi kãt̪ʰar maʈʰ perije raŋa nod̪ir dʒɔl.
In the market’s trade and drums, tree with lime fruit, past Embroidered Quilt Meadow, Red River waters.

Note: Directions to reach Kɔlaboti Kingdom? Some of these things turn up later in surreal contexts.

Five queens:

কোন দেশেরও কন্যা তুমি, যাও গো বলিয়া,
kon d̪eʃer(o) kon:a t̪umi, dʒao go bolija,
Tell us which country you are from, maiden,

সোনার চাঁদ ছেলে আমার, করো যদি বিয়া।
ʃonar tʃãd̪ tʃʰele amar, kɔro dʒod̪i bija.
if thou marry my gold-moon son…

Note: “Gold-moon” is idiomatic and used to refer to kids in common speech.

Enchanted princess:

কলাবতী কন্যা আমি,
kɔlabot̪i kon:a ami,
Princess Kɔlaboti am I,

মেঘবরণ কেশ,
meɡʱbɔron keʃ,
Cloud-Dark Hair,

তোমার পুত্র পাঠাও যদি কলাবতীর দেশ।
t̪omar put̪ro paʈʰao dʒod̪i kɔlabot̪ir d̪eʃ.
if thou sendest thy son to Kɔlaboti Kingdom.

আনতে পারে মোতির ফুল,
ant̪e pare mot̪ir pʰul,
If he bringeth the fashioned pearl,

ঢোল-ডগরখানি,
ɖʱol-ɖɔgorkʰani,
and the wedding drums,

আসবো তোমার ঘরে হয়ে সেই পুত্রের রানী, হয়ে সেই পুত্রের রানী, হয়ে সেই পুত্রের রানী…
aʃbo t̪omar ɡʱɔre hoje ʃei put̪rer rani, hoje ʃei put̪rer rani, hoje ʃei put̪rer rani…
I shall enter thy home as that son’s queen, as that son’s queen…

Narrator:

তাই শুনে পাঁচ রানী বলেন— ময়ূরপঙ্খী চাই!
t̪ai ʃune pãtʃ rani bɔlen– mojurpoŋkʰi tʃai!
Hearing this, five queens say– give us Peacock’s Wing!

পাঁচটি ময়ূরপঙ্খী এনে দিলেন রাজামশাই।
pãtʃʈi mojurpoŋkʰi ene d̪ilen radʒamɔʃai.
Mr. King brought them five Peacock’s Wings.

উড়ল নিশান ময়ূরপঙ্খী লাগল ঘাটে এসে,
uɽlo niʃan mojurpoŋkʰi laglo ɡʱate eʃe,
Flags aflutter, Peacock’s Wings entered the port,

পাঁচটি কুমার চলল তাতে কলাবতীর দেশে,
pãtʃʈi kumar tʃol:o t̪at̪e kɔlabot̪ir d̪eʃe,
Five princes departed to Kɔlaboti Kingdom,

চলে কলাবতীর দেশে।
tʃɔle kɔlabot̪ir d̪eʃe.
they go to Kɔlaboti Kingdom!

বদর বদর ভাই! গাজি গাজি বলো ভাই! বদর বদর ভাই! গাজি গাজি বলো ভাই!
bɔdor bɔdor bhai! gadʒi gadʒi bɔlo bhai! bɔdor bɔdor bhai! gadʒi gadʒi bɔlo bhai!
Bɔdor bɔdor bhai! Gaji gaji bɔlo bhai! Bɔdor bɔdor bhai! Gaji gaji bɔlo bhai!

Note: Sailor’s chant.

তাই না দেখে ভাঙা ঘরে, বুদ্ধু-ভুতুম বায়না ধরে,
t̪ai na d̪ekʰe bʱaŋa ɡʱɔre, bud̪:ʱu-bʱut̪um bajna d̪ʱɔre,
Seeing this, in their broken house, Goofy and Fright throw a tantrum,

কলাবতীর দেশে যাবে, ময়ূরপঙ্খী কোথায় পাবে?
kɔlabot̪ir d̪eʃe dʒabe, mojurpoŋkʰi kot̪ʰai pabe?
They will go to Kɔlaboti Kingdom, where will they get a Peacock’s Wing?

দুই সুপুরির ডোঙায় দিয়ে ধান-দূর্বা-পান,
d̪ui ʃupurir ɖoŋaj d̪ije d̪ʱan-d̪urba-pan,
A raft of two areca palms, held together with straw, grass and betel leaf,

সিঁদুরফোঁটা, কড়ি দিয়ে দুই মায়ে সাজান।
ʃĩd̪urpʰõʈa, koɽi d̪ije d̪ui maje ʃadʒan.
with a vermillion drop and cowrie shells, two mothers adorn.

সেই ডোঙাতে বুদ্ধু-ভুতুম চড়ল অবশেষে,
ʃei ɖoŋat̪e bud̪:ʱu-bʱut̪um tʃoɽlo ɔboʃeʃe,
In that raft, Goofy and Fright depart at last,

দুই মায়ে কাঁদিয়ে চলে কলাবতীর দেশে।
d̪ui maje kãd̪ije tʃɔle kɔlabot̪ir d̪eʃe.
Making two mothers cry, they go to Kɔlaboti Kingdom.

Two mothers cry:

বুদ্ধু আমার বাপ, কি করেছি পাপ!
bud̪:ʱu amar bap, ki koretʃi pap!
Goofy my child, what is my sin?

কোন্‌ পাপেতে দূরে গেলি, দিয়ে মনস্তাপ?
kon papet̪e d̪ure geli, d̪ije mɔnost̪ap?
For what sin do you leave me in such anguish?

ভুতুম আমার বাপ, কি করেছি পাপ!
bʱut̪um amar bap, ki koretʃi pap!
Fright my child, what is my sin?

কেন আমায় রেখে গেলি, দিয়ে মনস্তাপ?
kæno amaj rekʰe geli, d̪ije mɔnost̪ap?
For what sin do you leave me in such anguish?

পৃথিবীতে যেখানে যে আছো ভগবান,
prit̪ʰibit̪e dʒekʰane dʒe atʃʰo bʱɔgoban,
In the world, whatever god there may be,

মোদের বাছার তরে দিলাম এই দূর্বা-ধান।
mod̪er batʃʰar t̪ɔre d̪ilam ei d̪urba-d̪ʱan.
for our kids, we offer this grass and straw.

Narrator:

পাঁচ কুমারের ময়ূরপঙ্খী আগেতে চলিছে,
pãtʃ kumarer mojurpoŋkʰi aget̪e tʃolitʃʰe,
Peacock’s Wings of five princes sail ahead,

বুদ্ধু-ভুতুমের ডোঙা চলে পিছে পিছে।
bud̪:ʱu-bʱut̪umer ɖoŋa tʃɔle pitʃʰe pitʃʰe.
Goofy and Fright’s raft follow behind.

যুক্তি করে সবাই মিলে এই বেলা পাঁচ ভাই, এসো বুদ্ধু-ভুতুমের ডোঙা সাগরে ডুবাই।
dʒukt̪i kore ʃɔbai mile ei bæla pãtʃ bʱai, eʃo bud̪:ʱu-bʱut̪umer ɖoŋa ʃagore ɖubai.
Taking counsel, five brothers say: Let us sink Goofy and Fright’s raft beneath the ocean.

যেই না বলা, নীল দরিয়ায় উঠল কি তুফান!
dʒei na bɔla, nil d̪orijaj uʈʰlo ki t̪ufan!
As soon as said, in the blue deep there rises a typhoon!

ময়ূরপঙ্খী আছাড়-পিছাড়, ঢেউ ওঠে আসমান!
mojurpoŋkʰi atʃʰaɽ-pitʃʰaɽ, ɖʱeu oʈʰe asman!
Peacock’s Wing hither thither, waves reach the sky!

Five princes:

কে বাঁচাবে বুদ্ধু ভাই? কোথায় গেল ভুতুম ভাই? কে বাঁচাবে বুদ্ধু ভাই? কোথায় গেল ভুতুম ভাই?
ke bãtʃabe bud̪:ʱu bʱai? kot̪ʰaj gælo bʱut̪um bʱai? ke bãtʃabe bud̪:ʱu bʱai? kot̪ʰaj gælo bʱut̪um bʱai?
Who will save us, Brother Goofy? Where is Brother Fright? Who will save us, Brother Goofy bhai? Where is Brother Fright?

Goofy:

— ভাইরে!
bʱaire!
Little brother!

Fright:

— কি দাদা?
ki d̪ad̪a?
What, big brother?

Goofy:

— মনটা করে কেমন কেমন! যেমন কর্ম শাস্তি তেমন!
mɔnʈa kɔre kæmon kæmon! dʒæmon kɔrmo ʃast̪i t̪æmon!
I feel as if the punishment fits the crime!

Fright:

— অমন কথা বলে নাকি! এসো তো ডুব দিয়ে দেখি, এসো তো ডুব দিয়ে দেখি।
ɔmon kɔt̪ʰa bɔle naki! eʃo t̪o ɖub d̪ije d̪ekʰi. eʃo t̪o ɖub d̪ije d̪ekʰi.
Don’t say that! Let’s dive in and see. Let’s dive in and see.

Narrator:

থম থম থম পাতালপুরী, কেউ কোথাও নেই।
t̪ʰɔm t̪ʰɔm t̪ʰɔm pat̪alpuri, keu kot̪ʰao nei.
Thɔm thɔm thɔm… City of the undergloom! No one around.

Note: Thɔm is sound symbolism for stillness.

কাঁথা সেলাই করছে বুড়ি সেই পাতালেতেই।
kãt̪ʰa ʃelai kortʃʰe buɽi ʃei pat̪alet̪ei.
An old woman embroiders a quilt in the undergloom.

বুদ্ধুকে সে দেখতে পেয়ে কাঁথা ছুঁড়ে দিল,
bud̪:ʱuke ʃe d̪ekʰt̪e peje kãt̪ʰa tʃʰũɽe d̪ilo,
Seeing Goofy, she tosses the quilt at him,

অমনি হাজার সিপাহী ধেয়ে বুদ্ধুকে বাঁধিল।
omni hadʒar ʃipahi d̪ʱeje bud̪:ʱuke bãd̪ʱilo.
Immediately, a thousand soldiers tie him up.

বুদ্ধু তখন নড়ে না,
bud̪:ʱu t̪ɔkʰon nɔɽe na,
Goofy doesn’t move,

চোখ মিটমিট করে না,
tʃokʰ miʈmiʈ kɔre na,
doesn’t wink an eye,

মরার মতো পড়ে থাকে আঁধার পাতালপুরে।
mɔrar mɔt̪o poɽe t̪ʰake ãd̪ʱar pat̪alpure.
like the dead, he lies there in the city of the undergloom.

মরা ভেবে সবাই তাকে ফেলে দিল দূরে।
mɔra bʱebe ʃɔbai t̪ake pʰele d̪ilo d̪ure.
Thinking he’s dead, they throw him far away.

যেই না ফেলা,
dʒei na pʰæla,
As soon as they leave,

বুদ্ধু তখন মিটিমিটি চোখে
bud̪:ʱu t̪ɔkʰon miʈimiʈi tʃokʰe
Goofy, winking his eye,

সাত মহলা রাজপুরীতে চুপিচুপি ঢোকে।
ʃat̪ mɔhola radʒpurit̪e tʃupitʃupi ɖʱoke.
sneaks into the seven-halled royal palace

কুঁচবরণ কন্যা যেথায়
kũtʃbɔron kon:a dʒet̪ʰaj
where the bead-bright maiden

সোনার শুকের সাথে
ʃonar ʃuker ʃat̪ʰe
is with her golden Shuk bird,

কি কথা কয় চুপি সাড়ে সেখানে কান পাতে:
ki kɔt̪ʰa kɔj tʃupi ʃaɽe ʃekʰane kan pat̪e:
he quietly eavesdrops on their conversation:

Enchanted princess:

সোনার পাখি শুক রে,
ʃonar pakʰi ʃuk re,
Golden bird Shuk,

গেল না মোর দুখ রে,
gælo na mor d̪ukʰ re,
I languish in sorrow,

রূপার বৈঠা হীরার হাল
rupar boiʈʰa hirar hal
silver oar and diamond helm

রইল পড়ে চিরকাল,
roilo poɽe tʃirokal,
were of no use,

কেউ না এলো রাজার কুমার,
keu na elo radʒar kumar,
there came no royal prince

কি হলো বল শুক আমার?
ki holo bɔl ʃuk amar?
What happened, oh Shuk?

Golden bird Shuk:

— রাজকন্যার এলো চুল, মাথায় ছিল মোতির ফুল
radʒkon:ar elo tʃul, mat̪ʰaj tʃʰilo mot̪ir pʰul
In the royal maiden’s flowing hair, there was a fashioned pearl

দেখ তো ফুল আছে নাকি
d̪ækʰ t̪o pʰul atʃʰe naki
Take a look, is the flower still there?

কে নিয়েছে বল, দেখি? কে নিয়েছে বল, দেখি? কে নিয়েছে বল!
ke nijetʃʰe bɔl, d̪ekʰi? ke nijetʃʰe bɔl, d̪ekʰi? ke nijetʃʰe bɔl?
Can you say who took it? Can you say who took it? Can you say who took it?

Enchanted princess:

— কে নিয়েছে বলো না, কেন করো ছলনা?
ke nijetʃʰe bɔlo na, kæno kɔro tʃʰɔlona?
Tell me who took it. Why dost thou deceive me?

— মনের ভুল নয় গো তোর, ওই যে পিছে এসেছে তোর বর!
mɔner bʱul nɔj go t̪or, oi dʒe pitʃʰe eʃetʃʰe t̪or bɔr!
If my eyes don’t deceive me, there behind you is your bridegroom!

Enchanted princess:

— ও মা! ও মা কোথায় বর?
o ma! o ma kot̪ʰaj bɔr?
Oh mother, what bridegroom?

এ যে দেখি এক বাঁদর!
e dʒe d̪ekʰi æk bãd̪or!
I see here a monkey!

কি দেখেছি সকালে, এই ছিল কি কপালে!
ki d̪ekʰetʃʰi ʃɔkale, ei tʃʰilo ki kɔpale!
What did I see this morning that this was my fate!

Goofy:

— কলাবতী রাজকন্যা, এখন তুমি কার?
kɔlabot̪i radʒkon:a, ækʰon t̪umi kar?
Princess Kɔlaboti, whose are you now?

Enchanted princess:

— আগে ছিলাম বাপ-মায়ের, এখন যে তোমার!
age tʃʰilam bap-majer, ækʰon dʒe t̪omar!
Before, I was father and mother’s. Now I am yours.

Goofy:

— রাজকন্যা দাও না তবে পাঁচ ভাইকে ছাড়ি,
radʒkon:a d̪ao na t̪ɔbe pãtʃ bʱaike tʃʰaɽi,
Princess, let the five brothers go,

আমার মায়ের দুঃখ ঘোচাও, চলো আমার বাড়ি।
amar majer d̪uk:ʰo ɡʱotʃao, tʃɔlo amar baɽi.
End my mother’s anguish, come to my house.

Enchanted princess:

— আমি থাকি এই কৌটোয়, বাইরে যাব না,
ami t̪ʰaki ei kouʈai, baire dʒabo na,
I live in this can, I shall not leave,

শুকপক্ষী দাও তো দেখি ঢোল-ডগরে ঘা।
ʃukpok:ʰi d̪ao t̪o d̪ekʰi ɖʱol-ɖɔgore ɡʱa.
Shuk bird, strike the drum.

Narrator:

শুকপক্ষী টাকডুমাডুম যেমনি বাজায় ঢোল,
ʃukpok:ʰi ʈakɖumaɖum dʒemni badʒai ɖʱol,
When the Shuk bird plays the drum,

অমনি শুরু হাটের মেলা, হৈ হৈ হট্টগোল!
omni ʃuru haʈer mæla, hoi hoi hɔʈ:ogol!
there begins a market fair, hoi! Hoi! Cacophony!

হাটের ভিড়ে রাজকন্যার কৌটা খুঁজে পাইনে,
haʈer bʱiɽe radʒkon:ar kouʈa kʰũdʒe paine,
In the press of the crowd, the princess’ can is lost,

বুদ্ধু তখন ঢোল-ডগরে ঘা দিল ঠিক ডাইনে।
bud̪:ʱu t̪ɔkʰon ɖʱol-ɖɔgore ɡʱa d̪ilo ʈʰik ɖaine.
Goofy then strikes the drum on the right side.

কেন বল তো?
kæno bɔlo t̪o?
What does he find?

যদি ডাইনে ঘা দেয় কষে, তবে হট্টমেলা বসে, আর ঘা দিলে ঠিক বাঁয়ে, তখন হাটটি ভেঙে যায়।
dʒod̪i ɖaine ɡʱa d̪æj koʃe, t̪ɔbe hɔʈ:omæla bɔʃe, ar ɡʱa d̪ile ʈʰik bãje, t̪ɔkʰon haʈ:i bʱeŋe dʒaj.
When he strikes the right side, a market fair begins, and when he strikes the left, the market fair vanishes.

একবার হাট গমগম, সঙ্গে সঙ্গে ভাঙে, এই না জল থইথই, এই নেই জল গাঙে।
ækbar haʈ gɔmgɔm, ʃɔŋge ʃɔŋge bʱaŋe, ei na dʒɔl t̪ʰoit̪ʰoi, ei nei dʒɔl gaŋe.
Now a bustling market, then an empty field, first brimming river, then dry ditch.

Crowd:

ওঠা-বসার কষ্টে হয়রান মোরা হাটুরে,
oʈʰa-bɔʃar kɔʃʈe hɔran mora haʈure,
We men of the fairground are exhausted standing up and down,

আর পারিনা বাপরে!
ar parina bapre!
We can’t do this anymore!

গেল গেল হাটুরে!
gælo gælo haʈure!
The crowd collapses!

ঢোল-ডগর থামাও
ɖʱol-ɖɔgor t̪ʰamao
Stop beating the drum

একটু নি জিরিয়ে,
ekʈu ni dʒirije,
Let us rest,

রাজকন্যার কৌটা এই নাও দিই ফিরিয়ে।
radʒkon:ar kouʈa ei nao d̪i pʰirije.
Here, we will return the princess’ can.

Goofy:

রাজকন্যা, রাজকন্যা, ঘুমিয়ে আছো কি?
radʒkon:a, radʒkon:a, ɡʱumije atʃʰo ki?
Princess, princess, are you asleep?

তোমায় নিতে ঢোল-ডগর নিয়ে এসেছি।
t̪omaj nit̪e ɖʱol-ɖɔgor nije eʃetʃʰi.
For you, I have brought the wedding drums.

রাজকন্যা, কৌটা থেকে মুখটি করো বার গো,
radʒkon:a, kouʈa t̪ʰeke mukʰʈi kɔro bar go,
Princess, look out of your can,

তোমায় নিয়ে যাবো এবার রাঙা নদীর পার গো।
t̪omaj nije dʒabo ebar raŋa nod̪ir par go.
I will take you across the Red River.

Narrator:

তখন আবার মাঝিমাল্লা,
t̪ɔkʰon abar madʒʱimal:a,
Then again, the boatmen,

পাঁচটি রাজকুমার,
pãtʃʈi radʒkumar,
and five princes,

উঠল ভেসে নীল দরিয়ায় ময়ূরপঙ্খী।
uʈʰlo bʱeʃe nil d̪orijaj mojurpoŋkʰi
floated up from the blue deep with Peacock’s Wings.

আর তখন আবার বুদ্ধু নিল ঢোল-ডগর,
ar t̪ɔkʰon abar bud̪:ʱu nilo ɖʱol-ɖɔgor,
And then Goofy took the wedding drums,

কৌটা নিল হাতে,
kouʈa nilo hat̪e,
with the can,

ভুতুম বসে মাস্তুলে,
bʱut̪um bɔʃe mast̪ule,
Fright sits in the Crow’s Nest,

বুদ্ধু বসে ছাতে।
bud̪:ʱu bɔʃe tʃʰat̪e.
Goofy sits on the roof.

চোখ মিটমিট বুদ্ধু কৌটো খুলে রাতে, ফিসফিস কয় কথা রাজকন্যার সাথে।
tʃokʰ miʈmiʈ bud̪:ʱu kouʈo kʰule rat̪e, pʰiʃpʰiʃ koj kɔt̪ʰa radʒkon:ar ʃat̪ʰe.
Winking Goofy, opening the can at night, whispers to the princess.

হালের মাঝি এই কথাটা রাজকুমারে জানায়,
haler madʒʱi ei kɔt̪ʰaʈa radʒkumare dʒanaj,
The boatman at the helm informs the princes,

তাই শুনে পাঁচ রাজার কুমার বুদ্ধিটারে শানায়।
t̪ai ʃune pãtʃ radʒar kumar bud̪:ʱiʈare ʃanaj.
hearing this, five princes sharpen their cunning.

মাস্তুলে তীর মারতেই ভুতুম পড়ে জলে,
mast̪ule t̪ir mart̪ei bʱut̪um pɔɽe dʒɔle,
With an arrow shot at the Crow’s Nest, Fright falls into the water,

বুদ্ধুকে দেয় ঠেলা, পড়ল রসাতলে।
bud̪:ʱuke d̪æj ʈʰæla, poɽlo rɔʃat̪ɔle.
Pushed, Goofy sinks to the liquid floor.

ময়ূরপঙ্খী ভিড়ল শেষে রাজপুরীটির ঘাটে এসে,
mojurpoŋkʰi bʱiɽlo ʃeʃe radʒpuriʈir ɡʱaʈe eʃe,
Peacock’s Wings dock at last at the royal city’s port,

দুই মায়ে যে দৌড়ে এলো, বুদ্ধু-ভুতুম কোথায় গেল?
d̪ui maje dʒe d̪ouɽe elo, bud̪:ʱu-bʱut̪um kot̪ʰaj gælo?
Two mothers came running, where are Goofy and Fright?

Two mothers:

কেউ কি জানো, জানো কি কেউ?
keu ki dʒano, dʒano ki keu?
Does anyone know, knows anyone about them?

উথাল-পাথাল নদীর ঢেউ।
ut̪ʰal-pat̪ʰal nod̪ir ɖʱeu.
River waves splash back and forth.

বুদ্ধু আমার কোথায় গেল? ভুতুম আমার কোথায় গেল?
bud̪:ʱu amar kot̪ʰaj gælo? bʱut̪um amar kot̪ʰaj gælo?
Where is my Goofy? Where is my Fright?

Goofy and Fright:

— মা, মা গো, মা গো, মা, মা গো!
ma, ma go, ma go, ma, ma go!
Mother, mother dear, mother dear, mother, mother dear!

Two mothers:

বুকেরও ধন, হারা মণি, বুদ্ধু এসেছে, বুকেরও ধন, হারা মণি, ভুতুম এসেছে, বুকেরও ধন, হারা মণি, বুদ্ধু এসেছে, বুকেরও ধন, হারা মণি, ভুতুম এসেছে…
buker(o) d̪ʱɔn, hara moni, bud̪:ʱu eʃetʃʰe, buker(o) d̪ʱɔn, hara moni, bʱut̪um eʃetʃʰe, buker(o) d̪ʱɔn, hara moni, bud̪:ʱu eʃetʃʰe, buker(o) d̪ʱɔn, hara moni, bʱut̪um eʃetʃʰe…
Heart’s treasure, lost diamond, Goofy has come, heart’s treasure, lost diamond, Fright has come…

Narrator:

তারপরে কি হলো জানো?
t̪arpɔre ki holo dʒano?
What happened then?

রাজদণ্ড হাতে রেখে
radʒd̪ɔnɖo hat̪e rekʰe
With royal scepter in hand

পাঁচ কুমারের কীর্তি দেখে
pãtʃ kumarer kirt̪i d̪ekʰe
seeing the doings of the five princes

রাজা দিলেন তাদের সাজা।
radʒa d̪ilen t̪ad̪er ʃadʒa.
the king punished them.

তখন কলাবতী কন্যার সাথে বুদ্ধুর বিয়ের পালা,
t̪ɔkʰon kɔlabot̪i kon:ar ʃat̪ʰe bud̪:ʱur bijer pala,
Then it’s Goofy’s wedding chapter with Princess Kɔlaboti,

আর হীরা-মতি কন্যার গলে ভুতুম দিল মালা।
ar hira-mot̪i kon:ar gɔle bʱut̪um d̪ilo mala.
and Fright puts a garland on Princess Diamond-Pearl’s neck.

একদিন রাত ভোর না হতেই বুদ্ধু হলো বুধকুমার,
ækd̪in rat̪ bʱor na hot̪ei bud̪:ʱu holo bud̪ʱkumar,
One day, before night turns to dawn, Goofy became Prince Awakened,

বানর হলো রাজপুত্র,
banor holo radʒput̪ro,
the monkey transformed into a prince,

আর ভুতুম হলো রূপকুমার।
ar bʱut̪um holo rupkumar.
and Fright became Prince Beauty.

সেই বুধকুমার আর রূপকুমারে দুটি চোখের মণি করে রাজা সুখে থাকেন রাজা, সুখে থাকেন রাজা…
ʃei bud̪ʱkumar ar rupkumare d̪uʈi tʃokʰer moni kore radʒa ʃukʰe t̪ʰaken radʒa, ʃukʰe t̪ʰaken radʒa…
With Prince Awakened and Prince Beauty as the apples of his eyes, the king spends his days in pleasure, the king spends his days in pleasure…

Divinity as Care

Draft 1: Disconnected in places.


My objection to religions, as they are practiced, is that they involve establishing an irrational relationship of subordination to a deity or to a priest or master. (Religious art does not fall under this objection, because it does not usually require a serious commitment to subordination.)

The objection rests on two assumptions: that the gods to whom people subordinate themselves are believed to care about them, and that subordination is different from accepting that something exists. Several criticisms can be raised against these assumptions. A creator need not follow human morals toward its creation, any more than we follow the morals of the patterns in Conway’s Game of Life. Many religions have gods who are not perfectly good, all-powerful or all-knowing. Some people believe in a god who should not or cannot be worshipped. If we live in a computer simulation, its programmers might count as gods. Finally, accepting any mind-independent entity, such as numbers or laws of nature, might itself be a form of religious subordination. This post answers these criticisms. The argument rests on five points.

  1. A definition cannot be proved. For a common word, the definition that matters is the one most of its users share.
  2. In the common sense of the word, a god need not be perfectly good, all-powerful or all-knowing, but it must care about its creatures in at least one of two ways. It cares providentially if it made or ordered the world in a way that provides for them. It cares responsively if it treats them differently depending on how they act toward it. Care is necessary for divinity, but it is not sufficient.
  3. Subordination is following the will of another agent. Petitionary prayer, sacrifice and obedience to divine commands are forms of subordination, and they achieve something only if the god cares responsively.
  4. A powerful being that cares in neither way, such as an indifferent programmer running a simulation, is not a god, and nothing is gained by subordination to it. An entity without agency, such as a number, cannot be the object of subordination at all.
  5. Religions, as they are practiced, ask for subordination to a god that cares responsively, or to a priest or master, on the basis of claims that lack the evidence such obedience would require. This is what I mean by irrational subordination. I will expand on this below.

1 Definitions

A definition cannot be proved or disproved. It is an agreement about how to use a word, and it can therefore be adopted without argument. A mathematical result or a scientific claim is different. It must be demonstrated, and the number of people who accept it has no bearing on whether it is true.

Since a definition is an agreement, the question for a common word is who is party to the agreement. By “god” and “religion” I mean what most of the people who use those words mean. Anyone may stipulate a different meaning, but a claim made with it is a claim about something else. An unusual definition becomes the relevant one only when a large part of society adopts it. Until then it is a fringe usage, and having some adherents is not enough. In a 2013 poll by Public Policy Polling, 4% of registered voters in the United States endorsed David Icke’s theory that shape-shifting reptilians control the world (Wikipedia). A definition of “god” with a following of that size would still be a fringe usage.

The same applies to definitions proposed by respected thinkers. Section 6 discusses one example.

2 Divinity as care

Most monotheists believe in a benevolent creator, but many gods are not benevolent. What gods have in common is something weaker, which I call care. It takes two forms.

Providential care. The god made or ordered the world in a way that provides for its creatures. The limiting case is the god of strict deism, who designed the world, set its laws in motion and then ceased to intervene. Under such a god, nature runs reliably, and people can work out from it how they ought to live. This is natural law in the moral sense, as distinct from the laws of physics. Few deists held this strict view. Most believed that God still exercised some providence, and some prayed and expected divine rewards and punishments (Britannica; Wikipedia). Even the god of strict deism, however, cares providentially.

Responsive care. The god notices what people do and treats them differently depending on it. This need not mean kindness. A wrathful god who can be appeased by offerings cares responsively, and so does a god who punishes disobedience. A trickster god takes a close interest in humans, even if the interest lies in deceiving them. A god can care responsively without having made or ordered the world.

The gods of the major religious traditions care in at least one of these ways, and most care responsively. No major tradition has a pantheon made up entirely of indifferent gods, who want nothing from humans and give nothing to them. The nearest approach comes from philosophy. Epicurus taught that the gods exist but neither made the world nor take any interest in human affairs. In Cicero’s On the Nature of the Gods, the speaker Cotta asks why anyone should worship gods who neither care about humans nor act on their behalf, and what would remain of prayers and vows if the gods did not care. He also reports the view of the philosopher Posidonius that Epicurus abolished the gods while professing to retain them (book 1, sections 115–123; LacusCurtius). The view that an indifferent god is a god in name only therefore goes back more than two thousand years.

Care is necessary for divinity but not sufficient, and power alone does not make something a god. In 2020, Christians made up about 29% of the world’s population and Muslims about 26% (Pew Research Center). If Christians, Muslims, Hindus, Jews and adherents of other religions are counted together as the population of theistic religions, about 72% of the world, then Christians and Muslims make up roughly three-quarters of that population. Both traditions describe powerful created beings that may take an interest in humans but must not be worshipped. The New Testament warns against the worship of angels (Colossians 2:18; Revelation 22:8–9), and the Quran describes the angels disowning those who worshipped them and had in fact served the jinn (34:40–41). A definition of “god” that covers every powerful being therefore departs from the way most theists use the word. What else divinity requires varies between traditions. For monotheists, for example, God is the uncreated creator of everything else. The argument here depends only on care being necessary.

3 Worship and subordination

Subordination, as I use the term, is following the will of another agent: obeying its commands, seeking its favor or avoiding its displeasure. Petitionary prayer, sacrifice and obedience to divine commands are forms of subordination to a god. As ways of relating to a god, they achieve something only if the god cares responsively. There is no point in asking a god for help, offering it something in exchange or keeping its commands for its sake unless it responds to what one does.

These practices are widespread. In a Pew Research Center survey of 35 countries published in 2025, a majority of adults prayed every day in 14 of them, and the figure reached 95% in Indonesia (Pew Research Center). Responsive care is also what allows faith to be used to demand obedience. A priest who says that God wants something done relies on the claim that God cares whether it is done.

The history of religion shows worship following responsive care. Historians of religion use the term deus otiosus for a high god who has withdrawn from the government of the world. The idea is found widely in Africa, Melanesia and South America. Such a god remains a god, as the source of the world and its order, but it has delegated earthly matters to ancestors and nature spirits, who act as intermediaries between it and humans (Britannica). Some Gnostics held that the creator of this world is an ignorant or hostile lesser power. The Valentinian teacher Heracleon told his followers to “worship neither the creation nor the Craftsman, but the Father of Truth” (Wikipedia). In both cases, worship goes to beings that are believed to respond.

Reverence without subordination is possible. Epicurus took part in traditional festivals and sacrifices, but as an expression of admiration for the gods, not as a means of winning their favor, and he expected nothing from them in return (Catherine J. Castner, “Epicurean Hetairai as Dedicants to Healing Deities?”). The deists rejected revelation and accused priests of corrupting religion to protect their own power, which they called priestcraft (Wikipedia). Neither Epicureanism nor deism requires obedience to a priest. Both resemble the appreciation of religious art, which involves admiration without obedience.

4 Powerful beings that do not care

Two examples illustrate a powerful being that cares in neither way.

The Jinn. Suppose that a head sometimes appears inside a whirlwind. If one tries to communicate with it, it stares back. Sometimes it pokes people or does something that affects their quality of life in unpredictable ways. Then it disappears. It did not make the world, and nothing anyone does changes how it treats them. Folklore would call such a being a nature spirit, not a god. Praying to it, sacrificing to it or obeying someone who claims to speak for it would achieve nothing.

The Game of Life. Conway’s Game of Life is a grid of cells that live or die according to a few fixed rules. Simple patterns such as gliders move across the grid, and far more complex patterns are possible. In Winning Ways for Your Mathematical Plays (1982), written with Elwyn Berlekamp and Richard Guy, Conway showed that the Game of Life can contain a universal computer, and Paul Rendell later built a working Turing machine in it (LifeWiki). Suppose that a programmer runs a pattern so complex that part of it behaves like an agent, and that the programmer treats the grid as people ordinarily treat the Game of Life, as an object of study. The simulated agent prays to the creator of its universe, offers sacrifices or tries to reason with it.

In Abstraction as Simulation, minds are physical processes, and that the same high-level structure can be realized by many different physical setups. Given enough space and time, a universal computer can carry out any computation. If the physics of a brain can be computed, the Game of Life can in principle run whatever a brain does. The simulated agent would then be as real as one made of neurons, and its prayers would be real events with real causes. The question is whether anything outside the grid responds to them.

A programmer who treats the grid as an object of study has no reason to respond. The programmer did not set up the grid to provide for the simulated agent, and their main interest would be in discovering the causes of its behavior. They might dismantle it to do so. They can also edit the grid or change its rules at any time.

The power to edit the grid has a further consequence. Abstraction as Simulation also argued that mathematics works because it isolates regularities in physical law, and that calling the laws of nature mathematical means only that they are regular and proportion-preserving. The simulated agent could develop its own mathematics and science in the same way, by abstracting the regularities of the grid’s rules. Those rules are the laws of its world. The hardware running the grid continues to obey its own laws whatever the programmer does, but the programmer can break the grid’s regularities at will. Under such a creator, the laws of the simulated agent’s world are never safe from interference, and its knowledge of them holds only as long as the programmer leaves the grid alone.

This programmer cares less than even the god of strict deism. That god made the world to run reliably and then left it alone. The programmer made the grid for their own purposes and may interfere with it at any time, and so cares for the simulated agent neither providentially nor responsively.

From the simulated agent’s point of view, the grid’s rules and the programmer together amount to indifferent laws of nature with an agent among them that cannot be reasoned with. Ordinary laws of nature differ only in that they cannot decide to interfere. As a source of meaning or consolation, this arrangement offers no more than physics does. Its power resembles that of the Fair Folk, who act on whims and cannot be held to account, more than that of a god.

5 The simulation hypothesis

A creator that treats us as we treat patterns in the Game of Life is therefore not the god of theism. The simulation hypothesis does not change this. The hypothesis states that our universe may be run by someone outside it. That alone implies nothing about whether the simulator cares about us in either way.

Nick Bostrom, whose 2003 paper “Are You Living in a Computer Simulation?” is the best-known treatment of the subject, goes further. He compares the people running a simulation to gods: they created the world, they are far more intelligent than its inhabitants, and they can observe everything and interfere even with physical laws. He suggests that simulated people could not rule out being rewarded or punished for their actions, or even surviving death.

Bostrom describes a possibility, however, and offers no evidence for it. Nothing is known about what a simulator would reward or punish, if anything. For every simulator that rewards obedience, one can conceive of another that punishes it, or one that rewards something no one has thought of. This is the “many gods” objection that critics have raised against Pascal’s wager since Diderot (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). Bostrom himself concludes only that everyone might have a self-interested reason to behave ethically. That provides a reason to be good, which we already have, but no reason to obey a priest who claims to know what the simulator wants. Even if the simulation hypothesis is true, then, it gives no reason for religious subordination.

6 Latour on creators and creations

In On the Modern Cult of the Factish Gods, Bruno Latour attacks the picture of a creator who fully masters what he makes. He holds that this picture is wrong for gods and humans alike. An engineer does not master his machine, Pasteur did not master his lactic acid ferment, and a programmer does not master his program. Our creations, he argues, are as independent of us as we are of God, and he states that “God is a creature”.

Part of this is correct, and Abstraction as Simulation agrees with it. A high-level pattern has causal regularities of its own. Gliders collide and computations terminate whatever hardware runs them, and the programmer may be unable to predict what the pattern will do. In that sense a program is independent of its maker. Latour’s account should nevertheless be rejected, for three reasons.

It confuses independence of behavior with independence of existence. A pattern’s behavior is explained at its own level, but the pattern exists only as long as something keeps running it. The programmer can stop the grid, and a pattern in the grid cannot stop the programmer. A lack of full control does not make the relationship symmetrical, so the claim that our creations are as independent of us as we are of God does not follow from the examples.

It does not affect the argument of this post. A maker who cannot predict his creation and studies it to see what it does is the programmer of section 4. Latour’s examples describe a maker who need not care in either way, and they give the creation no reason to worship him.

It relies on an unusual definition. For most theists, God is the uncreated creator. Few believers share Latour’s conception of a God who is a creature, so by the standard of section 1 his account concerns something other than what most people mean by God.

None of this implies that Latour should be required to describe himself as irreligious. He identified as a Catholic, attended church and read the Bible devotedly (Wikipedia), and he was entitled to describe himself as he wished. The criticism here concerns only his account.

7 Why the subordination is irrational

Religions, as they are practiced, ask for subordination. Believers are told to obey a god, or a priest, master or scripture that speaks for it. Religions without a creator god can still ask for obedience to a teacher. In Tibetan Buddhist tantra, for example, students are instructed to regard their guru as an awakened Buddha and to follow his instructions wholeheartedly (Wikipedia).

The demand rests on claims that, in my view, the evidence does not support: that the god exists, that it cares how people act and that the priest knows what it wants, or, where there is no god, that the master has insight that justifies obedience. Religions usually ask for these claims to be accepted on faith. The argument does not depend on how faith is defined. It depends only on the claims lacking the evidence that obedience would require. Subordination on that basis is what I call irrational.

(Reminder: Religious art makes no such demand. One can admire a cathedral or listen to a requiem without obeying anyone or believing anything.)

8 Mind-independent entities

A broader criticism holds that accepting any mind-independent entity is a form of religious subordination. On this view, a mathematician who holds that numbers exist independently of human minds, or a physicist who holds that the laws of nature are real, defers to something outside himself in the same way that a believer defers to a god.

The criticism fails because subordination, as defined in section 3, is following the will of another agent, and only an agent has a will to follow. Numbers have no agency. Even mathematical Platonists, who hold that numbers exist independently of minds, regard them as abstract objects that are outside space and time and therefore have no causal effects (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). The number line has no will, so it makes no sense to speak of subordinating oneself to it.

The laws of nature are similar. They limit what people can do without commanding anything, and obedience presupposes that disobedience is possible. No one can disobey the law of gravitation, and no one punishes those who try. The same distinction applies to the programmer of section 4. The programmer is an agent, so subordination to the programmer is possible, but because the programmer is indifferent, it achieves nothing.

Accepting such entities does not require faith either. As section 1 noted, mathematical results are accepted on the basis of proof and scientific claims on the basis of evidence, and both are revised when a proof fails or the evidence changes. Abstraction as Simulation went further and argued that numbers are not Platonic objects at all, but features of physical structure isolated from surrounding detail. On either view, accepting numbers leaves no one to obey.

9 Scope

There are countless forms of theism, and a critic might argue that refuting one of them leaves the others standing. This post does not attempt to refute the forms of theism one by one. It makes a claim about a feature that most forms share, responsive care, and about the subordination that this care is used to justify.

That feature covers most theists. Counting the population of theistic religions as in section 2, Christians, Muslims and Hindus together make up about 97% of it (Pew Research Center). Mainstream practice in all three traditions centers on prayer, offerings and commands addressed to gods who are believed to respond.

There are exceptions. Epicurean piety, described in section 3, reveres what Epicurus called gods without requiring obedience. Deism rejects priestly authority, although whether a deist subordinates himself to God depends on the deist. Other fringe cases may exist. This is why the objection is stated as a claim about religions as they are practiced. Very few claims hold in every possible case, and fewer still if the words in them can be freely redefined.

The way this definition has been chosen determines which actual people and practices the claim concerns. Under the common definition, the objection applies to the religions of the great majority of theists, and to religions built around obedience to a master, because they require irrational subordination.

Materialist Economics: Modeling My Own Claims

Draft 2: Added some features.


Over the past year this blog has argued for a materialist political economy. The argument has three layers, and each one rests on the one before it.

  • Physical. Labor value is conserved when goods are exchanged. That one fact is supposed to make prices follow values and split the population into two classes by how much money they hold.
  • Social. Class relations drive capitalism’s dynamics. The profit rate tends to fall, a reserve army of the unemployed holds wages down, and people turn to radical politics when their living standards fall.
  • Programmatic. Democratic planning would remove those dynamics. Its tools are a job guarantee, labor vouchers that cannot circulate like money, a government divided against itself, and a cap on private assets.

In this post I put those claims to the test. They come from seven earlier posts:

I have boiled those posts down to seventeen claims, or propositions: thirteen in §2 and four about finance in §9. I then wrote each mechanism behind them as a set of rules in Palimpsest, a small programming language in which a program is a list of rewrite rules (§3 explains what that means). Running the rules is running the economy. Each proposition then gets three questions:

  1. Does the model actually produce the claim?
  2. Where does its behavior change? At what limits, thresholds and tipping points does a claim stop being true?
  3. Do published data show the same pattern, and at a size the model can match?

Here is what I found, in brief.

Value and profit. Three things follow directly from the rules: value is conserved, the planning computation converges quickly, and wages and profits move in opposite directions. Prices do follow values, as the data show. But the model’s prices stray from values by only 0.8–3.1%, while measured deviations are 7–20%. The profit rate falls only if something fixes the wage (Okishio’s theorem holds in 18 of 18 cases I tested) or if population growth slows. Its long-run level also hits a floor once the population shrinks fast enough, and the model tells you how fast that is.

Money. Conservation alone gives the lower class an exponential distribution of money, with a Gini coefficient of 0.524. US tax data give about 0.5. Without an asset cap, though, capital income piles up far beyond the real top-1% wealth share of 32.5%. In the simulation one owner ends up with 98% of all the money.

The labor market. The bargained wage responds to unemployment with an elasticity of −0.1 at 5.5% unemployment, which is the figure economists measure. When unemployment is below 1/12 (8.3%), moving capital abroad becomes the employers’ best move. A job guarantee raises private wages by 5% at 12.5% unemployment, close to what India’s NREGA scheme did, and has no effect below 1/11 (9.1%).

Politics. Voters pick a radical gamble only after a deep loss. How deep is set by the shape of their attitude to losses (its curvature), and hardly at all by loss aversion. That fits the finding that far-right votes rise after financial crises but not after ordinary recessions. A government divided into at least 1/P independent offices cannot sustain a conspiracy, where P is the chance of an audit and a whistle-blower’s reward equals the bribe.

The whole economy. With all the mechanisms running together under capitalism, labor’s share of income falls 19.9% over 60 periods. The US share fell 20.2% from 1960 to 2026. But the model’s unemployment rises without limit, because machines replace workers faster than new investment creates jobs. An economic shock turns into a lasting radical government once right-wing “aspiration messaging” passes a sharp threshold between 0.26 and 0.27. Under planning, every route into the radical vote disappears.

Finance. When buyers can borrow a share LTV of a house’s price, a fixed stock of houses sells for S/(1 − LTV), where S is what buyers have saved. The new money goes to the people who already own the houses, and no extra output is produced. When capital gains are set against the things that break fortunes up (inheritance, bankruptcy, taxes), the rich form a Pareto class whose shape is fixed by one number, the exponent log₂(q/p). Read this way, the US top-1% wealth share implies an exponent of 1.46 in 1989, close to direct estimates of 1.48–1.55, and 1.32 in 2026. Forced selling feeds on itself only when one sale pushes the price down further than the gap between one firm’s debt and the next. In a fourth, financialized version of the economy, credit keeps people employed until a falling profit rate and interest payments bring on a crash, the kind Hyman Minsky described. In the baseline run each of these crashes produces a radical government, through the moment when credit dries up for indebted households. None does when households carry no debt. This economy elects radical governments in all 27 stress settings I tried; plain capitalism does so in 15. Inflation delays the debt crisis and deflation brings it closer. Letting firms decide when to mechanize stops unemployment rising, but it also shows that the match with the falling labor share depended on that rise.

A separate Python program recomputes every table in this post and checks it character for character (80 checks). You can also run every program in your browser, in the Palimpsest playground.

1 Introduction

My earlier posts covered mechanical materialism, accountable planning, objections and responses, philosophies of contradiction, structural dialectics, fascism as an outgrowth of capitalism, and job creation. Read together, they make one argument that runs from physics to politics.

It starts with conservation. Following Paul Cockshott, value is abstract labor time, and exchange conserves it, the way collisions conserve energy in a gas. Just as energy conservation produces regular statistical patterns in a gas, conservation of value is meant to produce regular patterns in an economy: prices close to labor values, an exponential distribution of money, and a population split into two income classes.

Class relations come next. Who owns the means of production, and who can afford to walk away from a bargain, decide how the economy moves: a falling profit rate, a reserve army of unemployed people that keeps wages down, newly created money that favors people who already own assets, and radical politics when living standards fall.

Last comes a design. Accountable planning is meant to remove those dynamics.

Every link in that chain is a claim about how something works, so every link can be stated precisely and checked. For each one I ask three things. If I state the mechanism precisely, does it produce what the posts say? Where does its behavior change? And how well do the results match the data?

Why rewrite rules? The mechanical-materialism post defines a scientific law as “regularities governing how systems change states under specified conditions”. A rewrite rule says exactly that: when you see something of this shape, replace it with something of that shape, provided these conditions hold. So I wrote the economy as rewrite rules in Palimpsest, a language built around them. Three ideas carry the whole method:

  • One period of the economy is one complete rewriting of a term that holds the state of the economy.
  • A feedback loop is a chain of rules through which something computed in period t comes back in period t + 1.
  • To check that a cause-and-effect arrow in the diagram is real, I nudge one variable, hold every other one fixed, run the rules again and see which way the result moves.

Class analysis feeds the games. Some of the mechanisms are games, in the sense of game theory. Class position decides who the players are, what each can fall back on if bargaining breaks down, and how much is at stake. Under capitalism a worker’s fallback is the reserve army: if she loses this job, will she find another? A job guarantee replaces that fallback with a public job. That one change alters the wage bargain and the game between labor and capital, and through prospect theory, a model of how people weigh gains and losses, it changes how many voters back a radical gamble.

1.1 Summary of findings

The bookkeeping and the equilibria hold up. Conservation, the exponential law, the transfer to whoever gets new money first (the Cantillon effect), the fact that vouchers cannot circulate, and the job guarantee’s effect on employers all follow directly from the rules.

Claims stated without conditions turn out to have conditions. The falling profit rate, the radical coalition, the job guarantee’s power and the patronage spiral each hold only for some values of the model’s settings. The model shows where the boundary lies.

The patterns match the data, but some of the sizes do not. Without fitting anything to the data, the model comes close on the wage curve, the decline of labor’s share, the Gini coefficient of the lower class and the job guarantee’s effect on wages. It misses on how far prices stray from values, on how concentrated wealth is, and on the trend in unemployment. In each miss the model points in the right direction, and something is missing from it.

Finance makes the political results clearer. A financial crisis becomes a radical government at the moment credit dries up for indebted households, because borrowing had lifted the living standard people measure themselves against, and the crunch takes it away. Inflation delays the second debt crisis but cannot prevent the first. Capital gains produce a Pareto class, and policy sets its size. Adding two missing mechanisms, the breaking-up of fortunes and mechanization that responds to wages, repairs two of the misses above. The second repair also shows that the labor-share match depended on unemployment rising (§9).

1.2 How this post is organized

Section 2 lists the claims as propositions T1–T13 and explains the three tests; §9 adds T14–T17. Section 3 introduces Palimpsest. Sections 4–8 follow the posts from physics to politics: value, prices and profit (§4), money (§5), the labor market (§6), politics (§7), and the whole economy with every mechanism running at once, in three versions (§8). Section 9 adds finance: credit money, capital gains, debt deflation and a fourth, financialized version of the economy (T14–T17), along with two more mechanisms the first version left out, mechanization that responds to wages and the mobility of capital. Section 10 collects the verdicts, §11 explains how to reproduce everything, §12 lists the limitations, and §13 sums up.

2 The claims and how I test them

2.1 Seventeen propositions

The posts draw on three books in particular:

  • Classical Econophysics (Cockshott, Cottrell, Michaelson, Wright and Yakovenko, 2009), which treats value, money and profit with the tools of statistical physics.
  • How the World Works (Cockshott, 2019), a history of human labor that includes a demographic theory of the profit rate.
  • The Logic of Political Survival (Bueno de Mesquita, Smith, Siverson and Morrow, 2003). Its “selectorate theory” explains how leaders stay in power by rewarding the group whose support they need. I use it for the claims about party-states, patronage and divided government.

I reduced the posts to thirteen propositions, and §9 adds four about finance. The table quotes the post each one comes from.

propositionpost (quoted)tested in
T1Value is conserved in exchange; surplus value cannot arise from exchangemechanical materialism: “in the exchange of commodities, abstract socially necessary labor time is conserved”§4.1
T2Labor values predict market pricesmechanical materialism: “labor values reliably predict prices”§4.2
T3Conservation yields an exponential distribution of money, and capital income a Pareto upper classmechanical materialism: “the lower approximately 97% … follows an exponential law … the upper approximately 3% follows a Pareto power law”§5.1–5.2
T4Money creation redistributes real claims toward asset holdersmechanical materialism: it “does not create new value but redistributes existing claims on real output”§5.3
T5The rate of profit tends to fallmechanical materialism: “the rate of profit tends to fall over the long run”§4.3, §8.3
T6Planning is a fast contractive computationaccountable planning: “By approximately the twentieth pass they converge”§4.1
T7Quadratic voting replaces the purchasing-power filter and protects intense minoritiesaccountable planning: it “directly replaces the purchasing-power filter with a democratic one”§7.5
T8A job guarantee breaks employers’ poweraccountable planning: capitalists “must offer conditions attractive enough to compete with the government sector”§6.1–6.3
T9A divided government cannot conspireaccountable planning: it “is divided within itself … so that it cannot conspire against the people”§7.3–7.4
T10Vouchers and an asset cap prevent accumulationaccountable planning: vouchers “cannot be lent, invested, or accumulated”§5.2–5.3
T11Falling living standards and inflation drive voters to radical, authoritarian optionsfascism: “The more radical side will always form the more powerful coalition”; accountable planning on inflation as an existential threat§7.1, §8.2, §8.4
T12Right-wing patronage employment produces a self-reinforcing spiraljob creation: “The right buys off every community leader … It’s a downward spiral”§7.2, §8.4–8.5
T13Planning defuses authoritarian politicsaccountable planning: “Because workers’ purchasing power rises rather than erodes, the existential anxiety that drives populations toward authoritarian leaders is defused”§8.2, §8.4–8.6
T14Credit creates money and inflates asset prices, not outputmechanical materialism: “New money bids up the price of housing and equities without a corresponding increase in the real output of the economy”§9.1
T15Compounding capital gains produce the Pareto class, which reform cannot removemechanical materialism: “The Pareto (superthermal) class corresponds to compounding capital-gains income”§9.2
T16Nominal debt makes deflation a self-reinforcing spiral, so the system needs inflation, which cuts real payaccountable planning: “The system requires that the purchasing power of money be deliberately eroded as a condition of its own stability”§9.3–9.4
T17Debt deepens economic desperation and the turn to authoritarian optionsaccountable planning: insecurity is “an existential threat in the same register as mortality”; this evaluation’s first version: “Increasing debt increases desperation”§9.5

Two posts supply method rather than claims.

  • Philosophies of contradiction follows the Italian philosopher Lucio Colletti in treating class conflict as a real opposition between forces, rather than a logical contradiction, and it describes how an alternative can be “foreclosed”, shut off before it can happen. The real opposition shows up in the model as the trade-off between wages and profits (§4.2). Foreclosure shows up as a window for change that closes once a radical government takes office (§8.6).
  • Structural dialectics defines tests for when one social form should give way to another: viability, necessity, Phase Inversion, warrant and synthesis. I apply them to the full model (§8.6).

The objections post adds a rule for counting an hour of skilled labor as several hours of simple labor (§4.1).

2.2 Three tests

Every result in this post comes from an assertion or a printed table in one of the programs listed in Appendix B. An assertion is a line the program checks; if it is false, the program stops with an error.

Test 1: does the model produce the claim? I use four verdicts.

  • Derived: the proposition follows from the rules for every setting of the parameters.
  • Reproduced: it holds at the model’s chosen settings.
  • Qualified: it holds only under an extra condition, which the model makes visible.
  • Contradicted: it fails.

Test 2: where does the behavior change? I look for limits, thresholds and tipping points, and pin them down precisely.

Test 3: what do the data say? Do published measurements show the pattern the model produces, at a size the model can match?

I did not fit the model to any data. Its settings come from its own steady-state algebra (§8.1) or from the posts, so when it matches the data, that is a test of the mechanism rather than of my choice of numbers. Each empirical figure used in a comparison is stored, with its source, in examples/me-evidence.pal.

3 Method: feedback loops as rewrite rules in Palimpsest

Palimpsest is a term-rewriting language with an interpreter written in Rust. A program has four parts:

  • a set of rewrite rules;
  • strategies, which say where and in what order to apply the rules;
  • a starting term, called main;
  • a list of commands.

A program may also rewrite its own source file, but only if it declares that it is allowed to. Palimpsest runs in the browser too, in the Palimpsest playground. There, a Python port of the interpreter runs under Pyodide (Python compiled to WebAssembly), and it gives the same output and the same step counts as the Rust interpreter on every example program.

3.1 Terms, rules and strategies

A term is a symbol, a string, a number or a list in parentheses. A rule has a name, a pattern on the left, a replacement on the right and, optionally, conditions after where:

rule NAME : LHS => RHS where CLAUSE, CLAUSE, ...

Pattern variables come in three kinds:

  • ?x matches any single piece of a term.
  • ?xs... matches several list items in a row.
  • !x is strict: the matching piece is simplified completely (put in “normal form”) before the pattern is tried.

A condition is either a test, which must come out true, or a binding ?v <- EXPR, which computes a value and names it. Conditions are worked out from left to right, and they can use every rule in the program.

The model uses one strategy throughout. It always rewrites the outermost, leftmost piece it can, which computer scientists call normal-order reduction:

strategy eval = outermost(prim + rules)

Each rewriting step uses up one unit of “fuel”, and a program declares its budget with #fuel N. Running out of fuel is an error, never a silent stop. The fuel left at the end works as a fingerprint of the whole computation: if two runs leave different amounts, they did different things.

3.2 Numbers, records and commands

Numbers are exact. An integer can be any size, and a fraction is written n/d. A number whose value is a whole number is always stored as one, so 6/3 simply is 2, and two numbers are equal exactly when their values are. The built-in operations include exact division q/, num and den (numerator and denominator), expt (powers), isqrt (integer square root) and round-to x K, which rounds x to the nearest multiple of 1/K. Nothing is rounded unless the program asks for it.

Records hold the economy’s state, as in (rec (K 270) (kap 3) …). You read a field with @ and change one with set@, put@ or add@.

Commands. A program file starts with settings such as #fuel and #memo, followed by commands:

show TERM with S // print the normal form
display TERM with S // print a string normal form as text
assert TERM with S // PASS iff the normal form is true; a FAIL exits non-zero
let $NAME = TERM with S // normalize once, substitute $NAME in later commands
rewrite self with S // rewrite main and write the program back to its file

rewrite self writes the file in one step, keeps a copy of the old version so the change can be undone, and writes nothing when run with --dry-run. A program that moves its economy forward one step at a time stops changing once its condition fails. Rewriting it again then leaves the file byte for byte the same, so the program has become a quine, a program whose output is its own source.

#memo makes the interpreter remember pieces it has already simplified, which saves work: 400 periods of the small example below take 10,568 steps instead of 29,505. --trace N prints the first N rewriting steps, and --stats reports which rules did the work.

3.3 A worked example: one feedback loop, step by step

examples/me-tour.pal is the smallest complete example of the method. It is one loop: capital K decides employment E, employment decides unemployment u, unemployment decides the wage w, the wage decides profit, and profit becomes next period’s capital.

  • Capital K employs E = min(100, K/3) of N = 100 workers.
  • Unemployment u = 1 − E/N sets the bargained wage share w(u) (§6.1).
  • Three-fifths of profit, (1 − w)E, is invested, and capital wears out at 3% a period.
rule wage : (wage !u) => (q/ (+ 1/5 (* 4/5 (* ?u 2/5))) (+ 1/5 (* ?u 4/5)))
rule step : (step (st ?t ?k)) => (st ?t1 (round-to ?k2 1000))
where ?t1 <- (+ ?t 1), ?e <- (min 100 (q/ ?k 3)), ?u <- (- 1 (q/ ?e 100)), ?w <- (wage ?u),
?k2 <- (+ (* 97/100 ?k) (* 3/5 (* (- 1 ?w) ?e)))
rule run-0 : (run !s !n) => ?s where (<= ?n 0)
rule run-n : (run !s !n) => (run (step ?s) (- ?n 1)) where (> ?n 0)

Running palimpsest examples/me-tour.pal --trace 22 shows the first period (an excerpt):

      2   min: (min 100 (q/ 270 3))  =>  (if (<= 100 (q/ 270 3)) 100 (q/ 270 3))
      3   <prim>: (q/ 270 3)  =>  90
      4   <prim>: (<= 100 90)  =>  false
      5   if-false: (if false 100 (q/ 270 3))  =>  (q/ 270 3)
      6   <prim>: (q/ 270 3)  =>  90
      9   wage: (wage 1/10)  =>  (q/ (+ 1/5 (* 4/5 (* 1/10 2/5))) (+ 1/5 (* 1/10 4/5)))
     15   <prim>: (q/ 29/125 7/25)  =>  29/35
     21 step: (step (st 0 270))  =>  (st 1 (round-to 18981/70 1000))
     22 <prim>: (round-to 18981/70 1000)  =>  271157/1000

At u = 1/10 the wage share comes out as the exact fraction 29/35. The trace also shows a cost of putting off work: min copies an argument it has not evaluated yet, so the same division is done twice (steps 3 and 6). Laziness can cost much more than that. If the loop counter is not forced, it grows into (- (- … 1) 1) and every test has to work it out again, so a loop that should take linear time takes quadratic time. The strict variables !s !n prevent this, which is why every entry point in the libraries is strict.

The loop settles where investment just replaces the capital that wears out: w = 17/20, u = 1/12 and K* = 275.

4 Value, prices and profit (T1, T2, T5, T6)

This section starts with what is conserved, then asks how prices relate to it, and ends with what happens to profitability over time. The results are checked by me-value.pal (17 assertions) and me-classical.pal (8), and the thresholds come from me-extremes.pal (§X3, §X5, §X10).

The reference economy, which I call E3, has three sectors: means of production (machines and materials), necessities (what wages buy) and luxuries. A is the table of inputs each sector needs per unit of output, l is the labor each needs, and b is the workers’ consumption bundle:

A = ((1/5, 1/5, 1/10), (1/10, 1/5, 0), (0, 0, 0)), l = (1, 2, 1), b = (0, 1/4, 0)

4.1 Value, exchange and the plan (T1, T6)

Values and the plan. The labor value of a good is the total labor, direct and indirect, that goes into making it. Solving the input table exactly gives labor values λ = (50/31, 90/31, 36/31). A planner can find the gross output x needed for a final demand d by repeating the step x ← Ax + d until it settles. On a reconstruction of the four-sector plan in the planning post, the estimates agree to within one ton after 18 passes; the post says “approximately the twentieth pass”. For every final demand d, the value of the net product equals the living labor performed: λ·d = l·x.

Exchange. Suppose an exchange table says how much of one good trades for another. If the table is consistent (reflexive, symmetric and transitive), it has the form Tᵢⱼ = vᵢ/vⱼ for some set of values v, and any round of trades brings you back to what you started with. Break transitivity by 10% and a three-trade cycle returns 11/10 of what went in: money makes more money from trade alone, Marx’s M–C–M′, with no production involved. When exchange conserves value, trade cannot create surplus value.

Real data and skilled labor. Classical Econophysics Table 10.1 is a four-industry input–output table. From it, the labor values per dollar of output all fall within 5.65% of their average, and the value of final output equals the wage bill, 244. The objections post counts a skilled hour as 3/2 simple hours. If the people who train the skilled workers are themselves skilled, the coefficient has to be worked out as the settling point of a repeated calculation, and it comes to 7/4.

Verdict: T1 and T6 are derived. Conservation holds for every consistent exchange table and fails for every inconsistent one. How fast the plan converges depends on the largest eigenvalue (the spectral radius) of A.

4.2 Prices and the wage–profit trade-off (T2)

The profit rate, pinned down exactly. When every sector earns the same profit rate r*, prices p satisfy p = (1 + r)p(A + b⊗l). I never compute an eigenvalue. Instead I halve an interval of possible values of r again and again, and at each step I decide exactly, using the Hawkins–Simon test on fractions, which half contains r*. After 30 halvings, r* ∈ [0.22849294, 0.22849294).

Two theorems hold on every wage bundle I tried:

  • The Fundamental Marxian Theorem (Morishima, 1973) says profits are positive if and only if workers are exploited, in the sense that they produce more value than they consume. It holds on 21 wage bundles and on all 64 bundles of a grid, including the edge case λ·b = 1, where r* = 0.
  • The Generalized Commodity Exploitation Theorem says the same is true of every basic good, not just labor: on the same bundles, each basic commodity is “exploited” exactly when r* > 0. So the theorems do not single labor out. The case for labor as the source of value has to rest on evidence.

The real opposition. Measure the wage in units of the net product, and it falls from 1 at r = 0 to 0.0174 at r = 1.9 (Figure 1). Whatever one class gains, the other loses. Along the same curve, the average gap between prices and values, measured as the mean absolute weighted deviation (MAWD), rises from 0 at r = 0 to 0.0349 at r = 1. If every sector uses capital and labor in the same proportions, the gap is zero at every r.

Figure 1. The wage falls strictly as the profit rate rises
Figure 1. The wage–profit frontier of E3 (me-value.pal §3.5. Exact rationals shown to four decimals).

What the data say. The evidence supports T2 on direction and partly on size.

  • Cockshott and Cottrell (1997) report a correlation of 0.977 between prices and labor values for the UK. Zachariah (2006) reports 0.942–0.986 for the seven OECD economies listed in Classical Econophysics.
  • Shaikh (1998) measures a MAWD of 9.2% for the US, and Classical Econophysics reports 7.1–10.5% for 1947–1972. Işıkara and Mokre (2022), using 42 countries, find deviations that are small and stable; the mechanical-materialism post quotes them at 10–20%.

The model’s deviations are too small: 0.8% in E3 and 3.1% for Table 10.1, three to eleven times below Shaikh’s figure. The reason is aggregation. Three or four sectors cannot capture how much the mix of capital and labor varies across the 40 to 100 industries in real tables.

Verdict: T2 is derived in structure and supported by the data, but the model’s deviations are too small.

4.3 The falling rate of profit (T5)

One of Marx’s best-known claims is that the profit rate tends to fall over time. The model can look at this in three ways, over three time spans.

New techniques: Okishio’s theorem. I tested eighteen changes that replace labor with machinery. Capitalists adopt a change if and only if it lowers their cost per unit at current prices.

  • If the real wage stays fixed, Okishio’s theorem holds in all 18: every change capitalists adopt raises the profit rate.
  • If instead the rate of exploitation stays fixed, the profit rate falls after 11 of the 14 changes they adopt.

So whether the profit rate falls depends on what happens to wages. The tendency is only determinate once you say how the wage moves.

When mechanization pays. A technique that is rejected today becomes worth adopting if wages rise far enough. For three rejected techniques the switch point is the same, β* = 0.2822, a rise in the real wage of 12.9%. They share it because all three add machinery and save labor in the same ratio, 1/2. A technique with a ratio of 1 never pays at any wage. Economists call this the Ricardo effect: higher wages bring on mechanization, and here the threshold can be calculated.

Population: the long-run settling point. lib/longrun.pal runs the accumulation model of Classical Econophysics in exact discrete time. Capital grows at λR − (g + δ), where λ is the share of profit invested, and the workforce grows at n. The two keep pace when

R* = (n + g + δ) / λ

whatever the wage share. Four economies with wage shares from 0.2 to 0.8 all settle at R* = 2/15 (Figure 2).

Figure 2. Every wage share converges to the same long-run profit rate
Figure 2. Every wage share converges to the same long-run profit rate (me-classical.pal §C1 every fourth period).

The floor. Because there are always some workers per unit of capital (L/K > 0), the profit rate cannot fall below −(1 − w)(g + δ). The formula for R* leaves this floor out. The two meet when

n* = −(g + δ)(1 + λ(1 − w)) = −0.0248 (w = λ = 3/5, g = 0, δ = 0.02)
nR*floorR after 599 periods
−0.01000.01667−0.008000.01667
−0.02000−0.008000.00042
−0.0248−0.00800−0.00800−0.00534
−0.0300−0.01667−0.00800−0.00766
−0.0500−0.05000−0.00800−0.00799

The rate actually reached is the larger of the two, max(R*, −(1 − w)(g + δ)). Near n* the approach slows to a crawl: after 599 periods at n = −0.0248 the rate is still 0.0027 above the floor, while at n = −0.05 it is within 10⁻⁵. Physicists call this critical slowing down, and it happens wherever two possible resting points swap stability. Cockshott is right that a shrinking population pushes the profit rate toward a negative level. The model adds three things: the rate has a lower bound, the bound depends on the wage share, and near the threshold the rate approaches it very slowly.

What the data say. Maito (2014) finds that the average profit rate of six core countries (Germany, the US, the Netherlands, Japan, the UK and Sweden) fell from 40.6% in 1870–1874 to 10.8% in 1982, then recovered to 14.6% in 2007. Basu (2022) finds a falling world trend for 1960–2019, driven by a falling ratio of output to capital. Holding exploitation constant matches Basu’s breakdown, and slowing population growth matches the long fall. The model reads the recovery of 1982–2007 as the counter-tendency of §8.3, a growing reserve army and a falling wage share.

Verdict: T5 is qualified by the model and supported by the data as a long-run tendency. It needs a rule for wages or slowing population growth.

5 Money and its distribution (T3, T4, T10)

If money is conserved when people trade, as energy is when molecules collide, then statistics alone decide how it ends up spread across a population, before anyone’s merit comes into it. Capital income and newly created money then distort that spread, and the planning proposal is meant to undo the distortions. The results here are checked by me-distribution.pal (18 assertions). Its random numbers come from a fixed formula, so every sample comes out the same on every computer.

5.1 Conservation and the exponential law (T3)

The model. Following Drăgulescu and Yakovenko (2000), suppose every way of dividing M units of money among N people is equally likely. Then the chance that one person holds k units is:

P(m = k) = C(M − k + N − 2, N − 2) / C(M + N − 1, N − 1)

As N grows this approaches a geometric (exponential-like) law. The total-variation distance between the two, a standard measure of how different two distributions are, falls to 0.0003 at N = 1000. When the average holding is T = 10, the geometric ratio is q = T/(1 + T) = 10/11, and the Gini coefficient (0 for perfect equality, 1 for one person holding everything) is 1/(1 + q) = 11/21 ≈ 0.524.

The same law appears if you simply let people trade. In a simulation of 100 people exchanging one unit at random, the Gini rises from 0 to 0.46 after 20,000 trades, and 9.20% of people end up with nothing, against 9.09% predicted. Nobody in the simulation does anything except trade at random. So this much inequality needs no differences in productivity or effort; conservation is enough.

What the data say. Ludwig and Yakovenko (2022) find that the bottom 96% of US tax units follow an exponential law, with a Gini near 0.5, over 1983–2018. The model’s 0.524 is the version of that figure for whole units of money.

5.2 Capital income, condensation and the asset cap (T3, T10)

The model. Five owners and 95 workers trade in two kinds of event. A wage payment adds a fixed amount: an owner pays a random worker one unit. A sale works like interest: the owner who receives the payment is picked in proportion to how much each owner already has, so the rich are likelier to get richer. The planning post’s cap θ on private holdings is one more rule, which moves anything above the cap into a public fund that pays wages.

cap θowners’ share after 60,000 eventsworkers’ Giniowners’ holdings
none0.97640.8439(0, 0, 0, 0, 952)
600.24210.4905(0, 58, 59, 59, 60)
300.11590.4859(4, 25, 26, 29, 29)

Without a cap, capital income does more than produce a Pareto tail, the long thin tail of very large fortunes. The money “condenses”: one owner ends up with 98% of all of it. With a cap, the owners’ share stays below Cθ/M (C owners, each capped at θ, out of M in total), and the workers’ Gini stays near 0.49.

What the data say. In Ludwig and Yakovenko (2022), the top 4% of incomes form a Pareto tail holding 34% of income in 2018. The Federal Reserve’s Distributional Financial Accounts put the top 1%’s share of wealth at 32.5% in the second quarter of 2026. So the model points the right way, but it overshoots badly. Real economies keep wealth to a power law through forces the model leaves out: returns that vary from fortune to fortune, taxes, bankruptcy, and fortunes divided among heirs. Section 9.2 adds them.

5.3 Money creation and labor vouchers (T4, T10)

Money creation. Take an economy that produces Q = 1000 units of goods, where three groups (asset holders, the middle, and the poor) hold 600, 300 and 100 units of money. Give 100 newly created units to the asset holders, and let them spend before prices adjust. In real terms the asset holders gain 100 units of goods, the middle loses 75 and the poor lose 25. The gains and losses add to zero, and the first recipients gain exactly Q·D/M, where D is the new money and M the old money supply. If instead the same new money is handed out in proportion to what people already hold, and spent after prices adjust, nobody gains or loses. Creating money does not create goods. It changes who gets to claim the goods that already exist.

What the data say. Domanski, Scatigna and Zabai (2016) find that after 2008, monetary policy widened wealth inequality mainly by raising share prices, which benefits people who own shares. That is the same mechanism, known after Richard Cantillon as the Cantillon effect: new money benefits whoever receives it first.

Vouchers. Labor vouchers are issued for hours worked and cancelled when they are spent. No rule in the model moves a voucher from one person to another. So one person’s extra work changes nobody else’s holdings, which is not true of money, and there is no rule that would let anyone use vouchers to make more vouchers.

Verdict: T3 is derived and supported for the lower class, and qualified for the upper class, whose concentration the model overstates. T4 is derived and supported in direction. T10 is derived.

6 Class conflict in the labor market (T8)

Up to now the wage has simply been given. This section works it out from class positions. What a worker can fall back on (the reserve army under capitalism, or the job guarantee under planning) decides the bargain. The bargain in turn decides what is at stake in a game where labor can organize and capital can give in, crack down, or leave. The results are checked by me-games.pal (20 assertions), with thresholds from me-extremes.pal (§X1–X2) and data from me-evidence.pal.

6.1 The reserve army as a fallback

The bargain. A worker bargains with power β, a number between 0 and 1. If bargaining fails, she finds another job with probability 1 − u, where u is the unemployment rate, and otherwise lives on a benefit s. Under a job guarantee paying g, the guarantee becomes her fallback instead. The standard Nash bargaining solution gives these wage shares:

w_cap(β, u, s) = (β + (1 − β)us) / (β + u(1 − β)); w_ap(β, g) = g + β(1 − g)

Under capitalism the wage has two limits. At full employment, w(0) = 1: the threat of dismissal means nothing, because another job is always available, so labor takes the whole product. At total unemployment, w(1) = β + (1 − β)s = 13/25.

Where the wage reacts most. The elasticity of the wage with respect to unemployment says by what percentage the wage falls when unemployment rises by one percent. Here it is

e(u) = d ln w / d ln u = uβ(1 − β)(s − 1) / ((β + u(1 − β))(β + (1 − β)us))

which is zero at both ends. It is largest in size at

u* = β / ((1 − β)√s) = 0.3953; e(u*) = −0.2251

So the reserve army has the least power over wages near full employment and the most at about 40% unemployment.

What the data say. Blanchflower and Oswald (2005) estimate that pay responds to local unemployment with an elasticity of about −0.1, much the same across countries. The model gives −0.093 at 5% unemployment and −0.148 at 10%, and it passes −0.10 at 5.54% (Figure 3). I did not choose any parameter to get this. The model also makes a prediction that could be tested: the wage curve should flatten out when unemployment is low.

Figure 3. The model meets the measured wage-curve elasticity at 5.5% unemployment
Figure 3. The elasticity of the bargained wage against unemployment, with the measured elasticity (me-extremes.pal §X1).

6.2 The class-struggle game and capital flight

The game. Workers either accept the terms or organize. Capital either gives in (concedes), cracks down (represses) at a cost ρ, or moves abroad (flees) and earns r_ext there. Organizing costs workers k and raises their bargaining power from b_l to b_h, unless capital represses. With b_l = 1/5, b_h = 1/2, k = ρ = 1/20, r_ext = 1/10, s = 2/5 and g = 4/5, at u = 1/5, the payoffs are:

profilecapitalism: Wcapitalism: Cplanning: Wplanning: C
accept / concede0.73330.26670.84000.1600
accept / repress0.73330.21670.84000.0600
accept / flee0.40000.10000.80000.0000
organize / concede0.85000.10000.85000.1000
organize / repress0.68330.21670.85000.0000
organize / flee0.40000.10000.80000.0000

Under capitalism there is no pure Nash equilibrium, meaning no pair of choices that neither side wants to change. Instead the two sides keep switching, and the only stable outcome is a mixed one in which workers accept 70% of the time and capital concedes 30% of the time. Under planning, repression fails and flight triggers expropriation, so there is a single stable outcome: workers organize and capital concedes. I checked 243 combinations of the settings. Planning always has a stable outcome in which capital concedes; capitalism has none in 187 of them.

Along the unemployment axis. Under capitalism the game changes character at two points.

  • When u ≤ 1/12 (0.0833), capital flight is a stable outcome. Up to u = 1/20 there are two such outcomes, (accept, flee) and (organize, flee); above it only (organize, flee) remains.
  • When u > 1/12, there is no stable pure outcome. Labor’s average bargaining power falls from 0.2549 at u = 0.10 to 0.2188 at u = 0.50.

Michał Kalecki described this in 1943 as the political limit to full employment. Near full employment the wage takes nearly the whole product, so capital’s best response to organized labor is to leave. Section 9.7 lets the return abroad vary.

6.3 The job guarantee

A job guarantee raises private wages only if the guaranteed job pays better than what workers could get under the reserve army, w_ap > w_cap. Setting the two equal gives the point where that starts:

u_c = β(1 − w_ap) / ((1 − β)(w_ap − s)) = 1/11 (β = 1/5, s = 2/5, g = 4/5)

Below 9.1% unemployment the guarantee does nothing to private wages, because private employers already pay more than the guaranteed job. Above it, the gain rises: +1.4% at 10% unemployment, +5.0% at 12.5% and +14.5% at 20%.

What the data say. Imbert and Papp (2015) find that India’s NREGA, a rural employment guarantee, raised private rural wages by about 5%, while each public job replaced one private job. In a randomized rollout of better NREGA payments, Muralidharan, Niehaus and Sukhtankar (2023) find that 86% of the extra earnings came from outside the program, because private wages and employment both rose. The model gives +5% at 12.5% unemployment, a slack rural labor market, through exactly that channel: the guarantee improves the worker’s fallback.

Verdict: T8 is reproduced above 1/11 unemployment and supported in slack labor markets. At low unemployment the guarantee has no effect in the model, partly because of how the bargaining formula behaves near full employment (§12.1).

6.4 Exploitation as a property relation

John Roemer’s test calls a group of people exploited if they would be better off leaving with their per-head share of society’s capital and working it themselves. Six people hold capital (0, 0, 0, 1, 2, 9), and a job needs 4 units. On all 63 possible groups, the test agrees with a simple rule: a group is exploited when its average capital is below society’s average. When every worker has access to the social means of production, as under a job guarantee with land and job assignment, no group is exploited. Roemer’s thought experiment becomes an institution.

7 Politics (T7, T9, T11, T12)

The economy reaches politics through living standards. When they fall, voters weigh a radical gamble against a moderate sure thing. Networks that hand out jobs shape what voters expect. And the way a government is organized decides whether officials can collude against everyone else. This section builds each of these mechanisms on its own; §8 connects them to the economy. The results are checked by me-games.pal and me-selectorate.pal (7 assertions), with thresholds from me-extremes.pal (§X4, §X8–X9).

7.1 Losses, curvature and the radical coalition (T11)

The choice. Voters choose between a moderate option, a sure gain of +1, and a radical gamble that pays +6 with probability 1/4 and −2 with probability 3/4. The gamble’s expected value is 0, below the moderate option’s. Following Kahneman and Tversky’s prospect theory (1979), voters judge outcomes as gains or losses from where they stand, D, relative to what they consider normal. Losses hurt more than equal gains please, by the loss-aversion factor λ = 9/4 that Tversky and Kahneman (1992) estimated. I use a piecewise quadratic value function so that every calculation stays exact:

v(x) = x − x²/(2K) for x ≥ 0; λ(x + x²/(2K)) for x < 0; K = 10, λ = 9/4

Voters pick the gamble exactly when D is below −5.399. The fascism post names four groups of people, two falling (by 6 and 3) and two rising (by 1 and 2). Weighted by size, 30% of them would choose the gamble. If each group measures itself against an aspiration 3 units above where it stands, 55% would. If every group is rising, as in the Cold War years, none would.

What sets the threshold. The fascism post puts radicalization down to loss aversion. When every possible outcome is a loss (D < −6), loss aversion multiplies both sides of the comparison equally and cancels out, and the condition becomes

−1 + (11 − 2D)/(2K) > 0 if and only if D < 11/2 − K
curvature K10204080
threshold at λ = 9/4−5.399−14.5−34.5−74.5
threshold at λ = 1−4.838−14.5−34.5−74.5
11/2 − K−4.5−14.5−34.5−74.5

This holds exactly for K > 23/2. At K = 10 the threshold, −5.399, lies above −6, so it is not quite 11/2 − K. Raising loss aversion from 1 to 100 moves the threshold by only 0.74. Making the value function flatter (a larger K, which means people’s sensitivity to losses fades less as losses grow) moves it without limit, and a voter with a perfectly straight value function never takes the gamble. So what produces the radical coalition is how people’s sensitivity to losses changes as losses deepen, the convex shape that makes a gamble attractive to those already far behind. Loss aversion matters much less.

What the data say. Funke, Schularick and Trebesch (2016) find that far-right vote shares rise by about 30% after financial crises, across 1870–2014, but not after ordinary recessions. In the model, too, only a deep loss crosses the threshold. Lakner and Milanovic (2016) supply a related fact about who loses: in 1988–2008 the lower-middle class of rich countries saw almost no income growth. That is the group the fascism post describes as falling.

Verdict: T11 is qualified by the model and supported by the data. A radical coalition forms only past a threshold of loss, and the curvature of the value function sets it.

7.2 Patronage (T12)

The model. Two political networks, one left and one right, spend their resources on jobs and on messages. Following the job-creation post, a job ties a member to a network three times as strongly as a message does, and resources follow membership. If the right network is funded by capital (base funding 3 to 1), the best strategy for both networks, whatever the other does, is to spend everything on jobs. If the left creates no jobs while the right does, the right ends up with 0.942 of the membership, against 0.743 if both create jobs.

What the data say. Thachil (2011) shows that the BJP’s service networks in India win the votes of poor people who would otherwise oppose the party’s elite program. Material help ties people more strongly than messages do.

Verdict: T12’s premise is supported, and its conclusion is reproduced in this static setting. Whether patronage becomes a self-reinforcing spiral over time is a question about dynamics, which §8.4 takes up.

7.3 Collusion and the divided government (T9)

The model. K officials share a bribe, or rent, R if they all collude. Any one of them can blow the whistle and collect a reward B, and an audit uncovers the conspiracy with probability P each period. Collusion can last, with each official cooperating as long as everyone else does, only if they value the future enough. Their discount factor δ must be at least

δ*(K) = (1 − R/(KB)) / (1 − P)

If the whistle-blower’s reward equals the rent (B = R), collusion fails for every discount factor once the number of independent officials reaches

K̄ = ⌈1/P⌉

because δ*(K) ≥ 1 exactly when 1 − 1/K ≥ 1 − P. The program confirms this at five audit rates, from 5% (K̄ = 20) to 50% (K̄ = 2).

That gives the planning post’s divided government a design rule: it needs at least as many independently accountable offices as one over the chance of an audit. Fewer offices with more frequent audits work just as well. A single ruling party, whose members cannot collect a reward for reporting each other, can sustain collusion however little they value the future. That is Milovan Djilas’s “new class” (1957), here as the stable outcome of a game.

What the data say. Corporate leniency programs work the same way: they excuse the first member of a cartel who reports it. Miller (2009) finds that the US program, introduced in 1993, caught more cartels and discouraged new ones.

7.4 Political survival (T9)

Collusion is one way to hold power without being accountable. Selectorate theory describes another: a leader who needs only a few supporters can keep them loyal with private rewards.

The model. For the utility function the book uses, √x + √g + √y + √l, the model can be solved in closed form. The share of spending that goes on private rewards is

Wg/M = p / (p + W)

where W is the size of the winning coalition the leader depends on and p is the price of public goods. The book calls this “perhaps the key” result. As W grows, taxes, the private share and the leader’s surplus all fall.

How much the leader keeps depends on how much the coalition values the future (δ). With N = S = 100,000, W = 1,000 and p = 10,000:

δincumbent taxspending Mleader’s surpluscoalition member’s utility
00.561917,117.705.538
0.50.57334,752.212,394.23.481
0.90.5832207.616,949.31.668
0.990.58552.117,155.21.238

A coalition that cares nothing for the future (δ = 0) puts no value on loyalty, so the leader must spend all revenue to stay in power. A very patient coalition (δ close to 1) stays loyal almost for free, and the leader keeps nearly everything. Secure power breeds extraction. The selectorate model cannot tell accountable planning apart from any other majority-rule system, though, because it has no property relations and no division of offices. What makes the proposal distinctive lies outside this model.

Verdict: T9 is derived for collusion, with the design rule K̄ = ⌈ 1/P ⌉. Its selectorate reading is reproduced, but the evidence for selectorate theory is disputed (Clarke and Stone, 2008).

7.5 Quadratic voting and what gets produced (T7)

The model. In quadratic voting (QV; Lalley and Weyl, 2018), each voter has a budget of credits, and casting n votes on one issue costs n² credits. That lets people with strong feelings about one issue express them, at a rising price. Here 90 workers, 5 owners and 5 green voters spread their votes over investment, necessities and luxuries. The tally is (300, 450, 120), so luxuries get 13.8% of the votes. If instead demand is weighted by how much money people have, using the uncapped distribution of §5.2, 78.1% of spending goes on luxuries. In a market, purchasing power decides what gets made, not need.

Verdict: T7 is reproduced. Survey evidence on QV (Quarfoot et al., 2017) is consistent with it, but it is far from a test of QV as a way to plan production.

8 The whole economy (T11–T13)

The posts’ strongest claims are about how the mechanisms interact. Unemployment weakens labor, falling wages push voters into losses, a radical government represses unions, and patronage raises what people expect. This section runs all the mechanisms together, in three versions of the economy. The results are checked by me-regimes.pal (13 assertions), the self-rewriting me-economy.pal, me-loops.pal (5) and me-dialectics.pal (13).

8.1 One period as a chain of equations

Each period is a chain of equations, worked out in order over a record that holds the state of the economy. One equation connects the economy to the game of §6:

rule eq-B : (pe-eq B ?v ?p) => (pe-beta (pe-cs (@ ?v mode)) ?gp) where ?gp <- (pe-gpar ?v (put@ ?p u 0))

In words: each period, labor’s bargaining power is whatever the class-struggle game produces at that period’s unemployment rate. The chain then works out, in order:

  • employment E = min(N, K/κ), where κ is the capital needed per job, rising by μ = 1% a period as work is mechanized;
  • the wage share w, profit Π = (1 − w)E and the profit rate r = Π/K;
  • investment I = s_c Π, or none at all (a capital strike) when the profit rate falls below a minimum, r_min, or when capital’s best move in the game is to flee;
  • inflation and the living standard;
  • the radical vote, measured against a reference point that the right network’s messaging pushes up;
  • the right network’s share of membership;
  • viability Φ = min(economic margin, 2(1/2 − radical vote)), a single number for whether the economy and its politics can carry on.

The three versions differ in their equations, not in their numbers:

mechanismcapitalismCold War (to t = 30)accountable planning
outside optionreserve armyplus insurance at 9/10 of the employed standardjob guarantee, g = 4/5
wagesbargainingfloored to half of productivity growthpublic wage; private firms must beat it
money2% inflation, 10% shock at t = 40–41the same, indexedlabor vouchers
left networkno jobsjobsjobs
repressionradical government halves bargaining powerthe samerights entrenched
capitalaccumulatesaccumulatescapped at θ = 60

The settings come from the model’s own steady-state algebra, not from fitting. Investment just keeps pace when s_c·r = δ + μ, so with s_c = 3/5, δ = 3% and μ = 1% the profit rate needed to keep going is r = 1/15.

8.2 Three versions of the economy

At the baseline settings (Figure 4):

  • Capitalism. Unemployment rises in every period, from 0.100 to 0.299, and the wage share falls in every period.
  • The Cold War. The radical vote is 0 until t = 30. After that the unemployed lose their insurance, and the radical vote equals the unemployment rate.
  • Planning. Unemployment and the radical vote are 0, living standards rise, and Φ stays positive.

Under stress (an inflation shock, loss sensitivity 30 and aspiration messaging 0.40; see §8.4), capitalism elects a radical government that holds office for 58 of the 60 periods. The Cold War version does the same as soon as its concessions end. Planning never has a radical vote.

Figure 4. Planning removes the reserve army and the radical vote; capitalism keeps both
Figure 4. Unemployment at baseline and the radical vote under stress, three regimes (lib/polecon.pal).

Labor’s share. The US Bureau of Labor Statistics reports that labor’s share of nonfarm business income fell from 66.2% in late 1960 to 52.8% in mid-2026, a relative fall of 20.2%. The model’s wage share under capitalism falls 19.9% over 60 periods, from 0.864 to 0.692, as mechanization weakens labor’s fallback. The levels differ, because the measured share counts employer contributions and treats depreciation differently; the match is in the size of the decline.

8.3 Unemployment and mechanization

Why does unemployment rise in every period? As long as there is no crisis and the economy is below full employment, capital and employment are tied together by

s_c r_t = (E_{t+1}/E_t)(1 + μ) − (1 − δ)

Employment holds steady only if μ = s_c·r − δ. Running capitalism at five rates of mechanization shows where that boundary lies:

μu₀u₅₉r₅₉w₅₉μ that holds E constant at r₅₉
00.1000.1100.05000.8500
0.0050.1000.1790.05600.7750.0036
0.0100.1000.2990.05710.6920.0042
0.0150.1000.4610.05170.6270.0010
0.0200.1000.5960.05010.5170.0001

Without mechanization the profit rate settles at δ/s_c = 0.05, and unemployment settles near 11%. With mechanization the profit rate never gets above about 0.057, so the fastest mechanization the economy can absorb is about 0.4% a period. Anything faster makes the reserve army grow forever. The table also shows that faster mechanization first raises the profit rate, by weakening labor, and then lowers it, because fewer workers produce less profit.

What the data say. Here the model fails. US unemployment (FRED, 1948–2026) has no long-run trend; it was 4.2% in September 2026. Barbosa-Filho and Taylor (2006) find the boom-and-squeeze cycles that Richard Goodwin described in US data. Real economies must sit close to the boundary μ ≈ s_c·r − δ, held there by things the model leaves out, such as demand management, the growth of services and shorter working hours. Section 9.6 adds two candidates, credit and mechanization that responds to wages.

8.4 Stress, lock-in and the tipping point (T11–T13)

Under stress (loss sensitivity 30, aspiration messaging 0.40), capitalism elects a radical government at t = 2. Repression halves labor’s bargaining power, and the profit rate jumps from 0.045 to 0.086. Living standards then rise from 0.85 to 2.10 by t = 45, yet the radical vote stays at 1.

The government stays because of the reference point. With the right network holding 85–89% of membership, every group compares itself with a standard 34–36% above its own, so it feels behind however much it gains. This is the job-creation post’s “downward spiral”, made precise.

How much does this depend on the settings? I ran a grid of 27 settings, varying loss sensitivity, the size of the inflation shock and aspiration messaging.

  • Planning never has a radical vote after t = 1.
  • The Cold War never does worse than capitalism.
  • Capitalism elects a radical government in 15 of the 27.
Figure 5. Between aspiration 0.26 and 0.27 a two-period episode becomes a lock-in
Figure 5. Periods of radical government against aspiration messaging (me-extremes.pal §X7).

Where the spiral starts. Figure 5 varies aspiration messaging with the shock held fixed. Below 0.20 there is no radical government. From 0.20 to 0.26 the shock produces a two-period episode. At 0.27 the radical government outlasts the shock, for 10 periods. From 0.28 on it comes earlier and stays longer: 19 periods at 0.28, 39 at 0.30 and 58 of 60 at 0.40. The tipping point is sharp because the lock-in feeds itself: a radical government represses, profits rise, the right network grows on those profits, and aspirations rise with the network. Below the threshold the same shock produces only a protest vote that reverses, which matches what Funke and his coauthors find after ordinary recessions (§7.1).

Verdict: T11 and T12 are reproduced as dynamics above a threshold. T13 is reproduced in all 27 settings. No economy has run the planning proposal, so it cannot be tested against data.

8.5 Feedback loops

Put together, the mechanisms form a causal-loop diagram with 15 variables and 24 arrows, each marked as pushing its target up or down. The diagram has 14 loops: 5 reinforcing (they amplify a change) and 9 balancing (they damp it). Among them are the Goodwin profit squeeze (balancing), accumulation, radicalization and patronage (all reinforcing).

A diagram drawn by hand simply asserts its arrows. Here each arrow X → Y is checked against the equations themselves: raise X a little, freeze every other variable, recompute Y and read off which way it moved. I did this at ten different states of the economy, and 23 of the 24 arrows behave as drawn.

The exception is the arrow from unemployment to bargaining power, which turns positive near full employment. That is the capital-flight outcome of §6.2: where capital’s best answer to organized labor is to leave, more unemployment actually raises labor’s bargaining power. A hand-drawn diagram would have shown this arrow as negative everywhere.

Under planning, 12 arrows disappear: the reserve army, the trade-off between wages and profits, inflation, every route into the radical vote, and repression (Figure 6). One loop is left, accumulation in what remains of the private sector, and the asset cap limits it.

Figure 6. Accountable planning removes 12 of the 24 causal edges and leaves one loop
Figure 6. Capitalism’s causal-loop diagram. Dashed edges vanish under planning (lib/polecon.pal, me-loops.pal §7.3).

8.6 Structural dialectics applied to the model

The structural-dialectics post sets out tests for when a society should move to a new form. I applied them to the model for each period from t = 0 to 59. The diagnoses are s (stasis), I (instability), P (Phase Inversion) and n (not viable):

baseline capitalism ssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss
stress Cold War sssssssssssssssssssssssssssssIPnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn
stress capitalism sPnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn
moderate inflation crisis ssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssPnssssssssssssssssss

Baseline capitalism stays in stasis throughout: rising unemployment alone does not justify a transition. The Cold War shows instability only in its last period, when its concessions end. A crisis opens a window of exactly one period before a radical government closes it, which is what the contradictions post calls foreclosure. Whether a transition would count as a synthesis depends on the reference point the new society inherits, which can make its first period not viable.

9 Finance (T14–T17)

In sections 4 to 8, money appears only as something conserved in trade and as a one-off injection of new money (§5.3). The posts say a good deal more about money, and the earlier version of this evaluation left it out. Four claims stand out.

  • Credit money. The mechanical-materialism post says that when a bank makes a loan, it “does not lend out pre-existing deposits”, and that “New money bids up the price of housing and equities without a corresponding increase in the real output of the economy”.
  • Capital gains. The same post traces the Pareto class, the small group of very large fortunes, to “compounding capital-gains income”, and says the class structure is not something that “could be reformed away with the right policies”.
  • Debt deflation. The accountable-planning post says that “nearly all production is financed by borrowing”, and that falling prices start a spiral: “Falling prices cause insolvency, insolvency causes distress selling, distress selling causes further price declines”. So, it concludes, “The system requires that the purchasing power of money be deliberately eroded as a condition of its own stability”.
  • Debt and desperation. The same post treats economic insecurity as “an existential threat in the same register as mortality”. The first version of this evaluation added, among its limitations: “Increasing debt increases desperation, and therefore the effects of Terror Management Theory.”

These become four new propositions:

propositionpost (quoted)tested in
T14Credit creates money and inflates asset prices, not outputmechanical materialism: “New money bids up the price of housing and equities without a corresponding increase in the real output of the economy”§9.1
T15Compounding capital gains produce the Pareto class, which reform cannot removemechanical materialism: “The Pareto (superthermal) class corresponds to compounding capital-gains income”§9.2
T16Nominal debt makes deflation a self-reinforcing spiral, so the system needs inflation, which cuts real payaccountable planning: “The system requires that the purchasing power of money be deliberately eroded as a condition of its own stability”§9.3–9.4
T17Debt deepens economic desperation and the turn to authoritarian optionsaccountable planning: insecurity is “an existential threat in the same register as mortality”§9.5

Two other gaps in the first version also matter for earlier claims. Mechanization in the model was fixed in advance rather than chosen by firms, which the first version listed as a limitation; that bears on the unemployment failure of §8.3 (§9.6). And capital’s option to leave the country was held at a single fixed return abroad, which bears on the flight threshold of §6.2 (§9.7).

The results in this section are checked by me-finance.pal (7 assertions), me-financialized.pal (12) and the second table of me-evidence.pal (1). The independent cross-check adds 18 checks (§11).

9.1 Credit money and the price of houses (T14)

How banks create money. When a bank makes a loan, it does not hand over money someone else deposited. It credits the borrower’s account with a new deposit, and when the loan is repaid that deposit disappears. The model keeps a ledger of eight loans, payments and repayments, and after every one, the new deposits equal the loans still outstanding.

What credit does to prices. Now suppose buyers who have saved S each bid for a fixed stock of houses, and a bank will lend them a share LTV of the price (the loan-to-value ratio). A buyer can pay at most her savings plus the loan, S + LTV·P, and when buyers compete, the price rises to that limit. So

P = S / (1 − LTV)

Raising LTV from 0 to 0.8 multiplies the price by 5. Raising it to 0.95 multiplies it by 20. Not a single house is built, and nothing else is produced either.

Each sale creates new money, the loan LTV·P, and pays it straight to the person who already owned the house. When the seller spends it, prices have not yet adjusted, so the seller gains exactly Q·D/M in real goods, the first-recipient gain of §5.3, and everyone else loses the same amount between them. At LTV = 0.95, ten sales a period move 190 of the economy’s 1,000 units of output to the sellers.

What the data say. Favara and Imbs (2015) study US bank-branching deregulation in 1994–2005, which let banks lend more for reasons unrelated to the housing market. The extra mortgage credit raised house prices. Only where it was easy to build did the number of houses grow instead. Jordà, Schularick and Taylor (2016) find that across 17 rich economies, mortgages rose from about 30% of bank lending in 1900 to about 60% today, and that nearly all of the financial sector’s growth since 1913 is mortgage lending to households, which “has little to do with the financing of the business sector”.

Verdict: T14 is derived, since the price formula and the transfer are accounting identities, and it is supported by the data.

9.2 Capital gains, resets and the Pareto class (T15)

In §5.2, capital income did more than create a class of large fortunes: all the money ended up with one owner. What that model lacked were the forces that break fortunes up.

The model. I call the simplest exact version a wealth lattice. Picture fortunes sitting on the rungs of a ladder, where each rung is worth twice the one below (levels 2ⁿ). Each period:

  • a fortune moves up a rung (doubles) with probability p, which stands for a capital gain;
  • it moves down a rung (halves) with probability q, which stands for a reset, such as division between two heirs, a bankruptcy or a tax;
  • a fortune on the bottom rung, n = 0, has rejoined the ordinary exponential class and cannot fall further.

Over time the share of fortunes on each rung settles down to π_n = (1 − z)zⁿ, where z = p/q is how often fortunes double compared with how often they halve. The chance that a fortune is at least 2ⁿ is then

P(W ≥ 2^n) = z^n = (2^n)^(−α), α = log2(q/p)

which is a Pareto law, the classic shape of the top of the wealth distribution. The single number α, the Pareto exponent, describes how heavy the tail is: the smaller α, the more the top fortunes dominate.

What happens next depends on whether fortunes are broken up often enough.

  • If resets are frequent enough (z < 1/2, so α > 1), average wealth stays finite and every top share settles at a fixed value. Started with every fortune on the bottom rung, a ladder of 31 rungs reaches the settled distribution to within 10⁻⁶ in 300 periods.
  • If resets are too rare (z ≥ 1/2, so α ≤ 1), average wealth grows without bound, and an ever smaller group ends up with nearly everything. With the ladder capped at rung L and z = 3/5, the top 1% hold 42.3%, 90.7%, 99.8% and 100.0% as L rises from 10 to 80. At z = 2/5, by contrast, their share settles at 32.5%.

The model of §5.2 is the case q = 0: no resets, so the money condenses into one fortune. The asset cap is a ladder with a top rung, so it limits the top share whatever z is.

The top 1%’s share changes quickly with α: 9.5% at α = 2, 17.9% at 1.58, 32.5% at 1.32 and 72.6% at 1.07 (Figure 7).

Figure 7. The top-1% wealth share against the tail exponent on the wealth lattice
Figure 7. The top-1% wealth share on the lattice against the tail exponent, with the Federal Reserve’s 1989 and 2026 shares read on it (me-finance.pal §F2).

What the data say. If I read the Federal Reserve’s figures for the top 1%’s share of wealth on this ladder, they imply α = 1.460 in 1989, when the share was 22.8%, and α = 1.322 in 2026, when it was 32.5%. The 1989 value is close to direct estimates of the US wealth tail: Klass et al. (2006) find 1.49 from the Forbes 400 for 1988–2003, and Vermeulen (2018) finds 1.48–1.55 after correcting for rich households that do not answer surveys. Benhabib and Bisin (2018) report both.

The rise in concentration since 1989 corresponds to a 10.1% rise in how often fortunes double compared with how often they are broken up. That has moved the tail about a third of the way toward α = 1, the point where wealth starts to condense. The ladder treats all fortunes as one Pareto population, so these numbers are a way of reading the data, not a fitted estimate.

Verdict: The first half of T15 is derived. Capital gains set against resets produce a Pareto class, with exponent log₂(q/p).

The second half, that the class cannot be reformed away, is qualified. The class itself is structural: any p > 0 and q > 0 produce a power law. Its size is not. The resets are inheritance rules, bankruptcy law and taxes, and between α = 2 and α = 1.07 the top 1%’s share changes almost eightfold. Reform cannot remove the class, but it decides how big the class is. The condensation that went wrong in §5.2 becomes a threshold, z = 1/2, and real economies sit below it.

9.3 Debt deflation (T16)

The model. Twenty firms each own one unit of an asset and owe debts d_j, spread evenly (a gap of Δ between one firm’s debt and the next) from d_lo to d_hi.

  • A shock σ lowers the asset’s price to 1 − σ.
  • A firm whose debt is larger than the price is insolvent, and it sells its asset.
  • Each forced sale pushes the price down by η.

The model finds how many firms end up selling by repeating the count, firms whose debt exceeds the current price, until it stops changing. It also checks a formula against all 36 cases:

  • if η ≥ Δ, one insolvency brings down every firm;
  • if η < Δ, the sales stop after
m* = ⌈(d_hi − 1 + σ) / (Δ − η)⌉

In plain terms, the spiral feeds itself when one forced sale pushes the price down by more than the gap to the next firm’s debt. Financialization narrows that gap, by crowding firms toward high levels of debt. With η = 0.025:

  • firms whose debts are spread over [0.20, 0.80] (Δ = 0.032) absorb shocks of up to 20% without a single forced sale, and a 25% shock is amplified only 1.8 times;
  • firms crowded into [0.50, 0.95] (Δ = 0.024) all collapse after a 10% shock, which is amplified six times.

What the data say. Irving Fisher (1933) laid out the chain from paying down debt to forced selling, falling prices, falling net worth and bankruptcy. He also stated its paradox: “Each dollar of debt still unpaid becomes a bigger dollar”, so that “the very effort of individuals to lessen their burden of debts increases it” (p. 344, as quoted by Shiller). The model reproduces this mechanism and its threshold. I have not compared it with Fisher’s numbers.

Verdict: The spiral in T16 is derived, with a threshold: it feeds itself only when forced sales move the price by more than the spacing of debts. Section 9.4 tests the second half of T16, the need for inflation, in the full economy.

9.4 Financialized capitalism (T16, T5)

The model. lib/polecon-fin.pal adds a fourth version of the economy to the three in §8. It is capitalism with three financial channels added, each one equation with one setting.

  1. Firms borrow to invest.
    • Firms invest enough, (μ + δ)K, to keep their workforce as each job needs more capital. Banks lend a share lev of whatever their retained profit does not cover.
    • Interest of 5% on firm debt comes out of profit, and the capital strike of §8.1 now looks at the profit rate after interest. So a debt crisis is the same crisis rule as before, reached through interest payments. This is the “Minsky moment”, named after Hyman Minsky, who argued that long booms financed by debt end this way.
    • Debts are fixed in money, so inflation shrinks them in real terms. A crisis writes off the share of debt that the crash destroys, and banks stop lending.
  2. Households borrow to keep up.
    • Employed households borrow half the gap between their aspiration (the reference point of §8.4) and their income after interest.
    • Their debt is capped at one period’s income.
    • In a crisis, lending stops and they must repay a fifth of what they owe.
  3. Debt adds to desperation.
    • Debt payments are due whatever happens, so they come off what a worker can fall back on in the wage bargain. An indebted worker bargains from a weaker position.
    • The share of income going on debt payments, DS, is added to unemployment as a source of insecurity, which strengthens the pull of the right network’s institutions. In the equation of §8.1, the terror-management term 3(1 + U) becomes 3(1 + U + DS).
    • The interest households pay is income for capital, and it funds the right network along with profits.

With both kinds of borrowing switched off, this version reproduces capitalism period for period, and the program checks that it does.

The baseline run (lev = 1; Figure 8).

There are two crises, at t = 7 and t = 52, and each is followed by one period of radical government. Capitalism with the same settings has none.

Unemployment no longer rises every period. It stays flat between the crises, at 0.189–0.190 from t = 15 to t = 51, and jumps at each crisis. After 60 periods it is 0.298, against capitalism’s 0.299. Credit changes the shape of the rise, not its size.

Between the crises the wage share stays within 0.009 of a fixed level, while the profit rate falls every single period, from 0.073 to 0.040. Keeping people employed with borrowed money keeps the rate of exploitation constant, and as each job needs more capital, the profit rate falls. This is exactly the case §4.3 found when it held exploitation constant. There I had to assume it; here the economy produces it. The crisis then restores the profit rate.

Firm debt rises from 6.2% of capital at t = 24 to 19.0% at t = 51, as profits fall. Household debt sits at its ceiling from t = 15 until the inflation shock of t = 40–41 cuts real incomes.

Figure 8. Unemployment in four regimes and firm debt in the financialized runs
Figure 8. Unemployment in four runs, and firm debt relative to capital in the two financialized runs; dots mark crises (me-financialized.pal §F5.7, §F5.1).

One channel at a time. Firm borrowing alone produces crises at t = 5 and 50 but no radical government. Household borrowing alone produces no crisis. Both together produce crises at t = 7 and 52, and each is followed by a radical government.

Where the behavior changes. How far the banks are willing to lend decides whether there is a crisis at all. When banks cover at most three-quarters of the gap (lev ≤ 3/4), there is no crisis within 60 periods, and unemployment ends lower than under capitalism (0.240 at lev = 3/4). The boundary lies between lev = 0.7617 and 0.7622.

Inflation delays the debt crisis but cannot prevent it. The first crisis (t = 6–8) comes from the falling profit rate and happens at every inflation rate I tried. The second comes later as inflation rises:

steady inflation02%4%6%8%10%
second crisist = 4852545759none in 60 periods
real pay cut between settlements, π/(1 + π)02.0%3.8%5.7%7.4%9.1%

Deflation does the opposite. A 10% fall in prices at t = 40–41 raises the living standard of employed workers in debt-free capitalism, from 1.787 to 2.184, because their pay buys more. In the financialized economy the same fall in prices makes debts heavier. It lifts household debt above its ceiling, to 1.235 of income at t = 42, brings the second crisis forward from t = 52 to t = 49, and doubles the number of periods of radical government, from 2 to 4.

What the data say. US household debt rose to 99.1% of GDP in the first quarter of 2008 and has since fallen to 66.6% (first quarter of 2026; BIS data via FRED). That is the model’s pattern of debt rising to a ceiling and then being paid down, although the ceiling in the model is a chosen setting, not an estimate.

Verdict: T16 is reproduced and qualified. The financialized economy needs inflation to delay its debt crises, and the inflation that does so cuts real pay, as the post says. But inflation does not remove the crisis. It pushes the second one back by about one period for each percentage point.

T5 is reproduced in the financialized economy: credit supplies the rule for wages that §4.3 found the falling profit rate needs.

9.5 Debt, desperation and the radical vote (T17)

In §8.4 a shock turned into a radical government only under stress. In the financialized economy every crisis does so, even at the baseline settings. The reason is the credit crunch.

The crunch. In a crisis, banks stop lending and households start repaying, so employed workers’ living standard falls from a level that borrowing had propped up. That propped-up level is also what they had come to measure themselves against. The employed vote radical when their living standard falls below 1 + D*/20 = 0.730 of their aspiration, where D* = −5.399 is the threshold from §7.1.

runcrisisstandard beforestandard at crisischangestandard / aspirationradical
financializedt = 71.0950.851−22.3%0.670yes
financializedt = 522.5862.026−21.7%0.664yes
firm credit onlyt = 50.9350.959+2.5%0.889no
firm credit onlyt = 502.4912.553+2.5%0.871no

Without household debt, the employed are slightly better off at the same crisis. In both runs, the program checks that each crisis produces a radical vote exactly when the ratio falls below 0.730. So a crisis becomes a radical government through the credit crunch, not through lost output: the crash destroys 10% of capital in both runs.

How much households borrow matters. If households borrow an eighth of the gap, neither crisis radicalizes voters. At a quarter or three-eighths, only the second does, after their debt has reached its ceiling. From a half upward, both do.

How much does this depend on the settings? Across the 27 stress settings of §8.4, capitalism elects a radical government in 15, and the financialized economy in all 27. Radical periods add up to 386 under capitalism and 509 with finance. In five settings finance actually shortens radical rule. All five are settings where capitalism is already locked in for 56 periods or more, and there borrowing lets households soften the blow.

The terror-management link. Three new arrows in the causal diagram hold with the expected sign at all ten states I checked: debt payments strengthen the right network (DS → SR), more debt means higher debt payments, and more debt lowers the wage, because the indebted worker bargains from a weaker position. The first link is weak, though. A rise of 0.05 in the debt-payment share raises the network’s share by only 0.001–0.004.

Through these arrows, finance adds two reinforcing loops of four links each:

  • aspiration → household debt → debt payments → right network → aspiration;
  • wage → right network → aspiration → debt → wage.

Firm debt adds a balancing loop, capital → debt → profit rate → investment → capital: debt brings on the crisis that writes it off. The financialized diagram has 36 arrows and 37 loops, and 18 of the loops pass through a financial variable (7 reinforcing, 11 balancing).

Two arrows fail their checks. The arrow from unemployment to bargaining power fails, as it did in §8.5. And the arrow from inflation to household debt, which I expected to be negative because inflation shrinks debt, turns out positive at the first state checked, where households owe little. There, inflation cuts real pay, and households borrow to make up the difference. Which effect wins depends on how much they already owe.

What the data say.

  • Funke, Schularick and Trebesch (2016) find that far-right vote shares rise by about 30% after financial crises but not after ordinary recessions. The crunch in the model produces the same pattern.
  • Mian, Sufi and Trebbi (2014) find that countries become more politically polarized and fragmented after financial crises.
  • Mian, Rao and Sufi (2013) find that in the 2006–09 housing collapse, spending responded most to lost wealth in ZIP codes where households were poorer and more indebted, and spent more of each dollar of housing wealth.
  • Jordà, Schularick and Taylor (2013) find that recessions with a financial crisis cost more output. Three years after the peak, real GDP per person is 2.5% below it after a financial crisis, and 2.0% above it after a normal recession. The model does not reproduce this: its crises destroy the same capital whether or not households are in debt.

Verdict: T17 is reproduced, and the data support its political pattern. In the model, debt drives people to radical politics mainly through the fall from a living standard that borrowing had inflated, and only weakly through the burden of debt payments. That adds to the finding of §7.1: financial crises cross the threshold of loss because credit has raised the standard people compare themselves with, and the crunch then takes it away.

9.6 Two possible fixes for rising unemployment

Section 8.3 found the model’s clearest failure against the data: unemployment rises without limit, while US unemployment has no trend. Two mechanisms the first version left out could hold it down. Credit is one (§9.4).

The other is the loop that §4.3 closed only on paper: firms mechanize when labor is expensive and hold back when it is cheap. I let capital per job rise at

μ_t = μ · max(0, w_t − w_s) / (w_m − w_s)

So mechanization runs at the full 1% a period when the wage share is at its starting level, w_m = 0.864, and stops at w_s = 0.765, a wage share lower by 1.129, the switch ratio found in §4.3.

runu₀u₁₅u₃₀u₄₅u₅₉wage share, 60 periodsr₅₉crises
capitalism0.1000.1680.2050.2490.299−19.9%0.0571none
capitalism, induced0.1000.1410.1490.1560.161−8.4%0.0538none
financialized0.1000.1900.1890.1890.298−21.7%0.0494t = 7, 52
financialized, induced0.1000.1490.1400.1400.140−7.2%0.0477t = 7

Wage-driven mechanization stops the rise. After t = 30, unemployment rises by less than 0.001 a period. With credit as well, it stays at 0.140 in every period from t = 30, after a single crisis. The switch share w_s sets where unemployment levels off: at 0.187 when w_s = 0.70, and at 0.117 when w_s = 0.84.

But the fix costs the model its best match with the data. Labor’s share now falls only 8.4% (7.2% with credit), against 20.2% in the data. Across the different switch shares, the less unemployment rises, the less labor’s share falls: from −11.2% when unemployment ends at 0.187, down to −2.7% when it ends at 0.117.

The reason is that in this model, labor’s share depends on unemployment, and debt (§9.4) shifts it by only a point or two. So the earlier match in §8.2, a fall of 19.9% against 20.2% in the data, is the same fact as the unemployment failure. The US combination, labor’s share down by a fifth with no rise in unemployment, needs labor’s bargaining power to fall at any given level of unemployment, and neither fix provides that.

9.7 Capital mobility and Kalecki’s threshold (T8)

Capital’s freedom to move abroad is one candidate for that fall. In §6.2 the return abroad, r_ext, was fixed at 10%. Moving abroad becomes one of capital’s best options when the wage bargained against the reserve army reaches 1 − ρ − r_ext. For returns between 5% and 40%, that means

u ≤ u_f = β_l (ρ + r_ext) / ((1 − β_l)(1 − ρ − r_ext − s))

The game and the formula agree at all seven returns I tested. (At a return of zero the formula does not apply: flight is then a best option only at full employment.)

return abroad5%10%15%20%25%30%40%
flight up to unemployment u_f5.0%8.3%12.5%17.9%25.0%35.0%75.0%

From r_ext = 43%, flight is a best option at every level of unemployment. So easier movement of capital raises the unemployment rate below which capital leaves. It also lowers, point for point, the highest wage share at which capital stays and invests at home: from 0.85 to 0.80 as r_ext rises from 10% to 15%.

What the data say. Furceri, Loungani and Ostry (2019) find that when countries open their capital accounts, labor’s share falls by about 4.5% over the following years, most in industries that rely on outside finance.

The model’s version of this is cruder. When the game has no stable pure outcome, the return abroad does not enter the mixed one, so openness moves the flight threshold but not the bargained wage. On its own it cannot explain the combination described in §9.6.

Under planning, an attempt to flee triggers expropriation, so capital mobility leaves the job guarantee of T8 untouched. Under capitalism, Kalecki’s political limit to full employment moves with financial openness.

10 Assessment

10.1 The scorecard

The table collects the verdicts of sections 4 to 9.

propositionmodeldatalimit or condition§
T1value conserved in exchangederivednot directly testableholds for any transitive exchange table, fails for any intransitive one4.1
T2values predict pricesderived, deviation growing in rsupported (r ≈ 0.94–0.99)deviations 3–11× too small in a 3–4-sector model4.2
T3exponential lower class, Pareto upper classlower class derived; upper class qualified, and derived once fortunes can be broken up (§9.2)lower class supported (Gini 0.5); upper class matched by the lattice reading (α = 1.46 vs 1.48–1.55)condensation without resets (98% to one owner), a Pareto tail with them (z < 1/2)5.1–5.2, 9.2
T4money creation redistributesderived (zero-sum; first recipients gain Q·D/M)supported (BIS)a proportional injection spent after prices adjust redistributes nothing5.3
T5falling profit ratequalified: needs a wage rule or slowing demography; reproduced under financialization (§9.4)supported as a long-run trend (Maito, Basu)floor −(1 − w)(g + δ) below n* = −0.0248, with slow convergence there4.3, 8.3
T6planning converges fastderived (18 passes)consistent with the post’s worked examplespeed set by the spectral radius of A4.1
T7QV redirects production toward needreproducedweakly supported (survey QV)none found7.5
T8job guarantee breaks employer powerreproduced above u_c = 1/11supported in slack markets (NREGA)inert below 9.1% unemployment; capital flight up to u_f, which rises with the return abroad6.1–6.3, 9.7
T9divided government cannot conspirederived: K̄ = ⌈ 1/P ⌉plausible (leniency programs); selectorate evidence contesteda single party sustains collusion at every δ7.3–7.4
T10vouchers and caps prevent accumulationderived (non-interference; bounded owners’ share)no test availablethe cap bounds the last reinforcing loop5.2–5.3, 8.5
T11losses and inflation drive radicalismqualified: requires D < −5.4, a curvature effectsupported and qualified (crises, not ordinary recessions)threshold 11/2 − K in deep losses; tipping point at aspiration 0.26–0.277.1, 8.2, 8.4
T12patronage spiralreproducedpremise supported (Thachil)a spiral only above a threshold; below it the protest vote reverses7.2, 8.4
T13planning defuses authoritarianismreproduced in all 27 stress settingsno test availablean inherited reference point can make the successor’s first period non-viable8.4–8.6
T14credit inflates asset prices, not outputderived (P = S/(1 − LTV); the sellers gain Q·D/M)supported (Favara and Imbs; mortgages 30% → 60% of bank lending)none: accounting identities9.1
T15capital gains make the Pareto class, which reform cannot removederived (α = log₂(q/p)); “cannot be reformed away” qualifiedsupported (lattice reading 1.46 in 1989; direct estimates 1.48–1.55)condensation iff 2p ≥ q; the exponent is set by resets, which are policy9.2
T16debt deflation; the system needs inflationspiral derived with a threshold; the need for inflation reproduced as postponementsupported (Fisher 1933)complete spiral iff η ≥ Δ; second crisis at t = 48 → 59 for π = 0 → 8%9.3–9.4
T17debt deepens desperation and radicalismreproduced (2 of 2 crises radical with household credit, 0 of 2 without; 27 of 27 stress settings)supported (Funke et al.; Mian, Sufi and Trebbi; Mian, Rao and Sufi)standard/aspiration < 0.730 at the crunch; deeper output losses not reproduced9.5

10.2 The data at a glance

examples/me-evidence.pal prints the model’s figures next to the data, with the financial comparisons in a second table (§EV2):

§EV THE MODEL AGAINST EMPIRICAL DATA
quantity data model
wage-curve elasticity at u = 5% / 10% -0.10 -0.093 / -0.148
... unemployment at which the model gives -0.10: 0.0554
labor share, relative change -20.2% -19.9% (60 periods)
... levels: data 66.2% -> 52.8%; model 0.864 -> 0.692
price-value MAWD 9.2% E3 at r*: 0.8%; CE Table 10.1: 3.1%
job-guarantee wage effect +5.0% +1.4% / +8.4% / +14.5% at u = 10/15/20%
... no effect below u_c = 1/11; +5% at u = 0.1250
Gini of the exponential (lower) class 0.500 0.524 (geometric law, T = 10)
loss aversion lambda 2.25 2.25 (input; the threshold moves by 0.18 from lambda = 2 to 10, me-extremes §X4)
§EV2 FINANCE: THE MODEL AGAINST EMPIRICAL DATA
quantity data model
Pareto exponent of US wealth 1.49 1.460 (the lattice reading of the 1989 top-1% share)
... top-1% share 22.8% -> 32.5% (1989 -> 2026): alpha 1.460 -> 1.322; condensation at 1
far-right vote after financial crises +30.0% radical government after 2 of 2 crunches with household debt, 0 of 2 without
... the employed standard in the crunch: -22.3% / -21.7% with household debt; +2.5% without
labor share, relative change -20.2% financialized -21.7%; induced mechanization -8.4% (u_59 0.161)
capital-account opening, labor share -4.5% wage-share ceiling 1 - rho - r_ext: -5.9% (r_ext 10% -> 15%)

10.3 Five patterns

  1. The core holds. Conservation, the trade-off between wages and profits, the reserve army’s pull on wages and the exponential lower class all follow from the rules.
  2. Unconditional claims turn out to have conditions. The radical vote needs D < −5.4, the job guarantee needs u > 1/11, and a falling profit rate needs μ > s_c·r − δ or n < n*. Where data exist, they agree with the conditions: radicalization follows financial crises and not ordinary recessions, and the job guarantee’s effect on wages shows up in slack labor markets.
  3. The misses are about size, not direction. In the first version, three sizes were wrong. Prices stray from values too little, wealth concentrates too much, and unemployment rises without limit. In each case the model pointed the right way and something was missing: industry detail, the forces that keep wealth to a power law, and demand. Section 9 supplies two of the missing pieces. Breaking up fortunes turns condensation into a Pareto tail, and reading the 1989 top-1% share that way gives an exponent of 1.46, close to the measured 1.48–1.55. Wage-driven mechanization stops unemployment rising, but it shows that the labor-share match depended on that rise.
  4. Finance strengthens the political mechanisms. Every financial crisis in the model becomes a radical government, through the credit crunch that takes away a living standard borrowing had propped up. That matches what Funke and his coauthors find: radicalization after financial crises, not after ordinary recessions.
  5. Some claims are beyond the data. In the model, vouchers, the asset cap and a divided government remove the mechanisms the posts blame. No economy has tried them, so whether they would work as modeled cannot be tested.

11 Checking and reproducing the results

Every result is checked twice: by the assertions in the program that computes it, and by a separate Python program that recomputes every table from scratch and compares the text character for character.

All you need is a Rust toolchain (cargo) and Python 3:

cargo build --release
cargo test --release # 44 unit tests, among them exact arithmetic, memo, trace
./verify-materialist.sh # 15 checks, about 6 minutes; exit status 0 iff all pass
# individual programs (--dry-run: never write files)
./target/release/palimpsest examples/me-tour.pal --trace 22
./target/release/palimpsest examples/me-value.pal --dry-run # 7 s, 17 assertions
./target/release/palimpsest examples/me-classical.pal --dry-run # 7 s, 8 assertions
./target/release/palimpsest examples/me-distribution.pal --dry-run # 76 s, 18 assertions
./target/release/palimpsest examples/me-games.pal --dry-run # 8 s, 20 assertions
./target/release/palimpsest examples/me-selectorate.pal --dry-run # 9 s, 7 assertions
./target/release/palimpsest examples/me-regimes.pal --dry-run # 84 s, 13 assertions
./target/release/palimpsest examples/me-loops.pal --dry-run # 16 s, 5 assertions
./target/release/palimpsest examples/me-dialectics.pal --dry-run # 5 s, 13 assertions
./target/release/palimpsest examples/me-extremes.pal --dry-run # 11 s, 6 assertions
./target/release/palimpsest examples/me-evidence.pal --dry-run # 2 s, 4 assertions
./target/release/palimpsest examples/me-finance.pal --dry-run # 19 s, 7 assertions
./target/release/palimpsest examples/me-financialized.pal --dry-run # 56 s, 12 assertions
# the self-rewriting economy: run on a copy; six runs rewrite it, the seventh is a fixed point
cp examples/me-economy.pal /tmp/e.pal && sed -i 's#import "../lib/#import "#' /tmp/e.pal
for i in 1 2 3 4 5 6 7; do PALIMPSEST_LIB=$PWD/lib ./target/release/palimpsest /tmp/e.pal | grep -E 'WROTE|FIXED POINT'; done
python3 crosscheck/materialist_crosscheck.py # 80 independent checks

The same programs run, more slowly, in the Palimpsest playground, with the same output and step counts.

Two implementations that share a specification but no code catch programming mistakes: a period off by one, a wrong rounding, a sign flipped in a probe, a payoff copied wrongly. They cannot catch a mistake in the specification itself. That is what the comparisons with data are for.

12 Limitations

12.1 The model

  • It formalizes; it does not estimate. The settings come from the model’s own steady-state algebra or from the posts. A match without fitting is evidence that a mechanism works, not evidence that the model is calibrated.
  • The bargaining formula lets labor’s share approach 1 at full employment. That drives capital flight below 1/12 unemployment (§6.2) and the job guarantee’s lack of effect below 1/11 (§6.3). A formula with a ceiling set by productivity, or a floor from efficiency wages, would move both thresholds.
  • Mechanization is fixed in advance in the three versions of §8. Capital per job grows at a constant rate μ. Section 9.6 lets firms choose it, as an option; unemployment then stops rising, but the labor-share match goes.
  • There is no demand side. Output is whatever the employed produce. Credit (§9.4) pays for investment and consumption, and debt now adds to desperation and the terror-management link, but nothing in the model captures a crisis of unsold goods or government spending.
  • The financial settings are round numbers, not derived values. They are the interest rate (5%), how much of the gap banks lend (lev = 1), how much households borrow (half the gap), the debt ceiling (one period’s income) and the repayment in a crunch (a fifth). For each one that changes an outcome, §9 shows a range of values and the point where the outcome changes.
  • The financial model is partial. Households never default, the unemployed carry no debt, and the interest rate never changes. House prices (§9.1) and the wealth ladder (§9.2) are not part of the full economy. Crises destroy the same capital with or without debt, so the model cannot reproduce the larger output losses of financial recessions.
  • The wealth ladder treats everyone as one population. Reading the top-1% shares as Pareto exponents assumes all fortunes belong to one Pareto distribution. The resulting numbers are a reading of the data, not an estimate.
  • The shape of the value function is my choice. The piecewise quadratic form keeps everything exact, but it is only valid for losses smaller than K, and K sets the radical threshold (§7.1).
  • The simulations are small. They have 20 to 100 agents. The exact results of §5.1 are what they approximate.
  • Some inputs are reconstructions. These are the planning table, two pairs of priors and likelihoods in the dialectics examples, the intermediate population figures, and my encoding of Classical Econophysics Table 10.1.

12.2 The comparison with data

  • Most of the data are from the United States. The labor share, wage curve and distribution data are US series, and the evidence on profit rates and politics comes mainly from rich democracies. The posts’ claims are general.
  • The measures do not line up exactly. The measured labor share includes employer contributions and treats depreciation and self-employment differently from the model’s share of value added.
  • A match does not prove the mechanism. That radical voting follows financial crises fits the model’s threshold, but it does not show that voters reason the way prospect theory says.
  • Accountable planning cannot be tested. No economy has run it, so §8 describes what its rules imply, not evidence that it works.

12.3 What the model leaves out

  • international trade and unequal exchange (capital mobility enters only through the return abroad, §9.7)
  • the party-state, beyond its collusion and selectorate readings
  • how firms form (Wright’s social-architecture model, Classical Econophysics, ch. 13)
  • divisions of the working class by gender and race

13 Conclusion

The posts argue from conservation, through class relations, to politics, and the model follows the same chain. Its first links hold directly. Value is conserved in exchange, conservation fixes the exponential distribution of money, wages and profits trade off exactly, and the reserve army holds wages down with the sensitivity the data show.

The later links hold too, but each one only past a threshold that the model locates. The profit rate falls if something fixes the wage or population growth slows. The job guarantee raises private wages only above 9.1% unemployment. Radical politics needs a loss deep enough to cross a threshold set by the curvature of the value function, and patronage locks in only above a sharp level of aspiration messaging. Where there are data, they agree: radicalization follows financial crises and not ordinary recessions, and the job guarantee’s effect on wages appears where labor markets are slack.

The model’s failures are useful too. Prices stray from values more than three sectors allow, wealth concentrates less than the simple model predicts, and unemployment has no trend where the model’s rises. Each failure points to something the posts leave out and real economies supply.

The financial claims follow the same pattern. Credit inflates house prices without adding output. Capital gains create a Pareto class whose size depends on how often fortunes are broken up. Forced selling becomes a spiral only past a threshold. Inflation delays debt crises but cannot prevent the first one. And the link from insecurity to authoritarian politics runs most strongly through the credit crunch, which turns a financial crisis into a radical government by taking away a living standard that borrowing had propped up. Letting firms choose when to mechanize stops unemployment rising, but it also shows that the decline in labor’s share needs a cause this model does not contain.

Because every causal claim here is a rewrite rule, every arrow in the causal diagram can be checked against the same equations that run the simulation, and thresholds can be pinned down with formulas. Within the model, planning removes the mechanisms the posts blame. Real economies still contain things this model leaves out (§12.3), and whether planning would remove those mechanisms in a real economy is a question no data can yet answer.

References

Reference works

  • Bueno de Mesquita, B., Smith, A., Siverson, R. M., and Morrow, J. D. (2003). The Logic of Political Survival. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Ch. 3 and its appendix.
  • Cockshott, W. P. (2019). How the World Works: The Story of Human Labor from Prehistory to the Modern Day. New York: Monthly Review Press. §5.4.8, §5.9.
  • Cockshott, W. P., Cottrell, A. F., Michaelson, G. J., Wright, I. P., and Yakovenko, V. M. (2009). Classical Econophysics. London: Routledge. Ch. 8, §10.4 (Tables 10.1–10.3), ch. 13, §14.3.

Posts evaluated here: https://snapshotsofthelabyrinth.photo.blog/2026/03/21/materialist-economics-part-1-mechanical-materialism/, https://snapshotsofthelabyrinth.photo.blog/2026/03/21/materialist-economics-part-3-accountable-planning/, https://snapshotsofthelabyrinth.photo.blog/2026/03/21/materialist-economics-part-4-objections-and-responses/, https://snapshotsofthelabyrinth.photo.blog/2026/03/15/philosophies-of-contradiction-marx-contra-buddha/, https://snapshotsofthelabyrinth.photo.blog/2026/09/12/structural-dialectics/, https://snapshotsofthelabyrinth.photo.blog/2026/08/24/contemporary-fascism-is-an-outgrowth-of-capitalism/, https://snapshotsofthelabyrinth.photo.blog/2026/05/30/why-leftists-must-focus-on-job-creation/.

Theory

  • Bouchaud, J.-P., and Mézard, M. (2000). Wealth condensation in a simple model of economy. Physica A, 282, 536–545.
  • Colletti, L. (1975). Marxism and the dialectic. New Left Review, I/93, 3–29.
  • Djilas, M. (1957). The New Class. New York: Praeger.
  • Drăgulescu, A., and Yakovenko, V. M. (2000). Statistical mechanics of money. European Physical Journal B, 17, 723–729.
  • Fisher, I. (1933). The debt-deflation theory of great depressions. Econometrica, 1(4), 337–357.
  • Goodwin, R. M. (1967). A growth cycle. In C. H. Feinstein (ed.), Socialism, Capitalism and Economic Growth, 54–58. Cambridge University Press.
  • Kahneman, D., and Tversky, A. (1979). Prospect theory. Econometrica, 47(2), 263–291.
  • Kalecki, M. (1943). Political aspects of full employment. Political Quarterly, 14(4), 322–330.
  • Lalley, S. P., and Weyl, E. G. (2018). Quadratic voting. AEA Papers and Proceedings, 108, 33–37.
  • Minsky, H. P. (1986). Stabilizing an Unstable Economy. New Haven: Yale University Press.
  • Morishima, M. (1973). Marx’s Economics. Cambridge University Press.
  • Nash, J. F. (1950). The bargaining problem. Econometrica, 18(2), 155–162.
  • Okishio, N. (1961). Technical changes and the rate of profit. Kobe University Economic Review, 7, 85–99.
  • Roemer, J. E. (1982). A General Theory of Exploitation and Class. Harvard University Press.

Empirical sources

  • Barbosa-Filho, N. H., and Taylor, L. (2006). Distributive and demand cycles in the US economy: A structuralist Goodwin model. Metroeconomica, 57(3), 389–411.
  • Basu, D. (2022). World profit rates, 1960–2019. UMass Amherst Economics Working Paper 318.
  • Benhabib, J., and Bisin, A. (2018). Skewed wealth distributions: Theory and empirics. Journal of Economic Literature, 56(4), 1261–1291.
  • Blanchflower, D. G., and Oswald, A. J. (2005). The wage curve reloaded. NBER Working Paper 11338 / IZA DP 1665.
  • Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Labor share at its lowest level, 52.8 percent, in second quarter 2026. The Economics Daily, 15 September 2026.
  • Clarke, K. A., and Stone, R. W. (2008). Democracy and the logic of political survival. American Political Science Review, 102(3), 387–392.
  • Cockshott, W. P., and Cottrell, A. (1997). Labor-time versus alternative value bases: A research note. Cambridge Journal of Economics, 21(4), 545–549.
  • Domanski, D., Scatigna, M., and Zabai, A. (2016). Wealth inequality and monetary policy. BIS Quarterly Review, March, 45–64.
  • Favara, G., and Imbs, J. (2015). Credit supply and the price of housing. American Economic Review, 105(3), 958–992.
  • Federal Reserve Board (2026). Distributional Financial Accounts: share of net worth held by the top 1%, Q2 2026 (FRED series WFRBST01134).
  • Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis (2026). Unemployment rate, UNRATE, 1948–2026.
  • Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis (2026). Household debt to GDP for the United States, HDTGPDUSQ163N (BIS data).
  • Funke, M., Schularick, M., and Trebesch, C. (2016). Going to extremes: Politics after financial crises, 1870–2014. European Economic Review, 88, 227–260.
  • Furceri, D., Loungani, P., and Ostry, J. D. (2019). The aggregate and distributional effects of financial globalization: Evidence from macro and sectoral data. CEPR Discussion Paper 14001.
  • Imbert, C., and Papp, J. (2015). Labor market effects of social programs: Evidence from India’s employment guarantee. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 7(2), 233–263.
  • Işıkara, G., and Mokre, P. (2022). Price-value deviations and the labor theory of value: Evidence from 42 countries, 2000–2017. Review of Political Economy, 34(1), 165–180.
  • Jordà, Ò., Schularick, M., and Taylor, A. M. (2013). When credit bites back. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 45(s2), 3–28.
  • Jordà, Ò., Schularick, M., and Taylor, A. M. (2016). The great mortgaging: Housing finance, crises and business cycles. Economic Policy, 31(85), 107–152.
  • Klass, O. S., Biham, O., Levy, M., Malcai, O., and Solomon, S. (2006). The Forbes 400 and the Pareto wealth distribution. Economics Letters, 90(2), 290–295. As reported in Benhabib and Bisin (2018).
  • Lakner, C., and Milanovic, B. (2016). Global income distribution: From the fall of the Berlin Wall to the Great Recession. World Bank Economic Review, 30(2), 203–232.
  • Ludwig, D., and Yakovenko, V. M. (2022). Physics-inspired analysis of the two-class income distribution in the USA in 1983–2018. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A, 380, 20210162.
  • Maito, E. E. (2014). The historical transience of capital: The downward trend in the rate of profit since XIX century. MPRA Paper 55894.
  • Mian, A., Rao, K., and Sufi, A. (2013). Household balance sheets, consumption, and the economic slump. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 128(4), 1687–1726.
  • Mian, A., Sufi, A., and Trebbi, F. (2014). Resolving debt overhang: Political constraints in the aftermath of financial crises. American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics, 6(2), 1–28.
  • Miller, N. H. (2009). Strategic leniency and cartel enforcement. American Economic Review, 99(3), 750–768.
  • Muralidharan, K., Niehaus, P., and Sukhtankar, S. (2023). General equilibrium effects of (improving) public employment programs: Experimental evidence from India. Econometrica, 91(4), 1261–1295.
  • Quarfoot, D., von Kohorn, D., Slavin, K., Sutherland, R., Goldstein, D., and Konar, E. (2017). Quadratic voting in the wild: Real people, real votes. Public Choice, 172, 283–303.
  • Shaikh, A. (1998). The empirical strength of the labor theory of value. In R. Bellofiore (ed.), Marxian Economics: A Reappraisal, vol. 2. Macmillan. As reported in Classical Econophysics, Table 10.2.
  • Shiller, R. J. (2011). Irving Fisher, debt deflation and crises. Cowles Foundation Discussion Paper 1817.
  • Thachil, T. (2011). Embedded mobilization: Nonstate service provision as electoral strategy in India. World Politics, 63(3), 434–469.
  • Tversky, A., and Kahneman, D. (1992). Advances in prospect theory: Cumulative representation of uncertainty. Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 5(4), 297–323.
  • Vermeulen, P. (2018). How fat is the top tail of the wealth distribution? Review of Income and Wealth, 64(2), 357–387. As reported in Benhabib and Bisin (2018).
  • Zachariah, D. (2006). Labour value and equalisation of profit rates. Indian Development Review, 4(1), 1–21. As reported in Classical Econophysics, Table 10.3.

Sources consulted online

Appendix A: Palimpsest at a glance

#lang palimpsest
#fuel N // step budget (default 100,000)
#mode rewriting-as-running | rewrite-then-run
#caps { rewrite: [self] } // capability for self-modification
#rebind main // later commands see the rewritten main
#memo // normal-form memo and strict-argument cache
import "path.pal" // merge a library's rules and strategies (transitive, cycle-safe)
rule NAME : LHS => RHS where ?v <- EXPR, GUARD, ...
transition NAME : LHS => RHS // usable only by name from a strategy
strategy NAME = STRATEGY // id fail prim rules s1;s2 s1+s2 try repeat oncetd outermost innermost ...
main = TERM
run STRATEGY | show TERM with S | display TERM with S | assert TERM with S
let $NAME = TERM with S
rewrite self with S | rewrite file "p" with S
  • Pattern variables. ?x matches one term, ?xs... a sequence, and !x is strict (normalize first).
  • Numbers. Integers of any size and rationals n/d, with q/ num den floor ceil round-to expt isqrt decimal.
  • Records. (rec (k v) ...) with @ set@ put@ add@ has@ del@ keys@ sum@.
  • Other primitives. Strings: cat str sym padl padr explode implode. The deterministic hash: rng. Reflection: matches? match-witness.
  • Command-line flags. --dry-run (never write), --fuel N, --stats (rewrite profile), --memo and --trace N. The subcommand palimpsest undo FILE restores the last self-rewrite.

Appendix B: Files of the study

filerolesection
lib/linalg.palexact vectors and matrices, Hawkins–Simon, contractive iterations, strict combinatorsthroughout
lib/value.palvalues, plans, exploitation, certified profit rate, FMT, GCET, frontier, MAWD, Okishio, skilled labour§4
lib/longrun.palthe long-run attractor and its floor; CE Table 10.1§4.1, §4.3
lib/econophysics.palmultiplicities, random exchange, two classes, asset cap, Cantillon, vouchers§5
lib/classgames.palbargaining, the class-struggle game, Roemer, collusion, QV, prospect theory, patronage§6, §7
lib/selectorate.palthe selectorate equilibrium with certified square roots§7.4
lib/polecon.palthe integrated economy, its causal-loop diagram and probes§8.1–8.5
lib/finance.palcredit money and a fixed stock, the wealth lattice, the debt-deflation cascade§9.1–9.3
lib/polecon-fin.palthe financialized regime and induced mechanization, on the chain of polecon.pal§9.4–9.6
lib/cld.pal, lib/dialectics.pal, lib/report.palloop enumeration, Structural Dialectics, text reports§8.5–8.6
examples/me-tour.palone feedback loop, traced (2 assertions)§3.3
examples/me-value.palvalue, planning, prices, profit (17)§4
examples/me-classical.palthe long run, the accumulation identity, CE Table 10.1 (8)§4.1, §4.3, §8.3
examples/me-distribution.palthe distribution of money (18)§5
examples/me-games.palbargaining, class struggle, Roemer, collusion, QV, prospect theory, patronage (20)§6, §7
examples/me-selectorate.palpolitical survival (7)§7.4
examples/me-economy.palthe self-rewriting economy (an invariant assertion every run)§8.1
examples/me-regimes.paltrajectories, stress, the 27-setting grid (13)§8.2–8.4
examples/me-loops.palcycles, edge probes, what planning removes (5)§8.5
examples/me-dialectics.palStructural Dialectics (13)§8.6
examples/me-extremes.pallimits, thresholds and inflection points (6)§4.2–4.3, §6.1–6.2, §7.1, §7.3–7.4, §8.3–8.4
examples/me-evidence.palthe model against cited data (4)§§4–9, §10.2
examples/me-finance.palcredit money, the wealth lattice, debt deflation, capital mobility (7)§9.1–9.3, §9.7
examples/me-financialized.palthe financialized economy: channels, crunch, thresholds, stress grid, remedies, edges and loops (12)§9.4–9.6
crosscheck/materialist_crosscheck.pyindependent Python implementation (80 checks)§11
verify-materialist.shruns all of the above (15 checks)§11

A Semilattice Characterization of Convergent Local Self-Configuration

Draft 3: Changes Draft 2 on the status of the identity element, the CRDT comparison, the constant-operation example and one interpretation of the Telic Principle.

Draft 2: Corrects Draft 1 on the scope of the conclusion and the constant-operation example. Slightly fuller explanations.

Draft 1: Hopefully gets the basic idea across.


The Cognitive-Theoretic Model of the Universe (CTMU) models reality’s self-configuration through a two-stage process called telic recursion, wherein global generalized utility is maximized while local operators (telors) maximize local utility functions independently (Langan 2002). When the domains of two telors overlap, a single outcome must obtain, but Langan’s formulation does not specify an algebraic mechanism for reconciling the two contributions at the shared boundary. This paper models overlap resolution as a term rewriting system: contributions fold into a boundary state via a binary operation ⊔, initialized at an empty boundary state e. Within this model, and given that e is an identity, terminal states are invariant across all arrival orders and duplicate deliveries if and only if ⊔ is commutative, associative, and idempotent; that is, if and only if (S, ⊔, e) is a bounded semilattice. Order invariance is equivalent to commutativity and associativity. Invariance under duplicate delivery is then equivalent to idempotence. We verify these properties on finite Cayley tables and show that the same conditions underlie state-based Conflict-free Replicated Data Types (CRDTs).

1. Introduction

1.1 Overview

Consider a distributed system that configures state locally without central synchronization: autonomous processes update adjacent regions that periodically intersect. If each process updates state solely according to local utility without constraints on boundary combination rules, overlapping regions yield divergent states.

Convergence requires restricting the combination rule. If local processes resolve overlaps using an operation invariant to input sequence (commutativity), invariant to grouping (associativity), insensitive to repeated inputs (idempotence), and equipped with an empty boundary state acting as identity, boundary convergence holds across network delays, interleavings, and duplicate transmissions. These properties define a bounded semilattice. Within the operational model of Section 3, which defines the empty boundary state as an identity, commutativity, associativity, and idempotence are both necessary and sufficient.

1.2 Contributions

  1. A term rewriting model of local overlap resolution parameterized by a binary combination operation.
  2. A proof that, given an identity element, boundary derivations converge across all permutations and duplications of local inputs if and only if the combination operation is commutative, associative, and idempotent (a bounded semilattice).
  3. Counterexamples demonstrating the independence of commutativity, associativity, and idempotence, along with proof that an identity element is not implied by the other three axioms.
  4. Executable test cases verifying these properties on finite Cayley tables, and an implementation showing that additive totals converge when each contribution carries an identifier.
  5. An analysis mapping these conditions to the CTMU’s Telic Principle and to the homogeneity of SCSPL syntax.

2. Preliminaries

2.1 Terms and Rewriting

Let Σ be a set of function symbols and V a set of variables. A term is a variable, constant, or function symbol applied to terms. A rewrite rule is an ordered pair ℓ → r. A set of rewrite rules forms a rewriting system. A term s rewrites to t (s → t) if s matches pattern ℓ under substitution σ and t substitutes the matched subterm with σ(r). We evaluate ground terms over finite carrier sets.

Let L(D) denote the set of finite lists over carrier set D. A boundary rewriting system is permutation-confluent if derivations from sequences L1, L2 ∈ L(D) reach the same normal form whenever L1 and L2 are multiset-equivalent. The system is set-confluent if L1 and L2 reach the same terminal state whenever they contain the same underlying set of distinct elements.

Because each list reduces deterministically one contribution at a time, the system is confluent in the standard rewriting sense (invariance under redex selection order). Throughout this paper, confluence refers specifically to invariance of the terminal state under input order and input multiplicity.

2.2 Semilattices

Definition 1. Let S be a set, ⊔ : S × S → S a binary operation, and e ∈ S a distinguished element. The structure (S, ⊔, e) is a bounded semilattice if, for all x, y, z ∈ S:

  • (commutativity) x ⊔ y = y ⊔ x
  • (associativity) (x ⊔ y) ⊔ z = x ⊔ (y ⊔ z)
  • (idempotence) x ⊔ x = x
  • (identity) x ⊔ e = e ⊔ x = x

State-based Conflict-free Replicated Data Types (CvRDTs) share this structure: replica states form a join-semilattice and merge computes the least upper bound, ensuring replicas converge via pairwise merges without coordination (Shapiro et al. 2011). Whereas standard CRDT formulations require only a semilattice without a mandatory bottom element, this boundary model requires an identity element to initialize an unconfigured boundary state.

3. Local Overlap Resolution

3.1 Telic Recursion

The CTMU divides self-configuration into primary (global) and secondary (local) telic recursion (Langan 2002). In the secondary stage, local telors maximize local utility functions over their individual domains, while the primary stage corresponds to the global telor (reality as a whole). The framework defines local telors as operating freely and independently, producing contingent local states.

Under this framing, local divergence is an expected consequence of decentralized execution. Langan writes that “localized telic binding is freely and independently effected by localized, mutually decoherent telic operators,” yielding ubiquitous deviations from perfect complementarity (Langan 2002). Global coherence is maintained by SCSPL syntax, which “incorporates a global (syntactic) invariant that works to minimize the total deviation from perfect complementarity of syntax and state”. This invariant, the Telic Principle, functions as “a selection function with a quantitative parameter, generalized utility, related to the deviation” (Langan 2002). Addressing wave-function coherence directly, Langan states that without global coherence the universe “pathologically decoheres into independent and mutually irrelevant subrealities” (Langan, correspondence). Because the source formulation does not define an operational rule for local boundary reconciliation, this paper determines the algebraic conditions required to guarantee convergence when contributions arrive asynchronously without an ordering coordinator.

3.2 Rewriting Model of Boundary Merge

Let D denote the set of values determined locally by telors, closed under combination. Let e ∉ D denote an uninitialized boundary state, and let S = D ∪ {e}. Boundary states are unary terms (state w) for w ∈ S. An incoming contribution v ∈ D incorporates via the rule schema:

(merge v (state w)) → (state (w ⊔ v))

Given initial state (state e) and an incoming sequence of contributions L = [v1, v2, …, vn], sequential reductions yield the terminal state:

(state (...((e ⊔ v1) ⊔ v2) ... ⊔ vn))

This left-associative accumulation is defined as foldl(⊔, e, L):

  • foldl(⊔, e, [ ]) = e
  • foldl(⊔, e, v :: L′) = foldl(⊔, e ⊔ v, L′)

To ensure an initial contribution v ∈ D establishes boundary state v, e acts as identity: e ⊔ v = v ⊔ e = v for all v ∈ S.

This construction assumes that input contributions arrive asynchronously and that convergence must hold across every delivery sequence.

3.3 Asymmetric and Non-Commutative Rules Diverge

Arbitrary combination operations fail to guarantee boundary agreement. Let D = {p, q} and define two projection operations:

⊔first(w, v) = w      ⊔last(w, v) = v

Extend both operations so that e is a two-sided identity: e ⊔ w = w ⊔ e = w for every w ∈ S. In particular, v ⊔last e = v is defined explicitly, as an unextended projection rule would otherwise return e. Adjoining an identity to an associative operation preserves associativity.

Evaluating inputs [p, q] and [q, p]:

  • Under ⊔first:
    foldl(⊔first, e, [p, q]) = (e ⊔first p) ⊔first q = p ⊔first q = p
    foldl(⊔first, e, [q, p]) = (e ⊔first q) ⊔first p = q ⊔first p = q
  • Under ⊔last:
    foldl(⊔last, e, [p, q]) = (e ⊔last p) ⊔last q = p ⊔last q = q
    foldl(⊔last, e, [q, p]) = (e ⊔last q) ⊔last p = q ⊔last p = p

Reversing arrival order changes the terminal state. Because both projection operations are associative and idempotent, commutativity is logically independent of associativity and idempotence. Furthermore, if adjacent telors apply divergent projection rules (⊔first versus ⊔last) to identical inputs [p, q], their outputs contradict (p ≠ q).

4. Algebraic Characterization

4.1 Permutation Confluence

Theorem 1. Let S = D ∪ {e} and let ⊔ : S × S → S admit identity element e. The rewriting system is permutation-confluent; that is, foldl(⊔, e, L1) = foldl(⊔, e, L2) for any two lists L1, L2 ∈ L(D) that are permutations of one another if and only if ⊔ is associative and commutative on D.

Proof (Sufficiency). Because e is an identity, associativity and commutativity on D extend directly to S. Any finite permutation decomposes into a sequence of adjacent transpositions. It therefore suffices to prove that transposing adjacent elements vi, vi+1 in L leaves foldl(⊔, e, L) invariant.

Let L = [v1, …, vi-1, vi, vi+1, vi+2, …, vn] and let L′ be L with vi and vi+1 transposed. Let prefix accumulator a = foldl(⊔, e, [v1, …, vi-1]). The derivations evaluate identically on the prefix, diverging at positions i and i+1:

Derivation1: (a ⊔ vi) ⊔ vi+1

Derivation2: (a ⊔ vi+1) ⊔ vi

Applying associativity and commutativity:

(a ⊔ vi) ⊔ vi+1 = a ⊔ (vi ⊔ vi+1) = a ⊔ (vi+1 ⊔ vi) = (a ⊔ vi+1) ⊔ vi

The state at step i+1 is identical across both paths. Because both derivations reduce the same remaining suffix [vi+2, …, vn] from this common state, terminal states coincide: foldl(⊔, e, L) = foldl(⊔, e, L′). ■

Proof (Necessity).

  1. Commutativity: Let L1 = [x, y] and L2 = [y, x]. Because e is identity, foldl(⊔, e, [x, y]) = x ⊔ y and foldl(⊔, e, [y, x]) = y ⊔ x. Permutation confluence requires x ⊔ y = y ⊔ x for all x, y ∈ D.
  2. Associativity: The lists [x, y, z] and [z, y, x] are permutations of each other. Evaluating both gives foldl(⊔, e, [x, y, z]) = (x ⊔ y) ⊔ z and foldl(⊔, e, [z, y, x]) = (z ⊔ y) ⊔ x. Commutativity establishes (z ⊔ y) ⊔ x = x ⊔ (y ⊔ z). Permutation confluence forces (x ⊔ y) ⊔ z = x ⊔ (y ⊔ z) for all x, y, z ∈ D. ■

4.2 Deduplication and Set Confluence

Permutation invariance guarantees order independence over multisets but does not prevent divergence under duplicated inputs.

Theorem 2. Let (S, ⊔, e) be a commutative and associative monoid. The system is set-confluent; that is, foldl(⊔, e, L1) = foldl(⊔, e, L2) whenever L1 and L2 contain the same set of distinct elements if and only if ⊔ is idempotent (x ⊔ x = x for all x ∈ D).

Proof (Sufficiency). Let L contain v, and let L′ be L with an extra instance of v inserted. By Theorem 1, elements may be transposed without changing the terminal value. Reordering L′ such that the two instances of v are adjacent yields accumulator state a immediately preceding them:

(a ⊔ v) ⊔ v = a ⊔ (v ⊔ v) = a ⊔ v

The first equality follows from associativity and the second from idempotence. The intermediate state after both instances equals the state after one. Because the remaining suffix reduces from this identical state, foldl(⊔, e, L′) = foldl(⊔, e, L). By induction, duplicate inputs reduce without changing the final state, establishing set confluence. ■

Proof (Necessity). Assume ⊔ is not idempotent. Then x ⊔ x ≠ x for some x ∈ D. Evaluating L1 = [x] and L2 = [x, x]:
foldl(⊔, e, [x]) = e ⊔ x = x
foldl(⊔, e, [x, x]) = (e ⊔ x) ⊔ x = x ⊔ x
The outputs diverge even though L1 and L2 share the same underlying set {x}. Idempotence is therefore required. ■

Theorems 1 and 2 establish that when e is an identity, the system converges under arbitrary reordering and duplication if and only if ⊔ is commutative, associative, and idempotent, forming a bounded semilattice (S, ⊔, e).

4.3 The Identity Element

The identity element is an independent structural requirement. Non-empty subsets of {p, q} under union satisfy commutativity, associativity, and idempotence, but lack an identity element unless the empty set is adjoined explicitly as e. The characterization relies on identity to equate foldl(⊔, e, [x, y]) with x ⊔ y, evaluate three-element lists, and extend closure to S. Without identity, necessity does not hold under the present formulation.

5. Computational Verification

5.1 Representation of Finite Algebras

Finite binary operations are represented as explicit Cayley tables encoded as ground rewrite rules:

rules (rule (op a a) a) (rule (op a b) b) (rule (op a c) c)
(rule (op b a) b) (rule (op b b) b) (rule (op b c) c)
(rule (op c a) c) (rule (op c b) c) (rule (op c c) c)

This encodes the join semilattice ⊔ = max over D = {a, b, c} under order a < b < c. Adjoining ⊥ such that (op ⊥ x) → x and (op x ⊥) → x completes the bounded semilattice. In the test implementation, ⊥ is designated bottom, specifying rules (op bottom x) → x because a left fold initialized at ⊥ does not receive ⊥ as a right argument. The test predicates verify axioms directly on D.

Automated predicates evaluate the axioms across all carrier pairs and triples:

> (is-commutative? max-table (list a b c)) ==> true
> (is-associative? max-table (list a b c)) ==> true
> (is-idempotent? max-table (list a b c)) ==> true
> (is-semilattice? max-table (list a b c)) ==> true

A non-associative counter-table (broken-table) satisfies commutativity and idempotence while failing associativity:

> (is-commutative? broken-table (list a b c)) ==> true
> (is-idempotent? broken-table (list a b c)) ==> true
> (is-associative? broken-table (list a b c)) ==> false
> (is-semilattice? broken-table (list a b c)) ==> false

5.2 Order Independence

Evaluating permutations through max-table and broken-table confirms Theorem 1:

> (fold-op max-table bottom (list a b c)) ==> c
> (fold-op max-table bottom (list c b a)) ==> c
> (fold-op max-table bottom (list b c a)) ==> c
> (fold-op broken-table bottom (list a b c)) ==> c
> (fold-op broken-table bottom (list c b a)) ==> a
> (fold-op broken-table bottom (list b c a)) ==> a

The semilattice table converges across all permutations. The non-associative table diverges.

5.3 Duplicate Delivery

Integer addition with identity 0 satisfies commutativity and associativity, but not idempotence. The test implementation models this via a partial table (add-table) containing only sums generated by the test sequences:

> (fold-op max-table bottom (list a b c)) ==> c
> (fold-op max-table bottom (list a b a c b)) ==> c
> (fold-op add-table 0 (list 1 2)) ==> 3
> (fold-op add-table 0 (list 1 2 1)) ==> 4

Duplicate inputs leave the idempotent operator invariant, whereas the non-idempotent accumulator diverges.

5.4 Additive Tracking via Tagged Identifiers

Failure of idempotence in addition does not preclude additive tracking in distributed states. When contributions carry unique identifiers, boundary merge operations evaluate over sets via union (a semilattice), and totals are computed projectionally over the merged set. This corresponds to a grow-only set (G-Set) read through a summation projection, or a grow-only counter (G-Counter) tracking per-replica counts via entrywise maximum. In examples/semilattice-tagged.pal, events e1 and e2 carry values 1 and 2:

> plain addition, all orders of [1, 2] ==> (list 3)
> plain addition, [1, 2] and [1, 2, 1] ==> 3 4
> tagged, all orders of [e1:1, e2:2, e1:1] ==> (list 3)
> tagged, [e1:1, e2:2] and [e1:1, e2:2, e1:1] ==> 3 3
> tagged, distinct events [e1:1, e2:2, e3:1] ==> 4

The semilattice requirement governs the underlying boundary state, not downstream projection functions evaluated on that state.

6. The Degenerate Constant Operation

Consider the constant operation x ⊔k y = k for fixed k, extended such that e ⊔k v = v ⊔k e = v. Without this extension, the operation lacks an identity and does not satisfy the model in Section 3.2.

  1. On carrier D with |D| > 1: The operation is commutative and associative, but fails idempotence because x ⊔k x = k ≠ x for x ≠ k. By Theorem 1, its fold is order-invariant, reducing every sequence of length ≥ 2 to k. However, it violates set confluence: for x ≠ k, foldl(⊔k, e, [x]) = x, whereas foldl(⊔k, e, [x, x]) = k.
  2. On carrier D = {k}: The operation satisfies commutativity, associativity, and idempotence (k ⊔k k = k), forming a valid bounded semilattice with adjoined identity e.

The constant operation converges under both reordering and duplication only on a singleton carrier, where input distinctions do not exist. On larger carriers, it achieves order invariance solely by discarding inputs, and fails under duplicate deliveries. By Theorems 1 and 2, any operation with identity that converges across both reordering and duplication must be a bounded semilattice.

7. Discussion

7.1 Equivalence to Distributed Convergence

Under Section 3.2, the convergence requirements for boundary resolution correspond directly to the criteria for state-based CRDTs, supplemented with an identity element for boundary initialization. Both formalisms resolve asynchronous updates without centralized scheduling. These constraints govern telic recursion whenever overlap reconciliation proceeds via independent local updates without global coordination.

7.2 Syntactic Homogeneity, Shared Teleology, and SCSPL

The CTMU posits syntactic homogeneity: all regions instantiate identical grammatical rules (hology). However, shared syntax does not guarantee boundary consensus if combination rules remain unconstrained. Section 3.3 demonstrates that under non-commutative operations, terminal states depend on arrival sequence. Two regions executing the same rule on identical inputs in different sequences will diverge. Shared syntax ensures boundary agreement only if the shared combination operation is a semilattice.

This requirement aligns directly with the primary stage of telic recursion. If every telor resolves overlaps by computing a maximum under a shared total ordering of states (with consistent tie-breaking), the combination rule forms a semilattice. If telors apply disparate local preference rankings, boundary states diverge. Every semilattice induces a partial order (x ≤ y if and only if x ⊔ y = y), though not necessarily a total order (as shown by set union). A shared ranking provides a sufficient mechanism to satisfy this condition. Interpreting the Telic Principle as a global selection function parameterized by generalized utility (Langan 2002) yields a semilattice merge, formalizing Langan’s observation that distributed coherence relies on shared teleology.

7.3 Scope and Limitations

  • Model assumptions: The results depend on the framework in Section 3.2: outcomes fold independently delivered inputs, and convergence must hold across all delivery orders. If the CTMU’s global stage selects outcomes directly, or if boundaries enforce fixed arrival schedules, semilattice constraints do not necessarily apply.
  • Convergence versus optimization: A semilattice ensures deterministic agreement on a provided set of inputs, but does not constrain which inputs telors propose. Strategic proposals may still result in Pareto-suboptimal states.
  • Carrier scope: Computational checks verify finite domains, whereas the proofs in Section 4 hold for arbitrary carriers.
  • Scope of claims: This analysis formalizes the algebraic mechanics of overlap resolution and does not evaluate broader metaphysical claims in the CTMU.

8. Conclusion

Within the model of Section 3.2, where inputs arrive independently and the empty boundary acts as identity, boundary resolution converges across arbitrary arrival orders and repeated inputs if and only if the combination operation is commutative, associative, and idempotent (a bounded semilattice). Commutativity and associativity guarantee order invariance, idempotence guarantees deduplication, and an identity element preserves single contributions. These conditions match the convergence criteria of state-based CRDTs. In the CTMU, where overlap resolution is not algebraically specified, local convergence requires a bounded semilattice, which can be implemented by ordering states via generalized utility under a shared Telic Principle.

References

Christopher M. Langan, “The Cognitive-Theoretic Model of the Universe: A New Kind of Reality Theory” (2002).

Christopher M. Langan, reply to Paul Mackenzie on the coherence of the universal wave function, in The Portable Chris Langan.

Marc Shapiro, Nuno Preguiça, Carlos Baquero, and Marek Zawirski, “Conflict-free Replicated Data Types,” Stabilization, Safety, and Security of Distributed Systems (SSS 2011), Lecture Notes in Computer Science vol. 6976, Springer, 2011.

Appendix A: Reproduction

git clone https://github.com/thoriumrobot/palimpsest
cd palimpsest
cargo build --release
./target/release/palimpsest examples/telor-semilattice.pal
./target/release/palimpsest examples/semilattice-tagged.pal
./verify-semilattice.sh

The test suite evaluates:

  1. Axiom checks (commutativity, associativity, idempotence) and the composite semilattice check on max-table and broken-table (Section 5.1).
  2. Permutation invariance on max-table versus divergence on broken-table (Section 5.2).
  3. Deduplication invariance on max-table versus summation divergence on add-table (Section 5.3).
  4. Order and duplicate invariance of additive counters across tagged identifiers (Section 5.4).
  5. Output validation against reference test vectors via verify-semilattice.sh.

Translation: হলুদ গাঁদার ফুল দে এনে দে

Folk song by Salil Chowdhury.

হলুদ গাঁদার ফুল দে এনে দে,
Bring in yellow marigolds

সাতনরী হার কানে ঝুমকোলতা
Seven-chain necklace, floral pendant

রূপকুমারী মেয়ে মান করেছে
The pretty maiden has taken offence

বাঁধবে না চুল সে বাঁধবে না রে ॥
She won’t bind her hair, no she won’t.

আজ আকাশে, আকাশ কন্যা বাদল মেলেছে,
Today in the skies, the sky maiden has strung up a storm

নীল যমুনার কালো ঢেউয়ে ঢেউয়ে, মাতন লেগেছে
In the blue Jamuna, madness has touched black wave upon wave

রে আজ, মাতন লেগেছে।
Oh today, madness touches.

কনক চাঁপা! কনক চাঁপার ফুল দে এনে দে,
Golden magnolia! Bring in the golden magnolia!

কামরাঙা রঙ শাড়ি টিপকুমকুম।
Starfruit saree with vermillion bindi

রূপকুমারী মেয়ে মান করেছে
The pretty maiden has taken offence

বাঁধবে না চুল সে বাঁধবে না রে ॥
She won’t bind her hair, no she won’t.

আজ হিজলের শাখায় শাখায়, কোয়েল গাহে না,
Today mangrove branch to branch, the quail no longer sings

পাতায় পাতায় আর মর্মর তুলে দখিনা বহে না,
Murmuring from leaf to leaf, the south wind no longer blows

রে আর, দখিনা বহে না।
And the south wind no longer blows.

ঝুমুর ঝুমুর! ঝুমুর ঝুমুর নূপুর এনে দে,
Jhumur jhumur! Bring in tinkling ankle bells

পেঁছা রূপোর বেলোয়ারী কাঁকন।
Fashioned silver and glass bangles

রূপকুমারী মেয়ে মান করেছে
The pretty maiden has taken offence

বাঁধবে না চুল সে বাঁধবে না রে ॥
She won’t bind her hair, no she won’t.

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free